Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, June 30, 2009
Cal  Thomas :: Townhall.com Columnist
I'm (not) Gonna Live Forever
by Cal Thomas
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


"How fevered is the man who cannot look
Upon his mortal days with temperate blood,
Who vexes all the leaves of his life's book,
And robs his fair name of its maidenhood...";
So wrote English poet John Keats in "On Fame."

It's worth re-reading as we overindulge in the recent deaths of Michael Jackson and Farrah Fawcett. Ed McMahon's death the same week received somewhat less coverage because he was neither beautiful, nor weird, though he qualified as a celebrity. At least McMahon served in two wars as a Marine, which was a real accomplishment.

What is it about celebrity that so fascinates us? And it is celebrity, not fame. As the now defunct New Times magazine editorialized 30 years ago, "There are almost no famous people anymore; only celebrities." That's because, the editorial writer said, fame is too suggestive of steady achievement. Almost anyone can be a celebrity.

Listening to the Michael Jackson tributes would make one think he had created something of lasting value. Some said his music will "live forever." No it won't. No one today hums Stephen Foster songs or ditties from World War I, or the Great Depression, which were better songs and understandable. Can anyone quote the lyrics from Gus Kahn's greatest hits? Somehow "Butterflies all flutter up and kiss each little buttercup at dawnin'") doesn't seem to have the ring it had in 1922.

Tony Bennett is a singer. His songs have a better chance of longevity than Jackson's because they are about love and relationships, which are common to every generation. Bennett and his contemporaries, including Frank Sinatra, Mel Torme and Ella Fitzgerald, are in a league far above the "pop" culture headed at one time by Jackson, whose biggest hit "Thriller" came before the younger generation was born.

Our culture celebrates and promotes beauty, which fades. Farrah Fawcett attempted to remind people she was still around after her initial splash in the '70s by having plastic surgery, among other things, and appearing nude in Playboy. Michael Jackson, who had numerous plastic surgeries and other "treatments" to his skin and body, was rehearsing for a "comeback" when he died of an apparent prescription drug overdose. Jackson, the self-proclaimed "king of pop," got more coverage in newspapers and on the networks, especially cable TV, than Elvis Presley, the "king of rock and roll," received when he died of a drug overdose in 1977.

Diana, Princess of Wales trumped Mother Teresa in TV coverage of their deaths, but who made the greater contribution?

A culture that fixates on the likes of the Osbournes, and those dreadful reality TV celebrities Kate and Jon, is a culture that is cannibalizing itself. Embracing the base while rejecting the noble will produce more of one and less of the other.

"Why then should man, teasing the world for grace,

Spoil his salvation for a fierce miscreed?"

Keats asked a good question. So did the writers Jule Styne, Betty Comden and Adolph Green when they wrote "Make Someone Happy" (reprised by the late Jimmy Durante in the film "Sleepless in Seattle"): "Fame, if you win it, comes and goes in a minute. Where's the real stuff in life to cling to?"

The list of celebrities whose lives turned into a train wreck is long and lengthening. Why would so many want to follow these people and their broken and lousy relationships, drug use, and plastic surgeries, especially when we see where it leads for so many of them?

Last Thursday night, more people watched a Farrah Fawcett special on ABC than a Michael Jackson special on CBS, suggesting that beauty beats weirdness. Far fewer watched ABC's health care special with President Obama. By almost anyone's standards, health care is far more important than dead celebrities. That ratings disparity is a commentary on our shallowness and the refusal of so many to cling to the "real stuff" in life.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Cal Thomas is co-author (with Bob Beckel) of the book, "Common Ground: How to Stop the Partisan War That is Destroying America".
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Cal Thomas' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Almost Right
Yes beauty beats weirdness. It also beats an infomercial about snake oil.

True, Princess Di got more response about her death than Mother Teresa, but she received more press when she was alive as well. The public is greatly uninformed about the difference, but who do you suppose should inform them?


Musical contributions
Simply because someone's music eventually goes out of fashion does not mean that the composer's impact is not felt.

True, nobody sings Steven Foster songs anymore, but that does not mean that his musical impact is not still felt. It is ironic that people credit Jackson with bridging black and white music, but Foster did much the same a century earlier.

Albums like "Thriller" and "Off the Wall" still have a huge impact on today's popular musicians. They are monumental achievements, and should be celebrated because they are important to our culture today, even if people barely remember him in 100 years.

And who knows, maybe someone will write an opera about him, as a cautionary tale.

No...
"By almost anyone's standards, health care is far more important than dead celebrities."

Not government run health care. And Tony Bennett songs, or Sinatra's, have no such chance at longevity, anymore than Jackson's. "I left My heart in San Francisco" - yeah, I hear that a lot these days.

Wait a minute...
I do sing Frank Sinatra and Tony Bennet songs and Steven Foster is a great composer. Speak for yourself Mr. Thomas.

ABC's Healthcare Special
Healthcare is more important than Michael Jackson and Farrah Fawcett. However, ABC's special was nothing more than an informercial dedicated to the latest empty-suit celebrity, Barack Obama. According to your article, why would I want to watch that?

Fame is a Heavy Burden
Like the real king Elvis Presley, Michael Jackson died too early and I believe disillusioned with life. Money and fame are a very heavy burden on mere mortals. Just ask Michael Vick, Shawn Taylor and Paris Hilton to name a few.

Envy them if you must. Pity them if you will!

Shallowness has consequences
Great article Cal! Our shallow society thought it best to elect a "cool, young guy" rather than the "old guy" & here we are today, on the precipice of disaster. Thanks to the really "cool guy" who is in WAY over his head. I'm not a big John McCain fan, but he at least had experience! But, I forgot, he's not "cool". I wonder how the Hope & Change is working for them now?!

ABC's health care fairy tale
Thank goodness there was some competition for the ABC special that would have otherwise misled a large number of people into thinking that the proposed government action is really about health care. It's really about enlarging government power over individuals' right to make their own health decisions, and viewers of the health care fairy tale would not have been so informed.

I'm so happy that I watched none of the programs!


Priorities misplaced
Cal, congratulations! Now someone of importance has expressed what I have advocated for years.
It would be wonderful to hear some of the songs that I liked as a small lad. Those songs had heart and meaning and the artist did not have to yell and turn red in the contorted face to try and outdo the musicians.
I am a retired musician who knows the difference in the songs of yesteryear and the noise made by today's pop culture that takes unto itself the title of music.
As a guitarist, I can appreciate most types of music except noise. It has been said that music calms the savage beast, but in my opinion some of today's music is the beastly.

My two cents
People are attracted anything that takes their minds off their fears. There is a feeling among our people perhaps all people that our fates lie in the hands of other people upon whom we have no influence. Leftists look for others to solve their problems and hope that someone will rescue them. Rightists look for others to get out of their way so that they can solve their own problems and chafe at those i n government who are deaf to them. Fatalism sets in and "I wonder how the octuplets are doing tonight?"

3 shows, all celebrity hipe
There was no good "real stuff" aired that night. Farrah and Jackson lived,impacted us in some measure and died tragically. That was real. The ABC infomercial is tragic too and I fear will impact us greatly given that we are being fed our demise on a siver platter by a celebrity much less celebrated by me than others. We all will be singing the blues soon.

Ah, but the really smart people
were watching LSU take the NCAA baseball championship in the last game of an excellent College World Series against neighbor Texas.

Cal is right on the major premise of the piece, but the main reason people didn't watch Obama's health scare pitch was most viewers don't like infomercials for products they know won't work as advertised.

when celebrities
die, I can only think that the world is a little bit better. The less sin there is in the world--the better. When we sin, it affects the world in some way. God gave these people all the time they needed to love Him--if they didn't, it just means that their time is over for true change toward good in this world. The fruits of their lives did not have any lasting Godly qualities. When a saint dies--that is something to be sad about. Am I judging others? Well, of course to a degree. We ARE to judge and see and understand the 'fruits' of the works of those around us. The celebrities have fallen into the hands of God as surely as the saints. Only God's justice matters now...

Music
I cannot sing, I do not play an instrument, but music is/was and will be a major part of my life. It lifts me when I am down. It reminds me of my Mom and Dad who have been gone for many years. It reminds me of the years during WW2 when we were a nation of folks who pulled together, laughed together and cried together. It makes some special moments of my life flash back as if they happened yesterday.

It is the music of Bing Crosby, Peggy Lee, Frank Sinatra, etc. The message was LOVE, love for family, girl friend, Mom, love.

The cacophonous sounds of hip hop and rap induce a need for activity that often manifests itself in destructive deeds.

Don,t waste time debating, just let this old man spend his last years tuning in to Rhapsody and the sounds of love.

I close listening to the strains of Tony singing "My Foolish Heart".

It really doesn't make me want to pick up a gun and shoot someone---amazing!!

Elvis correction
For the record, Elvis Presley died of a massive heart attack. True, it was an overload of legal prescription drugs that weakened his heart in the first place. But to describe his death as a "drug overdose" makes it look as if the King were engaging in some reckless act of rock-star bravado.

Cal never wastes an opportunity to make us rockers look bad, does he?

drugs and elvis
Drug killed Elvis. And yes, he engaged in "reckless acts of rock-star bravado." Do you live in a cave?

Says It All For Me..........

"Embracing the base while rejecting the noble will produce more of one and less of the other."

The slide into debaseness and degeneration continues.......

Whose cave?
Verbivore:

You're not too good at reading text.

I fully acknowledge the role of drugs in Presley's early death. But at the same time, the drugs were legal and prescribed with a disregard for the effect on the patient's health. Presley consumed these drugs not out of bravado, but because his doctor and handlers told him that the drugs were necessary to get through the day. In the end, the cure was worse than the disease.

Music
Whenever I think of a Michael Jackson song, it almost always morphs into one of the Weird Al spoofs instead. I can't hardly remember any of the original lyrics, thank God!

Sandy, the irony
It's very odd how Michael's death somewhat trumped Farrah's, who had died the day before, while Diana's death trumped Mother Teresa's who died the day after.
What of course is very odd is that even Diana admitted that she was utterly awed and humbled when she met Mother Teresa...as self-centered as Diana was it's unlikely she would have thought it just that she trumped Mother Teresa.

Thanks
for running a picture of Farrah and not Michael Jackson -- it is just too frightening to see what he had done to himself.

Celebrity is worth more than just about anything now; hence our American Idol election and the Celebrity in Chief in the WH.

Susan
SoCal

nickel
I'm with you,I am constantly humming and trying to sing those old songs.I didn't see tv until I was 16,so I was raised on radio.Ah the good old days

Cold, Calculating Cal
I love it. If you have nothing nice to say, pull up a chair and have a beer with me. Cal is so right.

mourning these celebrities
Just my opinion, but I think what makes these celebrity death so major is not them exactly, but the memories they are connected to in our own lives.

By mourning them we're mourning an earlier time in our lives.

Farah is strongly connected to a hugely popular poster that hung on many a teenage boys wall in the late 70's. Michael's song 'Billie Jean' was likely to be on the radio during many 1st kisses.

Their loss is a connection to our own mortality. And loss innocence. We aren't mourning the "train wrecks" as Cal called, but our memories of our younger selves.

Darrel
9:40 a.m. post..well said

Mistermilo..ditto (11:57)

There's a difference between Elvis's music and Jacksons..one you could understand Elvis..but we had a mix in the 50's, even the Rock n Roll music was mostly happy although I HATED Jerry Lee Lewis, and other musicians of that yelling genre..but the other stuff was fun.
My Dad introduced me to the music he loved from the 20,30 and 40's and I still love that especially the Swing music. I am not in any way a musician although my mother desperately tried to get me to learn the piano..for ten years..I hated it and all I could play was the Tennesee Waltz ..badly.
When in school we had a course in Music Appreciation, I wonder if todays kids have it?
I enjoy all forms EXCEPT what passes for music which is noise that goes against our body rhythms. It's debauchery set to clashing noise passing for music.

Jeffrey -
I think that's excellent insight. Well said.

Personally
As I was never much to subscribe to Pop Culture, especially in the music area of Pop Culture. I find it sad that they pasted, Yet I could name musicians who have pasted, and not even from drug overdoses whose death far more affected me than MJ's. Yet I doubt more than a handful if that would even know their names. I Never understood the fascination with Michael Jackson, And as I was just a wee lad in the 70's Farrah Faucet was never someone that moved my loins as she may have my older brothers.

And these people vote.
Too many show zero interest on the news that actually effects their lives.
Even Gretta was scared to give an update on the Iran riots for fear that viewers would jump ship and watch the M.J. story elsewhere.

Jeffrey
That is a pretty cool point.

Jeffrey and truetolife
I think remembering our younger selves is a large part of it, but that doesn't explain our society's fascination with living celebrities. I call it the cult of celebrity and, as others have posted, this phenomenon is in large part responsible for Obama being in the White House instead of a man (or woman) with more experience and better ideas.

As a Christian, I feel sadness (pity really) at the passing of anyone, celebrity or otherwise, who has rejected Christ. The death of a believer is cause for rejoicing, since they have gone home to be with the Lord. No more sin or sorrow...now that is something to look forward to.

Songs?
Yes, I do some Steven Foster and Bluegrass, but I do much more music and lute songs centuries old. Even Dufay.

Most of the music of the last 50 years is junk.

Jeffrey
"By mourning them we're mourning an earlier time in our lives."

No way - I'm glad to be rid of it. The good things in my life to mourn was the presence of long-gone family members, not fleeting entertainers.

Rich D.
I disagree. Music is a gift given to man to create enjoyment for others. If it is then enjoyed, it is only junk in YOUR eyes and ears. I hate what Michael became and what he stood for in a lot of peoples eyes, but I do believe his music was his gift to the world, especially in the 70s. I very fondly remember "I'll Be There". The main difference is that was a different Michael.
To see his father so "consumed in grief" over a person he played a very big hand in creating is somehow false!

eastlake joe
How can you disagree with somebody's opinion? What you mean is that you have an opinion that is valid for you but different from mine. We already see how society filters art and culture. Will he last as long as Machaut?

Frankenfraud
Frankenfraud
Franken stole the election pure and simple, by selective recounts. The Democrats did this in the Washington Governor's race of 2002 and they tried their hardest to do that in the 2000 Presidential election.

We should make this a rallying cry of the 2010 electons. No more Frankenfrauds. Republicans and Independents and Conservative Democrats have to vote GOP to elect our candidates beyond the margin of any Democratic party Frankenfraud.

"Al Franken stole the day.
Harry Reid has got to pay."

This doesn't have anything to do with Cal Thomas' excellent column but I am just trying to get this idea out.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.