Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, June 17, 2008
Debra J. Saunders :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Russert Weekend RIP
by Debra J. Saunders
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


If folks in the news business wonder why the public hates us, they should look to the orgy of coverage over the untimely death of NBC TV's Tim Russert. It's not as if Russert wasn't an extraordinary journalist. On "Meet the Press," Russert gave the best-prepared interviews in Washington. He asked tough questions without the sort of ego-filled posturing that made the questions about him, when they should be about the answers. Most important, Russert cared deeply about policy, not just the horserace and latest polls.

To top it off, Russert was a giant of a man who left a strong, positive impression on just about everyone. So it made sense for Sunday's "Meet the Press" to devote the hour to the man who sat in the anchor chair for nearly 17 years.

Overall, however, the hours and hours of tributes across the cable spectrum show the news media at their worst. For me, the Russert Weekend only served to confirm my suspicion that in 2008, cable TV stations can only do one story at a time -- and then they overdo it and beat it silly. You now know more about Tim Russert than Vladimir Putin.

To wit: His father, Big Russ, was a sanitation worker. He still loved his hometown, Buffalo. Russert told his son, Luke -- named after St. Luke the Evangelist, who wrote, "To whom much is given, much is expected" -- that he loved him every day.

Do you get the feeling that some talking heads think that if you're on TV, then you're too big to have come from a working-class family or love your hometown? I do.

You now know more about Russert than you know about Paul R. Smith, Jason L. Dunham, Michael P. Murphy, Michael A. Monsoor and Ross A. McGinnis. Who are they? Men who received the Medal of Honor for their service in Iraq or Afghanistan.

But they weren't on TV.

Here's a question that seems not to have occurred to the network suits: How are viewers supposed to see NBC -- or other networks -- as impartial when they air segments with numerous politicians calling Russert their "friend"? Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Barack Obama issued a statement in which he said he was "grief-stricken" over the loss of his "friend." "I was proud to call him a friend," said the statement by Republican presidential candidate Sen. John McCain. Obama guru David Axelrod talked on CNN Friday and MSNBC Monday. He was a Friend of Russert, too. The rap all shared about Russert was that he was "tough but fair." But the cozy schmoozing made the bond between politicos and journalists appear downright incestuous.

Where's the news? It's not as if anyone is going to say anything critical about Russert. The guy just died. There's a mournful brass horn playing with his photo between segments. You get on TV by fawning about how much Russert loved his son, and no politician or regular guest is going to depart from the script. It's a bit like watching "Larry King Live" after an octogenarian Hollywood star dies, and fellow hoofers rush to reminisce about their tales with the deceased. Even in death, everyone wants in on the act.

The Republican National Committee sent out a statement. Ditto California Democratic Party Chairman Art Torres. California first lady Maria Shriver's statement said that Russert "was one of a kind to me and I was lucky enough to have had him as a best friend."

In this game, crass opportunism is rewarded. Shriver appeared via satellite from Sun Valley, Idaho, on Sunday's special edition of "Meet the Press" -- on which she started or repeated the thread about Russert being the product of nuns, Jesuits and parochial education.

Part of the Russert Weekend phenomenon can be credited to a profession's prerogative. Figure that doctors receive the best medical attention, bartenders pour generous drinks for each other and mortuary owners rate posh funerals. Likewise, one of the perks of journalism is that when we kick the bucket, we get a nice sendoff story.

An outstanding journalist of Russert's stripe rated more than a nice sendoff story. But there is another tenet of the profession that Washington TV news bureaus seem to have forgotten in the shock of Russert's passing: We are not the story.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Debra Saunders' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Overkill
Very well put. Russert was head and shoulders above most of the peers, pundits and politicians to rushed to call him "best friend," and to capitalize on the sad event of his sudden passing. I would bet his family first appreciated the outpouring of tribute, then became sickened at the brazen and blatant cashing-in that the weekend tributes morphed into as the hours passed. You are correct about one story at a time, and where was the news, after all? Our 24/7 news industry had become so bloated and overweight (just like our American citizenry) that they squat upon a story and sit on it far too long for nearly everyone's comfort. That's not to take anything from Russert, about whom many wonderful and richly-deserved things were said, but for a while there, a foreign stranger tuning in to our weekend long funeral dirge of TV news coverage might have mistakenly thought that Russert was the president, and that he had suddenly died or been killed. Perhaps some of this gushing was out of silent guilt that they had not paid sufficient respect to him and his talents while he was among the living. His death reminds us all that we never know when we have seen our last sunrise, and that we should make every day count as best we can. He told his son that he loved him every single day. How insightful was that?...
Tim Russert ~ May you rest in peace.

Dougg - And there's ad hominem...
--
...done to perfection, as only a "Liberal" wanker can manage it, losing the debate (were there a referee present to jerk your collar for you) by way of your prat-flashing stupidity in:

"...the logical fallacy of attempting to undermine a speaker's argument by attacking the speaker instead of addressing the argument."


What you *might* have tried instead, dimwit, was to make some sort of comment akin to "Good riddance? Isn't that a little harsh?" and then trying your feeble best to make the case that there's some sort of value to the career of Tim Russert - lawyer, aide to Daniel Moynihan and then Mario Cuomo, MSM root-weevil, etc. - such that an impartial observer might have some tenuous reason to allow the possibility that he was more valuable walking around than soaking up formalin.

But you couldn't do that, couldja, Douggie-doo?

Well, *what* a surprise.

Not that I've come to expect much more from the average "Liberal," almost every one of which seems to qualify - on the basis of demonstrating no evidence of electrical activity above the level of the thalamus - as ambulatory organ donors in dire need of harvesting before subtentorial necrosis starts to set in.





========
"At the core of liberalism is the spoiled child— miserable, as all spoiled children are, unsatisfied, demanding, ill-disciplined, despotic and useless. Liberalism is a philosophy of sniveling brats."

-- P.J. O'Rourke

Well said
you and whose army. And a great song I might add.

No one is asking you Doc to "pretend sympathy". But going on a public message board and declaring "good riddance" is completely out of line. But what do you care, you're just an angry old doctor. Your grandkids must be so proud of you.

You - To whom should sympathy...?
--
...be extended? Those whom one doesn't know? Those whose personal histories, evident objectives, professional conduct, and manifestations of ideation run counter to one's own?

Why should I - or anyone else - pretend a sympathy unfelt, uncalled for, unjustified simply because a guy drops dead?

I've written enough death certificates for patients I've known personally, whose families I continue to treat and whose survivors I meet on the streets, in the schools, in the stores of my home town. It's part of what you let yourself in for when you go into general practice.

For them I reserve my sympathies. For authors and editors whose works I've read and enjoyed - whether I've met them or not - I can and will express regrets when I learn about their passing.

That having been said, however, neither Russert's work nor his person have my acquaintance, and to treat a non-existent memory of him with spurious "sympathy" would be an act of unalloyed hypocrisy.

Which, of course, is the counterfeit coin and currency of the "Liberal" mentality.



And what the puck gives you to hold that I consider "O'Reilly, Hannity, Rush, Hewitt, etc." any more laudable than Russert? Have you yet read me cite, quote, or otherwise refer to these lackweights?

Gawd, what friggin' cripples these "Liberals" be!




=======
"The function of government is to provide you with service; the function of the media is to supply the Vaseline."

-- L. Neil Smith

Doc
You're an ignorant fool and a sad human being.

You didn't know who Russert was when you read his obit? You should be embarrassed to admit that on a political website.

"But he was a thorough (Grade 3) malignant Democrat, and with that he loses my sympathy."

So when (more than) half of the people in this country die, they don't have your sympathy? This is again a sad reflection of what little character you have. Even the partisan hacks you worship (O'Reilly, Hannity, Rush, Hewitt, etc.) would be embarrassed of and by you.

I'm sure this is no surprise to you, but given what we know about you by your kind words for a dead man, I'm sure NO ONE will miss you when you're gone. In fact, the world may even be a better place. I'm guessing by your bitterness, that you're pretty old and we won't have to wait long. What a relief.

my heart
My heart does go out to him and his family, but there really is something pathological in our culture when literally every live show I watched this weekend--including the U.S. Open--mentioned his death. Honestly, since when did this become so common?

There is afoot a sick tendency to bring drama and sadness into every news story and sports event. Thus, for example, we regularly have moments of silence at sporting events for people no one ever heard of. It's like endlessly wallowing in sadness when program after program after program mentions something like this. It is very self-indulgent.

I hate sounding cold or whatever, but we have to stop this nonsense.

Wow
You're for real aren't you? Amazing.

Dougg - How can you not know...?
--
...who Eric Topol is? Or Jim Dunnigan? Or L. Neil Smith?

Whines Dougg:

"How can you not know who Tim Russert is? Oh yeah, he isn't on Fox News. If it isn't on Fox or Townhall, you wouldn't know about it. You're an ignorant prick Doc."


So because Dougg sucked his pap stright from Russert's nipple, he's supposed to be au courant and I'm "...an ignorant prick," eh?

Kinda like my grandkids' bewilderment about my inability to accurately quote from episodes of *Barney* or *Spongebob Squarepants*.

Douggie-boy, there are a whole bunch of people who outgrew the need to have Tim Russert or his NBC News predecessors pre-chew our food for us a helluva long time ago.

You're obviously not one of them, but just because you still need to crawl doesn't mean that those of us who can stand and walk on our own consider your sullen resentment with anything but amused contempt.



By the way, Eric Topol is a cardiologist who ued to work out of the Cleveland Clinic; he's at Scripps Health now. Jim Dunnigan is one of the most prolific wargames designers who ever lived, and is Editor-in-Chief of the StrategyPage.com Web site. L. Neil Smith is a science fiction writer and RKBA political activist.

And you didn't know any of that before I told you, didja, Douggie-boy?

Ignorant *LITTLE* prick, ain'tcha?

--

Unbelievable
How can you not know who Tim Russert is? Oh yeah, he isn't on Fox News. If it isn't on Fox or Townhall, you wouldn't know about it. You're an ignorant prick Doc.

Tim's Finest Hour
One of the reasons NBC and other networks gave so much coverage to his death was they had hundreds of hours of audio and TV. He was a good man and a fair journalist, but who will remember him in 10 years?

I liked David Brinkley but I don't remember this tremendous outpouring of eulogies when he died. These are just actors and actresses with scripts, good teeth, and pleasant speaking styles. They don't produce products; they just communicate the news as burnished by their staff and them.

The real movers and shakers get a few obituary lines when they pass on.

R.I.P. Tim, you did the nation a great favor when you discombobulated Hillary on the auto licenses for illegal immigrants issue, which I think started the unwinding of her campaign for the presidency.

green green
your article is colored bright green

Why am I surprised
that Townhall would post this crap?

Change the subject rather than discuss?
I know it's too much to ask to think that you might just consider or even discuss the point being made instead of attacking the author and the website. Yeah, too much to ask. Sorry.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.