Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Friday, October 05, 2007
Brent Bozell :: Townhall.com Columnist
Congress vs. Gangsta Rap
by Brent Bozell
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


On Sept. 25, the House Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade and Consumer Protection, chaired by Bobby Rush, D-Ill., held a very unique hearing, focusing on the way the culture is being soured by the makers of sexist and racially charged rap music. Inspired by the furor over fired radio host Don Imus and his "ho" talk, the hearing was titled "From Imus to Industry: The Business of Stereotypes and Degrading Images."

That's a great title. For years now, record companies have made untold millions of dollars spreading a message glorifying the thug life, preaching greed and lust, and portraying women as nothing more than pornographic mannequins. From the debate that emerged on Capitol Hill, it's very easy to find the winners and the losers.

Winner: Bobby Rush. The congressman could have knuckled under from pressure by the anything-goes Old Guard of gangsta rap, but instead he boldly put his prestige where his heart is. He said this music of violence and degradation has ''reduced too many of our youngsters to automatons, those who don't recognize life, those who don't value life.''

He was unequivocal. "There is a problem -- a deep-seated, deeply rooted problem in our country," he said. "The paycheck is not an excuse for being part of the problem."

Loser: Michael Eric Dyson. The professor and Bill Cosby-hating author has become America's leading excuse-maker for irresponsible thug music. He blamed America, that never-draining cesspool of racism, for whatever problem exists. "America is built upon degrading images of black men and women, so any discussion of misogyny or homophobia or sexism has got to dig deep into America, including Congress and corporate and religious institutions."

Rush was not accepting that ridiculous excuse. He understands black rage against injustice in America, but in no way does it justify thuggery. He said: "I still have rage, but how do I channel it? Am I going to spew out counterproductively? Or do I accept a higher responsibility to take my rage and do something to improve the community?"

Winner: Master P. The former gangsta-rapper (his real name is Percy Miller) came to Congress and apologized for his musical transgressions. The angry music of his past, he said, came from seeing relatives and friends shot and killed. But he said now he doesn't even want his own children to listen to his music, "so if I can do anything to change this, I'm going to take a stand and do that." He also apologized to women for his music. "I was honestly wrong."

Later on NPR, he explained that listening to other gangsta-rappers "inspired" his own violent lyrics, like Ice-T boasting, "I am a nightmare stalking, psychopath walking." He said that song "put me in the mood when I was in the ghetto just to continuously make music like that." It was inspiring that he mustered the fortitude to confess before Congress.

Loser: David Banner. This rapper with the "Incredible Hulk" stage name (real name: Levell Crump) lived up to his rage-spewing image. He blamed everyone else for his own disgusting lyrics. "Hip-hop is sick because America is sick," he said. "Change the situation in my neighborhood, and maybe I'll get better."

But of course Crump doesn't really want to get better or do better. He wants to continue trotting out the usual poet-of-the-streets bilge: "Rap music is the voice of the underbelly of America. In most cases, America wants to hide the negative that it does to its people. Hip hop is the voice, and how dare America not give us the opportunity to be heard!"

Loser: the music-selling conglomerates. Corporate officials sitting before Congress were unafraid to stand up for lyrics extolling profanity, criminality and sexism. Asked if explicit lyrics by rapper 50 Cent constituted free speech, Doug Morris of Universal Music proclaimed: "Yes. It is not my place in life to tell him what to say."

Warner Music boss Edgar Bronfman said tasteless language ''is in the eye of the beholder.'' (Tell that to Don Imus.) And Phillippe Dauman, the president of Viacom (think MTV and BET), extolled the scummy street poetry: "We have a responsibility to speak authentically to our viewers." Viacom should be authentically rejected by consumers.

Winner: the music-buying public. In a poll of black Americans by The Associated Press and AOL-Black Voices last year, 50 percent of respondents said hip-hop was a negative force in American society. Due to a growing feeling that the gangsta rappers have grown far too negative, rap sales slid a whopping 21 percent from 2005 to 2006, and for the first time in 12 years no rap album was among the top 10 sellers of the year. If thug music is a sickness, the public seems to be getting immunized.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Founder and President of the Media Research Center, Brent Bozell runs the largest media watchdog organization in America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Brent Bozell's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Thank GOD
It's about time.

Let the people decide.
Free market capitalism, ya gotta love it. Not only are gangsta rappers taking a hit in the marketplace, cd sales have taken a nosedive as well. The reason being the American public is getting tired of the bilge being pushed by the music industry biggies. The internet has opened up a brave new world of consumer choice in music. The sheer arrogance of music industry executives attempting to dictate musical trends is mind boggling. Until they bow to the dictates of the marketplace, their days are numbered.

The dirty
language in this "cesspool screech" "music" surely offends some, so where are the harassment law suits?
And where are the parents?
And what ever happened to people who could SING?

I remember
the mid-80s when congress had hearings or some darn thing in order to show their concern with explicit rock music lyrics. algore and tippy were prominent those days and even Frank Zappa had a few things to say. (Anyone out there remember the "Phi Crappa Zappa" poster?) It was all a bit beyond ridiculous for those days, but that was nothing compared to these days.

Remember the Beatles? Remember how many influences their music had? IMO that was because they had grown up hearing all different kinds of music - blues, classical, jazz, skiffle, r&r etc. and so when they started making their own music, sooner or later those influences all showed up. Of course it also helps if you have talent.

In contrast to that todays's music(?) makers have grown up hearing not much more than r&r and so that's all they can really do, and it shows.

Rap? Cra>


Maybe
the people were afraid to express in thoughts relating to religion for fear of being sued by the communist led ACLU.

Religion is constantly under attack from the Socialist Liberals(hillary"s groundhogs), Schools, Universitys and Holywood's Hos & pimps.

A Bit Of A Sweeping...
...generalisation there Uncle Max!! While I'm no fan of gangsta rap (although if BBIII is against it the juvenile within me almost wants to try and like it), some rap music does have merit. Early Public Enemy was groundbreaking stuff with a substantive message whether one agreed with it or not. The Beastie Boys also have produced some amazing music and with Paul's Boutique changed the way music is recorded rather like The Beatles with Sgt Peppers.
I also have to say Eminem's first 3 albums were superb.

Dyson had a point
Racism is still a big problem in this country. But until we face up to the fact that a lot of it is black racism directed at white people, we won't solve that problem.

"free speech"
This is just more of the same liberal canard - freedom of speech does not guarantee you a forum to spew your filth beyond whatever corner you stand on.

The music industry has no obligation to put this filth out, any more than they would to publish Al Qaeda sermons. Freedom of speech claims like this are just an excuse for lack of judgment or responsibility.

Gangsta Rap
It is amazing that I have been able to avoid this plague that is gangsta rap. You know what I do? I don't buy it and I don't watch it. That is a novel idea. I think we should really start a charity that provides working remotes and channel buttons to those whose apparently don't work.

Also Rap music is sliding because the quality of its craft has seriously declined. It is nothing but an unintelligible chorus for the most part. When Gansta Rap started and NWA started that was not the case, the choruses were a smaller part of the song and the people that would mouth the song in public never concentrated on the chorus. The whole point of rap is the rhymes between the chorus. Master P should apologize for this more than his language because he started the craze by introducing Southern Rap to the populace. If Brent is trying to claim false victory for his statistic, he denies history, controversy in areas like rap, pop, and rock only increase sales. The last time they tried this, when they rolled out he Parental Advisory labels, rap shot through the roof. That was because there was adequate talent to ride the wave of controversy, not so today.




Bozo
is once againg rising the banner for United Soviet Evenglical Republics where Congress knows best what people should listen, read or watch. Given the free choice they might actually want to see something else Bozo and his ilk wants them to see.

More and more censorship, more and more curtailing of free speech, more and more congress meddling with consumer choices, more and more fake outrage and moralistic pandering...

Has this Bozo ever heard of freedom of choice. if you don't like it, don't buy it you idiot. Or market it by launching these neverending crusades against citizens choosing for themselves.


The problem is
the people making choices not the music. I grew up in the 90's on gangsta rap. I grew up poor and related to it. It didn't cause me to become a career criminal or a thug. It inspired me to keep focused to work and to avoid that type of life. I haven't bought a rap CD in the last 5 years, but I'll occasionally throw on some of my old CDs and remember the struggle I had. It's got nothing to do with teh music. It has to do with how you use the music.

The world is not nice and pretty it's ugly and hard. People are evil and greedy. You can't stop free will and you can't stop people who are looking for exuses to be violent thugs from finding them. Liberals have been trying to stop certain music and screw with social engenering for years as they attempt to mimic failed policies of the Nazis, the old Soviet Union, and other failed policies of failed nations. It's time for every real AMERICAN to stand up for their constitutional rights. I have the right to say it. You don't have to buy it, hear it, listen to it, or like it. You do NOT have a right not to be offended.

Get governemnt out of the life of the people and let us make our choices and accept the consequences of those actions. Don't try to save me from my decisions by banning what I like or offering me handouts (welfare) because I screwed up. Make me fix my life and be a responcible person. Don't try to do it for me because then I'll have no reason to try to fix it myself.

My music
I grew up as hip-hop was growing up, and to this day it remains "my music" and it ain't all bad. The problem is that for every Erick Sermon out there, the media concentrates on 50 Cent, so the real hip-hop artists are drowned out by rap music. The way I, and many others see it, there is a difference between "rap" and hip-hop. Hip-hop is more about the actual lyrics, the beats, and the the rhymes while rap music is corporate garbage. It is the rap industry that gives you 50, Li' John, and all the rest of the sound alikes. The real hip hop is being done by Jay-Z, Nas, Erick Sermon, Keith Murray, Common, Mos Def---the list goes on, but the mainstream media only gives you 50, Kanye West, and Snoop Dogg.

Also, not all hip hop is "gangsta" and if you don't believe me then check out Erick Sermon's "Chilltown, New York" album for real hip hop that is true to the game.

Finally, I have to ask if this is what we really want the Congress to be involved in? Does it bother anyone else here that Congress is holding hearings on lyrical content in music? I don't care how bad it is, Congress getting involved is even worse!

Stang200s6
You are so right. Let the people decide what they want to listen to.

Hypocrites
If a Skinhead Group put out a song about killing Black People, The Black community would rise up as one and DEMAND that it be banned and they would be right! But Gangsta Crap which glorifies Promiscuity, Murder and Addiction is excused. Why? Among the reasons given:
1. America is sick!
2. I grew up in a bad neighborhood!
3. America is built upon degrading images of black men and women!
WAAA! WAAA! WAAA!

Answers
1. No it’s not, Gangsta Crap IS!
2. MOVE!
3. No it’s not! Gangsta Crap IS!

Beetles
Hey, I remember when Evangelicals had heartburn over Beetle music. I think people are getting all nostalgic for the "Good Old Days" that really weren't all that good.

Remember the old "Satanic Messages when you Play it Backwards" nonsense?

Remember the old "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds is CODE for the illegal drug LSD"? The song was actually inspired by the songwriter's daughter, who painted a little picture, the sort of thing one attaches to the refrigerator with a magnet -- they kept quiet about that until much later, because the controversy generated sales.

Moralistic Busybodies who want to involve Congress in everything for everybody just NEVER learn. There is ALWAYS something "new" that is "worse than ever before" that's going to mean the "End of Civilization As We Know It" --

-- then, 20, 10, 5, or even 2 years later, all the ruckus is blown over, the Busybodies are off after new villains, Civilization is still here, the music that caused all the hoopla is playing on the "Golden Oldies" stations, and listeners (now parents themselves) get all misty-eyed over the "Good Old Days".

rap
again this is nothing more than the continued belief tyhat this is the level of accomplishment ? we should expect from blacks. Glorifying self hatred and violence is never going to help defeat low self esteem and lead blacks to the promised land of accomplishment of achievement. The gansta notion that learning to read , write and acquire an education is acting white is further proof of this destructuve life style. Even the sage rev jackson accuses obama of acting white when he disagrees with some position oabama takes. But until blacks through of the shackles of this self hatred and detructive lifestyles nothing will change. Hating society for your own self destruction is never going to change the status quo. Accepting the staus quo of poor education results and hero whorship for the gangsta culture will never put food on the table or a roof over anyone's head except for the handful of those sending forth this hatred and filth. But hat's how the dims want it to continue. As long as they can continue to stoke the fire of racism and assure blacks there is no consequence for irresposible behavior but that the dims will always sponsor programs that rescue poor choices nothing will change. But don't these same blacks who are chained to the dims plantation have a right to aspire to loftier goals. Obviously their leaders and the dims don't think so.

Anyone Here...
...remember the coniptions (?) certain people had over 'satanic messages' in music in the 80's? That farce even made it to court!!! That was a real "only in America" item over here.
I also remember Tipper Gore and her vendetta against the Dead Kennedys and Marilyn Manson being blamed for Columbine, I saw that one coming on the day of the tragedy and the great US media didn't let me down!!.
Also Georgetwin, I hope you are not inferring all skinheads are racist!! The original skinhead movement was born in the UK and it's main influence was the music and fashion of the West Indian immigrants

Uncle Alby
I understand your post, and I share the sentiment; congress should really not be wasting time on this nonsense.

That said, nobody can listen to modern hardcore rap and compare it to the beatles. Yes, parents were offended by Beatles lyrics, but if they had been exposed to modern rap music they would have had a coronary.

Recently I was working in a local kitchen that I service; the staff had a Fifty Cent CD on and the lyrics blew me away. I lost count of how many times the N word was used, usually in the context of killing enemies in a driveby shooting.

At one point, the lyrics state something to the effect of, "You shouldnt have moved away homie, cause I know where your mom and daughter live and Im gonna burn them out." That isnt an exact quote, but its fairly close. Glorification of murder should be offensive to everyone, not just, "uptight Christian types."

But again, it isnt something I think congress should be wasting their time with. Frankly we need to speak out against this kind of garbage as concerned citizens even though it will likely do little good. At least, we won't be condoning it by our silence.

bob
like all things that are circulating in the media. Probably the huge majority can hear something and it doesn't effect them in the least. But the message of self hatred and lack of respect for fellow human beings is unlike anything that has ever come before. Oh course there is no way govt should regulate anyone's free speech. But also others shouldn't be honoring hate speech as though it is emblematic of supposed culture. But there should also be alternative messages that tells the impressionable the essential message is one that teaches this disrespect for others but also teaches that you lack respect for yourself that this music is attracting your attention

Still, I'm Not Worried
For once, I feel encouraged after reading a Bozell column.

Apparently the Market has Spoken, and this kind of stuff just doesn't sell well anymore. So what's everybody all worked up about? Alternative messages *ARE* out there, people *DO* make their disgust known to record companies, and kids *EVENTUALLY* listen to what their parents keep nagging them about. And so, this kind of offensive garbage just starts to lose popularity.

When the Market stops Buying, the people stop Selling. Works every time.

Of course, there's always the *next* thing down the pike to "have a coronary" over! Then we can get back to fussing over the new Powers and Control that Bozell et al want to give the FCC to "stomp out" some new bit of offensiveness.

I can't wait!

Congress vs. Gangsta Rap
I don't like Gansta rap. That being the case, I don't buyor listen to it. The markett is in the process of making the problem much better. As market share declines less and less will be made.

I do not think that censorship is justified or practical. You would need a police state to get rid of all rap music.

khan
celebrating disrespect for others is not any indication of black culture. But celebrating gansta culture is likewise destructive. But the question remains can the damage already done already be overcome

Hi Wildwest
I agree about disrespect, but don't you think congress has more important things to do than holding hearings on the music we listen to? I though conservatives were all about less interference in our private lives.

I'm not a fan, by the way, I'm more of a jazz and classical music type...but I don't think rap has damaged the culture. Remember when we were kids, everyone said exactly the same things about Presley and Little Richard. And rock music in general.

Wild West
Go Tribe!!!!! Two to ZIP!!
I don't think the government getting involved in censorship is a good thing. That said I think a lot of parental oversight is needed here. half the people in America put their kids out the door at 9AM and don't see them again till 5:30-6:00. When their kids get into trouble, they scream why my baby?
As far as Vespanat saying Eminem is so "Excelent", I don't se how denegrating all women and promoting raping and beating women is so great. Sounds like the lyrics of a coward to me. Just my opinion.

Re: Rap music is destroying our culture
Here we go again, when are you and the rest of this country going to stop this madness about blaming music for societies ills. Censorship in any form is wrong. Of course as the saying goes you can't yell fire in a crowded theatre... unless of course the theatre is on fire. Isn't that the point here, the artists in the most part are commenting on what they see and hear in their environment. I don't own any gangsta rap music and maybe the reason is the same as to why I stopped buying Bruce Springsteen albums years ago when I started living in the suburban hills of Connecticut. Bruce himself said it's hard to sing songs for the working man when you are living in a several million dollar mansion in the country side of Jersey. There are many more infra and inter strucural problems in this society that need adressing then having our triple figure congress men and women spending our hard earned dollars on topics like The threat of Don Imus and the rap community on the well being of our children. How about universal health care...How about equality of resources for the inner-city education systems so they have the same tools to learn that the kids have in the suburbs. This whole issue is nothing more then a distraction form the real problems.

Wakes me up in the morning; ideally.....
I'm glad to say the lyrics still shock me, so I have one of these stations on my clock radio to wake me up in the morning. It keeps me alert to the rot, I suppose.

We've gone from a society where radio stations once banned "Wake up, Little Susie" and "Young Girl," which gave serious homage to shame, to this filth. Even many of the songs without explicit lyrics are (no doubt purposely) seductive, though you could argue no more so than many Jazz tunes of old, but there are enough with lyrics that leave nothing to the imagination but with little or no redeeming value.

The ideal solution would be for the market to dry up for this stuff, so it can be marginalized, at least to the point where we usually find XXX-rated movies, for instance (big business but not really mainstream). Short of that, some political noise doesn't hurt, so parents at least have a headsup. There are enough cesspools out there but if few people showed up, they would have a lot less impact.

--Mike D.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.