Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, April 08, 2008
Ed Feulner :: Townhall.com Columnist
An Enlightened Debate
by Ed Feulner
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


A flash of inspiration is known as a light-bulb moment. In an instant, things become clear, like items in a room when you flip on a light switch.

But soon we’ll need a new cliché. The latest light bulbs don’t spring to life. Compact fluorescent bulbs warm up slowly, only eventually giving off as much light as an incandescent bulb gives right away.

The new bulbs are more expensive than traditional bulbs, and have other significant drawbacks. For example, they contain mercury. In some states, it’s illegal to throw the bulbs in the trash -- they must be taken to a hazardous waste facility.

And heaven forbid you accidentally break a fluorescent bulb. If that happens, the Environmental Protection Agency recommends you turn off the heating or air conditioning, clear the room and air it out for at least 15 minutes.

After that, “Carefully scoop up glass fragments and powder using stiff paper or cardboard and place them in a glass jar with metal lid (such as a canning jar) or in a sealed plastic bag,” the agency advises. Then use duct tape to pick up any remaining shards of glass.

If you use a vacuum, “Remove the vacuum bag (or empty and wipe the canister), and put the bag or vacuum debris in a sealed plastic bag” once you’re finished. And “the next several times you vacuum, shut off the central forced-air heating/air conditioning system and open a window prior to vacuuming.”

Also, don’t forget to check to see whether your state requires you to deal with the bulb as hazardous waste.

Still, when they don’t break, the fluorescent bulbs are better in many ways. They last longer, use less electricity and throw off less heat. Consumers will reportedly save about $30 over the life of each bulb.

But that raises an interesting question: If the new bulbs are “superior in every measurable way,” as the Mankato (Minnesota) Free Press put it in an editorial, why did Congress need to make traditional incandescent bulbs illegal?

That’s right. As part of the energy bill passed last year, lawmakers phased out traditional bulbs. In a few years they’ll be outlawed, which could lead to a large black market in “Soft White” light bulbs.

Rep. Michelle Bachmann, R-Minn., wants to keep Washington’s hands off our light sockets. “I was just outraged that Congress would want to substitute its judgment for the judgment of the American people,” she told reporters when she introduced the “Light Bulb Freedom of Choice Act” last month. That measure would repeal the ban on incandescents, leaving Americans free to choose their source of illumination.

This only makes sense.

Americans are smart enough to decide for themselves which products they’d prefer to use. It’s only inferior or unnecessary products (think of ethanol) that require congressional intervention to survive. Useful or innovative products (iPods, cell phones) thrive on their own.

Not surprisingly, this is exactly what’s happening. Steve Rosenstock of the Edison Electric Institute says compact fluorescent lights make up more than 20 percent of bulbs sold in the U.S., up from just 1 percent in 2001. The market is working, as it always does when lawmakers stay out of the way.

The light bulb ban isn’t the first time Congress has attempted to protect Americans from wastefulness. Some years ago, lawmakers outlawed toilets that use more than 1.6 gallons per flush. The low-flow toilets don’t work as well, of course. Ironically they often require several flushes to, shall we say, get the job done.

Reflecting on the failure of a well-intentioned federal law, the late Daniel Patrick Moynihan once said it made him “wonder what ever became of our capacity to govern ourselves.” Simply put, that ability goes away when Washington tries to regulate everything.

Here’s a brighter idea: Let’s allow Americans to choose our own light bulbs. And let the best bulb burn on.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Dr. Edwin Feulner is president of The Heritage Foundation, a Townhall.com Gold Partner, and co-author of Getting America Right: The True Conservative Values Our Nation Needs Today .
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Ed Feulner's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
They ban just in time.......
They ban just in time.

GE was about to put new efficient incandescents on the store shelves next year.

Not unlike the clever - force the auto mfrs to increase fuel mileage. There goes the r & d money that would have been used to fund alternative power sources.

We'll be stuck with oil even longer!!

Not to mention the injuries and lives lost to even lighter crumple cars.

Can we elect someone who has read that old document - the Constitution ?

Did you Know . . .
if your electrical system is not in top shape, or you have a slight voltage drop, fluorescent bulbs can have a life expectancy of less than five minutes. A lot of old electrical systems will have to be replaced to use them. So much for any savings.

A couple of questions
Has anyone factored into the cost of flourescent bulbs the cost of the disposal of the hazardous material presently contained in the bulb. Do Federal studies consider this ?

The incandescent bulb is on its way to being made illegal. Will poor people be allowed a subsidy to buy the new bulbs since they are more expensive.

Tibby

A few watts short
Whoever dreamed up government lighting mandates is obviously a few watts short of a well-lit bulb -- or maybe they just inhaled a bit much mercury dust.

This issue neatly illustrates the divide between left and right: as always, it is the government mandate left versus pro-choice right, the mommy-state liberals versus free market conservatives, the emotion-based children versus the adults in the room. It's a never-ending battle.

I personally mix and match my bulbs depending upon specific needs and preferences. The last thing we need is another debacle from the hare-brained Greens. Screw that in your socket, Algore!

Will The Death of the Bulb
Be The Dearth of Ideas?

With all the Enviro-Freaks pushing this/that/or the other thing at us in the name of "Saving the...(enter your favorite species here - just don't make it MAN)'" it is little wonder we still have a lightbulb, a car, a factory or a single 'freedom' left anywhere in this country.

I could say follow the money to find out why this is happening but that would be too easy. The money flows in the opposite direction of all the BS we get FROM our elected officials in Washington these days. And the Enviro-freaks dispense a lot of both in their designated directions.

Just the case of Ethanol is a prime example of how good intentions often times go horribly wrong. Upon further review - the fuel produced is WORSE for the environment than the stuff it is destined to replace -GOOD JOB!!!

In the meantime we are being driven into better health (fighting obesity) as a direct result of higher food prices at the supermarket. And oh yeah, recession too - the offshoot of pricing ALL food out of the range of consumers. Going belly-up (pun intended) unilaterally doesn't seem like such a bright idea from where I stand. But then, I am just a meat-eating voter so what do I know.

I suppose if the PETA people couldn't get us to stop eating meat one way, they will settle for the "any means necessary" model.
I fear the Eco-Nazis will eventually cleanse the planet of US...
BUT at least the 'snot-nosed turd-munching cave-bat' will have a long & happy life!

W/O=

Light Bulbs
Another important feature of incandescent bulbs is that they work with dimmer switches and timers. Fluorescents don't, so if you have a home security system you may be out of luck.

ex-Wyomingite
Moonlight's the best.

Are you still stuck in the land of fruits and nuts?

Shoulda, coulda, woulda...
As a technical expert in the field, I can state with certainty that there is no reason fluorescent lamps could not produce a quality of light ever bit as "natural", convenient and pleasing as incandescent lamps. They just can't do it at anywhere near the same low upfront costs.

The performance of a fluorescent lamp depends somewhat on the quality of the bulb (natural, full spectrum triple+ phosphors are more expensive), but most of the upfront costs and lamp performance issues come from the hidden electronics that is necessary to make the bulb be able to connect to ordinary household ac power.

With the right electronics (all well known, non-exotic technology), fluorescent lamps could be:

+ instant on
+ completely flicker free and silent
+ fully dimmable
+ reliably last 10x+ times longer than incandescent bulbs (those annoying occasional early burnouts are caused mostly by cheap electronics)
+ draw only clean power from the ac line (without disturbing radios, tvs, etc. and further decreasing electricity billing costs)
+ work well over a wide range of temperatures

To minimize costs, the lamp should be replaceable separately from the electronics.

Right now, no bulb company has really tried to educate the consumer what to look for in a quality product and practically none of the necessary information is ever listed on the product package, so it's very hard to buy a top quality product even if you are more than willing to pay the upfront costs.

Think well - see clearly. :)

Color stinks
It may not be true of all compact fluorescents, but the ones I bought had a terrible yellow color. I was unable distinguish grey pants from khaki under that light it was so bad.

I exiled that bulb to the front porch and went back to the soft white in the bedroom.

I'm hoping LED technology will develop a good white light before the incandescent ban takes effect. Meanwhile, I'm stocking up on 60 watt soft whites.

Irony
The folks behind this believe in the precautionary principle except for things they do. Earlier they brought us MTBE (a carcinogen) in gasoline to reduce CO in the 1990s. We are still paying for that blunder in contaminated groundwater. Now they are banning mercury thermometers and complaining about mercury emissions from coal fired power plants and foisting off compact fluroscents onto the rest of us as a climate change solution.

In point of fact I buy compact fluroscents. Also the incandescent buld is on its way out just like all the other vacum tubes in electronics. In the next few years LEDs will probably make a big dent in the home market just as they are for major lighting needs where long life and low energy use is important. Plus they are harder to break.

I'm waiting for the Toilet Paper
Dispensing law that the congress critters are bound to pass eventually. You know, the one that only dispenses one sheet at a time. It operates on a timer, so you'll have to sit for 15 minutes at a stretch to receive the next sheet!

Then we'll have showers on a timer or a better idea would be coin operated or credit card readers, with the proceeds going to Washington to fund more ridiculous programs.

If they can regulate the water in your toilets and now light bulbs, just wait and see what they do next.

Not really surprising
There is not exactly a mystery as to why flourescent bulbs could be a good deal for consumers and yet not favored by them. As the article notes, flourescent bulbs cost in the short term and save money in the long term. Consumers do not exactly tend to focus on the long term in making minor purchases like light bulbs.

Of course that does not mean that regular light bulbs should be banned. But it does mean it is silly to think that people's purchasing of regular light bulbs tells us anything about the economic wisdon of buying them. Cases in which the rewards are more than a year away will be precisely those cases in which people make foolish decisions. After all, why does one suppose so many believing Christians act in ways that their beliefs tell them will send them to hell? And there the tradeoff is a lot bigger than with light bulbs.

Just a point of interest.
I watched a discovery show on light bulbs and one of the very first light bulbs created is still in use at a fire department, somewhere in the USA.

Technology seems to have given us a disposable society instead of quality.

Who are they
to pass laws, on what bulbs we can use? Is that in the constitution?
The bulbs of today, last only a few weeks it seems, compared to the bulbs of yesterday. I am constantly replacing bulbs all the time. Now that things are becoming more financially difficult and we are pinching pennies, we are left with one bulb in each room. Yet, my electric bill is still 400 dollars a month, in a nuclear powered area?

And yes we use the new bulbs, but they are crap and throw off crappy light, kind of a haze, instead of a bright constant light.

I dont like em, and like congress and the senate, even less.

Quality control
They say that the higher cost is offset by a longer life and lower energy consumption; but some of my florescent bulbs have not lasted very long. I'm all for saving money but I've lost a lot of my enthusiasm for these bulbs.

Fly in the florescent bulb
The just might be a tiny, little fly in that funny looking light bulb.
There's a study out there that shows that florescent lights just might contribute to, or, cause cancer.
We can't smoke because we might get cancer, but we MUST use light bulbs that might give us cancer.
I sit here and scratch my head and wonder.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.