Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, November 02, 2007
David Strom :: Townhall.com Columnist
Science vs. Symbolism
by David Strom
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Is Governor Tim Pawlenty looking to get a Nobel Peace Prize by following in the wake of Al Gore?

Minnesota’s Governor Tim Pawlenty is reportedly planning a spring trip to the Arctic to dramatize the impact of climate change. He is also planning a series of forums across the State to warn about the impact of climate change on Lake Superior.

Newsflash Governor Pawlenty: Lake Superior was formed by the melting of a massive glacier about 10,000 years ago, and the last glaciers retreated from Minnesota about 9000 years ago. Global warming started about 15,000 years ago, and without it Minnesota would be a vast desert covered in a mile thick layer of ice.

The effect of global warming on Minnesota is pretty obvious: without it there would be no Minnesota to govern.

In some ways, it makes sense for Pawlenty to visit the arctic, if he were to take away the real lesson offered there: without the global warming that has occurred over the last 15,000 years, Minnesota and much of the Northern Hemisphere would be as barren of life as the arctic is today.

But of course, that is not his intent. Instead, Pawlenty seems inclined to jump on the climate change bandwagon while it can still help his political career. Known as a strong fiscal conservative in a state with a liberal bent, he appears to be doing nothing more than burnishing his credentials for those seeking a “moderate.”

It would be a matter of little consequence if Governor Pawlenty were just another Midwest Governor seeking the limelight and the approval of the chattering classes, but he is not. As Chair of the National Governor’s association Pawlenty wields considerable power over the agenda of that organization.

Contrary to the scaremongering being pushed by the media today, few credible scientists would stake their careers, no less the world economy, on predictions of disasters due to human-induced climate change. In fact, there is a long list of credible scientists who have staked their careers and reputations on questioning climate change, and their stories can be found in a wonderful series written by Lawrence Sullivan of the Canada Post. Climate change skeptics include even Al Gore’s mentor, Dr. Roger Revelle. When Revelle disagreed with Gore, Gore insisted that he was senile.

Why do these scientists go out on a limb when it would be easier to go along to get along? Just about every testable prediction that climate scaremongers have made has turned out to be false.

Take the current hurricane season, or for that matter last year’s. Both were predicted by the Climate scaremongers to be among the worst in human history, but instead they have been among the quietest.

Contrary to their predictions, Polar Bear populations have been steady or increasing, and are so populous that hunting them is legal.

And most importantly, contrary to their predictions, human life spans are increasing and by any measure human well-being is at its all-time high in human history. In fact, if one were to plot average global temperatures along with human well-being, there is pretty much a one-to-one correlation between a warmer earth and better standards of living and human population growth.

Unfortunately, for politicians the facts are entirely beside the point, because studying the facts would get in the way of those trying to grasp enormous amounts of money and power at the expense of the average citizen.

Governor Pawlenty’s trip to the Arctic this spring is a purely symbolic move. Climate science will not be advanced one iota. If anything, his trip will further the propaganda of those with everything to gain and nothing to lose if their “science” proves faulty.

But it will also, he calculates, advance his political career. Just as the Climate Scare has advanced the careers of Al Gore, the scientists who are enjoying a 10-fold increase in government spending on climate research, and the phony “carbon trading” schemers who are making out like bandits while the rest of us fork over our freedoms to them.

The question Governor Pawlenty should be asking is this: what would the effect on human population of reducing carbon emissions by 80%? In a state with a climate that mirrors Siberia, I would suggest that the consequences would be very grave indeed. Millions of Minnesotans freezing in the dark, unable to travel because their cars have no gasoline, and unable to heat their homes because natural gas and electricity production are far from carbon neutral does not look like a good future to most Minnesotans.

So let me suggest a better trip for Governor Pawlenty than the one to the Arctic this spring: try living a Minnesota winter without the power and heat sources that emit carbon dioxide. Try eating only locally produced food in the middle of Winter. Avoid using the State car and walk to the Capitol some morning when it is 30 below zero outside.

Because that is what life would be like if the policies he is proposing truly were enforced.

Something tells me that asking Minnesotans to truly make those sacrifices might not enhance Pawlenty’s political career quite so much as he thinks.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

David Strom is the President of the Minnesota Free Market Institute. He hosts a weekly radio show on AM-1280 "The Patriot" in Minneapolis-St. Paul, available on podcast at Townhall.com.

Be the first to read David Strom's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Global Warming Morons
Rush reported a story last winter of a Global Warming Moron who went to The Arctic to document THE DEVASTATION Global Warming was causing. This Idiot lost 2 TOES TO FROST BITE!

maybe
Shouldn't the good Governor be more worried about using some his budget money to fix the substandard bridges in his state, instead of going on a global warming jaunt? It seems that his priorities need to be recalibrated.

good thing we averted
that ozone hole crisis a decade or two ago...LOL.

When will people learn not to lap up everything that comes from the fear-mongers mouths?

T-Paw the liberal in republican clothing
Tim Pawlenty, Tim Pawlenty, Tim Pawlenty. I hate to say this, I voted for him. I supported him, I backed him, I wanted him as my governor...Man did he trick me!

Oh, he was good when he voted down the largest tax increase in MN history, but now...TIM WHAT THE SHATNER are you thinking!!!

We had a huge tax surplus, HUGE, and Tim STOLE that money. If you buy a pop (soda for those of you not in MN) and you give the store clerk a 5 dollar bill you expect $3.75 back right? NOT in MN. If you overpay your taxes in MN Tim Pawlenty keeps your change and uses it for GLOBAL WARMING!!! I want my change Tim!!! I want my money back, it is not yours it is mine and I dont want it going to a half baked theory built in lies!

I want Minnesota to learn from California, recall Pawlenty and replace him someone better. I hear Goldy the U of M mascot is not doing anything today.

To Strom:
And your point is?

Does it go something like this? Heaven help us
if any politician has a touch of green in his/
her makeup?

Politics, not science
Are we really so shocked or concerned that a politician will go to almost any extreme to increase his approval ratings?

Does it matter whether our global warming fears are reasonable or unfounded?

Does it matter whether we can (or should) do anything to combat the problem?

No, no and no!

Global Warming
Pawlenty has refused to listen to anyone for any information about the arguments against the GW panic control freaks. He had the gall to send out a request for money this week to his supporters. Not a dime, Gov, not a dime.

As for where did MN get is liberal leftists? I'm a transplant so coming in from the outside (albeit a long time ago), guilt is a big component of the leftist/socialist mindset here. We actually had a very active Communist party on the Iron Range (NE MN for non MN's). MN has not had to content with a significant minority population so they talk the talk but don't walk the walk. They ignore real change. There are a ton of wealthy districts in this state - mostly Democrat - that's where the power is.

Remember, this is the state that gave the country Hubert Humphrey (he did clean up MPls. from the mob).

Science & the Rat
Have you read the "The Rat That Schook the World"? It runs for hours: Lives longer: More Sex: Eats without gaining weight. Now here's you a prize in the make'n.

Hummmmm...puts me in mind of my widowed father-in-law.

Pols like GW because they see
higher taxes:

more taxes on all transportation--including the family car

more taxes on any kind of energy--and making you decided whether to heat or cool your house

more taxes on energy companies--as if pols drill for oil and steer tankers around the Horn of Africa

and more taxes to assuage liberal guilt for being human and living on the earth now

Boo! Hiss!
Our governor has NO BUSINESS fighting global warming. This is Minnesota, fer gosh darn sakes! It NEEDS warming.

I hear tell we're in for our first snow next Tuesday.

Does the governor really approve of that sort of thing???????

Weight shift, gyroscopic wobble.
Think of billions of tons. If you take tons of mass (oil) and move it from one side of the planet to the other the gyroscopic principle wobbles to the weight shift. Fortunately contained within the harmony of spheres, yet does not stop the top of the planet tilting toward the sun more, and the bottom away. Hence the North Pole warmer the South Pole colder.
I have yet to hear this discussed once,
To me it seems like what could be truth is ignored or hidden, why?



Oh, man, I had to laugh!
Column: "Is Governor Tim Pawlenty looking to get a Nobel Peace Prize by following in the wake of Al Gore?"


Well, that IS a pretty wide wake!


Think of the possibilities for slipstreaming!




MN and GW
GW in Minn....LOL....Mr. Paw is trying to sell ice cubes to eskimos????!! Or sand in the desert!

Gee
Can Mr. Paw come & fix Michigan too?

Sorry Minnesota, you are too small-time for Mr. P. He is running for governor of the world. He can't be bogged down with Minnesota's problems.

Surely he uses his own money to travel around the Arctic and he does it on his own time during vaction since it has NOTHING to do with governing Minnesota.


viruddh
How's the kool-aid?

Can't politicians just wear green? Since you are not at all concerned about reality or what a governor's job is, that should be enough.

BTW - warming Earth = more GREEN.
Cooling Earth = less GREEN.

Too much Kool-aid = GREEN PARTY.




So what has changed?
renny writes: Friday, November, 02, 2007 11:13 PM "Pols like GW because they see higher taxes"

Strom gets it:
"those trying to grasp enormous amounts of money and power at the expense of the average citizen."

History gets it:

"He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harrass our people, and eat out their substance."

Wait till the Federal Department of Lifestyle and Enviroment knock on your door, or fight now. Our chains are being forged.


This is just another ploy
Both parties have their issues. Global warming is a great issue for a politician to embrace. We don't know what causes it, we don't know how to fight it, we can scare everyone into voting against it, and it will never come back to haunt you, because if it does disappear, you can take credit for eliminating it.

If only this audience could see that the Republicans have an issue just like this: We don't know what causes terrorism, we don't know how to fight terrorism, we can scare everyone into voting against terrorism, and it will never come back to haunt you, because if terrorism does disappear, you can take credit for eliminating it.

Perfect issues.

Vote for common sense. Vote Ron Paul.

“Lysenkoism
Recently several TH blogs addressed atheism and I choose to get in the middle of the fighting. One of my comments referred that atheists have zero concept of the Four Seasons and the notion of “abundance”. To atheists food is delivered in a truck. I am sure some bone atheists grow marijuana or attend to the organic food craze, but that is a far distance from family truck farming and growing market sustainable crops.

“Lysenkoism is a term given to the repressive political and social campaigns undertaken in science and agriculture by the powerful Stalinist director of the Soviet Institute of Genetics, Trofim Denisovich Lysenko and his followers, which began in the late 1920s. (AMERICAN THINKER; James Lewis, 10/02/2007) Soviet mass-media presented Lysenko as a genius who had developed a new, revolutionary agricultural techniques. During this period, Soviet propaganda often focused upon inspirational stories of peasants who, through their own canny ability and intelligence, came up with solutions to practical problems. Lysenko's widespread popularity provided him a platform to denounce theoretical genetics and to promote his own agricultural practices. He was, in turn, supported by the Soviet propaganda machine, which overstated his successes and omitted mention of his failures. Instead of making controlled experiments, Lysenko relied upon questionnaires taken of farmers to claim that vernalization increased wheat yields by fifteen percent.” (Wikipedia)

My closing remarks about atheist agriculture was that the Russian people starved

MINNESOTANS OUT THE CRATS
Minnesota is a classic case of Vermontization; ergo, single party control of key districts and precincts and control the state. Sixty percent of Minneapolis, sixty percent of St. Paul add seventy percent in Bemidji, Northfield Mankato and voila the Crats have the whole bag. Vermont is Burlington plus a few other precincts to control. NYC controls New York State and Cook County controls Illinois.
It is an ugly game but Crats are ugly and they play ugly. But there are some beautiful solutions and we will prevail. There is clear evidence the Crats are desperate. In spite of all the mendacity the Crats are running off the cliff. Positively predict a year from now the Global Warming-Climate Change mirage will be no more.
Attended prep school and college in StP. The people in MN are not all Mondale or Ventura idiots. Education and public health remain priorities and the Twin Cities have grown ten fold since I was a teenager. They deserve highest regards and better government then what Crats can provide.

Why Spring?
These politicians will visit the Arctic in the spring when the weather gets warmer and all the weight of heavy compacted snow from the winter will cause the sides of these glaciers to fall off. This is a natural event every spring. So these kook politicians will go up there and say see, the glaciers are falling into the sea because of global warming! Why don't they go up there in the beginning or middle of the winter?
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.