Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, December 19, 2008
Dan Gainor :: Townhall.com Columnist
Media's Gas Price Crystal Ball is Murky
by Dan Gainor
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


News by its very nature is unpredictable. Too bad many journalists don’t seem to understand that fact.

Ever since gasoline prices began a wild ride in 2004, the media have been obsessed with predicting future energy prices. Gasoline, we were told, would hit $5 a gallon. Or $6, or $7. Or maybe even $12 or $15.

The predictions were consistently wrong. ABC, NBC and CBS, who can seldom get current events correct, are even worse guessing future news. In fact, for most of 2008, network news stories that predicted oil or gas prices were wrong nearly two-thirds of the time (63 percent).

Two-thirds? You’d be better off flipping a coin or even counting on an NFL referee. Not one network report had guessed that gas would drop to $1.66, the current national average.

Journalists weren’t content with reporting high prices. They had to warn those prices would go higher – much higher. In 2008, they got their wish. Sort of.

Gas started the year near $3 a gallon and oil near $100. Network reporters hyped each daily increase -- $3.50, $3.75 and finally $4. CBS’s Ben Tracy told viewers in his March 10 broadcast of “the rude awakening that high gas prices are here to stay.” Other stories bemoaned the impact on truckers who had to cope with “over $1,000 a fill-up.”

But those stratospheric prices weren’t enough for journalists who live by hype. CNBC quoted Robert Hirsch, a Management Information Services Senior Energy Advisor, saying: “others who watch this very closely forecast that we're going to be hitting $12 and $15 a gallon, and then, after that, when world oil production goes into decline, we're going to talk about rationing."

ABC’s Charles Gibson zeroed in on the fear du jour on his July 11 broadcast. “We told you earlier that crude prices hit another new record today, which has analysts warning that $4 a gallon gas may become a permanent fact of life.” Gas prices began to decline just a week later and dropped below $4 a gallon before the month was out.

And they kept right on falling – for 86 days straight. Even media outlets desperate for doom and gloom should acknowledge that’s big news. Few reports did so. Instead, the networks tried to predict how low gas prices would go, which they also got wrong by underestimating the price collapse.

No one says predicting energy prices is easy. It isn’t. Every group that tried failed – oil experts, government officials and, of course, journalists. But that didn’t stop those same journalists from trying again and again. CBS warned of the “triple threat” of “falling home values, empty nesters returning to the city, and sky-high gas prices.” These were supposedly “driving suburbia to the brink.” Correspondent Ben Tracy warned of a suburban housing disaster by 2025 and that “there will be a surplus of 22 million large-lot homes in suburban areas.”

This oil and gas price information comes from a new study by the Business & Media Institute, which analyzed evening news 548 stories about oil and gas during 2008 from Feb. 11, when gas prices hit an early season low point, to the end of November. The results show that supposed experts were wrong both about how high prices would go and then the price collapse that followed.

It wasn’t just the predictions that were wrong, of course. Reporters ignored the impact of lifting the ban on offshore drilling. President Bush made that move on July 14, the day oil closed at its all-time high of $145. The steep drop started the very next day.

Journalists also chose to focus only on the bad news of energy prices. When prices were rising, newscasts were awash in oil and gas stories – 114 just in July. And rightly so. The cost of energy rippled through everything from food and travel to the stock market. One estimate said $1 on the price of oil meant $1 billion out of consumer pockets. But when those prices dropped, those issues were no longer important – even though that meant a savings of $100 billion. In November, as gas prices dropped to less than half their highs, there were just 26 stories.

One of the biggest national news stories of 2008 had ceased to become important because it became good news and the media were predictably absent.

OPEC is moving aggressively to increase the price of oil and gas prices might soon follow. Though it is hard to guess the future, I predict the media will continue to get gas prices wrong.

OK, some predictions are easier than others.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Dan Gainor is The Boone Pickens Free Market Fellow and director of the Media Research Center’s Business & Media Institute.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Libs. love high energy prices
They think it punishes capitalism, and it does.

What they don't get is when they want to fly to some party in Europe or Mexico, planes need gas to fly on, and companies have to be able to afford the fuel in order to fly the planes.

One of the most lib. industries and most energy intensive is entertainment. The lights used to illuminate a stage are as bright as a constant bank of flashbulbs. You do not need photo flashes to take pix onstage.

I once saw a night scene from Law and Order being being filmed in Morningside Heights (just south of Harlem), and the entire block was surrounded by 18-wheeler-sized containers that were the battery trucks for the tv lights. It took a powerful amount of energy to recharge those trucks.

Paul Newman and Toms Cruise used to drive Formula 1 race cars as hobbies, cars capable of 250 mph, and which prob. use as much gasoline in one race circuit as I use in a year. And yet both, altho' Newman is recently deceased, bill themselves as *green* environmentalists.

So does Julia Roberts who has solar pannels on her ranch but flies privately to movie openings and events. DeCaprio just bought into a *green* building in NYC, but when he filmed *The Beach,* the movie crew left a wreck of the Pacific island used as a set.

It reminds me of River Phoenix, a very promising actor, who bragged he was a vegetarian--no meat shall pass these lips, but he died with seven mostly illegal drugs in his system that gave him seizures and death. It wasn't the meat that killed him.

The Problem with low gas prices
When the price of gas pushed past $4.00 per gallon, it got the people's attention. With the exception of those whose income levels allowed for such an incredible impact to their budgets, most, to include many businesses were stretched to the max.

The good news, the people finally saw through the idiocy of prohibiting the exploitation of our own abundant oil, coal and natural gas resources. Now that the price of gas has fallen to its lowest price in many years, that realization is still there but the urgency to address this asinine prohibition has once again been pushed to the back burner.

The demand to "Drill Here, Drill Now" and "Drill Baby Drill" has lost its volume. However, between Barack Obama's naive energy policies and a Democrat controlled Congress that will once again ban domestic production of oil, the nebulous predictions of the media may still materialize.

Sadly, the people will not continue to push our useless government to get off their fluffy butts and get on with the business of tapping one of our greatest sources of energy, not to mention revenue until we are a bankrupt and broken nation. At, which point it, will no longer matter, we will have achieved third world status.

Oil is a commodity
Oil is bought and sold on the open market. That's what determines the real price. Government will always tax the use and sale of oil and oil products. We must learn that oil is too precious a commodity to waste as fuel. It has too many other uses (plastics, medicine et al). Until there is a viable alternative, we should at least be using our own oil and tell OPEC to go flip themselves.

By the way, Paul Newnam and the phony Cruise never drove F1. Racers they are (were), but not F1. Also F1 uses about 250 liters per race. Do you uses that little in a year?

Gas/Oil Prices
I've been telling friends and family to not become comfortable with current gas prices JUST yet. With Democrats in control of the legislative and executive branches of government after Jan 20th, the push and race to expand domestic oil production will collapse under the assault and re-instatement of the offshore oil bans. When foreign oil producers see we are NOT serious about drilling for our own resources they will simply begin another long steady increase in the price of their oil. The resulting price of gasoline will (inmho) reach $6 per gallon by Jan 2010. Ad they will be right. They've already seen us willing to pay $4.50, so they know we're "good for it." Most of those to whom I throw this prediction simply say "Naaaaah.......it wont happen." Someone once said "Denial is not a river in Egypt." One year. Mark it on your calendars.

Scrap Iron
You are partially right--oil is a commodity and it is sold on the open market. It does not respond to the normal pressures of supply and demand because supply is controlled by a cartel.Normal market forces, if allowed to work, would make oil a true world wide commodity with competition driving prices.

Uh Huh
"Reporters ignored the impact of lifting the ban on offshore drilling. President Bush made that move on July 14, the day oil closed at its all-time high of $145. The steep drop started the very next day."

One of the many things President Bush doesn't get credit for from the MSM.

No shopping to do?
I dont recall any broadcast or news article concerning oil or gas prices that didnt quote or reference an industry spokesperson or statistic. And I am on the wire 18 hrs a day.
THE MEDIA is not responsible for your no news day.

What is news is that while oil prices have continued to decline, retail has now leveled off, proving again that the connection between prices at the pump and oil wholesale are loosely connected if at all.

Care to put your motives where your mouth is and try writing about something that matters?

michigander
You bring out a good point. Why would just saying "boo" to the oil futures market bring down prices?
I wonder....oh subliminal message - "time to take your profits and run" my oil business friends. And run all the way to the bank.

james
How did you find out that Palin was taking a pay cut?

Congress should get no increase until 2012.

No$
"What is news is that while oil prices have continued to decline, retail has now leveled off, proving again that the connection between prices at the pump and oil wholesale are loosely connected if at all."

I agree. Oil has dropped about $3 this week, but gas at my local station has remained a constant $1.68. Gasoline rises immediately on just a rumor of high oil prices, but it's slow to come down on "actual" low oil prices. Go figure. Very "loosely connected" indeed.

Michigander
The operators of gas stations have to make back the cost of the fuel plus a few cents profit. If they bought 1000 gals at $!.68, that means they have to sell it for enough to finance the next fuel delivery, even if the price has gone down in the meantime. If they dropped their price at the pump whenever the price of oil drops, they couldn't make enough profit to buy another 1000 gallons.

On the other hand, if they don't raise the price at the pump soon after oil prices jump, they won't make enough from their fuel to finance the next tanker full.

It's just like someone who lives from payday to payday. They don't make enough profit from selling gas to build in a cushion. Governments - local, state and federal - make on average about $.70 off each gallon sold, PLUS they take a percentage of the oil companies profit, while the gas station operator generally makes about $.06 - .07 cents.

Not sure if all my figures are currently accurate, but I do know a lot more about the petroleum industry than say, Bill O'Reilly, OR CONGRESS!!!

james
just read reply #7. I'm not laughing. What I read there is a cry for help. You choose to be a bigot but racism is taught. For a better life change your associations.

Obama's Gas Price Crystal Ball 1

With his latest Cabinet appointee, he can help Nancy Pelosi complete her job, [who in her own words on July 29 while in the midst of $4.00 p/gallon plus gasoline prices, and not even allowing for a vote in the House on drilling, and against the will of over 73% of the American public, declared: "I'm trying to save the planet; I'm trying to save the planet."
Obama, yesterday, picked Berkeley Lab Director Steve Chu for Energy Secretary, who told the Wall Street Journal in September:

"Somehow we have to figure out how to boost the price of gasoline to the levels in Europe."

Chu said he favors gradually ramping up gasoline taxes over 15 years to nudge [read: extort]consumers into buying cars that are more fuel efficient and homes that are closer to work.

Chu spoke with the WSJ in September but the newspaper didn't publish the tax comments until last week, shortly after he was identified as Obama's nominee for Energy secretary.

http://sec.online.wsj.com/article/SB122904040307499791.html

Is this the "change we can believe in" that Obama was talking about.

How does this insanely radical nutjob's proposal not mean a tax increase for the Middle class?

Is this a tax break?

...why, yes!

...guaranteed to break one off in your @$$

the joke's on us
Objective and truthful reporting by the Media has become the exception rather than the rule. Like Congress, they have forgotten their responsibilities and purpose in pursuit of hidden agendas and self-indulgent crusades. We have traded our freedom for political correctness, our basic rights; life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, are in serious jeopardy because we have lost sight of whats truly important, instead our leaders lie, pander and with the Media's help, manipulate us to believe that something is being done to make us energy independent. The truth is, nothing can compete at this point with hydro-carbons for price and efficiency. Unless we make a commitment to utilizing our own resources, we will continue to send billions of dollars to people that despise us, how unreal is that?

Obama's Gas Price Crystal Ball 2

This coupled with Obama's saying:

"The problem is not technical, and the problem is not sufficient mastery of the legislative intricacies of Washington."

"The problem is can you get the American people to say this is really important and force [force?] their representatives to do the right thing? That requires mobilizing a citizenry [read: brainwash with global warming nonsense]. That requires them [the ignorant masses] understanding what is at stake, and climate change [we need to stop the climate from changing,i.e.,contol the universe's thermostat from a secret bunker in Al Gore's basement, I suppose] is a great example."

"When I was asked earlier about the issue of coal...under my plan of cap and trade system, electricity rates would necessarily skyrocket...even regardless of what I say about whether coal is good or bad, because I'm capping greenhouse gases, coal power plants, natural gas...you name it...whatever the plants were [note past tense],whatever the industry was, they would have to retro-fit their operations."

From the donkey's [read: @$$'s mouth]:

1.Higher gasoline prices & taxes

2. Skyrocketing electricity rates ["necessarily"]

Change you can believe in?

...absolutely.

Aren't we going to be so-o-o much better off now that we have a good president like Barack Hussein Obama?

...I can't wait...

...can you say...pass the Vaseline?

Restrict Energy, Limit Freedom,
Does anyone else find it odd that once high gas prices triggered the inevitable collapse of the poor-grade 30x leveraged mortgage debt that had fueled the bogus "Clinton's Great Economy" of the '90's & now formed the basis of our financial system, they fell back to right around pre-Katrina levels? Does the word "bubble" come to mind in this connection?

Everything about the anti-energy ranting and "climate change" dogma has to do with facilitating leftist big-government agendas & attacking the American way of life & std of living.

All this obsession over "sprawl" & "McMansions" (the latter due to the destruction of creditworthiness standards thanks to CRA) & carphobia, is rooted in the desire of the elite to corral us into little boxes in cities where we will be subject to hi taxes, untouchable criminals, gun bans, officious bureaucrats running every aspect of life, public-employees unions, city budgets treated like windfalls to be gifted to supporters, public schools run by federal judges' fiats, & so on.

One circumstance that has irked and frustrated leftie elitists since the 1970's has been our ability to simply drive away from their urban disasters. Energy is freedom, & their strategy is to restrict our ability to get & use energy so we have to live where & as they say.

The REAL impact of energy restrictions is felt w/ heavy industry. The elites have been trying to eliminate heavy industry in the US for decades, & the "climate change" dogma will probably complete the process.

There is so much more to it tho. Our present ruling elite seem poised to reduce America to 3rd world status & a province of the UN.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.