Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Thursday, July 27, 2006
Chuck Colson :: Townhall.com Columnist
An unwelcome reunion
by Chuck Colson
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


If you know where to look, it’s easy to find evidence of Spain’s Islamic past: You can see it in Spanish architecture and in the faces of the people. You can hear it in Spanish music, especially flamenco, and in the Spanish language itself.

Despite these undeniable historical links between Spain and the Islamic world, Spaniards have no interest in turning back the clock, not after their ancestors spent seven centuries expelling the Muslim invaders who forced themselves on Spain. However, there is one group that remains committed to such a “reunion”: Islamist radicals.

A few weeks ago, the FBI arrested eight men in charge of plotting to blow up the underground rail tunnels that link New Jersey and New York. The suspects included members of al-Qaeda living both in and outside of the United States.

An overlooked detail in the story was the name of one of the alleged masterminds of the plot: “Emir Andalusi.” As with many terrorists, that’s not his real name but, instead, what the French call a nom de guerre, a war-time alias. And as with most such aliases, it provides an insight into his and other jihadist motivations and aspirations.

“Andalusi” comes from “Al Andalus,” the Arabic name for southern Spain, the part known as Andalusia today. As one Israeli writer has pointed out, references to “old Muslim Spain are . . . [increasingly] common among jihadists who have set themselves against the Western world.”

The best-known such reference is Osama bin Laden’s 2001 video message that declared that al-Qaeda would not permit the repeat of “the tragedy of Andalusia” in Palestine. The “tragedy” he was referring to was the expulsion of the Muslim invaders by Spanish Christian forces.

In case the Western world didn’t get the point, al-Zawahiri, al-Qaeda’s number two, “later swore that ‘the tragedy of Al Andalus’ must not be repeated.”

It isn’t just al-Qaeda that wants to force this. Hamas isn’t just interested in Israel. It has “demanded the return of the city of Seville to Islam” and what it calls “the lost paradise of Al Andalus.”

These dreams of “Al Andalus” make Spain a target as the Spanish have already learned the hard way. And Spain isn’t a target because of its policies toward the United States or the Middle East, but because its existence is regarded as a “tragedy” by the jihadists. As former Spanish Prime Minister Aznar put it, the problem with al-Qaeda has been 1,300 years in the making.

Unfortunately, the current Spanish Prime Minister, Zapatero, seems to share the same sense of denial that the British elites do as described in Melanie Phillips’s book Londonistan, which I have talked about on “BreakPoint.” He has demonstrated open contempt for Spain’s Catholic heritage while increasingly accommodating Islamic interests. Some five hundred years after the fall of the last Islamic stronghold in Spain, his government is financing the teaching of Islam in public schools.

What’s it going to take for the West to wake up? There is a real clash of worldviews, and it’s deadly. And just like between the two great World Wars, Europe is asleep.


For further reading and information:

Clash of Worldviews: Defending the Truth” -- speech by Chuck Colson given to the Wilberforce Forum Centurions, March 4, 2006.

Melanie Phillips, Londonistan (Encounter Books, 2006).

BreakPoint Commentary No. 060710, “While Britain Slept.”

BreakPoint Commentary No. 060210, “That’s Not Funny: Eurabia.”

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Chuck Colson was the Chief Counsel for Richard Nixon and served time in prison for Watergate-related charges. In 1976, Colson founded Prison Fellowship Ministries, which, in collaboration with churches of all confessions and denominations, has become the world's largest outreach to prisoners, ex-prisoners, crime victims, and their families.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Chuck Colson's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
RE: An unwelcome reunion
Much has been said about Jihad. Yet there are two other concepts affected by Jihad that should be mentioned. They are “Bar Al Islam” and “Dhimmitude.”

Once Muslims are victorious thru Jihad, what’s the fate of the vanquished? Infidels can convert to Islam. Should they refuse and are "people of the book," i.e., Jews or Christians, they may be granted Dhimmitude. Basically it’s a second rate citizenship status approaching slavery with the paying of a heavy tribute. The rest face execution.

Much of Christian Europe faced this between the late seventh and early twentieth centuries but eventually the Islamic yoke was thrown off with the fall of the Ottoman Empire in WW I. In the eight century, Charlemagne was instrumental in saving Europe from complete domination by the Muslims. The Crusades were European attempts to take back parts of Southeastern Europe and defend the Roman Empire, called the Byzantine Empire from the eleventh to the thirteenth centuries. After the First Crusade, failed primarily due to poor leadership or financing, and often degenerated into plundering rabble. It was the fall of the Eastern Roman Empire to the Muslims and the blocking of trade routes to India and China in the fifteenth century that caused Columbus to sail west and run into an unexpected island.

However, what was and is the Islamic viewpoint on the European lands lost? With the exception of Israel and Lebanon, Islam has recovered the Mideast and N. Africa.

Your article about Spain gives us an excellent clue. Under the Islamic concept of “Bar Al Islam,” any lands previously conquered by Muslims forces belong to the Islamic Nation in perpetuity. For that reason, Islam sees most of Europe from Spain to the Caspian Sea, N. Italy to the Baltic Sea, and the Balkans as rightfully theirs. That’s the stakes and unfortunately many non-Muslims are in such denial that they refuse to realize the danger.

Now, what would America’s chances of survival be if caught between an Asia controlled by China and a Pan-Arab Nation from Gibraltar to India? And why is it that we are so afraid to teach the true historical nature of Islam?

Bob Benitez
Omaha, NE



Gutless Europe
Let's face facts here, Europe in 30 years will be renamed Eurabia. They lack the guts, other than the Brits that is, to seriously wage WW IV (WW III was the Cold War) against the Islamofascists. They're too mired down with political correctness, seeking MORE multi-culturalism and diversity, to see the threat in front of them. I'm sure that the Islamofascist religious police will be kinder and gentler when Europeans forget to don their burkahs, grow their beards, and pay their "tolerance" tax. More likely, it'll be a throat-cutting or a stoning.

Not disagreeing exactly...
But, as Mr Colson points out, the "tragedy" of Andalus is that it was "lost" to the Christians. The "tragedy" is that now Spain is apostate. It WAS islam, but now isn't - hence it is apostate. And must be cleansed. Which would explain the violence.

According to my take on 'dar al Islam,' or the house of Islam, the whole world MUST BE MADE ISLAM. Whether they EVER had it is irrelevant. In essence, it means that any where there are people - those people must be islam.

The huge difference between the dar al Islam and the dar al Harb is that one is converting what wasn't Islam and the other is at war with what WAS Islam.

Both are toxic to Christianity.




Islam is not the main danger
The time has come to examine the use of the phrase “Muslim extremist”. This is used to describe those who commit acts of terror. This phrase allows us to think that the situation we are dealing with is temporary and can be resolved as long as we deal with the few aberrant fanatics whom could be considered “extreme”.

To understand the dynamics of the times in which we live, we need to understand that we are in essentially a three way religious war. The key to understanding this is to understand secularism as a religion instead of the absence of religion. Secularism could be called the worship of man in general and self in particular. It can be seen to be replacing Hinduism and Buddhism in one generation in India and China.

Secularism has defeated Christianity in Europe and has it on the ropes in America. Secularism thinks it will defeat Islam by the same methods it used against Christianity, chiefly government and education.

Secularists are well established in the media and refer to anyone who would oppose what to them seems the obvious inevitability of their religion as extremist. For example, they might say, “George Bush had to appease the “right wing extremists” in his own party”.

They cannot think that Islam, as a religion, is the cause of trouble because they disfavor thinking in terms of right and wrong. They may also recognize at some subconscious level that if Islam as a religion is “wrong”, then Christianity may be “right”.

We need to elect true Christians as political leaders who eschew the relativism of the secularists and have the courage to call Islam evil. The only time in history Islam has failed to kill its neighbors is when it lacked the technology, numbers, or will for war.

We need to leave the fight against Islam to the European secularists who think they can make a deal. We need to focus our attention back in America and fight the fight against the secularists in their jihad against our Christian heritage.

Islam is not the worst problem
The time has come to examine the use of the phrase “Muslim extremist”. This is used to describe those who commit acts of terror. This phrase allows us to think that the situation we are dealing with is temporary and can be resolved as long as we deal with the few aberrant fanatics whom could be considered “extreme”.

To understand the dynamics of the times in which we live, we need to understand that we are in essentially a three way religious war. The key to understanding this is to understand secularism as a religion instead of the absence of religion. Secularism could be called the worship of man in general and self in particular. It can be seen to be replacing Hinduism and Buddhism in one generation in India and China.

Secularism has defeated Christianity in Europe and has it on the ropes in America. Secularism thinks it will defeat Islam by the same methods it used against Christianity, chiefly government and education.

Secularists are well established in the media and refer to anyone who would oppose what to them seems the obvious inevitability of their religion as extremist. For example, they might say, “George Bush had to appease the “right wing extremists” in his own party”.

They cannot think that Islam, as a religion, is the cause of trouble because they disfavor thinking in terms of right and wrong. They may also recognize at some subconscious level that if Islam as a religion is “wrong”, then Christianity may be “right”.

We need to elect true Christians as political leaders who eschew the relativism of the secularists and have the courage to call Islam evil. The only time in history Islam has failed to kill its neighbors is when it lacked the technology, numbers, or will for war.

We need to leave the fight against Islam to the European secularists who think they can make a deal. We need to focus our attention back in America and fight the fight against the secularists in their jihad against our Christian heritage.

Gutless USA
Why don't we fight the Islamofascists (Iran) who threaten us (and harbored Al Qaeda) rather than a secular regime (Iraq) that didn't threaten us (and didn't harbor Al Qaeda)?

Just asking.

Of course, given the bumbling incompetence of our defense secretary et al today, it's probably best we wait until at least 2009 before fighting anybody new.


double cappuccino
What is your real name? john kerry.

True nature
Bob asks a reasonable question: "Why is it that we are so afraid to teach the true historical nature of Islam?"

Timf hits close to the answer, in identifying the three competing faiths; secularism (or, to be even more accurate, Atheism), Islam and Christianity. As a result of their world-view, the secularists see their competitors through a funhouse mirror. The total aberration of an Eric Rudolph, for example, is seen as being completely typical of conservative Christianity. On the other hand, the centuries-long bloody history of Islam is seen as a completely unconnected series of events, in which psychotics who are completely unrepresentative of the Religion of Peace (TM).

However, even believing Christians hesitate to name what they see in front of their own eyes, for two reasons. First, it is one of the unheralded triumphs of America that it is truly inconceivable to the vast majority of Americans that anyone would want to kill or oppress anyone else because of their faith. Even believers think, "SURELY there must be SOMETHING else at work?!?" Second, because it goes against something they all hold nearly as dear as Scripture; the First Amendment. If there IS such a faith, how can we respond to it without violating the true meaning of Amendment I?

double cappo
is wayyyyy off the mark. Watch out D.C. your hatred of Bush and Co is showing. I guess that unless the outcome is absolutely perfect, you libs will piss and moan. I attend classified meetings on terrorism and it looks like Bush and Company is doing a damn good job keeping us safe. It's almost five years since 9-11 and we've thwarted a few possible attacks.

Bush and Co piss you libs off because they DO something about it whereas Bubba and his co-president shrillary merely sent FBI investigators in or shot off a few missiles at an empty warehouse. Talk about incompetence! It really is a shame that Bubba was more concerned with chasing tail than in Sudan's three-time offer of OBL. On top of that is Bubba's quest for diversity and multi-culturalism that overrode the FAA's questioning of Atta and crew's pilot training.

In closing, you libs mewl and yammer about Bush but Bubba did nothing about it (Khobar Towers, WTC pt 1, US barracks in Saudi, US Embassy in Kenya, US Embassy in Tanzaniya, etc) and Hanoi John Kerry, the guy you voted for, voted FOR the war in Iraq before he voted AGAINST it! (I thought we were a one vote per person system??)

Comments by Bob Benitez
Bob: Excellent reponse!! You seem to really know your history.

Not only do the Muslims want to retake Spain, but they are having babies faster than the rest of the world and may be able to accomplish it via population explosion.

An excellent read on the subject is, The Wests Last Chance by Tony Blankley,

WW IV
What Pres. Bush won't discuss as he ought is that this war will last a long long time. Perhaps as long as we struggled against communism before Reagan / Thatcher / the Pope won WW III. We would be better off recognizing we are in a war of attrition, the forces of light (us, IMHO) against the forces of dark. It is always so. The whole generation of islamofascists must die off; the west MUST defeat them intellectually, materialistically, and most of all, spiritually so the rising generation loses interest in Islam. Until Christian missionaries are operating in every islamic country, this war is interminable.

Christian missionaries/Muslim countries
There are quite a few unofficial Christian missionaries in Muslim countries, even countries that are closed to missionaries. Generally, they are what's known as tent-makers. They go in under cover of another job -- oilfield worker, English teacher, swim coach, agricultural engineer, doctor -- you name it. They have to be careful not to be too public, but they're there to spread the Gospel and they make relationships and do just that. It was a system well used when China was totally closed to official missionaries and it's being used in Muslim countries today. Although their names cannot be published because it might mean death to them, we should all be praying for the success of their missions.

Andalus Sounds Like Azatlan
Mr. Coulson, the desire of the Islamic radicals to recapture the lost lands of Andalusia sounds eerily similar to the desires of many Mexicans to recapture the lost lands of the American Southwest. It's too bad that you seem to comprehend the danger of the former but not the danger of the latter.

DocJ writes...
"What Pres. Bush won't discuss as he ought is that this war will last a long long time."

I remember shortly after 9-11 President Bush speaking on that very subject. He told us that this war on terror would last a good long time; that perhaps we would never see the end of it in our lifetime. He told the truth at the outset, what more needs to be discussed?

BTW Christian missionaries are in every islamic country you just don't see it on the leftist CNN.

Impressive Commentaries
Deception occurs in unexpected places. After reading the commentaries I think, 'wow! Folks really do know what's going on.' The realization that only a few fairly intelligent people read other than MSM seeps in and I am back in my nightmare world where 200 million Neros fiddle while the world burns.
We are being attacked from all sides by many nations for various reasons but one thing is certain: Other than Israel our only allies are English speaking nations.
After pulling France's bacon out of the fire in 3 of the 4 wars we were involved with in the 20th century, that nation would rather come under total Islamic rule than aid us one whit.
Germany would care not if we were suddenly attacked by N. Korea, China, Iran and Venezula all at the same time. Italy and Spain are so cowed by embedded Muslims they are afraid to commit to the war. Russia is so enamoured with capitalism (its newfound toy) that it is going to sell every nuke in its inventory to the highest bidder. The Catholic Church, once formidable foe to the Islamic threat, is now just a repository for much of the world's treasures. The Pope is going to go on mouthing platitudes about love and peace and Christainity and reason and understanding. Right up until the time Muhammid Saladis Muhammid XX or some other Islamofacist marches into the Vatican and beheads the Holy See. Definitely not Pope Leo.
The lack of comprehension is incredible. After 9/11 no American should remain ignorant as to the true intentions of Islam. President Bush does his country a disservice when he repeats over and over that Islam is a 'peacful religion'. There is no such thing as a 'moderate Muslim'. If there were, they would be up in arms against the 'Islamofacists' who are perpetrating atrocities against unarmed and non combative peoples. A Bible-thumping friend of mine says this is the beginning of Armageddon. He might be right. If we lose to these religious fanatics they will gain control of the world. The Thousand Year Rule of the Anti-Christ will have begun. And it will be Hell!

Merrygoboy
What on earth are Rushdooneys?

Al-Errors.
According to your article, I suppose that you haven't ever been to Spain. When you say:

"it’s easy to find evidence of Spain’s Islamic past... in the faces of the people"?

Most of the moors were expeled from Al-Andalus in stages. Maybe you have seen some inmigrants from Morocco and tink that's the common Spaniard.

The architecture reminds the muslim past, but only few examples, that were preserved by the christians, unlike the moors, that destroyed all they wanted.

You say something that makes me laugh:

"“Andalusi” comes from “Al Andalus,” the Arabic name for southern Spain, the part known as Andalusia today."

Al-Adalus IS NOT Andalusia.

That's incredible! I couldn't believe you were so uninformed. Every schoolchildren know that Al-Andalus was Spain. Tariq, Musa or any other muslim invader called it to Seville as well as Barcelona.

But, dont't worry. These are some of the tons of myths about Al-Andalus.


Apart from these, I agree with the rest of the article. The anti-christian Spanish Prime Minister (or President , as they say) is an irresponsible that is ruining all that Aznar built.

I think he might read, for example, the books of Oriana Fallaci.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.