Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Sunday, June 28, 2009
Debra J. Saunders :: Townhall.com Columnist
Disability, Inc.
by Debra J. Saunders
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


This is not a joke. Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a 6-3 decision that required an Oregon public school district to pay a $5,200 monthly tuition (plus fees) for a private boarding school for a high-school senior whose psychologist had diagnosed him with ADHD, depression, math disorder and cannabis abuse.

Also not a joke: The Obama administration had urged the big bench to so rule. Thus the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), which mandates that all "children with disabilities" have the right to a "free appropriate public education," is turning into a cash cow for disability lawyers and private schools. According to an amicus brief filed by Obama's solicitor general, Elena Kagan, Oregon's Forest Grove School District had tested the student -- known as T.A. -- in 2001, but determined that he had no learning disabilities; specialists did not test for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), although they suspected he had it. Parents and school officials agreed to take a "wait and see" approach.

As he continued to have trouble in public school, T.A.'s mother e-mailed school officials that summer suggesting "there must be some method of teaching more appropriate for him."

In 2002, T.A. started using marijuana. In March 2003, Kagan wrote, T.A.'s parents sent the boy -- then a junior -- to a psychologist who diagnosed him with "ADHD, depression, math disorder, and cannabis abuse" and recommended that he be admitted to a residential program. The parents pulled T.A. from school, sent him to a three-week wilderness program, and then to the Mount Bachelor Academy, which specializes in students with "learning disabilities, substance abuse, and behavioral problems." The parents requested an independent hearing in April 2003 to get taxpayers to pay their son's tuition, as per the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act as the school district again determined that T.A.'s disabilities did not merit special education. But in January 2004, a hearing officer found that T.A. had ADHD and Mount Bachelor was appropriate for him.

A district court found against the parents. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the district court. Monday, the Supreme Court ruled that taxpayers should foot the bill for T.A.'s private boarding school.

At issue was a 1997 revision of the IDEA. Dissenting Justice David Souter argued the revision banned subsidizing parents' decision to send their kids to private school without getting approval from the district. The majority ruling, written by Justice John Paul Stevens and joined by conservative and liberal justices, argued that the revision did not change the law.

Manhattan Institute education senior fellow Jay P. Greene argued that Souter's dissent -- joined by two bench conservatives -- "was unreasonable in raising alarms about costs."

"The aggregate burden of this kind of policy is a tiny, tiny fraction of aggregate spending," said Greene.

On the other hand, the court arguably engages in policy-making when it tells districts how they must spend valuable education dollars.

Walter Olson of overlawyered.com nailed the problem with the majority ruling when he opined in an e-mail, "The impulse to get a better shake for one's kid is universal, but it's disproportionately wealthy and clever parents, with their hired lawyers and experts, who succeed in using these rules to obtain a private school education at public expense. In this case, the question was whether parents should at least try the public schools' proffer of special-ed services before declaring them inadequate, which doesn't seem to me to be too much to ask."

And what a test case. You could understand the court's order for tuition payments for private school for a severely disabled child -- but not a teenager who had managed to graduate without any special education from kindergarten to the 11th grade, when he developed a marijuana problem.

The Obama administration blithely went along because, as Solicitor General Kagan wrote, it would be wrong to leave parents with "the choice of leaving the child in an inappropriate placement or paying for an appropriate placement in a private school."

Sadly, many parents face a similar dilemma. But only parents with the resources to game experts (who will diagnose a disability) and lawyers stand to win full boarding school tuition.

Noting that Souter's dissent was joined by conservative Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas, Olson noted, "I'm still trying to figure out why being progressive on this issue means siding with the private schools and affluent parents, while the conservative justices are the ones to defend the public school ideal of universal service."

It's one of those nice people things. The government has expanded the notion of disability to the point of absurdity. But nice people refuse to look at the impending drain on public school budgets, or how one child's boarding school tuition can mean that much less funding for all the other students' educational needs.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Debra Saunders' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Math Disorder?? (part 2)
There is no such thing as a math disorder. Some have more aptitude in this area than others, but lacking aptitude, does not a Disorder Make.

I have no aptitude or ability for Basketball, but I do not have a Basketball Disorder.

The reason that many, especially boys, have a problem with math that really shows up later in life is this:

At age 6, when most kids are Mandated Wrongly by Government to enter first grade, most boys are not intellectually or emotionally mature enough to enter these structured settings, and then be introduced to Abstract Concepts, such as math, when they are Very Concrete Thinkers.

Little boys lag behind little girls by 2 to 3 years generally, in the areas of emotional and intellectual development at age 6. They catch up later in life after they are grown up, but they start out behind.

As a teacher of high school students who were Diagosed as having Emotional and or Behavior Disorders, along with ADD, ADD/HD, LD, etc., the first thing that I would do with a new student was to Screen Him to find out exactly what academic skills he possessed so as to prepare a plan to catch him up and teach him.........

Keep in mind, these students would now be 14 thru 18 years of age, and had gained in Intellectual Maturity and ability. Once you identify where the learning stopped, you start there, and within a school term, this student who was likely at about 3rd or 4th grade in arithmetic skills and comprehension, would be above or past Grade Level Expectancy. He was able to Learn Now, What He was not able to learn when he was not prepared by nature to do so. But, you have to start where the learning stopped, and begin there. These older, more intellectually mature boys, now learn quickly things they could not comprehend when they were first presented with the material. This is what accounts for Most Of The Disorders That are Wrongly Placed Mostly on LIttle Boys.

Math Disorder??
There is no such thing as a math disorder. Some have more aptitude in this area than others, but lacking aptitude, does not a Disorder Make.

The reason that many, especially boys, have a problem with math that really shows up later in life is this:

At age 6, when most kids are Mandated Wrongly by Government to enter first grade, most boys are not intellectually or emotionally mature enough to enter these structured settings, and then be introduced to Abstract Concepts, such as math, when they are Very Concrete Thinkers.

Little boys lag behind little girls by 2 to 3 years generally, in the areas of emotional and intellectual development at age 6. They catch up later in life after they are grown up, but they start out behind.

So, what happens is that when little boys are put into Unnatural and Abnormal settings such as a Structured School Setting, this little boy is not ready for this setting. And, if he continues to Behave Like A Normal or Natural Little Boy, he is labeled with a Disability label or worse. Many get labels such as ADD or ADD/HD, LD, and others, just because they continue to be little boys who do not sit still in their seats, misplace things, speak out of turn, etc. And, of course, they also have some problems in understanding Abstract Concepts such as math, because they are not intellectually ready to begin learning this stuff, and also have no need to at age 6.

As a teacher of high school students who were Diagosed as having Emotional and or Behavior Disorders, along with ADD, ADD/HD, LD, etc., the first thing that I would do with a new student was to Screen Him to find out exactly what academic skills he possessed so as to prepare a plan to catch him up and teach him.

See Part 2 for conclusion of Math Disorder??

MATH Disorder??
So American kids can't do math because they're DISABLED?!? Funny, but I don't see any Asian kids suffering from this disability.

I'm surprised no one else picked up on this bit of bureaucratically-endorsed excuse making. We need to get back to the basics in this country in many more ways than just constitutionally.

Private School tuition under IDEA, etc.
The problem is IDEA requires the courts to decide local education policy. I haven't read the majority and dissenting opinions to see why, for example, Thomas and Scalia joined the dissent and Roberts and Alito went with the majority, but you can bet those four all voted the way their sincere analysis of the law and maybe the constitution let them to vote, also taking into consideration the procedural posture of the case and the issues raised by the parties on appeal. That is what judges are supposed to do, not just order, as Ms Saunders would like, what they think would be the wiser policy.

Ricci WINS!!!

Take that Sotomayor, Obama, and Liberals!!!

Your district and mine, Renny!
A few weeks back we had a poor, hapless aid reading the HSPA to a kid who was literally pacing around the room while wearing a cowboy hat and talking about drilling for oil at his apartment complex. I think this aid has had her share of taking the HSPAs!

End of my ADA
College students in NJ get to take their LD tests in a special *testing center,* and if a prof isn't vigilant, those students might take a week to finish a test the rest of the *normal* students took in 45 mins.

Like welfare, food stamps, unemployment insurance, and other social *safety nets,* these legislations and programs immediately become objects of abuse by malingerers and shyster lawyers.

Cap and trade will do the same to all products produced in the US. Nothing anyone can conceive or create will not attract the tax man and your wallet. Suits will skyrocket against energy producers and limit your ability to heat and cool yourself, drive your car, or even ride a plane to a vacation. In the meantime, Cong. will garner TRILLIONS more in indirect taxes to spend on their careers and cronies.

ADA (Bush I and Dole)
is a tort lawyer cash cow all down the line.

If you are a business and renovate with a new bathroom to accommodate wheelchairs, ADA lawyers' shills come through to measure everything. If your toilet holder is 1/16th of an inch off, they don't give you a warning. They sue and call you a bigot and oppressor and a *meany* because your contractor was careless or stupid.

In public schools, often the learning disabled have their own private rules and regs.--like *normal* kids can have detention, be suspended and/or expelled, fail tests and courses, but the *disabled* are the affirmative action of education: usually they cannot be disciplined (just understood), cannot fail (the tests and courses must be adjusted to *accommodate* them), they rarely receive a detention and almost cannot be expelled, even if violent against both other students and teachers.

My entire family in FL sent their kids to private schools to get away from classes made bedlam by uncontrolled *students* who destroyed materials and attacked others at the worst or just could not sit still or kept quiet at the least.

The school I retired from had 7% *learning disabled* in the 70s and 24% by the time I retired. Some NJ schools have 60% and 70% *LD*--whadda joke.

For parents, LD brings Soc. Sec. SSI benefit checks, and as long as these *children* are enrolled somewhere until 21, they can collect checks.

The LD students get extra time and even their own *environment*s to take tests. One of my former LDs had the entire SATs read aloud to him during school hours, not in a regular Sat. exam, as no one could do the reading on a weekend.

raymond...tj is right
i have never seen ss grant disability, no matter how truly someone is disabled. refuse to work for 2 years while a crooked disability lawyer games the system, and anyone, no matter how able, will receive disability.

Debra
I understand that you have a condition, but even if you'd never said so, the way you jumped on oldsocialworker would have given it away. My first thought on reading his comment to you was that he was complimenting you. I'm surprised you didn't consider it from that point of view before you let loose with a mean reply, since I'm certain this isn't the first time you've misunderstood a comment and come to realize it later. This, also, is not intended to insult you, only to suggest you consider different angles before lifting your poison pen (or keyboard.) I don't have Aspberger's, and it's something I try to remember to do for myself.

corruption
Justice? Not in this life.
Hasten the day of your return, Lord Jesus, that we may live with you in justice!

Separation of Powers
If all three bodies of the Executive branch of government ever followed the law, there would never what is commonly referred to as an "Executive Order". It simply doesn't exist anywhere in American law.

Joel-De Oppresso Liber
Social Security Code and Disability from the Veterans Association are Federal programs on the rolls to assist individuals with Physically Disabilities. After I was diagnosed with Bi-Polar Disorder (that's Manic/Depression to some of you!), At 57 I finally decided to retire. I have Emphysema and a skin disorder which requires daily treatments. So I checked into an Assisted Living Center, using my Social Security.

By the way, if anybody ever tries to tell you that SocSec was never intended to be an insurance program, DON'T YOU BELIEVE THEM! The next time you get your paycheck. look at the deductions and you'll find a column called F.I.C.A , which most call simply call Social Security! What do you" think F.I.C.A. stands for? It stand for the Federal Insurance Contributions Act" of 1936. Remember, I said I spent most off my working days as an accountant!
Gotta run. Shalom

Aniko
Your 9:22 post describes our future here in the US well. Glad you are here, sorry this country has become unable to learn.

Joel-De Opresso Liber
Section 504 of the Federal Code, aka Americans with Disabilities Act, was created to aid persons with either severe speech or physicals disabilities, such as Cerebral Palsy, paraplegia or quadriplegia, etc. receive education (if they were adjudged as educable, achieve skills that would allow them to become productive citizens in the workplace.The ADA helped them to to receibee wheelchairs and walkers for mobility. My wife has Cerebral Palsy with a severe speech disability. She received assistance in getting a power wheelchair. Through her OWN efforts she received a Bachelor's degree Social Work. Because of herr speech, she was trained in thee use of a "talking keyboard". At the age of 56 she has retired.

Why do you think that restaurants and other businesses are required to a minimum of qheelchair parking spaces? The ADA! Why do you think that places of business are required to have ramps into and out of the establishment (whenever possible)? The ADA! The PRIMARY reason for the ADA was for what is called "Reasonable Accommodation"! Employers should, if possible, find a job that fits their abilities, e.g. Greeters at Wal Mart (I use a walker and occasionally a wheelchair to work as a greeter.) It's better than being on the welfare rolls! For years I was an accountant, until my hands got too bad, I never asked for a hand-out . . . just a hand-up.

The price of "free"
I sang the praises of my Romanian schooling, only as a contrast to what the public school system is like in my adoptive country, America. To be fair, I have to tell you the consequences of the “free” education we received:
When I graduated from high school, I had to finish in the top 5% to even have a chance to apply to Medical School. The competition for being accepted into the few medical universities was on the average 4000 applicants for 1 opening! I knew all throughout my high school years that I had to excel in EVERY subject to have a chance to pass the bachelor exam (graduating exam from high school was called “baccalaureate”). I had no time for boyfriends, or TV or any entertainment. From the age of 14 I HAD to know what I wanted to do with my life if I wanted to succeed! I did succeed in being accepted in a medical university, but by the 4th year I was exiled form the country for my political views; (my oldest brother was already in jail for his anti-government writings)!
My colleagues, who graduated medical school (6 years), told me that only the party members’ kids got the “job openings” in “well to do areas” of the country. Those who had no “connections” ended up in the mountainous pauper areas, with muddy roads and primitive population, who had a tough time accepting “conventional” medical help. Furthermore, since the “salaries” of everyone was set by the government, it was the same whether you worked in the poor outposts or in the big cities. The “free” medical care was free only in as much that all had access, but treatment only if you “greased the palms” of the doctors. Most of my colleagues were disgusted, embarrassed (to accept a couple of leis from sick paupers) and disappointed with the kind of care they could offer from the Ceausescu regime’s regulated clinics and hospitals.
Nothing is ever free!

It's time to get past the absurdity.
"The government has expanded the notion of disability to the point of absurdity."

It's time to get past the absurdity.

i

My Uncle's Been Promoted!
We always thought ol' Earl was just a raging drunk. Turns out he's disabled. What a relief for all the people he's hurt in his life! It's not his fault, it's his disability.

I have a lot of compassion for the disabled. They deserve our attention and help. However, when drug abuse or drinking is a disability, or when bullying and violent behavior is a disability, it demeans the disabled and ultimately all of us.

Debra, I knew
before you revealed it that Clarence Thomas was one of the dissenters. He is among the few on the SC that consistently follows the Constitution and uses common sense.

No wonder the left tried so hard to prevent his confirmation.

In another ten years, the pundits will discover there is a "crisis" among the private schools. Tuition for private schools will sky rocket, and NOBODY will be able to figure out why.

If you want more of something, subsidize it. If you want less of something, tax it.

Obama is killing our country by taxing everything we need more of, namely productivity and wealth, and subsidizing everything we need less of; i.e. Rising costs for education and health care and the subsidizing of failure both personally and in business.

Tell me again how intelligent he is.

america
what next?

Calm down, Debra
I was paying you a compliment. I totally get the learning things differently and the spectrum that people can be on with Asperger's. My work is primarily with kids with behavioral issues, so when I see an Asperger kid the work is somewhat delightful for me. The few I've worked with over the years have gone on to great careers and are doing very well.

One boy had trouble because he was very literal and would fight with his history teacher, who took his precise interpretations as him being insubordinate. History teacher would send him to thew disciplinarian, who would be ranted at by the boy who couldn't understand why the teacher would want so much info left out. Things got colorful. Helping the teacher understand him and helping him build coping skills was FUN!

Another girl would disppear off on a single subject and have a really hard time recognizing the affect of others around her. She was lonely and couldn't understand why other kids avoided her. She was bright and fun to work with, and did very well.

Both kids were brilliant; one musically gifted and the other in mathematic (he's a GW now). I am simply saying that my experience in working with Asperger's kids has been nice and positive.

Take the compliment- even from an ignorant git like myself.

Lilly
I understand aspeerger's and the issues that accompany it- I see it as a condition rather than a disability or an ED issue. That is all. There are issues to be addressed and worked with, but its got better attributes to work with.

So citing examples of over accommodation and rampant litigation is evidence of burn out? How so? Folowing your Pampered Woman logic, if it is discovered that a drug actually harms patients, this should be ignored or it just indicates the pharmaceutical company is staffed by a bunch of burned out poo-poos who are obviously mean to people and should quit their jobs. This is exactly what you are saying, but in another context.

To find fault with systems and calulating the human damage that is caused is evidence of honesty. Staying in a system to help people avoid being labled disabled for life is hardly hanging on for a pension. Judging by the contact I enjoy from kids I've worked with even over 20 years ago, I don't think the pickeled assumptions of a silly woman who cannot tell the difference between disliking systems and people matters at all.

didnt mention the condition
I did not want to mention the name of the special ed category of the "brilliant" student who assaulted the Downs syndrome student because, after all, we are all just "equal" arent we?

Aniko vs. Lilly
I have recently been a special ed teacher in a school of 2400 high school students, 253 of which qualify for special ed services.

My education was in a system much more like that described by Aniko.

Which was more effective educationally and in terms of the greatest number of happy students and numbers of behavioral issues?

Both Aniko and Lilly make some good points.

But the winner: Aniko, by a mile! And the system I was educated in did a better job of helping disabled students. We just did it because students and teachers were on the same behavioral page. This in a time before we had a formal system to "help."

I now firmly believe changes in behavior can produce changes in attitude and thinking. A certain a degree of discipline and high expectations causes positive thinking and a calm atmosphere which benefits the disabled students. I know; not politically correct.

Change the behavior and we will respect and like you. Don't change the behavior and we won't. I know there are some who can't. But there are so many more now who won't because they have been trained that they don't have to.

When you have to physically protect a Downs syndrome student from a "brilliant" student who was "just expressing himself", you know that we have gone too far in "understanding and compassion"
We have ended up with less of each.

When you walk down the hall behind two IEP students who are talking about the "cool" behaviors which are acceptable for them because of their disabilities, we have gone too far. Sorry. Not politically correct, but at some point you have to tell the truth and let everybody else adjust.

The kids with real disabilities are getting run over by the ones who are just "behavioral" but qualify for "services." My estimate: out of the 253? Maybe 50, who have to defend themselves from the other 200.


Lilly - A True Believer
I understand your position, Lilly. And I acknowledge your good intentions. People who support government programs, which always result in massive fraud and unintended consequences, usually beleieve they can be fixed.

But please remember two things.

One - Government is insatiable. It will never say it is big enough, or powerful enough.

Two - Every dollar government spends was earned, and seized from its productive citizens. And it is usually spent in ways intended to help politicians get and keep power.

If government would just get out of the way, there is no telling how much Americans could accomplish through voluntary cooperation. Certainly far more than all the bureaucrats and politicians in the world. Pity we will never be allowed to find out, even in our "free" country.

Re: ADD and ADHD
I went to school in Communist Romania. Nobody had these "learning disabilities" there! Do you know why? Because our teachers were "god" in the classroom, and if anyone got an "itch,” our public school professors (they were specialists in their fields - math, chemistry, physics, languages etc., so I think of them as PROFESSORS of their subjects), took care of them so they would not dare scratch it for themselves EVER in the classroom! Each period was 50 minutes long with 10 minutes breaks, during which time our professors went to classrooms to present their subject matters to a class of 30 to 35 students. There was no "mass migration" of 600 to 800 students within those 10 minutes as we have in this country. Subjects that required laboratory or special devises auditorium style rooms where students, one roomful at a time (30 kids) went to during breaks. No wonder kids here get into all kinds of trouble, including lack of self-discipline (which we conveniently describe as "learning disabilities"), when they have lockers rather than book bags; test sheets with multiple choice answers pre-printed, rather than individual oral quizzes each and every day (approx three randomly chosen pupils within one period), and scored test sheets rather than daily "progress report cards" that would have to be seen and signed by parents, each and every day. We had uniforms and hair length policies as well. It was good for us all! Back talking to a teacher meant weeks of DETENTION (after school hours spent in school), not SUSPENSION! All of this cost the Romanian government less than what we spend in this country for education from K -12 per pupil.
We don’t need “special education” classes for unruly children, but teachers passionate about the subjects they teach, who have full authority to humiliate misbehaving kids into respectful behavior.

To Jerry
Actually, in my experience it is much harder to get on "the public dole" with an emotional disorder than an obvious physical one, or even a physical one that is pure BS. Two examples from real life: 1) A man who received disability money because his arthritis allegedly made him unable to stand or walk enough to get to or hold a job. What he did with his (copious) free time: he taught roller-skating. 2) A man a)so emotionally disorganized that he could not remember what day it was b)so depressed that without medication he could not get out of bed and c)with a long history of being unable to sustain employment, was repeatedly refused disability money and ended up living in the street, a very dangerous place for a vulnerable person. Just like the folks on townhall, people who process disability claims tend not to believe that mental illness is real.

Greyhawk
You hit exactly on the problem. Joe the Plumber or an X-Ray can see that a spina bifida child in a wheelchair needs special accommodation. But, for example, a schizophrenic child may appear to Joe the Plumber to be just an out-of-control kid who needs a smack across the fanny, and the mental disorganization, delusions, noises in his head, and other torments the child suffers will not show up on X-Ray. So how do we know they are there? At what point do we trust that a qualified child psychiatrist with no history of unethical behaviors or malpractice lawsuits may actually know what he's talking about when he diagnoses the child as schizophrenic? Do we accommodate only children whose disability convinces the Joe the Plumbers of our world that help is needed, sometimes urgently?

Oh Lilly!
But with the new ObamaCare being rammed down our throats, all those disabled people who need ramps will manage to fall elsewhere instead. They'll break their hips--and rather than getting that "free medical care" (i.e. hip replacement), they'll get their "free" painkillers instead. CHANGE we can choke on!

Think of a Concrete Example
Mental illness, ADHD, Asperger's etc make some people nervous because they can't see or comprehend what's wrong so they conclude that nothing is wrong and the claim is a scam. So, instead, think of a child who is blind or stone-deaf from birth or infancy. Obviously the average school for non-blind and non-blind kids is not set up to accommodate the special needs of these children. Mainstreaming was tried in the 1970's and left something to be desired. Few parents can afford the cost of private schooling for blind or deaf kids. Do you see anything wrong with the school district providing an alternative to the local school?

HUDVASH (Part 2)
Americans with disabilities act, I imagine, was intended to cover legitimate disabilities. As Lilly pointed out. If you are confined to a wheel chair or scooter, and are otherwise immobile, nobody would argue that you are disabled. So, Lilly, I get your point, but the point you and many liberals miss is the absurdity of some "so-called" disabilities.

In this article, the writer wrote:

"It's one of those nice people things. The government has expanded the notion of disability to the point of absurdity."



This program is the biggest enabler for veterans who are drug addicts or alchoholics than almost any program I know of. When you are an alcholic or drug addict, you did this to yourself and you choose to continue in that life style and do not take responsibility for changing your life. The VA and HUD enable these irresponsible to stay irresponsible.

And, the Bureaucratic Empire grows and grows and grows, and this is exactly what Obama and the Liberal Demcorats are doing to this nation. They are expanding the Numbers and Types of New Victims for The Government To Enable and of course, these agencies and departments keep their Empire Status, and of course, these Are Natural Liberal Voting Blocs.

HUDVASH
Americans with disabilities act, I imagine, was intended to cover legitimate disabilities. As Lilly pointed out. If you are confined to a wheel chair or scooter, and are otherwise immobile, nobody would argue that you are disabled. So, Lilly, I get your point, but the point you and many liberals miss is the absurdity of some "so-called" disabilities.

In this article, the writer wrote:

"It's one of those nice people things. The government has expanded the notion of disability to the point of absurdity."

And, to make this point. The HUD and VA now have a new program aimed at paying rents for disabled veterans called HUDVASH, which is subsidized housing for disabled veterans who have the following disabilities: (1)Alchoholic or Drug Addcit; and you can still be a practicing Drug Addict or Aclholic, and the govaernment picks up the tab on the majority or your rent payment and you have a full time social worker minding your case.; (2)You have AIDS; or (3) Other mental health issues including depression, bi-polar, OCD, and others.

These are the three groups that are covered by this bogus program. Most of the Alcoholics and Drug Addicts using this program are continuing to drink, do drugs, and otherwise get on with their destructive lifestyles. Have cars and are otherwise able to do all the things they want to do, and instead of paying part of their disability checks for full rent, their rent is subsidized and they also qualify for food stamps and other programs that their full time Social Worker/Case Manager helps them with.

This program is the biggest enabler for veterans who are drug addicts or alchoholics than almost any program I know of. When you are an alcholic or drug addict, you did this to yourself and you choose to continue in that life style and do not take responsibility for changing your life. The VA and HUD enable these irresponsible to stay irresponsible.


To goatlocker
Seems to me your problem is with unethical physicians who sign for the malingerers. I personally knew a City of Chicago bus driver who admitted he was sick and tired of driving a bus; what he wanted to do was stay home and write songs. He got some sleazy MD to sign a paper saying he had a diagnosis which he did not actually have, and got full disability. We need something either put in place or enforced if it's already in place to prevent such abuse. Meanwhile people who are legitimately mentally ill cannot get benefits that would provide them, at a minimum, medication and safe housing. All mental illness is not a scam.

Americans With Disabilities Act
To all who resent the Americans With Disabilities Act I say this: although now you may be relatively young and healthy, it may come to pass one day that a stroke, arthritis, diabetes with amputations, heart disease, a deteriorating neurological condition, or some other medical problem may land you in a wheelchair or on a scooter. And when that day comes, you will suddenly make a discovery that had previously escaped your notice: curb cuts. At the end of every block, and in other places like at the entrances to parking lots, the curb has been cut away and replaced with a mini-ramp so you can cross the street. Without these curb cuts, you would be confined to your home. With them, you will be able to go to doctor's appointments, to the pharmacy to pick up your prescriptions, and to the grocery story for a half-gallon of milk.

At that point, you will give thanks for the ADA, which was passed over the strong objections of Republicans, who didn't want to pay the cost of operationalizing the Act. Thanks to the ADA, you will also be able to get into restaurants, theaters, office buildings, department stores, cruise ships, and shopping malls, and onto public transportation. If you are able to work, ADA access will allow you to GET to work.

I wonder if, at this great point of discovery, it will occur to some of you that social programs are not just meant to help those minority poor that you so loathe: they are in place to help YOU.

PERFECT STORM
This is a perfect storm for the all children of failing school districts. D.C. comes to mind. Now all that students need is an ADD diagnosis and the school district will have to send them to private schools. No need for "Opportunity Scholarships". No need for Presidential or union approval of the program.

I also see a business opportunity. We need to set up a medical practice: "ADD, INc. funded by Medicare/Medicaid. Think of the profits.

To Jaime
Let's take a less subtle example, the child born with Down's Syndrome (like Sarah Palin's youngest). Within living memory these kids were called "Mongolian idiots" and were thought to be incapable of using any education at all; parents were urged to commit their sons and daughters to a custodial institution.

Now we know that early intervention with appropriate special education can help Down's Syndrome kids achieve an amazingly "normal" level of function. In a big city like New York or Chicago there might be enough Down's kids of each grade level to justify a special local public school. But in small towns and rural areas, there aren't, because populations are smaller. So, what's the solution? Waste the potential of God's creation and let these kids sit at home staring at the TV? Or use some state money to help the parents get what their children need? (Only the super-rich would be able to pay the cost out of pocket.)

What should we do with judges & lawyers?
Do you really need for me to answer this?

To oldsocialworker
If you don't understand the difference between cognitive "brilliance" and emotional disorganization, poor social judgment, obsession with ideas of reference, neurological symptoms, inappropriate affect, inability to pick up social cues, inability to sustain anxiety, and the many other symptoms that torment some "brilliant" people to the point that they become nonfunctional, maybe you should go back to oldsocialworkschool and find out. Or just do some googling. Look up "Asperger's Syndrome". (Unless, of course, you agree with the talk radio host who opined that autistic children are "just brats".)

As usual, you sound burned out. Are you just hanging onto your job for the sake of a steady salary and state pension? I am sick at the thought of how your punitive, harsh, and dismissive attitudes must assault your clients.

Sickening!
'nuff said!

TO OLD SOCIAL WORKER
Oldsocialworker, I'm surprised that since you 'claim' to be a 'social worker' you are also so IGNORANT on the FACTS!!!!!!!!!

The fact is that Children WITH ASPERGERS 'learn' in a 'different' way than people who YOU DEEM to be 'worthy of life'.

In order for adults 'with' ASPERGERS to become BRILLIANT, they need to be EDUCATED as 'children' first!

And in order for the CHILDREN to be 'educated' (if one does not have MILLIONS OF DOLLARS in the bank), that's were 'special education services' come in.

BY THE WAY, THANK YOU FOR TAKING MY POST COMPLETELY OUT OF CONTEXT (ignoring the fact that I turned down medicade, medicare, social security, and 100% disability for Myself and my childen).

And then having the FALL to attack myself, my children; and then every man, woman, and child WITH Aspergers for DARING to get special education Services.

Plan A for school vouchers.Down with DoE
OK, this is my game plan, for now.
I am going to write my congressman and ask him to tell me who in my state legislature has already or might be willing to write legislation for school vouchers. I know there are some because here in Texas, we have already had some legislation written, but never made it to the floor. Once I have the names, I am going to get my email friends to write their representative and I will write mine. I'll pre-write the "letter" so that they can cut and paste if they want and I'll send the link to find out who their rep is (from the League of Women Voters-Texas or one of those types of sites). I will also find out what it takes to get something on the ballot here. In California you can sign a petition and get a Proposition on the ballot there, for those of you who are in California...I used to live there but I escaped! haha! You will stil need your rep to help you. We have to start somewhere...

I have to laugh
to keep from crying.

Remember when Homer Simpson decided to eat his way to a DSS disability "retirement" for obesity? Hilarious, in no small part because of its truth.

Many of us who come from "working class" backgrounds could tell you elites lots of stories about friends and relatives who know every trick in the book for welfare, social security, and disability scams. How many people suddenly became bipolar, or ADD, or whatever other psychobabble crock du jour you can name when they discovered it could pay? Millions, I'll wager. I certainly know dozens personally.

To all you do gooders, socialists, government lovers, and crusaders out there: Will you ever be finished?

I Get Splitends Sometimes

Can I qualify for IDEA? Will SCOTUS tell Treasury to pay my hairdresser?

Thanks. Joel
I agree completely with you, Joel, and look forward to your comments. What do you think about this?:
If we really want school vouchers and community control of our schools through the private sector, we need to have a bill put onto our state's legislation that we can all vote on and that way get around the Dept.of Education's plans for our kids. If any state gets a petition going with 10% of the state's population signing on, the legislation must appear on a ballot, right? Is this correct? Can we accomplish our goals through grass roots efforts?
I know that any state can refuse to go along with No Child Left Behind if they also agree to not take the 9% of their entire school budget money that comes from the Federal Gov't. So far, only one state had tried to do this (I think it was Virginia, but I am not sure). Their state congress voted against the governor and they took the money. But the timing now is good...many people and governors are upset with BO's plan and just might not want to take their handouts and the rules that come with it. Well, please tell me what you think.

At first blush this seems
like a ridiculous court decisione. However, if parents can sue the teacher-union run, government monopoly schools for "appropriate education" it might just be the wedge to force broad voucher systems. Obviously, it will only take a modest number of parents and students, forcing payment for private schools, to put considerable pressure on the schools to either (1) provide a decent educations or (2) pay someone else to do it. With the drain on resources, it is more than likely that at least some districts might prefer to go out of the school business and let competition into the education business.

Debra
I've never met anyone who is Aspergers who isn't also quite brilliant. I'm not sure why its considered a disability.

States rights
were lost in 1912 with the 17th amendment. Also they were lost by the 16th amendment which gave power ti the US and by a 1912 law limiting the House of Representatives to 435 members and last by the federal reserve act which gave us paper money

There is one authority
that can take on the SCOTUS-that's a grand jury As Jefferson declared " A jury is the greatest anchor of man to hold a government to the principles of the constitution. It would be interesting to see if the SCOTUS was ever subpoenaed by a grand jury and asked where they got the authority in the constitution to declare the constitutionality of laws-it ain't there. The Marbury precedent is a farce as Justice Marshall who ruled on the case was the actual cause of the case

No Child Behind Leaves Behind Plenty!
To Marcus... thanks for posting the exact text of the No Child Left Behind Act. Problem is, this Act is only for "eligible children." The government decides whether your child is eligible. No win situ for parents.

Original Sin - The Serpent's Temptation
The people, through government, have decided to pursue for the love of god and our children, universal K through 12 education. Like an inch becoming good as a mile, that generous decision seems to have no limits. It has now genetically combined with the decision to care for the disabled. Politics, and the interests of strategically positioned interest groups, have made their ability to swing elections into the growth of a free lunch public industry. Individuals may no longer be responsible for school lunches, clearly, and soon, day care and college. The disabled are included, naturally. Other good things have, or are being considered, like subsidized housing, incomes, food stamps, and now, health care. We forget that there is no such thing as a free lunch. Working people have to pay, unless they are unemployed or unemployable. But then we pay them or send them to more schooling.

Is there anyone out there that doesn't believe in the tooth fairy?

Joel-De Oprresso Liber
I like some of your solutions, but unfortunately we know the way this is going to go. The outcome coming down the pike from Cloward-Piven is not going to be the outcome either of them, as well as progressives, expected.

Stop Whining...Time for School Vouchers
What, the government is whining because it lost? Serves them right! This entire issue could be avoided with school vouchers. We get a voucher from the state to educate our kid that equals the money that's currently going to the zoned school we DIDN'T choose! We use the voucher to pay (or help pay) for the right school for our child. BTW, this article is fallacious... if the school district deems the child "doesn't qualify" for special ed, the child can easily flounder in the school system for 10 years getting failing grades and becoming increasingly depressed. Been there, done that! School districts ARE NOT allowed to diagnose (by law) such disorders as ADHD, depression, bi-polar disorder, math disorder, etc. As parents, we have to spend the money to find out what the heck is keeping our kids from learning. Then we have to fight the school district to force them to provide teachers who are capable of teaching our horribly imperfect kids... and there are very few teachers who qualify, frankly! I have 2 special needs teens, adopted as children out of foster care, and I know first hand how hard it is to get our school district to provide educators who know how to teach my boys. Private schools are far more motivated to provide appropriate education, because dollars are on the line. I for one am glad the courts ruled as they did on this one. Serves the feds right.

No Child Left Behind
(e) SUPPLEMENTAL EDUCATIONAL SERVICES-
(1) ... the local educational agency serving such school shall, subject to this subsection, arrange for the provision of supplemental educational services to eligible children in the school from a provider with a demonstrated record of effectiveness, that is selected by the parents and approved for that purpose by the State educational agency ...
(2) LOCAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCY RESPONSIBILITIES- Each local educational agency subject to this subsection shall—
(A) provide, at a minimum, annual notice to parents (in an understandable and uniform format and, to the extent practicable, in a language the parents can understand) of—
(i) the availability of services under this subsection;
(ii) the identity of approved providers of those services that are within the local educational agency or whose services are reasonably available in neighboring local educational agencies; and
(iii) a brief description of the services, qualifications, and demonstrated effectiveness of each such provider;
(B) if requested, assist parents in choosing a provider from the list of approved providers maintained by the State;
(C) apply fair and equitable procedures for serving students if the number of spaces at approved providers is not sufficient to serve all students; and
(D) not disclose to the public the identity of any student who is eligible for, or receiving, supplemental educational services under this subsection without the written permission of the parents of the student.
(3) AGREEMENT– In the case of the selection of an approved provider by a parent, the local educational agency shall enter into an agreement with such provider. Such agreement shall—
~SEC. 1116. ACADEMIC ASSESSMENT AND LOCAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCY AND SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT.

Fire the Usurper
The traitor SCOTUS can rule in a case like this but not on Obama's eligibility to be POTUS.

Congress,POTUS, and the entire Washington inner circle should be flushed along with the main stream media, down the nations toilet. My T V never gets turned on anymore.

Who ever decided anyway that corrupt lawyers were the best people qualified to run our federal and state governments? It certainly wasn't You and I.
It's suppose to be for the people and by the people

We as a nation don't need to send just a few honest citizens to Congress, We need to flush the entire stinking mess out of Washington D. C.

We sit back and marvel about how Iran's corrupt government rules, when our own corrupt politicians are just as guilty of treason.
The constitution means nothing to them anymore. Our own past election was as corrupt as Iran's was.
This Kenyan Obama, will totally ruin America if he is allowed to rule for 4 years. At present date, I can't even seem to find very many citizens who will even admit to voting for him.
His Kenyan Birth Certificate is now for sale on Ebay with bids starting at one million.
We as Americans can fix all of this, but now it's going to require absolute change. We're going to have to realize that the word democrat and republican, are just words that politicians use against us to divide and control us.

Get out Americans and join in the Fourth of July tea parties. Let the traitor main stream media know that you're tired of them being traitors to America. Tell them they are partially to blame for all this mess they have created. Then we can talk about absolute change.
Change for the better begins with firing the USURPER.
Listen, I don't care what color the presidents skin is. I do demand as an American, that he or she be a natural born citizen.
Obama is not. Most intelligent Americans know that (now).
If only SCOTUS were not traitors, we could begin to fix all of this sooner.

Joel de-
I. for one, appreciate the recurring posts of yours.
You even explained WHY you do it.
My only question is, may I use those posts in whole or part, on other discussion threads, in other mediums?
Ten chew berry mud
Scrap Iron

There was a . . .
ada "lawyer" in california that would shake down small businesses citing the ada due to door handles "of the wrong type" or an entrance with a lip on the threshold (which did not inhibit wheelchair access). He ran this scam for YEARS until a few shopowners FOUGHT BACK with video evidence. Although he claimed to be "disabled" and utilized a wheelchair to perpetuate his scam, he was also caught on video WALKING.
Most small businesses paid rather than risk a lawsuit (which was more expensive than the $2000 to $4000 that he demanded).

Enough!
It is time for all parents to file suit for school district to pay for private schooling for every child in order to provide a PROPER education, period.

Sorry, but you're misinformed
Most parents that request due process hearings to resolve conflicts with their school districts are NOT wealthy. Many take out 2nd mortgages on their homes or borrow from family to hire a good attorney. And "good" attorney's are hard to find for parents since parents normally lose these cases (look at the actual statistics - it's the school districts that win and THEIR attorneys that make the big bucks).

Had the school district not dug in their heels and provided what sounds like some simple modifications to his program - VERY inexpensive - they could have avoided this lawsuit altogether and saved their district thousands of dollars.

We don't have this problem in rural areas where schools generally have a more traditional approach and WORK WITH parents and treat them respectfully.

ADA is not unconstitutional
The way that the great BO is 'inteprating' it, and DECIDING who is and is NOT protected UNDER IT ............IS!!!!!!!

Joel-De Oppresso Liber .. I understand your frustration at these accesses, and abuses that the great BO has taken.

But please know that not all people, or children who live with Disabilities are out to SUE! And not all people, or children who live with disabilities are on the Government DOLE!

I live with Aspergers syndrom, as do my two children. I turned myself and my children DOWN for all government benefits (when in fact (at the time) we qualified BIG TIME).

The only services my children get is bus transportation, occupational and speech therapy, and counseling services (provided by the school).

(by the way I OFFERED to pay for these services myself out of pocket to the schools they attended and the school districts and board said NO).

And when my children do behave badly (or when their behavior interfers with the teacher's ability to teach, and the other students' abiltiy to learn,) I don't let my children get
away with it!!!!!!

I discipline my children responsibly, and ensure that the teachers do the same. I work as a team with the teachers to ensure that my children learn, are able to get along with their classmates, and are productive!

The ADA that you CALL UNCONSTITUTIONAL; infact protects MY right and my childrens' right to live as human beings, and NOT wards of the state.

IN short as long as I and my children (as well as the rest of us who have the unfortunate task to live with physical, mental, and learning disorders) are law abiding, working, productive citizens; you have no right to abuse us.

I am against the President's 'education' act. As the ADA does the same thing, only in a RESPONSIBLE MANNER.

The ADA that you are so against, actually does not allow for the accesses written about in this article. Only the great BO does.

The State of the Supreme Court (SC)
ATTENTION BOZZOS on the SC: Where's the birth Certificate?!?
The SC is no longer a friend or the upholder of the constitution. These coddled loafers are bereft of all intestinal fortitude, cherry pick the easy cases, and even get those rulings wrong more often than not. When more demented liberal justices (WHAT JUSTICE?!?) are appointed it will get worse, much worse. Welcome to hell.

The leftist/liberal/subhuman mind is a pathetic and dangerous thing. Every argument based on common sense, nature's edicts, long and frequent historical examples, as well as the founding principles of this Nation is turned on its head. An appropriate, controlled, and necessary response to protect innocent lives from unspeakable acts is considered worse than the terrorist acts themselves. Killing nascent life in the womb is OK but don’t execute serial murderers. Their answer to a tanking economy brought on by malfeasance is to bailout the miscreants. Granting citizenship to rabble that broke dozens of our laws, many of them felonies, and who are here not to integrate but to suck the life’s blood from the Nation versus securing the borders, no amnesty, and direct the want-to-be citizens through the legal immigration process with careful screening and quota procedures. Law abiding citizens should not have guns but never mind that the crooks all have them and use them indiscriminately. This is a recipe for our collective, rapid demise; self annihilation.

Charles Krauthammer: Sotomayor on the Ricci case: And on her statements about the inherent differences between groups, and the superior wisdom she believes her Latina physiology, culture and background grant her over a white male judge. They perfectly reflect the Democrats' enthrallment with identity politics, which assigns free citizens to ethnic and racial groups possessing a hierarchy of wisdom and entitled to a hierarchy of claims upon society.

On the OTHER side of the coin
I am a married woman with Aspergers, and raising two girls with Aspergers. THe only benifits my children recieve is 'special educiton services' via the public school system.

And the teachers know that I do not ALLOW my children to disrupt the class. I am avialable 24/7 so that my children actually learn something and will not be productive citizins instead of in jail.

No I don't agree with the way the 'president' has chosen to handle special needs. I also don't agree with the legislation currently in the senate and house (S.819 and HR 2413) which calls for a voluntary 'registry' and MONITORING system of every MAN, Woman, and CHILD with Autism/Aspergers.

But that is the way our great PRESIDENT wants to operate.

Here it is where I refused myself and my children for government benifits (via medicade, medicare, 100% disability, and social security benifits), so that I could choose the right treatments for them.

And instead of being treated equally under the law, we are on the brink of being told we are nothing more than WARDS OF THE STATE; while EXCESSES like this occur.

IN short Mr. President, LEAVE US ALONE!

One more before I go
You must know the story of "Janie". Janie is Down's, and very indulged. She has a knack for projectile vomiting at whomeever she's mad at. Janie's parennts are always calling meetings with the district and always bring their "advocate".

The parents are angry that Janie doesn't have a job yet; Lord knows our special services job placement instructor (a great lady) has been trying. Janie didn't like the grocery store, the food service dept. at a hospital, the florist, or any other place we have arrangements with. She wants to work with dogs- period.

At the last meeting, our placement instructor made arrangements with Pet Smart for Janie to have some sort of job their (complete with job coach). She had to show up at 10:00am on a Saturday to start. Janie's mom whips out the planner and says, "I'm afraid that's not possible- Janie has horseback riding and then volleyball that day. You must change the time." This attitude is not uncommon.

Janie is now 16 and will remain in the public school system until the age of 23, as do many special needs kids.

For the record
In my region we have alternative schools that have been in existence for around 30 years. These schools allow "graduates" to receive diplomas from their district high schools (okay, fine) and classes include: "Dance as Math" (because you count steps): "Art as Expression" (which counts as English), "Natural Literature" (where students are read to in an outside/solarium classroom). The cost is about $90,000.00 per student per year. We now have parents who went to these schools (there are3 in our area) who coach their kids on how to act out in such a way so that they are sent to this school.

A lot of good it did the parents.

Public shame!
Public schools are magnets for abuse of all kinds-abuse by deadbeat parents like the ines that sued for their neighbors to pay for a private school, teachers union ripping off the taxpayers and politians grabbing power on the backs of them. The US students are below average in tests but we all expect the highest standard of living for everybody. The country is on a fast track to ruin and poverty will be us.
Since when public education must take place in schools run by government? Provide a stndard voucher for education to parents and beyond that, it is parents responsibility. Also, would some one explain what a math disorder is? There is nothing wrong with Math. It is still 2+2=4 and not 5.

Not their job.
I'm surprised at this. It is NOT the Supreme Courts right nor is it their decision to even rule on this case. It appears everyone has forgotten their job. Including them.

Their ONLY job is to make sure the legislative and executive laws are legal constitutional laws. THAT'S it! I don't see where in the Constitution is says dumb Johnny gets a free ride on tax payers.

It's so sad how ignorant everyone has become in this country.

More and more
Then there is the contracts our local hospitals have with the school district. There are SO MANY kids diagnosed with psychiatric conditions they do not have. The medical model employed in mental health "services" is disasterous, and NEEDLESSLY sentences many people to lives as "special needs" psych patients.

Kids are very often diagnosed with bipolar disorder by some stupid staff clinician- which gets signed off on by an incompetent psychiatrist (most are incompetent, in my experience). This suits some parents just fine; often they don't want to take responsibility for their bad behaviors, so they get to blame their kid (who is actually reacting to craziness at home) for being "mentally ill". This, of course, means special education services or at least a 504 (classroom/school day modifications).

As society devolves into increasing chaos and personal entitlement, "special needs" will increase and become more absurd in cost and demand for accommodation.

I could talk about this ALL DAY for 1,000 days.

Its much worse than this!
Here in Jersey it is common for the special education staff and services to equal or outnumber that of regular staff. I work in an alternative program ( for at-risk and/or adjudicated kids) and have watched as the "need" for services and what qualifies as a disability explode over the past 20 years. As for the cost of private schools, it can be in excess of $80,000.per student each year. In addition, students do not have to be rich to sue dictricts; there are plenty of vultures who cloak their legal services as "advocacy". Illegals are becoming quite adept at suing, which has increased over the past 3 years.

Currently my district includes:

A 14 year old illegal from Ecuador who is entirely inambulatory, non-verbal, cannot communicate on any level, cannot visually track, has seizures every couple of hours, and is incontinent. She has been "mainstreamed" into our school and this includes:

Personal bussing
Personal physician 3x per week
Personal nurse at all times
Occupational therapy 3x per week
Physical therapy 3x per week
Personal aid at all times
Personal climate controlled classroom
All equipment related to "learning"
Plane tickets back to Ecuador for "therapeutic" breaks.

This ONE student costs about $125,000.00 per school year.

There's more.

Joel is right, as usual
Joel, you have a valid point. I know exactly what needs to be changed in our country and have no plan to accomplish it. My posts on these threads are only preaching to the choir and to a few repeat trolls.

It takes a lot of people to make a change and far too many Americans never overcame our "education" and indoctrination in the socialist (government owned) schools. Most Americans even believe that our founders formed a "wonderful" de-mob-ocracy so any law passed at any time must be honored. A majority (the largest mob) passed it so it must be the will of "We, the people".

Wow!
If we continue to allow this, then wait to see what's next. Luckily there are good patriots out there like this blogger at http://www.theblacksphere.net. He is HILARIOUS and spot on!

Joel...
...I think it may be the best "screw" you ever had

..."At least I offer a proposal for political recovery..."

Yes, Joel,you do.Offer and offer and offer...every day and on every thread.Can't you at least re-word it once in a while?!

A death penalty for you would seem to be someone taking away your "cut and paste" button.

The entitlement mentality strikes again!
Oregon, like the other left coast states, creates disability by rewarding it. People have learned that they do not need to work for a living/education...all they have to do is convince the liberal gov't that they are somehow disadvantaged. The article missed a related abuse, here in Oregon, kids with learning disabilities/ADHD can receive monthly payments because their "disabilities" would prevent them from being able to work. I know of 2 cases in which parents have been receiving payments for their children since the kids were 3 or 4 years old (courts ruled it would be discriminatory not to pay based on age).

It's ridiculous. I have a (now) 24-year-old son who had severe ADHD as a child. It took constant involvement in his education and working with the public schools to have him succeed but guess what...that's what a parent does! And the lessons he learned outside the books was self-reliance, persistence and that he was responsible for his own future.

Raymond . . .
You will need to hire a disability lawyer.
"social security" ALWAYS denies applications for disability compensation on the first try. They discourage the truly disabled while the scammers who know how to "game the system" benefit.
It may take two years for your wife to receive benefits but she will get them.
Good luck and best regards,

We All Have It
We live in the era of "experts" and disorders. We all have disorders and if we don't think so, then the experts will tell us we're just denying it. It seems to have started with those in the medical profession having no answers for certain behaviors and so, not wanting to be considered unlearned especially after all that education, someone came up with the universal disorder. Old people that live with too many cats? Obviously, a cat disorder. Can't read or write? Not your education, just an attention deficit disorder. If a veteran and twenty years later's worth of drugs and alcohol, just blame it on PTSD. With all this, we're seeing the public dole is becoming common place. Not able to work? Well, we have all kinds of encouraging avenues to receive money, insurance and other welfare as you obviously have workplace disorder. All of this subtracts from serious illnesses as there can never be enough money for all of society's ills and those wonderful vagabonds of virture - lawyers!

Another day,another...
...cut and paste bonanza.The Supreme Court rules,like it or not(I DON'T!)So live with it or start your armed rebellion.

But PLEASE stop cutting and pasteing THE SAME ARTICLES!

Thank you.

Why fund wealthy parents?

Why are we funding wealthy parents at all? Why not privatize and fund income qualified only where the money follows the child to any accredited school.

This would take care of the highly intelligent and those truely disabled children. It even helps the cannibis addicted.

And, it is affordable and appropriate..

Calling all monkey-wrenchers
First, I applaud Mrs. Paddy. Dumping everybody from government -- D, R, I, whatever -- is our only means of surviving these troubled times.

Second, I remind everyone that the Obama playbook isn't copyrighted. Anyone may use any part of it anytime. This is a good occasion for turning the Cloward-Piven strategy to the people's advantage. (Cloward and Piven were professors at Columbia and followers of Saul Alinsky. In a 1966 article in _The Nation_, they advocated hastening the arrival of socialism by creating crises and overloading welfare rolls till the safety net snaps.)

The government schools are broken beyond repair. Stuffing them them with money has only exacerbated their problems. So have various kinds of internally generated reform. Private and home schooling have obvious advantages, but they impose financial burdens that not every family can bear in addition to taxes that support the dysfunctional government system. Vouchers deserve a fair trial, but they won't get one under this regime.

In _Forest Grove School District v. T.A._, however, SCOTUS has opened the back door. It has ruled that a doper with math problems has a disability that can't be accommodated by public schools. Surely the millions of students terrified by gangs and bullies or appalled by official indoctrination suffer some disorder that qualifies them for private education at public expense. Maybe FFLS (Fear-For-Life Syndrome) or GDR (Generalized Disgust Reaction)?

One clever lawyer could make a complete hash of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. A hundred clever lawyers could wreck the entire government school system and force a reexamination of the government's role in education.

When Jay P. Greene (quoted above), said, "The aggregate burden of this kind of policy is a tiny, tiny fraction of aggregate spending," he obviously wasn't thinking clearly.

States' Rights
I agree with the technical aspects of the 10th amendment. The feds have no authority in this case.

The problem is that we fought a war over states' rights and the states lost in 1865. From then on, the federal government has grown, and will continue to grow, until the states are little more than administrative bodies and tax collectors.

Sorry, but that's the reality check.

WOW
My wife has bi-polar disorder. She can not tell you what day of the week it is or what she had for her last meal. Can never remember where she put things. Yesterday I found the saltines in the silverware draw. Obviously she can not hold down a job. Yet the Soc Sec refused her application for disability. Reason she had not worked enough quarters. Duh she is unable to work, every employer had let her go. Of course a person with B-polar she can not get health ins. Too bad she wasn't a teenage pot head. Then all her needs would be met by the government.

I have an IDEA
Lets dump everybody from government.

If the Obama persuasion of the SCOTUS is a correct call, then "we be screwed."

There is NO separation of powers, no checks and balance, and Congressman Bachmann was correct.

We have a Gangster Government.

I can't believe this
Where was the chief justi ce on this - can't imagine him falling for this.

And we don't even have Sotomayor yet!

Is it legal for a president to tell the supremem court he wants them to vote a certain way?

Is there anything else obama can do to ruin this country?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.