Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, August 28, 2009
Dan Kennedy :: Townhall.com Columnist
Front Page to Back Page to No Page: the Outrage that Went Away
by Dan Kennedy
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



Immediately following Obama's coup at General Motors, and near-takeover of Chrysler as well, there was about two weeks of news coverage of the shocking number of dealerships summarily, and seemingly arbitrarily, put out of business.

The demand for explanation of why and how one dealership was killed, while another was spared execution, was ever so briefly loud, then quieted, and finally silenced. This front page story moved to the back pages and, in short order, to oblivion - and the questions it raised were never answered.

Case in point: Ron Marhofer, the owner of Marhofer Chevrolet in the little burg of Stow, Ohio, got one of those letters informing him that his dealership would be closed. As of October 2010, its doors would be closed, and its 80 employees' jobs killed, although his access to new inventory would stop immediately after the 20 cars already on order.

You might think, well, it's a small town dealership not selling enough cars to make it worth Government Motors' trouble supplying it, but this dealership, in business since 1933, is the county's oldest Chevy dealer, and it has been having a banner year. While the auto market nationwide is down 40 percent, Marhofer's new car sales are up 57 percent for 2009 – that is before the cash for clunkers nonsense. In each of the past two years, this was the top selling Chevy dealership in the entire county. A competing dealership two communities away, in this same county, is not having such a good year, but it was apparently chosen to profit from Marhofer's execution.

When Marhofer pressed GM for explanation of his dealership being selected for slaughter, he was told "We can't tell you." One wonders who has dictated to GM that it can't explain. Since Mr. Marhofer and his 80 employees are tax payers and, thus, actually own GM, it would seem particularly reasonable for them to demand and get a rational explanation for their execution. Even in most communist or dictator-run countries, some charge is brought and at least a mock trial is conducted before sentence passed. The victim is given some reason for his beheading.

Of course the fates of Mr. Marhofer, his paltry 80 employees, and the employees at other small businesses near his dealership, are of no measurable consequence to you or me or, certainly, the Great and Wonderful Ozbama. He has bigger fish to fry, but multiply Marhofer times a hundred and you're talking 8,000 jobs. If you multiply by two hundred, it's 16,000 jobs - good blue collar jobs for mechanics and service techs, and clerical jobs held by working moms. In Congress and the media, much shouting has gone on much longer over much less.

Not to mention the principle at stake here - a family's equity in its business built out of the Great Depression and sustained over generations has been arbitrarily wiped away at the stroke of a pen, and it is refused explanation. The President's Car Czar's grubby fingerprints are most certainly on the pen, should the CSI crew investigate.

Obama has been sending messages. He has told CEO's, I will fire you at will, take your company, impose new and arbitrary capital requirements, rules and governing czars as I please. You serve at my pleasure. With the savaging of the small businesses in the auto industry, he has told all of us who own small businesses that he can with impunity shutter our doors, dismiss our employees and destroy all we have worked for. With the mercifully short-lived "snitch" web site, he threatened critics of his health care takeover. His Democrats in Congress intimidate the insurance companies with threats of dragging CEO's to televised hearings, holding up receipts from some resort sales conference and demanding explanation for the steaks and shrimp cocktails.

Ron Marhofer now knows what everyone else will learn: whatever you think you own, you don't. The only power is Obama's. The only rights you have are those he decides, day to day, to let you have.

To their shame, the media has let this story go, even though there's good chance there's a Watergate buried in it somewhere. Killing the successful auto dealers, while sparing the less successful, is most likely a political rather than equitable or rational decision.

They let the story go, even though it illustrates the dire threat to anyone who thinks they actually own anything, they actually have no control over anything.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Dan Kennedy is a serial entrepreneur and contributor to the Business & Media Institute.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.

 
Popular Articles By Kennedy

Given the Goebbels' School takeover
... of the world's mass media; that almost every one of the propagandist pamphleteers presently pretending to be be "pressman" is but a "Democratic" potty plant who'd make his patron proud -- and that the sail-eared simpleton's National Socialist/Statists seek to impose their freaking fasciSSocialism on us -- what hope the preservation of the beloved fraternal republic?

Brian Richard Allen :.
Lost Angels - Califokennedycated 90028
And the Far Abroad

Talent Scout
Reply # 3
Date: Aug 29, 2009 - 4:46 PM EST

Your comment: "This is going to lead to violence at some point, and that also is planned for by this administration." This has been a real concern of mine also, for these reasons.
All of the ugly comments made by Democrats against the Tea Party and Townhall particpants are very divisive with the intentions to shut us down.

Obama's speeches pit one group against another if you listen carefully you can pick up on it.
A good leader, "of all Americans" would make an effort to seek union among the people, not disunion.

All of the radicals that he has appointed as Czars and their associates are not there for solutions, they want their agendas put in operation. I listened to Van Jones, the admitted Communist, who is the energy Czar, speak yesterday at the "Minority Small Business Conference." He's a poor speaker with no substances. Everything he said about energy savings is already being done around this country in every community. Why do we need a separate Minority Business Conference? Why not a Small Business Conference where everyone can attend?

Now the DNC is sending out paid activists to disrupt the townhall meetings. This is deliberately pitting one group against another.

If there are any efforts by ACORN, SEIU, The New Black Panthers and other groups to interfer with the elections next year, I believe there can be serious confrontations.

There is a video posted on World Net Daily's website today that shows a policeman threatening to arrest a man going to a Townhall meeting in VA because he did not like the poster the man was carrying that showed Obama as a Socialist. The man said he had a right to, after a few more words exchanged the man said, "This is American". The policeman answered, "Not anymore".

It made my blood boil.

Keep this story alive!!
This artical highlights the failure of the media tobe the voice of the people. The govt actions regarding the automakers is an astonishing attack on the very foundations of capitalism. Obliterating bond holders' rights stands right alongside the "taking of property (dealerships) without just compensation". Where is the outrage?!? Please keep this story alive. jim, PA

What is going on?
I'm a granny and I really don't comprehend what is happening. It appears for the last 40 to 50 years we have been paying reparations for all our past sins and it still isn't enough. If you donate to the right party or person, you keep your dealership; or is that it? What will happen to the USA with the national debt in the trillions and still going up? Is it to weaken the country or is more pretty ominous change coming? Will we ever have an honest election anymore? Maybe I'll just go visit one of Oz's death panels.

A violation of law
As a life long General Motors buyer and having worked at a local Chevy for twenty years before I chaged jobs , I can asure the UAW that I will never purchase another vehicle made by them. The outrage that I have over the bond holders not getting thier day in court will not subside. If everyone stops buying cars made by these gangsters perhaps justice will prevail

IT'S GONNA GET WORSE FOLKS !
This is an excerpt from The National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, Inc., from whom I received a weekly newsletter. I subscribe to it because of the card check legislation, and having been an owner of three different businesses:

"Ron Bloom, the former United Steelworkers (USW) union bigwig appointed by President Barack Obama as “car czar” earlier this year is now poised to oversee ALL American manufacturing.

That’s right, a union boss whose forced unionism dogma destroys jobs, crushes employee free choice, and cripples the country’s competitiveness will soon be in charge of America’s entire industrial policy.

Bloom’s appointment and pending promotion are just pieces in the pattern of Obama’s shameless payback to the union bosses who got him elected.

What’s so troubling about Bloom’s ascendancy is the obvious connection between forced unionism and the debacle of General Motors and Chrysler in Detroit.

As the chief policy maker on manufacturing, Bloom would be charged with reviewing U.S. competitiveness in the global economy. His job would likely encompass trade, taxes and other economic issues . . .

Just what American industry needs: another "czar" whose relevant work experience involves running struggling companies into the ground and exploiting their workers. We're sure industry leaders across the country are thrilled at the prospect of taking orders from a union czar.

The result of this personnel move seems likely to be more forced unionism, less American competitiveness, more job losses, and ultimately more bankruptcies and taxpayer-funded bailouts of corruptly run union pension plans."

My intentions are to address this issue at the next town hall meeting I attend.

We are already under fascism
So when does the rebellion begin is the only question.
But then again, it has began.

This is going to lead to violence at some point, and that also is planned for by this administration

America's in deep trouble
I hope and pray our country can make it to 2010 and 2012. 2010 is 15 months away. 2012 is 3.5 years away. Obama and his corrupt cronies can do a lot of damage in that time.

However, in November of 2010 & 2012 we can take back our country by getting rid of ALL liberals (Dem or Rep) in Congress and make sure those who are elected to replace them will actually defend our country and our Constitution... and undo all of the Usurper-in-Chief's destruction.

'The ONLY Power Is Obama's'
Hi Dan,

You said,

"Ron Marhofer now knows what everyone else will learn: whatever you think you own, you don't.

"The only power is Obama's.

"The only rights you have are those he decides, day to day, to let you have.

- - - -

Dan, your short article is accurate, but, something's MISSING... and that's a CALL TO ACTION a la Glenn Beck this week.

Before watching Glenn Beck's series this week of August 24 - 28 about who is advising Obama and Obama's apparent (or is it deliberate?) implementation of the 'Cloward / Piven Strategy' of overwhelming our capitalist system to bring it down (as in the 'crisis' / bankruptcy of New York when Guliani named them by name) and build a new 'social justice' (communist) system, I might have accepted the tacit acquiesence of ownership to the usurper-in-chief re: the stimulus money and the takeover of General Motors to Government Motors... but not now.

Obama has NO POWER!!!!

He has only intimidation because WE THE PEOPLE respect the authority of our constitution AS WRITTEN... not as Obama has interpreted it.

WE... the PEOPLE... must DEMAND that the 'communerd' and 'Lenin wanna be' POTUS Obama CEASE and DESIST his dismantaling of our constitutional republic in his 'communerd' and 'Lenin wanna be' image.

He MUST be brought to account and Obama MUST answer Glenn Becks's questions...

Does Obama know about and thus condone the inclusion into his inner circle of Advisors/Czars such self-proclaimed marxists / communists such as Green Jobs Advisor/Czar Van Jones and Mark Lloyd and Jeff Jones and assorted others who are merely anti-capitalists?

Check out the YouTube videos, especially the Monday segment 'The Cloward/Piven Strategy In A Nutshell' for a big picture quick overview.

Auto Dealers
I spent a number of years in the auto industry, including 5 years as a dealer. I was forced out of the business thanks to Jimmy Carter and high interest rates back in the early '80's. That was long ago and far away. Nevertheless, I do retain some knowledge of the business and the relationship between the manufacturers and their dealer networks. When the dealership closings were announced, I was really puzzled. I couldn't understand why the Obama administration was imposing this draconian action. I still don't get it. Dealerships exist to sell the manufacturers' products. They don't cost the manufacturers anything; they make money for the manufacturers and, of course, for the people who own the dealerships. They also provide thousands of jobs. So why close so many of them down? And why can't those who were forced out of business get any answers from the government and their former suppliers? Something dark and devious went on here, and it was just a harbinger of things to come. More of Obama's questionable agenda is emerging every day. We must STOP THIS MADNESS before he completely remakes our country in his socialistic image.

Front page to back...
Remember, the reason for the dealer closings that was advanced by the obama Task Force, was stated to be a 'business decision' by the industry to close under performing dealerships. There was even talk in the media that there were sales performance criteria, which had to be met for a dealership to stay open.

Those stories were soon exposed as the bilge they were, when many profitable dealerships were dropped and small underperforming ones kept open.

The story just gets more and more crooked as we go along. Now we are treated to the third act of this little B.S. scenario as Chrysler and GM move back in to areas they deserted and open new franchises with dealers, who curiously are mostly competitors of the dealers who were closed.

There may have been criteria but they had absolutely nothing to do with sales or with any 'business decision' by the industry...

This has been nothing short of a criminal operation, from the beginning.

Marhofer's views
I can't assess Mr. Marhofer's political views, but he advertises heavily on Christian Radio in Cleveland. That may be enough to get you shut down with the bunch in control now.

St. Denis
Not only was contract law abrogated, but the arbitrary closing of dealerships violated franchise laws in several states. Obama's version of the Golden Rule - I's got the gold, I make the rules.

Bankrupt Administration
Obama is a facist.

The Sleeping Awake
We bought a big old house in the early '60's. After moving in my mother found some interesting things in the attic. One of them caused her to call the FBI. It was a huge flow chart showing the Communist Party plan for the take-over of the USA.

Everything was targeted including churches, Boy Scouts and local city councils. She spent her short life banging her head against the wall trying to get the frogs to realize the water was slowly getting hotter.

She always regretted handing that document over to the FBI. Live and learn.

http://www.barbaradcrone.blogspot.com/

Where is our Catherine Graham
who single-handedly funded the WaterGate investigation effort, telling those two clowns she didn't care what they had to do, she wanted Nixon out of the White House (now the white HOUSE with its current rezidentura). But then, we'd actually need a more balanced media to help spread the (in this case) facts as they so eloquently spread so many lies during the 70s.

Obama, Disrespectful Disgrace to USA
Socialists Have No Decency and No Shame.
The Liberal Democrats have no shame or scruples. They will take any event and politicize it, even death. The news media is making a big ado over nothing about Obama Making a Pecedent-Setting eulogy to Senator Kennedy. This has everything to do with Barack Hussein Obama, the only POTUS that we have ever had who suffers from Narcissitic Personality Disorder, and must Be The Center Of Attention, no matter what the situation.

To use Rahm Emmannuels words, "The Death of Ted Kennedy Is A Crisis, Too Good To Let Go To Waste." They are using the death of this man to further Promote Socialized Medicine.

The Liberal Democrats have no scruples, morals or sense of decency. They will Exploit any and All Events to Their Political Advantage to Push Their Agenda and to Grab Power.

President Obama speaking at this funeral and delivering the Eulogy For Kennedy ought to Bring National Shame. The very idea that they Capitalize On Death shows you that the Liberal Socialists in this nation will Do any and everything to promote their own power.

Controlling our lives.....
the auto industry, the banks, healthcare, broadcasting and the internet (new bill)....what is next.....the food industry. I have never been a conspiracy nut, but i see a plan in place. Control our logistics/mobility, our money, our health and the information we are privy to and our ability to communicate and we will become dependent on the government and be forced to live as drones. The dismantling of our economy will do what flying planes into our buildings did not do. That only served to pi&& us off. Make no mistake, we are under attack from within and we must work to save our way of life. Our freedoms are systematically being taken and it is up to us to stop it. Get to Washington on 9/12. It is important to show up in great numbers to show that we cannot and will not be ignored.

Ron Marhofer
Ron Marhofer is a great car dealer, I know him, done business with him in the 32 years I have been in Ohio. It is just wrong to take away a dealership that is doing good. They close that one down and the one closest to us in Kent, Ohio. Now to get repairs done we have to go to the other side of town. Dan Kennedy, keep up the good work. Closong down businesses isn't helping and government run auto is not going to work. Let the people that know the business have control.

front page to back page to no page
not only did car dealers get put out of business when gov took over the auto industry, I believe that even more dealers will go down when they find they're not getting their reimbusements from "Cash for Clunkers" and that many new car buyers will go down, too because of the debt they have incurred. I think the same thing will happen to many first time homebuyers who get that $8,000 credit for buying and going into debt.

Wish I could ...
... give Dan Kennedy's essay a ten check-mark rating here. Also wish it could be forwarded to every editorial page editor in the country, gratis, to see how many would publish it.

Watch
for the "chosen people" to reopen some of those dealerships in the future, with "gummit" help, of course.
For those who forget, caucasian IS NOT what da massiah chose.

George Washington

Any taking of private property without an eminent domain or a tax issue is UNCONSTITUTIONAL. Unfortunately, Obama abrogated the Contract Clause when he stole from Peter (the pension funds belonging to Indiana school teachers, policemen, and firefighters) to pay Paul (the UAW). SCOTUS allowed this egregious violation of the US Constitution. It is a flagrant disgrace.

People, just so that you know -- Most dealerships are OWNED by the dealers, not GOVERNMENT MOTORS.

Offhand
I'd wager that the Chevy dealership contributed to the rnc. That IS what they did, that was the plan all along. Close dealerships that contribute to the repubs and give them to the dems.

Just like they are trying to tax conservative radio stations at 100% to take their licences and give them to democrats.

Spreading the wealth, you see. Hope and change.

It is unconstitutional, unethical, illegal, offensive, and very real.

Obama has declared war on America... And he is using our own money to fund the war against us.

Who will govern the governors?
If this were a private enterprise, it'd be no big deal, but Obama runs GM. If I were a closed dealership, I'd team up with the other like former-owners and get legal representation. If the gubmint owns GM, they just can't fire their "employees" without cause. But perhaps they aren't gubmint employees after all. There may be a basis for a suit. There certainly is a basis for investigating who and how dealerships were chosen for closure. Should we expect failure of this gubmit enterprise (I'm sure it won't stand on its own without gubmint $) or should we expect it to be perpetually subsidized like Amtrack? Is there no reporter willing to pursue this like Woodward and Bernstein?

Obama has increased his power by taking over GM and I say has no intention of getting out of the car business in spite of what he says. Most of what he says are lies anyway.

johninoregon
"someone who has gone out of his way to find bipartisan solutions"

Now that's funny. Name one time. Just one.

Obama wants small businesses to die..
Why would anyone want small businesses to die? Because small businesses make men free by giving them jobs and allowing them to have liberty without begging help from the Government. So it isn't odd that Obama has a "Stimulous Plan" that doesn't give any help to small businesses, but rather makes it harder for small businesses to survive, by more taxes and additional health mandates. It is his objective. Anyone who can get work from a capitalist doesn't need to be dependent on Obama and the Democrats for a government job or a handout. It is about time that we all put our strength together and showed this Government of Fascist cowards that American's don't roll over for slime.

Where are the lawyers when...
...you really need them?

If someone could show that citizens were deprived of their property (dealerships) for partisan political reasons...we would be talking bombshell stuff.

...couldn't the dispossessed dealers bring suit and get at the information (smoking gun) via the discovery process (requests for production of documents, etc.)?

I'm no lawyer...maybe St. Denis would know...I do know that if I were one of the closed dealers that I would never rest until I obtained the answer to the question of how the determination of which dealers were to be closed was made...

Your Obedient Servant,

George Washington

"mild-manned pol"??
You're joking, right? What does Obama's disposition - even assuming that characterization is accurate - have to do with anything?

As some of us have been saying since well before he was elected, it is about what he DOES, not what he SAYS (or how he says it, which is what seems to make most Lefties swoon).

But if you prefer cold hard clarity, then read what Obama's mentors and inspirations DO SAY: Frank Marshall Davis and Saul Alinsky will tell you plenty. And Obama - by his own admission - follows their lead.

Easily explainable
The little dinky dealerships that were allowed to take over the larger market of the profitable dealerships that were closed is because the dinky dealerships coughed up enough campaign money for Obama and the profitable ones didn't.

Simple as that.

Is Mr. Marhofer...
by any chance a Republican? Even worse, might he be a conservative?

Since we now live under a regime that seems to make all decisions by partisan standards, this would seem to be a useful avenue to investigate.

dreadnaught
No, you're wrong! It won't be Obama's fault.

It's Bush's fault! It's Rush Limbaugh's fault! It's Fox News's fault! It's those evil corporate Republicans in Congress's fault!

why is this so shocking?

It was only yesterday Mark Levin stated unequivocally; Obama's doing these strange things DELIBERATELY! Levin says Obama will do whatever is necessary to finally KILL our capitalist economy for good.

I stopped and thought about it. WOW!

Yeah, that's the only explanation! Obama doesn't want to save our economy. He intends to finish it off! We'll be Socialists if he's allowed to continue as president.

johninoregon
Seems to me you pulled this last week!

In your post, change the word Obama to Bush, Democrat to Republican, Conservative to Liberal, and right to left.

No, johninoregon, the whole thing on the far left is to gin up fear among Americans who are too information-deprived to recognize who their real enemies are.

Big, Bad Obama
I love this conservative effort to create the myth of the big, bad Obama. Here's an overly mild-mannered pol who is looking more and more like a go-along-to-get along corporate Democrat---someone who has gone out of his way to find bipartisan solutions despite absolutely no cooperation from the other side.

But never mind all that. The whole thing on the far right is to gin up fear among Americans who are too information-deprived to recognize who their real enemies are. The scrooges had better hope the stooges don't finally figure it all out.

they do the same to the media
Gentle Readers,

While leftist bias in the so-called 'mainstream media' pre-dates the Obama Administration, this administration has exercised more control, and frankly, used more vicious controlling tactics on the media, than any administration I can recall all the way back to Pres. Johnson.

Obama shoves car dealers around, and the media doesn't report it to a certain extent, I believe, because they fear the same treatment.

Kindest Regards to all,

I am,

John Lepant
Brighton
Colorado

( ps: I put my name & city up as a) I have very little respect for people who ' flame ' anonymously on the internet, and b) I choose not to be afraid. If you want to speak out, thats terrific, please be polite and please be
fearless! )

Brandon

I did read the article. I started seeing the socialism/fascism spouting be statists MANY years ago.

Marching On Washington


Are you waffling about going to DC on Sept. 12?

Have you even considered it?

A bunch of TH bloggers are converging on DC along with patriots from all over the country.

Will you be there?

If not, Why not?

Visit my blog to get more info.
http://fundmental.blogtownhall.com
(Or just click my nick)

Obama's Amerika
He's got what it takes to take what you've got.

Dear Leader doesn't care about how many lives he destroys. History is littered with the bodies of those that were destroyed for "The Common Good".

The Kmher Rouge, Stalin, Hitler, Mao, all heroes of the left, and all guilty of the mass murder of Millions.

These are the people that our lefty "friends" worship.


This isn't leading anywhere healthy
To "St. Denis in Obama's Red Amerika," this is a legitimate commentary. You're addressing a separate subject that doesn't even prove its own point. The notion that America is heading towards a socialist (or worse) state is proven more by Dan's commentary and Obama's sweeping actions in just 8 months, than the point you make -- and that's even assuming Chrysler did exactly what you say.

Regarding your article, Dan, I don't like this takeover of private industry. The federal government now owns a foothold in the automobile industry and banking. It has its eyes feasted upon healthcare. There's talk they want to overhaul the broadcasting industry. These are among the most sensitive and important industries in our nation.

Which industries are next?

And, People Criticize Me

For changing "America" to "Amerika".

I changed it the day that Chrysler ABROGATED CONTRACT LAW AND STOLE the pension funds of teachers, police officers, and firefighters from Indiana to give to the UAW AND WHEN GM FILED FOR BANKRUPTCY.

Recall that Obama promised that neither Chrysler or GM would file for bankruptcy.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.