Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, August 08, 2008
Diana West :: Townhall.com Columnist
Free Speech Jilted by Muhammad Romance Novel 'Warpath'
by Diana West
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Reading about the late Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, we are reminded of his epic force of will -- despite the threat to life and limb posed by the Soviet police state -- to bear witness, to document, to record everything he could about totalitarianism in the USSR.

Then, reading about Random House Publishing Group, which called off the publication of a romance novel about Muhammad "for fear of a possible terrorist threat from extremist Muslims," we should be reminded of something else: How apt was Solzhenitsyn's much-maligned critique of the West, which he excoriated for, among other things, a decline in "civil courage" that was "particularly noticeable among the ruling groups and the intellectual elites."

In the week after Solzhenitsyn's death, accounts of his determination and toil filled the news. When he had a typewriter, he typed single-spaced on both sides of a sheet; when he had pen and paper, he wrote in miniscule print. When he had neither -- as at a remote penal colony in Kazahkstan -- he devised a memorization technique involving a rosary made of bread in which each "bead" came to represent a passage of work that he committed to memory. He would later write that he memorized 12,000 lines this way.

By 1973, microfilms of The Gulag Archipelago, the writer's massive history of the Soviet prison camps, had been smuggled out of the USSR to publishers in New York and Paris. Solzhenitsyn asked them to delay publication, however, hoping to see the work come out first in the Soviet Union. But then he changed his mind.

Why? Solzhenitsyn had learned that the KGB, after interrogating his typist Elizaveta Voronyanskaya, had found a buried copy of the book. She hanged herself soon afterward. The author quickly approved the immediate publication of his 300,000-word indictment of the communist system.

This is the most serious stuff of history, epoch-changing events on which the wheel actually turned. What happened with a romance novel at Random House this summer isn't going to change any epochs -- but it may tell us something about how much our times have already changed.

As the Wall Street Journal reported, author Sherry Jones also "toiled," writing weekends since 2002 to tell a "tale of lust, love and intrigue in the prophet's harem" through a fictionalized story of Aisha, Muhammad's 9-year-old bride. All was well enough until Random House sent out galleys of the book to seek endorsements from writers and scholars. Among them was Denise Spellberg, an associate professor of Islamic history at the University of Texas at Austin. According to the Journal, Spellberg read the novel and became "frantic," explaining, "You can't play with a sacred history and turn it into soft-core pornography."

You can't? Says who in our free-speech world?

Says Islam in our formerly free-speech world. (That's what I mean about how much our times have changed.) Whether Spellberg is herself a Muslim isn't clear, but she certainly went on the warpath (jihadpath?) over this bodice-ripper (burqa-ripper?), activating a chain of Muslim bloggers and Web sites that spread the word, as one Islamic Web site put it, about a "new attempt to slander the Prophet of Islam." Soon, there was a "seven-point strategy" online to ensure "the writer withdraws this book" and apologizes to "Muslims across the world."

But that turned out to be unnecessary. Spellberg also e-mailed her editor at Random House -- did I mention Spellberg has a contract with another Random House imprint to write a book called "Thomas Jefferson's Qur'an"? -- labeling the Jones novel nothing less than "a declaration of war," "a national security issue," and "far more controversial" than either "The Satanic Verses" or the Danish cartoons. She said the book should be withdrawn "ASAP."

And so it was after Random House consulted "security experts and Islam scholars" -- possibly the same ones who urged the U.S. government never again to use the words "Islamic" or "jihad," but I digress. Thomas Perry, deputy publisher at Random House Publishing Group, said the company received "cautionary advice not only that the publication of this book might be offensive to some of the Muslim community, but also that it could incite acts of violence by a small, radical segment."

So, Perry, by all means, just give in to this thuggish blackmail. In fact, why not just stop publishing altogether?

It's too late to ask Solzhenitsyn for his opinion of this capitulation by our elites. But then again he already offered it long ago.

"Should one point out," he asked, "that from ancient times a decline in courage has been considered the beginning of the end"?

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Diana West is a contributing columnist for Townhall.com and author of the new book, The Death of the Grown-up: How America's Arrested Development Is Bringing Down Western Civilization.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Diana West's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
With "Friends" Like Spellberg
Who needs enemies?

Mohamo, or whatever his benighted name, was not only a pedophile, he was also a pederast.

A pox on those unworthy humans who revere him. May they roast in unending infamy.

But, then, perhaps I am being too "judgmental." After all, Christ advocated FORGIVENESS didn't He.

And I'm not even religious. May all Muslims spend their lives in abject misery. May they all live forever.

Soft Core Pornography?
People write all the soft core pornography they feel like about King David, Jesus Christ, Richard the Lion Hearted, Thomas Jefferson, Judah Benjamin....There was a time when burqua rippers, set in sultan's harems ABOUNDED.

Elites? Courage?
An Associate Professor at UT is 'elite'? In whose mind (besides her freshmen students)? A Deputy Publisher of Romance novels at at Random House? Elite? Either one a receptacle of any virtue, great or small?
Please!
Money-grubbing, attention-grabbing weasels is more like it.
Let's not dirty up the meaning of words like 'elite' and 'courage' by applying them to pseudo-academic busy-bodies & hare-brained romance-publishers. We'll need them in pristine shape, eventually, to apply to genuine heroes... the ones who have to clean up the messes made by the weasels.

Which is worse?
In the Middle Ages there was the black death...now we have the black burqas.

Impeach Mohammed..
..stains on Aisha's blue burqa.

pb has it quite correct
I agree that a clash of civilizations is inevitable between Islam and the West with their contrary impulse between, on the one hand a culture of tolerance and respect for individual liberties and rights and that of a culture of forcible subsuming of individual rights and prerogatives to that of the collective, but let us make the flashpoint be that of something of significance.

Romance novels? Please.

Mohammed and his followers can rot
First, Apollo, quit pasting your diatribe after every column...it's boring and tedious regardless of whether we agree or not. I've seen it in 4 different places already today.

Second and most importantly, Those barbaric, primitive thugs that follow the warmongering imbecile Mohammed as well as Mohammed himself will all burn for eternity...it won't be pretty. Don't be cowed by the followers of this perverted "religion".


Meanwhile, HAMLET 2 is coming
The trailers are more blasphemous toward Christ than this entire novel is to the "Prophet."

No theaters will be bombed. No filmmakers will be murdered. And the film will not be "withdrawn."

Anyone who claims all religions are equivalent needs to remember this.

Gonna write my own
I'm going to write a gay sex story about the false prophet Moohamed and his buddies and upload it to multiple free sites.

Call it backlash.

Now if I could just find out the name of the publisher that backed out so I could throw him into the bath house.

Hmmmm... How can I work Denise Spellberg into the story.

ASSoc.Prof. Spellburg...
...is a dhimmi IDIOT!

A Prof. who specilizes in Islamic history & fails to understand the simply FACT that it is an ideology MASQUERADING as a religion is a complete moron.
This sure speaks to the quality of hired help at the U of T & the ed-u-ma-cation one is to expect from these clowns.

Cowardly Behavior
Spellburg is another gender-studies academic with an emphasis on feminist issues in her work. Throwing frantic hissy fits is a feminist speciality. Interestingly she published "Politics, Gender, and the Islamic Past: The Legacy of `A'isha bint Abi Bakr" in 1994. Aisha was, of course, the 9 year old bride of Mohammed about whom Sherry Jones has written. Note he "consumated" the relationship when she was 9. They were betrothed when she was 7 and he was a mature man.

Islam employs bully tactics wherever it thinks it can get away with it. Muslims and Muslim sympathizers who are employing these threats aren't hard core fanatics. Those are always conveniently someone else - the bogeymen in the closet, not the "good" Muslims, who use them like a club to suppress anything they don't like. It's like having a particularly nasty little kid living next door with a large, belligerent, crazy brother. Knuckling under, as Random House has done in such a cowardly fashion, only exacerbates the problem. We will see it again and again until people learn to say, "Enough!"

I AM MUCH MORE
upset with Random House than I could possibly be with the UT prof. I wouldn't expect much more from her. On the other hand, I think any publisher that caves because of threats, or in anticipation of threats, deserves loss of their sector of the market. I am reminded that the Detroit auto manufacturers rolled over to the unions, rather than take a strike, twenty or more years ago. Their future was predicted in the business schools of the time, and now it has come to pass.

Can't fictionalize religion?!
I guess Spellberg never saw, "The Last Temptation of Christ", nor has ever read "The Da Vinci Code."

Obama delenda est.

How many Aishas do you know?
This is a hugely popular name in our AA community and does not equate to being a muslim, to say the least. Why the affinity for this figure? She was not Muhammed's child bride, but his infant bride. It is on the basis of the Aisha fairytale of a sublime pederasty that so much perversity regarding force and consent in sexual relations is tolerated in Islam, including the sexual abuse of boys as well. Islam will not let ANY uncensored tale of Aisha or anything else to do with Muhammed or the history of Islam be told because they rely on the sanitized version domestically and for their foreign supporters, so prevalent in the US. They will burn and rage and riot. They will mutilate and enslave and torture. They will lie, deny and suppress whatever they do not like and, friends and foes, they do not like YOU, not one bit.

Hit Random House where they live
Sherry Jones should sue Random House for breach of contract. I guarantee that they fear that more than any Islamic wrath.

Obama delenda est.

Random House Afraid of Offending- Who?
Are they going to screen every manuscript for any phrase or idea that someone, somewhere in the world, might be "offended" by? They'd have to limit their output to books about organic gardening!

Or --let me go out on a limb here-- are they only going to chicken out when the subject matter relates to a certain pseudo-religion which is sooo peaceful and tolerant that its most devout followers make videos celebrating the decapitation of "unbelievers"?

Yeah. I thought so.

We're as bad as Canada, where Ezra Levant was hauled before the Alberta Human Rights Commission for publishing the Mohammed cartoons. He was only recently acquitted (after 900 days and thousands of dollars of legal fees), and NOT because Canada's laws guarantee "freedom of speech". He was acquitted because the commissioner determined that IN THIS CASE the cartoons were "in context" and not merely a gratuitous offense to the religious sensibilities of you-know-who.
See
http://www.ezralevant.com/
for more details
(And see Mr. Levant's notes on Rev. Boissoin, a clergyman who was found guilty of hate-speech for declaring homosexuality to be an abomination per biblical scriptures. The reverend has been directed by the HRC to renounce his statement -- and thus repudiate his theological convictions.)

This same camel's nose is already under our tent...

"intellectual elites"
I am a quiet conservative English professor in a small university. I've been one of two conservatives in an English department of more than a hundred fifty in a division 1 school. Given the usual behavior of "intellectual elites" that I've known, I'm not surprised by the outcome. Saddened, yes, but not surprised.

There are times I wonder why I stay in academia. All I have to do to figure out the answer is remember that I'm typically the only voice of reason that my students have in the humanities.

The saddest part of this is that a fiction publisher caved under the hissy-fit of the so-called "elite scholar." It's really not like she could have easily found another publisher, after all, had Random House stuck to their guns. People read fiction. They don't read scholarly work unless assigned to read it in a college class by its author.

You cannot defeat Islam without freedom
of speech.

Muslims all over the world, and especially here in America need to be confronted with the fact that they love and adore an old dead pervert.

No matter how superior and virutuous Muslims feel they are, they have yet to be confronted by their grave and almost mass psychotic ethos which honors a pervert.

Everything Mohammed was is sacred and holy, including his having sex with a child when he was in his mid to late fifties.

The only way to help Islam implode is to reach young Muslims with the fact that Mohammed was a pervert and thus it is IMPOSSIBLE that any god would choose him. This is especially true in America where Muslim youth have a better chance of rejecting Islam.

If we cannot express these ideas freely, throughout the world, Islam wins, as it always has, over its critics.

The critics will have submitted.

Holly in MO:
As a rarity as you are in todays academia, it should be looked at as a golden opportunity to plant the seeds of independent thought to those young minds of grey matter, while also using caution to prevent drawing attention to yourself.

Sadly,far to many students are sent out w/ only the socialist indoctrination.

Drawing the lines
It is a simple, obvious fact about Islam that it does not value, nor will it support, what most Americans regard as freedom of the press, nor will it do so for artistic expression. For the devout Muslim who understands his or her religion as that religion has been traditionally taught, the notion of some sort of right that individuals have to express their opinions or to create works of art (even a lowly bodice-ripper) without taking into account the imperative not to insult Islam, or the Prophet, does not exsit.

Yes, it really is that clear. Random House dishonored itself as a publisher by yielding to the threat of Islamic retribution. Let's not kid ourselves. This sort of repression is precisely what the expansion of Islam has brought, and will bring, wherever it spreads.

The line is clear, but do we really see it?

50 Years ago...
Hmm?

50 years ago, somebody threatens you, you smash them in the face.

Today, if somebody threatens you, you get down on your knees, beg their forgiveness, kiss their toesies, plead humbleness, and hope you will be overlooked.

Am I the only one who prefers the 50 year old method?

Sadly, I believe there are too few of us who prefer the old ways.

If that is the case, we ARE DOOMED !

I may die, but it will not be because I bent over for anyone. It will be because I died in BATTLE.


OK. I rattled the saber. Does anyone desire to tussle with me?

I do hope you are prepared, if you do.


The Angry Rat

Rats
(and mice)



Note to Rosie O'Donnell, Christianne
Amanpour (CNN God's Warriors doc.), et al.

These two women and their ilk love to compare what they call "Radical Christian Fundamentalists" and the Islamic Jihadists tho I don't know what they call them--probably "freedom fighters"--

When "Catholic" director Martin Scorcese puts out "The Last Temptation of Christ"--the taking of a sacred text and imposing soft-core porn if ever there was one--there was no thought of pulling the film. Christians protested peacefully, some of us wrote letters to express our disappointment or outrage, and the controversy likely accounted for the majority of the ticket sales!!!

The musicals Jesus Christ Superstar and Godspell both deny the deity of the one Christians worship as the son of God. Not only are there no acts of violence threatened at any theatres where these works are performed--schools, churches, broadway....But I participated in a seminary production of Godspell in which we revamped (no pun intended)the suggestive song so that the prostitute sings about love of money rather than lust for Jesus. We also added the Resurrection to the end of the show.

The list of artistic/civic attacks on the sacred beliefs of Christians are endless, and Christians are ridiculed for simply wanting to be treated with respect.

I am so sick of the twisted fear-mongering by the left in this regard.

I would like to see, at the very least, enough respect given that we stop being compared UNFAVORABLY to terrorists!!!

Thick Skin
America, the home of the afraid land of the socialized, politically correct, and weakest people on the earth or so it seems these days. No Rodney we cant just all get along anymore. There are people that want to shove their religion down our throat or kill us in the process(preferably the latter if left to them). I am an American, I wasn’t born here, I was born in Holland. This is my country by choice, I speak two languages, and can think outside of the box. I see this world in a better light than most because I can think for myself. I don’t listen to our political pundents and I never ever call myself a Dutch American because I am an American first. I think that is part of our problem is that we say Mexican American or African American, or Asian American, and not American first. We are all guilty of allowing our government to take away too much of our lives. We are moving too far left and I see this nation becoming socialist and that bothers me. My father served in the Dutch underground during the Second World War, and I will follow in his footsteps. This nation can not stand if we the people are divided. We must all have respect for other religions nut first we must have respect for our own. We must respect other peoples and cultures but again first we must respect our own, and every part of this begins with respect for self. AS FOR ME AND MY HOUSE WE SHALL SERVE THE LORD GOD OF ABERHAM. As for me and my house we shall defend the rights of all of Gods children beginning with our own. So Socialists beware especially those in the Congress of the United States of America we as a nation are coming for you and thru the ballot box you will fall. Americans have been able to do for themselves and the world since our beginnings we have lost our way sometimes like right now but we have always risen to the challenge and we will do so forever so help us GOD.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.