Watch how Maine Republican Olympia Snowe and Arkansas Democrat
Blanche Lincoln vote in the Senate Finance Committee on the Baucus version
of the Obama health care plan. As Snowe and Lincoln go, so will the
Congress.
The Democrats need Snowe's vote desperately to convince wavering
moderate Democrats that they can offer a veneer, however thin, of
bipartisanship to the health proposal. If Snowe, their last chance at a
Republican vote, opposes the Obama/Baucus proposal, there is no hope of a
bipartisan fig leaf for the package.
On the other hand, if Snowe backs the bill, it will send a
signal to moderate Democrats that it's OK to join in, and the bill will
probably attract the 60 votes it needs for Senate passage.
Lincoln's vote becomes critical if Snowe votes "no." Lincoln of
Arkansas is probably the single most vulnerable Democrat running for
re-election in 2010. She is the proverbial canary in the coalmine. If she
makes it, so will all the Democrats. Hailing from a conservative Southern
state, her poll numbers suggest that she would be in a heap of trouble with
a stiff challenger.
If Lincoln defects and joins the Republicans in voting "no" (as
she has done on a number of amendments), she will do a lot to cement her
chances to remain a senator, but will open a wound in the Democratic Party.
A domino effect will likely set in. Her Arkansas colleague, Democrat Mark
Pryor, will feel exposed by her defection and will probably consider voting
no, as well. It will be very hard for the son of moderate David Pryor to
explain why Lincoln jumped ship but he chose to stay on board.
Sen. Ben Nelson of Nebraska, encouraged by Lincoln's vote, will
probably vote no, as well. These negative votes will bring huge pressure on
Mary Landrieu, the Louisiana Democrat. Nor can the president count on the
support of independent Joe Lieberman of Connecticut, who has warned that,
despite his basic support for the concept of the bill, it would be hard for
him to back it in the current economic and fiscal crisis.
Once Obama's plan will clearly fail to attract 60 votes,
Majority Leader Harry Reid will fall back on reconciliation as a strategy
and hope for 50 votes. But if the Democrats pass the bill with 50 votes, it
will set a precedent they may come to rue. It would basically eliminate the
filibuster as a parliamentary tactic and would condemn any future minority
party (Democrats in 2011?) to the same irrelevance as afflicts their House
colleagues. To be in the minority in a chamber run by a bare majority is not
a fun task.
If Lincoln votes "yes," however, it will send a signal to all
moderates that even the most endangered of their species is willing to risk
backing the program and will do a great deal to shore up the president's
defenses.
All this means that if the elderly citizens of Arkansas and
Maine -- and their families -- want to avoid the evisceration of the
Medicare program contemplated in the Baucus/Obama bill, they had better get
busy. They need to deluge both senators with urgent pleas to vote against
the $500 billion cut in the Medicare program. Neither senator can afford to
alienate her elderly constituents, but what do they expect when they vote to
take the hatchet to Medicare?
Newt Gingrich found out that cutting Medicare is a ticket to
political oblivion. Barack Obama will learn the same lesson. The question
is: Will Olympia Snowe and Blanche Lincoln join him? |