Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, December 07, 2007
Brent Bozell :: Townhall.com Columnist
Another Twisted Christmas
by Brent Bozell
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


The Christmas season is upon us, which means it's that special time of year for the American Civil Liberties Union and Americans United for the Separation of Church and State to make sure no wayward city council will allow a whiff of frankincense on government property. They must send out direct-mail fundraising letters asking "Help Us Crush a Creche at Christmas!"

The Christmas season is also that time of year when the business world implores us to consider the material as more important than the spiritual, all in the spirit of "the holidays." So we celebrate the arrival on Christmas Day of iPods and DVDs.

This year, there's a new twist. The nativity scene has become commercialized -- but in a way you would never imagine.

Reuters reports that an angry Italian priest persuaded the makers of the energy drink Red Bull to withdraw an animated advertisement on Italian television that has a fourth Wise Man arriving at the scene of the nativity to add a case of Red Bull to the frankincense, gold and myrrh. Father Marco Damanti, from Sicily, denounced their cartoon as "a blasphemous act" and said he had received a prompt reply promising to discontinue it.

"The image of the sacred family has been represented in a sacrilegious way," Father Damanti told the Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera. "Whatever the ironic intentions of Red Bull, the advert pokes fun at the nativity and at Christian sensitivity." The priest also objected to the company's regular slogan, "Red Bull gives you wings," illustrated at the commercial's end by flying angels singing Hallelujah.

You can find the ad on YouTube, and while the Fourth Wise Man shtick is vulgar huckstering, the angels singing at the end is sort of sweet, if you overlook the fact that they're singing glory to God for the manufacturing of Red Bull. But then, it's hard to judge the ad in its entirety without an Italian translator. For all I know, it's possible that when the Virgin Mary speaks in the ad, she's saying, "I'm going to need an energy drink after those twice-a-night feedings."

It's interesting that Red Bull would run the ad in Italy and not in the United States, which suggests they can sense which markets are more amenable to the "ironic intentions" of advertising. It would not be wrong to state that many Europeans view Christianity like a faded old painting -- it looks nice and induces nostalgia, but it doesn't have much modern relevance.

But it's not just commercials that are using the nativity story for non-religious purposes. The London Telegraph reports that the BBC has provoked Christians by announcing plans for a "contemporary" nativity play "featuring Mary and Joseph as asylum seekers instructed to report to the nearest passport office." To add to the gimmickry, it will be performed on the streets of Liverpool, featuring pop tunes from the Beatles, like "Let It Be" and "Lady Madonna."

The play doesn't culminate in the birth of God made flesh but in triumphant Liverpool pop tunes. BBC's press release boasted: "This unmissable hour-long event will open with the iconic image of a star that shines high in the sky above Liverpool -- and it will culminate with the nativity scene brought to life, as thousands of voices sing Liverpool's greatest pop songs together."

In other words, BBC still believes that arrogant John Lennon quote from the sixties that the Beatles are bigger than Jesus. But why a star shining high in the sky? Didn't Lennon's "Imagine" tell us there was no heaven?

Unsurprisingly, this "Liverpool Nativity" wouldn't be fully "contemporary" without an extra dose of political correctness. The character of Herod is changed to a female named Herodia, "a paranoid government minister in a fictional state desperately clinging to power who orders a crackdown on immigration. In the midst of the turmoil, Mary discovers she is pregnant and must fight to protect both Joseph and her unborn child."

It certainly doesn't matter to the BBC that Mary and Joseph were not illegal aliens in Bethlehem but were reporting for the Roman census. The point must be that anyone who opposes contemporary illegal immigration is metaphorically comparable to an ancient mass-baby-murdering tyrant.

Anglican traditionalist Tony Kilmister of the Prayer Book Society insisted, "This is not the sort of thing that Christmas needs. The story is loved and revered by Christians around the world. There is a dignity to it that will be lost. Adding political correctness of this sort is harmful and quite uncalled for."

Someone should be seeking asylum, all right -- to put the BBC in a straitjacket and leave it there. Then again, maybe this is precisely the kind of seasonal silliness that causes the Christian faithful to shut out the noise and contemplate the real nativity scene and its eternal promise.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Founder and President of the Media Research Center, Brent Bozell runs the largest media watchdog organization in America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Brent Bozell's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
THERE IS NO WAR ON CHRISTMAS!!!!!!!!!!!!
THERE IS NO WAR ON CHRISTMAS!! PERIOD!! Will you all stop acting like idiots by listening to demagauges who just want to make a whole bunch of something out of nothing?! I have rarely used the Lord's name in vain, but goddamn it! It makes me so angry when these pernicious demagauges try to scare you into believing that there is a so-called "War On Christmas." These liars are only in it to get raitings! I, as a Jew, say Merry Christmas all the time during the Christmas season, and I have yet to see any foward attack by any liberal organization. So you know what? Merry Freakin' Christmas! Get over it and get on with your Christmas shopping. You shouldn't be scared into complacency by these pathetic losers!

Christmas is fine
Out here in Los Angeles. The lights are up, the trees are out, the sun is shining...well tonight it's raining :(

We've even had the Hollywood Christmas Parade.

I'm sorry Brent is having problems again. Maybe he should just watch Charlie Brown and have some extra eggnog to get him into the spirit of the holiday. Perhaps due to his constant complaining he's 86ed from everyone's Christmas parties this year.

Poor poor Brent.

Lighten up.

On a personal level
These bad-taste excursions need to be dealt with one on one, just the same as crude remarks at Christmas parties need to be greeted with the look of Freezing Scorn your Mama should have taught you instead of rushing off to hire a lawyer and file a Sexual Harassment Suit.

Make the point personally that you find the particular event, exercise, commercial or whatever low class and pass it by. If it is not successful, it will go away.

Incidentally, Red Bull gives me indigestion.

Merry Christmas to all...
...and to all a good night.

you know
I never tire of this topic. It gets especially good at Christmas. No one is stopping Brent from expressing his faith in any manner. Unfortunately (for Brent), his right to swing his arms ends at my nose. This axiom often goes over-looked when it comes to religious freedom.

important distinction illustrated.
This was actually a good column in the way that it accurately reflected that on one side there are people trying to get government out of Christmas, and on the other there are people trying to prevent people saying things that they dislike. That is an important distinction, and one that Bozell brings out nicely.

MikeR
Unfortunately, there are some attempts to stop us from expressing our faith in any manner.

In my own small town, it was only through the townspeople forcing the issue that we were able to put up the manger scene in our town square.

This manger scene had been put in the same spot for as long as anyone could remember.

There were no complaints about it - just the threat of a lawsuit by the ACLU was enough to scare the town.

The townspeople, over the objections of the county attorney, set up the nativity anyway.

In history, townsquares have always been places that invited free speech. In our town, no one objected when a Jewish display was put up. No one objected when Santa Claus's workshop was put up. No one objected when pro-abortionists used the townsquare for a display.

Our town is an exception. Several towns near ours ended their tradition of manger scences whe threatened with similar legal action. Why? No one in the towns complained. It was the threat of the ACLU that did it.

If you're not a Christian
you probably don't see the Christmas "war", because you won't ever be the "target". But here in Dallas, deep in the bible-belt, we still have ongoing litigation by one of our school districts against a young girl who handed out "Jesus Loves You" candy canes at a AFTER HOURS school "Holiday Party" over 2 years ago. The school district wanted to suspend this girl for this "crime" of exercising her freedom of speech. Luckily the Alliance Defense Fund (alliancedefensefund.org) is representing this girl and her family, which the school district is appealing after losing it's initial judgment.

This all comes from the secular perversion of our 1st amendment rights. From the "establishment" and "free exercise" clauses, which were intended to protect religious freedom, to the made-up "separation of church and state" interpretation, to now the "freedom FROM religion" movement. It is all a perversion that we Christians have been too silent about for too long. But no more.

I encourage all Christians to read Ephesians 6 and realize that the "armor of God" described therein is the outfit of a warrior. That the admonition to stand for our faith means we must push back against secular encroachment. Supporting legal defense organizations like the ADF or Liberty Legal is a great way to make a difference. Take it to the ACLU!

Merry Christmas!
Merry Christmas! Merry Christmas! Feels great to say it! For all you secular-progressives, Happy Hillary!

separation of church and state nonsense
the establishment of a church has been twisted beyond recognition.

Christianity is NOT a church. the First Baptist Church of Smalltown USA is a church.

we have let clever lawyers twist the meaning of the text and judges have fallen for these ruses.

everyone speaks of precedence, but if Johnny says 2+2=5, do we have to agree with him as a matter of precedence?

we need people that are used to specifications and requirements to be judges. engineers instead of lawyers.

we need people that can cut through the pretty rhetoric and actually interpret the law as written.


Husker 2
I know what you mean. You make a good point; and I would actually like to see someone take the ACLU on as to define public usage of the town square. I think there is a legitimate chance for success. On the other hand, you may still have a nativity scene in your yard or church property. You can hire any of our numerous billboards and put a depiction of the nativity there with an inspirational message.

Jen Jen: When you defend the young girl with the “Allah Akbar” candy canes then I’ll take you more seriously. Otherwise, your interpretation of Ephesians 6 seems to be to shove your particular style of faith down my throat. I’ve always found the Armor of God to be something that encases me and makes my faith impregnable.

Moses: I always thought that separation of church and state meant that all churches had to be built off the ground or suspended in air. Seriously, you recognize the other definition to the term ‘state’ but somehow think it is legal trickery to use all but one definition of the term ‘church’. That is very odd.


One question...
Since when did it become minority rule in this country, as opposed to majority rule as envisioned by the founding fathers?

Psalm23 1:37pm
Our country is a constitutional republic. It is neither "minority rule" nor "majority rule". It is "rule by law".

The majority can be just as wrong as the minority.

But I agree with most of the comments, the ACLU has gone way too far and needs to be legally destroyed.

Merry Christmas!

Merry "Christ"mas!
As a homeschool mom, we support the HSLDA (Homeschool Legal Defense Assoc.) They fight for our freedom to educate our children in the way we see best. (Without being indoctrinated by the gov't. sanctioned public school system. BTY-I'm also a former public school teacher. I speak from experience.)

I agree that supporting lawyers and assoc. that will take on the ACLU is one of our best options. If we don't act now, it will only get worse. I don't want to know that I was passive and handed our precious freedoms to the Pro-commies. My children deserve a "red, white, and blue" America, not a "RED" Amerika. Wake up and smell the stench of communism! It's at our door step.

Christianity is just one of many faiths
Christianity is just one of many faiths to be had in the States. So by all means, put out a creche, but put it out with a Menorah (better yet, put out a display for Rosh Hoshanah or Simchat Torah which are much more important days) and maybe an homage to Eid and deck an evergreen tree for the Winter Solstice and figure out what people do for Diwali. As long as the religious display doesn't elevate Christianity as more central or important than any other religion, I've no problem with it. The problem is many people want Christianity vaunted above other faiths in the land, and that is something I would argue with as I'm no Christian yet am just as much a part of this nation as everyone else.

It would be a VERY MERRY Christmas if
the ACLU WERE "legally destroyed"!

Thanks for that picture in my mind, Grey Ghost!

Send Christmas cards to the ACLU
Address:

ACLU
125 Broad St.
18th Floor
NY, NY 10004

Send a creche with three wise men and no mealy-mouthed Season's Greetings, either.

Christianity is just one of many faiths
HOWEVER it would be fake for followers of one religion to "celebrate" another religion just so the practitioners of the "minority" religion wouldn't feel left out.

This is a democracy ruled by the majority where the rights of the minorities are protected.

I am free to stand up a say what I believe. Why should I have to stand up and tell you what someone else believes?

If You Don't Want A Creche
If you don't want to see a creche in the town square, ...

If you don't want to hear "Merry Christmas" from store greeters, ...

If you think school children shouldn't sing "Away in a Manger" and "We Three Kings" at the Christmas concert, ..

Then you'd better not be attending any Christmas parties; you'd better not be preparing festive, holiday (HOLY day), foods; your kids had better not be getting presents from Santa Claus (St. Nickolaus); you'd better have been first in line to volunteer to work on December 25; and you'd better be ready to give your Christmas bonus back to the boss.

If you have any desire of any kind to restrict Christians' constitutionally-guaranteed RIGHT to the free exercise of their religion, which means that we are allowed to be Christian in public, then you'd better be taking steps to make 100% certain that you do not benefit from Christmas in any way whatsoever.

Otherwise you're the lowest, sleaziest, most disgusting sort of hypocrite.

Absolutely no war on Christmas
This chant was designed to gather more viewers to a few nonsense TV programs. That is all. Every store that I have been in when Christmas shopping has said whatever it is they wished, and nobody really cared until a few merchandisers thought they'd stand on a pulpit and claim they were being treated unfairly.

BillO sold Holiday merchandise while he launched into his panty-bunching tirade.

Didn't the ACLU help out Rush Limbaugh when he illegally obtained Oxy and lost his hearing as a result of his own drug addiction? The ACLU's client is the Bill of Rights, and even a man who should go to jail for doing drugs (Rush's own words) deserves to be put in jail. Thank your God that the ACLU has a real mission and sticks to it.

Kudos to Mother of 4
Right on. I too see the hypocracy of being a non-believer in Christianity and opposing public displays of faith and yet gladly accept the benefits that come with the celebration. I especially like suggesting being willing to work on Christmas Day and giving your bonus back to the boss. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to all. To my Jewish friends Happy Hannukah.

I Take Back The Blasphemy
I apologize for using the lord's name in vain, but you all must understand that it infuriates me when I hear about the ravings of demagagues who try to scare innocent, naive civilians into believing that a war on Christmas is being waged against you. It's just as phony as the so-called North American Union. These people are no better than 9/11 Truthers who claim that the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center were staged as an inside job.
I base my thinking on reason, and reason tells me that if there was a concentrated front against Christmas, I would have seen some tell-tale signs. But I haven't. I still see the great workers of The Salvation Army ringing their bells outside of the Vons supermarket I shop at. I go by the city hall of my town, and I see a beautifully decorated Christmas tree, readied to hold all sorts of presents and goodies. It just infuriates me when a couple of isolated incidents, which they clearly are, are blown out of proportion by conspiracy theorists who want to make a cheap buck by scaring you into their sick-twisted beliefs. I'm sorry, but all of you must be above that and celebrate Christmastime without fear.
Please sing some Christmas carols. Please set up your Christmas lights and make the most joyous and creative displays posible. Please set up a manger scene and share the story of the Birth of Christ. But most importantly of all, tune out the crazies and the pathetic losers who try to scare you into unneccessary paranoia. Merry Christmas To All, And To All A Good Night.

My jaw has dropped and my lip is pouty..
knight,

From olivercromwell.org:

"It is a common myth that Cromwell personally ‘banned’ Christmas during the mid seventeenth century. Instead, it was the broader Godly or parliamentary party, working through and within the elected parliament, which in the 1640s clamped down on the celebration of Christmas and other saints’ and holy days..."

Putting aside the fact that your declaration is WRONG, I fail to see the relevance. I'm sure King Herod was against Christmas, too. But how does that affect us today?

Gray Ghost: we live in a democratic (not constitutional) republic, in which the representatives are elected by the majority, who then enact laws on our behalf.

Moses: you are right on! The Founders feared endorsement of a particular sect within the broader umbrella of Christianity, just as the Church of England (a sect within Christianity) was preferred and established by the crown over Catholicism, etc. The Founders believed that Christianity should always be preferred by the state and, yes, even endorsed [gasp] over other religions or no religion at all.

"There is no war on Christmas"
Just like there's no push for socialism, no concerted effort to shove abortion down our throats, no push to shove indecency down our throats and so on.......


Libs in this country could be standing with the hammers they used to destroy a creche in a town square, all the while screaming at the top of their lungs "There is No war on Christmas!"

I have personally seen towns around here sued by the ACLU over Christmas decorations. I have seen local schools ban "Christmas colors" Kids can't wear Red or Green to school during the month of december, because it may "Offend" a non christian!!!

Since when is freedom from Offense a civil right???

Want to know what the future holds?

http://www.fundmental.com/funpages/flash/pcxmas.php
(My version of a P.C. Christmas card!)

Merry Christmas to everyone (even the trolls) To our jewish friends, Happy Hanukkah!

to "intheMinority"
Didn't the ACLU help out Rush Limbaugh when he illegally obtained Oxy and lost his hearing as a result of his own drug addiction?

So because they backed one right winger, that absolves them from all they've done to destroy the fabric of american life?

Al Capone gave money to charity, that didn't absolve him of the countless murders he committed.

Pull your head out of Hillary's derrierre for a second or 2 and you'll see the world like it truly is.

The ACLU was formed by a reknowned communist, yet you claim they're only looking out for our "civil rights"?

What a maroon.

I want my pagan holiday back.
I want to see Santa Klaus come rollicking through town, tossing out gifts to children while their elders stagger around in drunken debauchery. I want to see fir trees decorated with lights and gifts to the gods, and table laden with food and wine, and naked women dancing the bachanal to the flute music of a cloven-hoofed satyr. I want to see all the things liberals hate; revelry in the streets, happy kids, heterosexual; men and women enjoying each other's company, and if some of them want to go to church and pray to Jesus and wish others a Merry Christmas, so be it. Whatever makes them happy.

And for all of you people who don't like it, go attend the closest ACLU get-together, where I'm sure you'll enjoy the somber silence while waiting for the end of the year to arrive, so you can start banning things all over again.



NOT EQUAL
MikeR, you and too many other mentally lazy Americans use equality as an excuse not to think.

"Jen Jen: When you defend the young girl with the “Allah Akbar” candy canes then I’ll take you more seriously."

And when YOU defend the young girl with the "Eat Shjt and Die" or the "Happy 9/11" candy canes, then I'll laugh at you as I'm laughing now, for the hypocrisy of your universal equality. There is good and evil in the world, and good things don't equal evil things just because you can slap the same label on them (e.g. "religion").

ISLAM is evil; Christianity is not.

Quick quiz: how many Moslems signed the Declaration of Independence?

Islam != Christianity.

Let's see you defend the young girl giving away candy canes that say "Jesus Loves you"... in Tehran. You might even survive the experience. Just don't call a Teddy bear "Mohammad".

THE SECRET MIRACLE OF CHRISTMAS

Each year, more and more friends tell me they have become disillusioned with our modern Christmas. They are depressed by what Christmas now represents in the collective mentality of our society. The expensive glitter of this once Christian holiday is even an economic burden for some people because they spend themselves into serious financial stress trying to satisfy everyone’s expectations.

Hollywood’s Christmas as emotional family gatherings, pleasant as they can sometimes be, is not the point of this day either. Astonishing as it may seem, the true meaning of Christmas is greater drama than anything the shallow moguls of Hollywood could possibly serve up.

Before Jesus appeared, mankind desperately needed, among other things, a far clearer message concerning the definitive purpose or principle by which we should live our lives. This is surely the most profound question each of us must face; therefore, a superb answer was of utmost importance for our well being.

Continued---

The Secret Miracle of Christmas cont.---
So, it was decided in the august counsels of heaven that a divine Person, the Logos (John 1:1, New Testament Greek term for the pre-incarnate Christ Jesus) would permanently divest Himself of the superlative capabilities that had always been His prerogative amid the myriad splendors of the heavenly state (Philippians 2). This glorious Personage of immense authority and majesty would eventually shine mega wattage of theological light into our dark world. But first He literally had to be “morphed” into a divinely enlivened, minuscule human egg in the womb of a virtuous young Jewish girl and then be born as a tiny, helpless baby boy. He would be named Jesus. His incarnational goal was that we might come to understand in fully human terms His principle of benevolent motivation as the only possible basis for a harmonious, salvific one-to-one relationship with God the Father.

As we can easily see, the secret miracle of Christmas wonderfully illumines the true nature of this day, so, Christmas becomes, for those of us who understand it, a joyous celebration of a deliberate, totally unselfish, divine choice for our immense benefit. A choir of a million beatific angels could never adequately praise the exquisite love of the mighty Logos of immense power and glory who became our tiny baby Jesus. This Jesus becomes the Savior of each one of us who responds in profound love to Him who was born that holy night 2,000 years ago.

Now that’s biblical Christmas.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.