Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Saturday, August 05, 2006
Doug Giles :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Se7en Deadly Sins: Gluttony
by Doug Giles
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


“I eat because I’m unhappy and I’m unhappy because I eat.” - Fat Bastard, from Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me

Thanks to the pervasive spread of gluttony within the Land O’ Plenty, Fat Bastard is no longer just a character in an Austin Powers’ flick . . . chances are, he’s your kid. Never in American history has there been so many sweaty sea cowesque adults and so many man-boobed little boys and chunky cheese, disease-primed little girls.

I’m forty-three years old as I write this column. When I was twelve years old growing up in Texas there was only one overweight kid in my sixth grade class of 300. That was one boy, not two, not 60% of my school carting around junk in their trunk, but one. Today, according to MSN online, over half of the adults in the good old US of Excess weigh too much and nearly a quarter of our kids aren’t just a little pudgy, but are obese. Wow.

Just yesterday while I was kayaking in the Atlantic, I saw this one boy (somewhere between 6-8 years old) on a boat with his shirt off. This kid was so chubby you could have hidden small toys in the folds of his fat. This kind of ruinous abuse, to me, is just as sad and as bad as the eight-year-old Russian heroine addict I saw on a video blog last week.

So what is gluttony?

Gluttony, according to Os Guinness, is the “idolization of food.” Os states, “Just as avarice idolizes possessions and lust sex, so gluttony idolizes food. It lifts it out of its place and distorts both food and eating. Thus, unlike a gourmet who enjoys and appreciates food, a traditional glutton enjoys eating, almost regardless of its taste, beauty or the company shared.

Whereas the gourmet savors, the traditional glutton devours.” What’s funny is that the church used to look at you weird if you were a glutton. Yeah, the ecclesia used to side with God and denounce the glut. We can’t do that nowadays because the church is packing more pork than a congressional subcommittee. Oh sure, we will condemn the obvious bacchanalian, Diddy-like excesses of the unwashed rich and famous with their groaning tables and uncouth comportment; but that doesn’t keep the called out ones from getting seconds of the Savory Sausage Slam at Denny’s! Glory, hallelujah!

I find it real convenient for the chunky church of the 21st century to go postal on the vices of drunkenness and porn, but you don’t hear a peep out of them when it comes to their paunch. Just the other day I was watching TBN . . . Why? I do not know . . . Anyway, the preacher was railing against drinking, smoking and pornography. Y’know, the unholy trinity, the three big sins the church really needs to be focusing on right now. The funny thing was that this man of God was at least, at least, 100 lbs. overweight, and he had more chins than a Chinese phone book.

Yes, the church will go medieval if you snort coke by the gram or toke marijuana by the ounce, but they won’t say a word if you commit spoon suicide by eating chicken by the bucket, pizza by the foot and hamburger by the pound. Why won’t they? Well, to say something about the sin of overeating would equate putting a knife to their own throats.

Now granted, in the grand scheme of things, gluttony is less egregious to other people than some sins. I’d rather be driving on the road with a guy who’s had eight hot dogs than a Mel Gibson lit up on eight Glenlivets. Having said that, gluttony (unless you want to blow off huge chunks of the Bible) remains a sin; and according to historic church doctrine, a deadly one. Can you say, “deadly”?

But before all the svelte health freaks start to self-congratulate, the medieval view of this vice was not simply constrained to ravenous appetites and bulging hips. That’s way too easy and such a narrow definition; it lets far too many food fanatics off the hook. No, the medieval ones saw five ways in which one could maintain the sin of gluttony without looking like a manatee: by eating and drinking too soon, too expensively, too much, too eagerly and with too much fuss. Ouch, baby, very ouch.

Guinness states that the above “are all symptoms of a philosophy of life that is finally materialistic, and hedonistic, captured in the motto, ‘let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die.’ Thus modern ethicists point out: modern gluttony is not observed only in bulging midriffs, high blood pressures, poisoned livers, bottlenoses and bad breath. It can also be traced in the fanatical modern devotion to dieting, health foods, and drug taking. In a society in which cookbooks outsell the Bible by something like ten to one, food and diets have been given a time and a place that are gluttonous.”

So what is the cure for the obvious glut and for the carb counting, package over-perusing, tofu fussing, soymilk manic?

How’s about getting a vision, sir or ma’am, of being and doing something great? Yeah, that’s it. Why not instead of sitting and gorging yourself or getting wrapped around the axle obsessing over your grub, getting fixated on something noble, something that will cause you to place food in its proper light; namely, as just a tool that is used to fuel greater ventures instead of the end all, be all that you’ve made it to be?

Jesus, Moses, Abraham and a bunch of other believers in the Bible loved life, lived large and ate well without bowing to their belly—and you can, too. They found fulfillment in an eternal mission and not just in their temporal taste buds. They could eat and drink and stay in controooooooooooooooool. And you know what? So can you. Yeah, it’ll be tough but that’s life in all it’s glory, girlfriend.

So, work with me now. Put down that gallon of Ben and Jerry’s cookie dough ice cream and back slowly away from it. Now, put on a fresh change of clothes and go out into the desert to speak to God about giving you some reason for living . . . something great to live and die for. And watch, just watch, what that’ll eventually do for your waistline—and your life!

* ClashRadio.com has been upgraded! We have added several new features to our show such as: Skunk Boy's "Evolution's Holdover", Dr. Full's "You can be a Loser". In addition, Giles has a new :60 spot called "Hey, Monkey Butt", a ten minute "Growth Stimulant" session for personal oomph and he has a excellent interview with Kevin McCullough, author of the book, Musclehead Revolution.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Doug Giles’ new book “If You're Going Through Hell, Keep Going!" is now available. Ann Coulter says "Doug Giles is a substantive and funny tour de force for traditional values.” Doug’s talk show and video blog can be seen and heard at www.ClashRadio.com.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Gluttony
Amen brother, Amen

Where does the Bible condemn overweight?
It is not clear precisely which "huge portions of Scripture" the author refers to in this interesting article. While it is true that gluttony (having one's belly as one's "god") is condemned in Scripture, the Bible nowhere even once makes overweight or obesity out to be somehow a sin.

Further, while it is of course true that gluttony can be one of the causes of obesity, modern medical research recognizes other factors which contribute to overweight/obesity, which fact the author so callously fails to recognize. The fact is, God designed the human body in such a way as to promote survival during times of famine, which virtually guarantees weight gain in the absence of regular physical exercise, even if a person is on a regular, non-gluttonous diet. Also of note is the rather ubiquitous occurence of *skinny* people who virtually worship food.

Yes, by all means let's do whatever we can to help curb the obesity epidemic in our country, but let's not misrepresent God and the Scriptures by saying something is a "deadly sin" when it is not even mentioned as a deadly sin in Scripture.

Now I need to get up and go exercise. :)

Sincerely,

John E

Gluttony
Many who read Giles' article or any posts thereon may be in their 20's, 30's or 40's in age, who may not be aware of what is probably the main cause of today's preoccupation with excessive food intake, and resulting natural obesity. Being in my early 70's, my compatiots and I, though, have lived through or remember enough of the days of the 30's and 40's to know that during the depression, much of the United States (and worldwide during these times) poverty made food supplies dear and many families had only just enough to eat for sustainance. You may find this hard to believe, but even during WWII, with food rationing, even relative plenty still limited much food intake, so when the economy took off after the war, most families could hardly believe their fortune when food once again became plentiful and people began to gorge on food, just because they could. But, the big contributor to today's obesity problem came in the 50's and 60's, with the advent of fast food and the explosion of "all you can eat" restaurants, which survives to this day. Add to that today's parent's desire, encouraged by a society that encourages not denying our children anything (even small children have cell phones!), the whole "eating" thing has grown to the place where any restaurant meal means plates with so much food that "doggy bags" are required, since most people can't eat what is placed before them. Add to that the lack of family life so common, with "eating on the run" instead of sit down meals, likewise encouraging poor nutrition and eating of overly fattening foods. Yes, we are eating ourselves into shortening our lives through developing high blood pressure and diabetes and other life threateing diseases and there seems to be no end in sight.

Here's your condemnation, John E
"Thou art fat."

The Bible doesn't say planting landmines in your neighbor's dog's doghouse is a sin, but it is. So quit acting like you're doing something that won't come back to haunt you. Why should we like fat? It's disgusting. Fat is unpleasing to the eye, a waste of energy to carry around, and tastes horrible. Face it: you like crap.

Fat is the physical result of an emotional problem, not just a problem caused by "over-eating". You eat more because you're unhappy. You're unhappy because you never accomplish anything. You never accomplish anything because you're lazy. You're lazy because you've always been that way.

Now everybody, exercise being offended. Because if you laughed at anything I said, you would burn calories from juggling that spare tire you call a waist.

Gluttony
Seems to me that whether obesity is specifically mentioned as a "deadly sin" scripturally or not, it is an effect more often than not of an unhealthy, obsessive interest in food. People are social eaters, both children and adults. Fast food restaurants are not to blame, how about church socials? It seems like other than during the service we cannot meet without refreshments or meals, as though it's impossible to go more than 2-3 hours without consuming something.

An obsession with being thin, agreed, is equally "sinful," any obsession with self is, or escape from self through meaningless, obsessive pleasure seeking, regardless of the crutch, whether alcohol, drugs, food, sex, or yes, even intellectualism. Seeking God (though some imagine this foolish, for they haven't found), is the answer to all sins, deadly and petty.

It's time to quit glorifying, sympathizing with, excusing, denying, disease of any sort: it's time instead to applaud health. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it;" if it is broken, do. "There is health in all things," find it!

Some people require more exercise, or think they do, than others? So what? Some wear glasses, some false teeth, some artificial limbs. Equality is an idle dream. A handicap is a challange, not a disaster. Nothing is so futile as a pity party. Success is making the most of what one has. Envy is never productive. To assume that another is effortlessly thin, when it fact it may be due to conscious, willed effort, is akin to assuming good students are just born smarter, when in fact they may be studying twice as hard.

Yet, I think Mr. Giles has stated an important truth: where life is employed in pursuit of meaningful achievements, food and all other unsatisying crutches are perceived as sidebars, rather than as necessities to a happy life. Then one grasps that, "Less is more" is quite true, and is freed to determine what would be truly "great" to do, rather than consume.

FOOD...YOWZA!!!
ALL THIS TALK ABOUT FOOD HAS MADE ME VERRRRRY HUNGRY. TIME FOR A COUPLE OF XL DEEP DISH PIZZAS WITH ALL THE BELLS AND WHISTLES!!!

Interesting...
The word "glutton" ends with the syllable, "ton". Which is the weight some of us are approaching.

Gluttony
Being a Great Depression baby, I can recall when food was not plentiful. Many a lunch (dinner, because the evening meal was called supper)consisted of crackers and cheese. After WW II food was more plentiful and more affordable. At every meal we were made to eat everything on our plate as "there are children in China with no food". If we wanted seconds of any item, we had to take seconds of every item on the table.

All family gatherings were at my parents' home and usually in the kitchen/dining area. Eating and socializing together was the norm. We have refreshments after church services each Sunday. However, being in a rural Ozark area, members drive as far as 40 miles to attend services and our refreshments afterwards is just a part of the socializing we cannot do except on Sundays.

Good thing I am tall because even though 25# overweight, I can carry it without being called obese. I am guilty of the sin of gluttony and remind myself of this when I am "browsing" the kitchen, foraging for something "special", even though I know I didn't buy anything special. It is probably a psychological thing, but then, what isn't psychological these days with all the stresses we incur.

Genetics definitely plays a role here. However, it is up to each and every one of us to dissect our actions and our needs, to consider what this banquet of food is doing to us.

Mr. Giles did us all a service by writing about gluttony. How many will read this? How many will change their lifestyles from reading this?

A fat belly is money in the pocket.
In Arab prisons fat Arab men walk around the yard rubbing their bellies. It makes them happy. To them a belly is a sign of wealth. To keep belly full required coins.
Buddha does not look down at his overloaded belly in disgust, he’s in a state of bliss.
Fatness is an assertion, a security blanket for the insecure, carbohydrates of fear. It should cost more to get a seat on an airplane, aviation fuel is calculated by weight. A fat person adds to a full airplane’s jeopardy.


Fat Phobia, Simply Not Conservative
While Mr. Giles is all to pleased to denounce the sin of gluttony, he is conspicuously silent on what he considers an acceptable solution. Given the level of public hysteria on this matter that we are currently experiencing, it seems obvious that we are heading to some kind of food prohibition in which the government tells us what we can and cannot eat--Big Brother is watching you eat.

Is this something conservatives should advocate?

Christian perspective
Interesting that such a judgemental article should be written from a supposed Christian context. It certainly proves itself by the very unchristianlike responses it evoked. Is it the job of Christians to persecute or is it better to lighten the way to the path of rightiousness? What leads away from gluttony of ANY kind is abstinance. The Christian perspective, in my opinion, would have been to preach the answer to sin.

By the way, the answer to pride (vanity) is humility.

fat & fast food...
uwcharlie writes: 'But, the big contributor to today's obesity problem came in the 50's and 60's, with the advent of fast food and the explosion of "all you can eat" restaurants, which survives to this day.'

Were that true, I'd still weigh 185 lbs as I did in 1966 (or more) vs 145 lbs today. Laziness is the real problem. Most obese people have a great dislike for physical work.

Gluttony
Gluttony is more than an overindulgence in food. Many overweight people don't need to eat much to gain weight, but the key to knowing about gluttony is that it is an overindulgence in pleasure. Avoidance of suffering, and looking to food or any other substitute for what Christ commanded in MT 16:24, "Whoever wishes to come after me must deny himself, take up the cross, and follow me. For whoever wishes to save his life must lose it."
Sadly, this is lost in most churches today. The idea of suffering and self denial is almost unheard of anymore.
I like Doug Giles. He is a bit abraisive, but so were many of the prophets, including John the Baptist. I think that he lost his head for being so out there. Truth in love is indeed charity of the highest order.

Gluttony
Ah, the last accepted prejudice rears it's ugly head. I am overweight but I work two jobs. I take a shower each day and am complimented on my hard work and intelligence. You people who have been blessed with thin parents and thin genes should remember the most important quotes in the Bible. "Do unto others as you would have them do unto yourselves" and "Judge not lest ye be judged." What is your next article Dougy? Amputee stumps make me sick? Well Dougy, YOU MAKE ME SICK! It is a shame that a conservative paper would print your colum.

Blame it on the genes?
"I am overweight but I work two jobs. I take a shower each day and am complimented on my hard work and intelligence. You people who have been blessed with thin parents and thin genes..." etc.

Mernie, I appreciate you as a hard-working American. But being lazy is called "sloth," a different sin altogether. The article is about gluttony, which is eating or drinking too much. Your metabolism and other factors can make you gain weight more easily than other people. But that doesn't make you overweight. Eating more than your body needs does. If you are overweight you are eating more than you need. That's not to say that eating the right amount or the right kinds of food is easy, but that's the bottom line to weight loss or maintenance. Your genes might make it tougher for you to lose weight than others, but you can do it.

GLUTTONY

I have been an evangelical Christian for 19 years and have only ONCE heard this subject addressed in a tiny church far away.
I 'own' this sin today.

Thanks.....
kim

[quote]Here's your condemnation, John E
"Thou art fat."[/quote]

LOL. Still waiting on you or anyone else to show where the Bible condemns anyone for being fat.

[quote]The Bible doesn't say planting landmines in your neighbor's dog's doghouse is a sin, but it is. [/quote]

Apples to oranges. Action vs. state.

[quote]So quit acting like you're doing something that won't come back to haunt you. Why should we like fat? It's disgusting. Fat is unpleasing to the eye, a waste of energy to carry around, and tastes horrible. Face it: you like crap.[/quote]

That's a very odd thing to say. Where did I ever say I liked fat? The simple fact is, Mr. Giles asserted that huge portions of Scripture condemn obesity, when that simply isn't the case. Even the biblical condemnation of gluttony begs the question, "What is gluttony?" It seems to me that Mr. Giles article would curse the darkness rather than light a candle.

John E


How does he know?
>> Moses, Abraham and a bunch of other believers in the Bible loved life, lived large and ate well without bowing to their belly <<

How does he know whether Moses and Abraham were overweight or not?? I must have missed the part of the Bible where it says "the THIN Moses was in the desert ..."


>> Never in American history has there been so many sweaty sea cowesque adults and so many man-boobed little boys and chunky cheese, disease-primed little girls. <<

Yeah, sounds like a Christian response to me. [Btw, shouldn't "seq cowesque" and "chunky cheese" be hyphenated?]

The Se7en Deadly Sins: Gluttony
As I was looking at our grossly overweight pastor today, I was reminded of this column. Unlike other deadly sins, this one is hard to hide. This pastor seemingly grows bigger and bigger every week. And this column keeps coming back in my mind....
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.