Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Monday, March 10, 2008
David Strom :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Hidden Cost of 'Good' Ideas
by David Strom
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


What happens when politicians and pundits succumb to the notion that it is all right to micromanage our daily lives?

Well, for one thing, Daylight Savings Time. I bring this up because I am struggling to stay awake because I lost an hour of sleep to this abominable government regulation.

Daylight Savings Time is now and always has been a bad idea—the product of do-gooders who believe that they can tweak things from Washington to make the world a better place.

They tweak, we submit meekly.

Daylight Savings Time was invented by William Willet in 1905 because he was annoyed that his fellow Londoners slept through what he considered the best part of the day—the early morning. The solution proposed by this busybody was to use the power of government to force everyone to wake up when he thought they should.

The idea didn’t catch on until the advent of World War I, when other busybodies in government latched onto the idea that DST would help save energy, which was then at a premium due to the war. Like many bad ideas, nobody actually did the math to find out whether the underlying premise was correct, and modern DST was born.

It wasn’t until 1918 that the United States joined the bandwagon (soon after we joined the war), and due to the salutary pigheadedness of at least a few Americans it was not universally adopted. Unfortunately, Arizona and Hawaii are the only holdout states left.

Today’s version of Daylight Savings Time—which perversely lasts about twice as long as “standard” time—is still motivated by the supposed need to save energy. Our wise Congress decreed in the Energy Security Act of 2005 a modification that extended DST by another month in order to save energy and reduce greenhouse gases.

The do-gooders are wrong, of course. It is not so easy to tweak the real world in order to get the results you want.

Consider these facts:

Daylight savings time likely increases energy use, despite the fact that Americans use somewhat less lighting than without it. It turns out that heating and air conditioning usage goes up; · Billions of dollars were spent by individuals and companies change the DST rules in computer programs when Congress decided to tweak the rules, creating a mini-Y2K problem;

· Americans spend, conservatively, about $1.7 billion in time wasted changing their clocks and watches to reflect the springing forward and falling back each year;

· DST causes deaths, as more pedestrians are hit in the fall after the return to standard time, and more car accidents happen due to tired drivers in the spring.

The point is not that we should abandon DST because it is bad policy (we should and it is), but that we should abandon the notion that bureaucrats and politicians can tweak policies to make a better world.

The law of unintended consequences makes it unlikely that the good anticipated will come about, and ensure that all sorts of bad things not anticipated will come to pass.

The world is imperfect, as are we. But with few exceptions it is better to let people muddle about in relative freedom than to try to socially engineer them into some preconceived and probably impossible better world.

Ironically enough, that was the point of the Benjamin Franklin’s satirical essay that has led many to believe that he, not William Willet was the inventor of DST. What Franklin thought absurd and amusing, forcing Parisians through government fiat to abandon their love of nighttime activities, has now become the official public policy of much of the world.

Ah, progress!

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

David Strom is the President of the Minnesota Free Market Institute. He hosts a weekly radio show on AM-1280 "The Patriot" in Minneapolis-St. Paul, available on podcast at Townhall.com.

Be the first to read David Strom's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

WAY off the mark on this one David
"I lost an hour of sleep to this abominable government regulation."
Then go to bed an hour sooner.

I kind of like going home from work and having some daylight to play with. If it was up to me, I'd jump the clock ahead two hours.

Obsolete
Our society, businesses and recreation time is now 24/7/365(+1, leap year). Therefore, we can conclude that Daylight Savings Time is obsolete because our activities carry on REGUARDLESS of the sun.

End it now, please.

Corndog
I'm with you, I want sun in the evening.

Morons
"abominable government regulation"?????

Are you kidding me, a three-trillion dollar endless war of choice and this is an abomination?

The only abomination is David Strom.

DST
When I grew up in Hawaii, I was a bit mystified by the Daylight Savings Time the rest of the nation seemed to adopt, since for the first five grades of elementary school I never had to bother with it. Then my family and I move to Oregon and I was introduced to this odd tradition. I always assumed it had something to do with the railroads, because time zones were created mainly because of this. I didn't realize it was a federal government mandate.

Responding to Great Patriot's (an exaggeration, to be sure) gesticulation, you're missing the point, and you're operating under false pretenses. There are some things that are under federal pervue, and war is one of them. All wars are wars of choice; so your statement about this war on terror being a war of choice is sophomoric. Setting the country to adopt a meaningless Daylight Savings Time is ludicrous, and arguably beyond the pervue of federal mandate. Read Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution, then read the 9th and 10th Amendments.

Strom is Right . . .
. . . about both the little and big pictures.

Little Picture: DST has not accomplished what it set out to, and has thus failed even on its OWN terms.

Big Picture: DST is an example of Washington elites who want to manage the daily lives of we great unwashed.

Good article. Kudos!

Norman is right
And so is Strom. Mandatory recycling, bottle bills, daylight savings time, outlawing freon, HOV lanes, etc. Torture, if not death, by a thousand cuts. In all things great and small some politician or bureaucrat thinks up an idea and then stuffs it down our throats. Where are the Sons of Liberty when we need them?

geewilikers
I know it's screwing me up!

stupid government.....

The justification I was taught...
...for Daylight Savings Time was that the extra hour of afternoon sunlight during the summer months would be a boon to farmers -- it would give them more daylight in which to do farm chores. How long has it been since we last heard that rationale? Did it ever really apply?

Francis W. Porretto says:
The justification I was taught for Daylight Savings Time was that the extra hour of afternoon sunlight during the summer months would be a boon to farmers ...
.............................

My grandfatHer and some of my granduncles were farmers... they worked from sunup to sundown, and didn't worry about the clock, they wanted to SEE WHAT THEY WERE DOING ... so just how did DST help the farmers?? (Hint to answer: It didn't!!)

Marching Mommies
The same Mommies (of both genders) who want to strip search 1400 kids on their way into school -- not for drugs and guns, but for peanuts -- and who shriek if a tobacco cigarette is lit up 300 yards from a toddler downwind in a hurricane but who demand the legalization of marijuana so Mom can toke up any time anywhere, are the ones who think it is better for me to go to work in the dark than to come home in the dark.

They are also the women in the SUVs driving along behind us proles who have to walk in the street after a blizzard because the sidewalks are not plowed until the sun rises, blowing their horns incessantly while they yammer on their cell phones and slap their kids and drive through slush to splash those waiting for the bus. They know what is best for everyone else, but the rules are not for them.

Creative
This is truly creative. I know about conservatives hating no-smoking laws, Civil Rights laws, no snowmobile laws, helmet laws, child safety seat laws, nutritional labeling laws, Affirmative Action laws, speed limit laws, teen driving age laws, teen alcohol laws, Equal Opportunity laws, environmental protection laws, all forms of regulatory laws, hate speech laws, and most of all gun control laws, but their hating Daylight Savings as government interference frankly had never occurred to me as a possibility.

I remember during World War II they said something about increasing the hours of productivity. I also remember walking to school ca 1943 in wintertime upstate New York when it was pitch dark out at 8 AM---try that nowadays with creeps and predators plentiful.

Lilly again
Lilly, please tell us what you like to do so we can get a law passed to make it illegal. People like you protect terrorist rights to plan mayhem under the umbrella of privacy but want to call what I say hate speech making it illegal.

What's the Point
The government should just leave it alone. It's all just another notch on the road to total government domination. You want an extra hour of daylight at the end of the day? Talk to your boss about starting work at 7:00 instead of 8:00. I've worked jobs where we started even earlier in the summer, to take advantage of cooler temps.

I just think it should be up to individuals, and not the government. The government is taking an ever growing bite out of our freedom.

DST advantage
The only real advantage of DST is that I get an extra hour of sunlight after work so I can get in 9 holes of golf. Other than that it is a nusance. I think the real gist of this article is the intrusion of govt do gooders into our daily lives. At some time the American people are gonna dump the tea in the harbor. They can't control the borders but they can damn well control the clocks therfor they will.

How about low volume flush toilets?
That's a stupidity that irks me on a daily basis. Instead of saving water, people routinely flush 2-3 more times, and don't even talk to me about the frequent "log jams."

I sure am glad Lilly has all my dislikes noted. Apparently I need to ramp up my ignorance, bias, racism, and bigotry and come into compliance with her definition of conservatives.

What a smug, snotty, elitist, NE liberal you are!

I may only be a gun toting, Christian, Redneck from AZ (NO DST - YEA!) but I believe in live and let live. It's not my job to force change on anyone (in spite of the unfounded fear libs have for my religion), and I GREATLY RESENT busybodies decreeing from high what I have to do... and I'm not going to take it anymore.

DST And Other Stupid Laws.
Some of these posts on this page seem to miss the point as I see it.The problem to me is seeing how the government,now,rules our lives.

One of the most daring changes was moving our holidays.Even changing the dates of some and eliminating ones that were a tradition.I was always glad to have a long weekend from work,but hated the way I got it.

But changing the time the sun rises and sets is really messing with Mother Nature.How can it get more powerful than that?


roadmaster
You forgot low-flow showerheads and, more importantly, low-flow faucets, especially at the kitchen sink. Some nameless, faceless bureaucrat in Washington, D.C., has given me more time to contemplate life as I wait for my watering can or my cooking pot to fill with water, thankyouverymuch. Not so good is the fact that it takes some pre-planning to arrange to have enough water to safely transport waste down the garbage disposal--but then I should be grateful they haven't outlawed the garbage disposal, shouldn't I?

On the other hand
I would just soon that we were permanantly on daylight savings time. I particularly like to have some time after work to get yardwork done so I can clear my weekends for more relaxing activities. DST provides just that! I am with him in that moving back and forth is a pain and changing it from year to year is a really bad idea.

I agree
I hate govt mandates by busybodies like Eliot Spitzer, the state doesn't own our time.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.