Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, May 05, 2009
Cal  Thomas :: Townhall.com Columnist
Margaret Thatcher Plus 30
by Cal Thomas
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


LONDON -- There is a story, probably apocryphal, about Margaret Thatcher who became prime minister 30 years ago this week and led Britain's economic and political revival.

The newly elected Thatcher takes her all-male cabinet to dinner. The waiter asks her what she would like to order.

"I'll have the beef," says she.

"What about the vegetables?" asks the waiter.

"They'll have the same."

The story says much about a woman who in many ways exuded more gravitas than most of her male contemporaries, which is why, in 1990, they conspired to dump her as leader of the Conservative Party.

Not since Winston Churchill -- and not since Thatcher -- has Britain had such a dominant leader; even Tony Blair could not measure up to the Iron Lady.

To gauge her success, one must recall Britain's condition before she took office. Like Jimmy Carter's America in 1979, people were talking about managing Britain's decline. As Robin Harris writes for The Heritage Foundation, "The pace and scale of this revolution justifies the description, even though the chief revolutionary herself was someone of very traditional instincts who always considered that she was restoring what had been lost, not imposing a utopian plan."

This is the definition of "conservatism." Thatcher understood proven principles. She wasn't looking for "new" things, but rather old things that had proven to be successful. She called on the British people to remember their history and to embrace it. She was not indulging in nostalgia so much as she was taking from a living past in order to build a better future. In this, she was the mirror image of Ronald Reagan.

This is the key to leadership. Leadership doesn't lie in poll numbers, though all politicians take polls to measure the public temperature. Leadership is about convictions with ample references to past successes and the principles behind them. If one doesn't bake a cake without first reading the directions, how can a damaged nation be repaired without discerning what works and what doesn't? If a people forget their history -- as too many in Britain and America have done -- they are then susceptible to being snookered by politicians who propose something "new."

Given our self-centeredness, it is refreshing to recall what Lady Thatcher said about personal accountability and responsibility: "Disciplining yourself to do what you know is right and important, although difficult, is the high road to pride, self-esteem and personal satisfaction."

First, one must know what is "right." In our "anything goes" culture we are told that people who believe they have discovered "right" are wrong, because that requires judgment and someone's feelings might be hurt if they hold to another "tradition."

As for the notion of "fairness" and "spreading the wealth around," which is the philosophy of the Obama administration, Lady Thatcher said, "I do not know anyone who has got to the top without hard work. That is the recipe. It will not always get you to the top, but should get you pretty near." Today, in America and increasingly in Britain where Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling has proposed a 50 percent tax on "the wealthy," admitting he just plucked the figure "out of the air," hard work is to be punished and slothfulness subsidized.

About wealth, Lady Thatcher said: "It's not the creation of wealth that is wrong, but the love of money for its own sake." Republicans in America, now debating among themselves whether to appeal to "moderates" to rebuild their party, would do well to consider Thatcher's wisdom: "Standing in the middle of the road is very dangerous; you get knocked down by the traffic from both sides."

Britain, like America, is not in turmoil because it once embraced the conservative principles of Margaret Thatcher -- principles that worked. Britain and America are in turmoil because they too quickly abandoned Thatcher's principles in favor of a superficial, "feel-good" philosophy. Using another food analogy, we want dessert before -- even instead of -- our vegetables, though we know what's best for us.

Lady Thatcher's official portrait will be unveiled this week and hung at 10 Downing Street. A greater honor would be for the British people to again "hang" her principles in their minds and hearts. It is something the Conservative Party leader David Cameron has pledged to do should he prevail in next year's scheduled elections.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Cal Thomas is co-author (with Bob Beckel) of the book, "Common Ground: How to Stop the Partisan War That is Destroying America".
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Cal Thomas' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
God Bless Lady Thatcher...
and Ronald Reagan!

Amen
Ronald Reagan saved the world from communism, but he couldn't have done so without a great deal of help from Margaret Thatcher and Pope John Paul II. They gave us a gift beyond valuation. I'm ashamed to survey the mess we've made of it.

I must correct you sir
The story you reference was a Spitting Image sketch, which wanted to show the manly Thatcher against her "Wet" Cabinet, and was part of the general assault on Mrs Thatcher and added to the canon of anti-Thatcher "humour".

Busy Intersection

I've always loved that quote about the middle of the road. It is precisely this straddling of the median that is killing the GOP, and they are, in fact, being knocked down by the traffic to their right and left. Moderate Republicans should take note: let the roadkill be your guide.

Iron will
Poor Maggie must be crying now seeing her beloved Britain going down the toilet and the worst part is she doesn't have Reagan's shoulder to cry on;although if Reagan were alive, he would be crying too.

I've heard the story too
I've heard that story too; like yourself, I don't know if it's true, I really hope it is!

One reason Mrs Thatcher found herself facing a coup was arguably that, as the years went by, she allowed herself to be surrounded by more and more "let's-do-it" people (as valuable as they are) to the detriment of the "let's-wait a minute-and-think-this-through" folk, until the latter were almost unrepresented within her inner circle.

The difference between Thatcher and the Labour leaders is that they had weeded people who wanted to wait and think about things *before* they conned their way into power.

Frugal Dougal
England
NE Alabama

@Paleocon - I agree
Paleocon - I couldn't agree more!

http://draughtyoldfentales.blogspot.com/2009/05/margaret-th atcher.html

Frugal Dougal
England
NE Alabama

David Cameron and Daniel Hannan
I'm for Cameron even though I don't know him or have a dog in that hunt. If he's good enough for Cal, he's good enough for me. And someday, someday, I'd like to see Mr. Daniel Hannan leading the world. He's a great man, and I say this not as some congenital conservative, but as one who recognizes "authority." When Hannas speaks (or writes) it is as from "one who has authority." Or leadership, or whatever you want to call it.

In my library I have a copy of Thatcher's "The Path to Power." Thanks to Cal, I'm gonna finally sit down and read this book through.

Representation without Taxation
The problem is not that conservative ideas are not popular. They are perhaps more popular today than they ever were. The problem is that the voting franchise has been extended to people who should never have been allowed to vote.

John Stuart Mill wrote in 1861 that it was "required by first principles that the receipt of parish relief [welfare] should be a peremptory disqualification for the franchise." And he was the big liberal of his day.

Wards of the state, including those who only pay taxes with funds given to them by the state, must not be allowed to vote.

It is absolutely absurd that persons whose only address is a park bench are allowed to vote!

We are not perilously close to that point where those voters who pay no tax outnumber those who do. When that point is reached, the republic will fail and Obama, like Hugo Chavez, will be President for life. Or at least until the coup d'etat.

I am cheered every time the socialists denigrate the US Marine Corps. When the time comes, I hope the Marines will turn against the One. It is perhaps the only hope for those of us who believe in limited government.


Excellent article
One reason I respected Thatcher-amma (note the word "respected", not necessarily "liked") was that she would stand by her decisions, even if wrong--in contrast to such "leaders" as Carter, Mulroney and Oblunder (for all of whom I have zero or negative respect) who would be excellent substitutes (actually, some would say IMPROVED substitutes functionally) for weather-vanes.

A Leader of Note
Margaret Thatcher practiced her profession without rancor, bigotry or intolerance for ideas that ran counter to her own. Since she is a true conservative, I suspect that she is more comfortable with Barry Goldwater than Ron Reagan today as they look down on a troubled world.

No Thatcher in US
I truly do not believe there is an equal to Thatcher in this country at this time in history. Most so-called conservative women in this country are in the mold of Kay Bailey Hutchison, Sandra Day O'Connor, Condoleezza Rice and yes, Sarah Palin. Female Colin Powells, if you will. They all talk a conservative game, but when it comes to action, they let their personal experiences get in the way of conservative governance. Such experiences such as sexual discrimination in their younger days will go into their decisions, most notably their favoring affirmative action. Most American women today also see the government having a greater role in our lives than men. Sexist maybe, but it's true. For those reasons, a woman will have to do a real selling job on me to get my vote.

CAl Thomas
Brits should hang her principles in their minds and hearts.

Looking back at our past we should choose to copy what worked and learn from the many mistakes made by the Utopians.

The American people could use a teaching tour on our prosperous foundation instead of a listening tour on our many woes and gripes. Tell the Republican Party. People forget. They need to be told again and again what it means to be an American. We need to study our Constitution and history thoroughly and teach our children about the advantages of personal propery rights and the free market. Let's go!!!

Rush is right. And you agree!
Rush opened my eyes. And you helped me see.
Your book is the first I read when converting to Conservatism. I am forever thankful.

Ben
I am a woman and I agree with your last statement..I've often said there were only two women I would have been comfortable voting for.
The first was Maggie Thatcher (made me proud of my British heritage, she's the England, like Churchill, I grew up hearing about from my immigrant family) and Jeanne Kirkpatrick. Jeanne impressed me with her no nonsense work at the U.N., didn't take any guff from the thugs infesting that place.
I liked SARAH and voted for her in 2008 however, I will reserve judgement regarding
future votes.
Whatever candidate that's fielded in 2012, that candidate had better be an unabashed and serious Constitutionalist. The GOP would do well to bring up the pertinent Constitutional
enumeration whenever the Big O starts his anti Constitutional power grabs..they already have lost a lot of time and ground by being so passive.

Ben
Ann Coulter.

She is fearless. She is passionate about freedom, justice and the poor.

But since she doesn't have an accent she doesn't get away with it.

Tea Party
Checks and balances are not working. Dems are not passionate about our Constitution. They are on their way to an enlightened Utopia in la-la-land.

Joycey
Is Ann Coulter running for office? Even if she is running, I will need more than just words. Same with Laura Ingraham. I love them both because they talk my language, but I do not know what's in their heart. They have no track record. When Sandra Day O'Connor was appointed, I had every reason to believe she was a conservative. She was a big disappointment. Frankly, I don't care about the gender or color of the candidate, unlike half the Obama voters who picked him for his skin pigment.

Tea Party
The GOP has a golden opportunity in 2010 and 2012. When McCain got the nomination, I was secretly hoping for a Hillary victory to provide the wake-up call America needed. With Obama getting the nomination, my greatest hopes were realized. I saw McCain as slow socialism. We do not need that. We need someone like Obama to pursue socialism so hard and fast that even the least informed of us will wake up and say hell no, that is not what we want. Obama so far has done a great job in scaring the passive among us to take a part in our political system. As you said, the GOP better point out the difference between them and Obama. We need another contract with America. Anything short of a total committment to conservative principles will be the end of the GOP and our country as we know it, because I and other will not vote for another RINO.

Leadership does not go on listening
Tours.
This thread contrasts leaders from listeners


Been hearing about some republicans going on a listening tour, and it struck me as very funny.

The implications of such an agenda with all that has been said they still haven't heard enough to make up their minds.

No leader goes on a "listening tour" he goes on a speaking tour and states boldly the path he is set upon.

No leader in the history of the world went on a listening tour and led anyone anywhere.

Political mouth pieces of party politics are not leaders like Churchill, Reagan and Lady Thatcher.

Do not let spacious plans for a new world divert your energies from saving what is left of the old.
Winston Churchill

My G'daughter

just spent the school year at the Pepperdine University Campus in London.

One day Lady Thatcher visited and talked with the students. My G'daughter talked with her a few minutes, and had her photo taken with the Lady.

The most important thing is, when she told me the story of her few minutes with the Lady, she sounded and acted just like I did when I visited with Ronald Reagan.

That made me proud of her, and very happy with my dozen or so meetings with Reagan.

Peas in a Pod. We need a new crop of peas from our Conservative garden.


A bully is not a leader
Why do Conservatives always confuse being rich with working hard? Nurses and teachers are hard-working people, but conservatives never miss an opportunity to beat up on them. A nurse has saved my life. No hedge-fund bully has ever done that for me, and no right-wing politician who took money from these hedge funds and banks that have defrauded me out of my pension has ever saved my life, either. Many people who do work hard do become financial successful, but the two are not perfectly correlated. Bernie Madoff was sitting in the Bahamas thanking God that a conservative Republican President was in charge 2000-08 so that he could get away with stealing $50bn without the inconvenience of regulation looking into what he was doing. Conservatism is just a polite word for running society so that criminals can keep on donating money to right-wing governments who ensure that these people rarely get sent to jail.

Thatcher inflicted fiscal trauma on the British economy for the priniciple reason of destroying the political power of organised Labour, who were her only critics when our political opposition were divided and in thrall to demogogues. The only people that benefitted from this Conservative earth-scorching were the already super-wealthy, not the common man. (The same people that Conservatives would deride as elitist if they supported left-wing rather than right-wing causes.) Thatcher got working class support for her abrasive Red-baiting style and her strong nationalist tendencies, and because her shrill style was a vicarious viscious pleasure for many who were angry already. The same right-wing British people would never admit that their incomes increased at a greater rate- and were further boosted by 'left-wing' tax credits conservative politicians opposed- under a Labour government than they did under the Conservative.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.