Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Ben Shapiro :: Townhall.com Columnist
The Never-Ending Bailout and the End of American Economic Dominance
by Ben Shapiro
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Our political leadership -- folks like President George W. Bush, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson, Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., and President-elect Barack Obama -- told us that the government would save us. They said that the economic crisis was so dire, so grim, that we needed to allow the government to spend our money to bail out Wall Street. They stated that Paulson, with full authority and no oversight, would be able to right the ship.

We were ignorant enough to believe them.

Now they tell us that Paulson has exercised his authority recklessly. They say that they want their oversight back. They state that they need more cash for bailouts, and they need more leeway to create new regulatory schemes.

Will we be stupid enough to believe them again?

So far, the federal bailout, which was designed to jumpstart lending, has cost $300 billion and produced no effect. This is not a surprise. Lenders are rational actors. They tightened lending standards because they were hit hard by the subprime crisis -- a crisis caused by lax lending standards. But instead of seeing stricter lending standards and occasional bankruptcies as the natural outgrowth of bad decisions, the government panicked. The credit had to flow, our politicians told us. And the best way to make the credit flow was to hand over more cash to lenders.

This, of course, was sheer idiocy. Handing lenders money wasnt going to get them to loosen lending standards again. That money was earmarked for lenders savings from the moment they received it -- lenders first priority is to their stockholders, who want to see profit margin, not more bad loans.

But the government wants bad loans to continue. And so the government has decided that if lenders wont provide them, the government will. The first step is rescuing the Big Three in Detroit. Were told that General Motors Corp., Ford Motor Co. and Chrysler are the key to American industry -- a statement laughable in its exaggeration. Were told that if automakers go under, unemployment will skyrocket. Were told that these companies are too big to fail.

Heres something thats too big to fail: Americas entrepreneurial spirit. But no one seems to care about that. Instead, were supposed to worry about the risky lenders who bet wrong on the market; the risky borrowers who took mortgages they could never pay; and the risky investors who counted on both risky lenders and risky borrowers to keep the waterwheel of cash turning. In doing so, we ignore those who could actually heal the economy: solid lenders, solid borrowers and smart investors who will pick up the pieces of broken businesses and lead the way. But they dont matter. Instead, say the politicians, we should focus on GM. We should focus on Lehman Brothers. We should focus on the failures. And we should bail them out.

If we do, we will pay the price of a prolonged recession.

These bailouts have monetary costs that will cripple American business. Someone will have to pay for these bailouts. Either we will have to pay for them with higher taxes, or we will have to pay for them through inflation. The government is investing our money in bad stock. Would you buy GM stock right now? The government will, with your hard-earned dollar.

These bailouts also have psychological costs that breed dependency. Paulson is fond of saying that he wants to be wary of moral hazard the idea that we must not give incentives for bad behavior but then pushes rewarding reckless companies with taxpayer handouts. Meanwhile, both Democrats and Republicans recommend rewarding risky borrowers by keeping them in the houses they cant pay for. How long will it be before folks stop paying their credit card bills and mortgages altogether, hoping that the government will step in to save them?

What we are watching is Carter-esque interference with the economy. President Bushs handling of this economic debacle will go down as the biggest black mark on his legacy. While supposedly touting the importance of capitalism, Bush has embraced the same Keynesian solutions that trashed the economy during the 1930s and 1970s. And both Republicans and Democrats go right along with him, psychotically citing the Great Depression while ignoring the basic fact that Presidents Herbert Hoover and Franklin Delano Roosevelts tinkering made a depression into the Great Depression.

The bailout is a disaster. And the politicians will continue fostering this disaster until the American people say, Enough. We dont need your help. We will do this ourselves.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Ben Shapiro is a regular guest on dozens of radio shows around the United States and Canada and author of Project President: Bad Hair and Botox on the Road to the White House.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Ben Shapiro's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
 
©Creators Syndicate
Dear Ben ....
I never believed them. In my mind politicians are usually lawyers and their credance level starts at about the level of child molesters and actors and works down from there.
If Washington DC were nuked tomorrow I can't see the loss, there's always someone else who is completely void of principle waiting in the wings to take charge and the country is predominantly filled with folks who celebrate demagoguery.
If a person's doctor or garbage man dies, the person has lost something of real value. Too bad folks aren't able to see the valuable from the profane.
How could anyone not anticipate all the events that are occurring. It couldn't possibly be any other way.
We should be happy with ourselves, this is where we were aiming and we've hit the mark!

I disagree, Ben
We must have the auto bailout or loan if we are to save the middle class in the US....and save the Republican Party......and save our last major industry in the US.

The annihilation of the middle class is on the international elites' agenda. If we don't give the auto industry the bailout or loan, they can check off that goal on their to-do list.

Indiana is #1 in manufacturing. We have many, many, many auto industry suppliers in this state.

The Republican Party stands to lose lots and lots of votes in the future if they do not agree to this bailout or loan for Main Street. Although it is apparent to conservatives that it is the liberals who are the hogs at the trough on Wall Street, the Democrat voters don't see it that way. And perception is truth.

Pamela form IN
The airline industry went through a few bankrupcies. It too has many suppliers in the pacific northwest.

After going through bankruptcy and reorganization, the airliines are better able to compete and the high paying jobs for its suppliers are still there.

Today most of the problems airlines are incountering have more to do with the high cost of fuel and delays due to increased security.

Two problems caused by Liberals.

Home mortgages paid tax free.
The government has royally screwed up this bailout. There is a very simple solution. This mess is because of the housing market so without fixing that first we will not recover. My idea is to allow people to pay down their mortgages with pre tax dollars and to purchase new homes with the same. Set a time frame 2 -5 years and set a limit 25-50000 a year. It would solve the housing problem very quickly and create confidence in the country. Please get this idea out there. I proposed it on Fox Business Network on Sat. morning and the idea went over very well. More to it than just this but I want someone on the blog or radio to put it forth.
John the Dentist

America's surreal mess
I honestly wake up each day, feeling as if I am in some surreal, Franz Kafka story. Will I wake up as a giant cockroach tomorrow? Or will Henry Paulson? How does one makes sense of this, go to work each day, plan for Thanksgiving (irony of ironies) and maintain sanity? Only my hairdresser and the illuminati Wizard of Oz know for sure.

Sheer Faith
Your answer is in your name. We go on because God is in the heavens and all is in His hands. This Thanksgiving concentrate on the true blessings in your life. Things can always be worse, and usually in someone else's life you can see that. Last year I was fighting for my life through catastrophic illness that my dr. told me, after all was said and done, he thought I would never make it through. Blessings. My grandkids, blessings. We have food, and housing, blessings.

Pray for our great country and God's intervention on our behalf. Blessings will flow. Read Job in the Old Testament. Things got worse for him before they got better.

There is always hope for those who believe. Maybe not here on earth, but things will get better.

Ben, Ben, Ben
You are wise beyond your years sir. You did however make one mistake. You stated that there has been no results from the bailout, that is incorrect, there is a result.....the stockmarket is deeper in the toilet than it was before the bailout. Other than that, 5 checks as per usual.

Pamela
"and save our last major industry in the US."

Since when? You mean the last major dinosaur from a part of the economy that is a living fossil from a by gone era? GM is the industrial version of the Ginkgo biloba.

Microsoft, Intel, Google and the like aren't part of a major industry in the US?

Years ago there were many many "buggy" producers. Now very few--there are still some, but very few. The US probably doesn't need over a dozen car companies--let's see BMW, Benz, Toyota, Nissan, VW, Audi, Saab, Suzuki, Kia, Hyundai, Honda, Isuzu (soon to be gone), Mazda, Alpha Romeo (sooner or later). I am sure I have missed some--just as the airlines are finding out it can't go on with 6 full fare airlines.

In the 1950s there were seven major US car makers and now down to 3. It won't be the end of the world if that number goes to two or one or even zero. A reduction from say 12 car makers in the US to nine won't be the end of the world, the end of the US economy or even millions of people out of work. Will there be some job losses? yes. Will some areas like Michigan be hurt badly, well that is what happens when you foolishly engage in monocrop business models, but yes. But that is the nature of markets. They reward the good--see Toyota and punish the bad--see GM. Giving GM anything only prolongs the pain and suffering. GM's salvation is the bankruptcy courts, it should file post haste.

Ken
Bankruptcy won't work in this case. Comparing the auto industry with the airline industry is like comparing apples to oranges.

People want to know they have a warranty they can depend on when they make a major purchase like a car. It's completely different from shelling out a couple hundred dollars for an airline ticket.




Subsidise failed businesses?
Chrysler was bailed out once. Now we have to bail out the entire industry?
It was a mistake to bail out failed monetary institutions.
It will be another mistake to bail out automakers who have obviously make poor business decisions.
When the government backs up everything, we have a socialist state. Communism doesn't work, no matter who practices it.
Better to let new business spring up to allow the free market to act. And provide temporary unemployment to CONSUMERS who will then put it into the market to allow it to recover.

Reaganite
One word: Kia. 'Nuff said. The claim that "people won't buy our products...blah blah blah..if we go bankrupt." Is pure tripe. No worse, propaganda to fools and idiots inside and outside government to approve the welfare payments.

Did people still buy Kia? Yes. Is Kia still around? Yes. When Mitsubishi was under heavy stress and people weren't sure if it was going to make it people still bought from them. And if they (GM et al) do fail, so be it as I said there are probably way too many brands out there for the market to support and if the three that fail are GM, Chrysler and Ford, again, so be it or if say Toyota now has a 40% stake in GM and Honda has a 35% in Ford, again, so be it.

But money from the government is not going to solve the problem. Reorganization via the bankruptcy courts will.

Builders have also gone bankrupt and people still buy those homes. You will no doubt have to find a way to assure that the 3/36,000 or 5/60,000 or whatever will be honored even if say GM vanishes and you will have to greatly discount the inventory as well so people will be willing to take the chance, but to say no one will buy your product simply because you are bankrupt is pure tripe.

What keeps people from buying are other issues. Cars overpriced compared to other brands and the perception--often well deserved--that the Big Three make crappy products.




SAY NO TO THE BAILOUT...
If we give the big 3 a handout and the unions get it… We will be fund the Dem’s next election cycle.. ARGGHHHHHHHHHH

http://www.conservativeusa.org/mega-cong.htm

The Never-Ending Bailout
I wrote this over a month ago:
Paulson is just trying to “bail out” a few of his big bucks buddies at taxpayers’ expense. America better completely disregard this bozo and look at the problem from a clean slate approach. Flow chart and diagram in detail the whole Ponzi scheme of the financial industry. Determine exactly what went wrong and why. Assign fair blame and seriously punish wrongdoing. Create new, better rules/laws to make the financial industry more honest, transparent, and accountable. Include “just right” oversight by regulatory agencies. This will take time, lots of time but if we don’t want a repeat of this or worse in 5-10 years then we need to do it right…now. Oct 3, 2008 - 12:52 PM EST

NO IS EASY TO SAY
NO MORE BAILOUTS, STOP THE STIMULUS CHECKS BALANCE THE CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET

$25 billion feast
People would still buy GM - if they got their money's worth. The truth is that unions have pushed the costs of these cheap, overdesigned deathtraps to where they just aren't competitive.

Here's another truth. With GM's stock so low, why doesn't some other big conglomerate step up and buy the company? The reason: the union contracts make the future of GM unviable. It will fail unless those contracts are renegotiated.

What we have here is a short-term bailout of the unions. They will renegotiate, eventually, but only after they've feasted on the $25 billion Uncle Sam is sending their way.

Looking thru the looking glass - Pt. II
The consumer-price-index released this morning showed that the consumer price index fell the most in 60 years in the last month and people cheered! Are they insane? This is a huge step on the critically painful route of devaluation. House mortgages are bad now, but what will they be if devaluation takes root? Possibly, one-fourth of what they are today. Will people want to buy a car today for $20,000 when it might be worth $10,000 in the future? No.

Right now, is not the time for experimental surgery or another retarded governmental “band-aid.” First, everyone needs to calm down for a few days. Then, let the car companies go into voluntary bankruptcy where they can renegotiate their contracts without the union breathing down their necks. The shareholders and option holders will get slammed and their value will become $0, but they have already lost so much anyway that there seems that nothing can be done to get it back. So, into Chap. 11, a federal judge will rework the contracts with dealers, unions and suppliers, fire management, and hire someone like Romney, who knows the business and saw his father do the same thing and studied his father’s model in Bus. School and used it through out his career to turn around companies. Also, Obama needs to step back on cap-and-trade and another more difficult Kyoto.

This is the wrong time in our market to even talk about experimentation and instituting new requirements on an economy in dire straits and an industry on life support. If Obama does any of this and Congress gives the automotive industry a bailout, I am with Mitt Romney that we “can kiss” American car companies “good-bye”. And, “back to the future” policies of the 1970’s or 1930’s for everyone else.

Looking thru the looking glass - Pt. I
Obama, this sure sounds like it will both help the economy and the global environment! NOT.

GM, individually, is hemorrhaging $66 million dollars a day; loses between $500 and $1,000 on each and every car it sells; owes $48 Billion Dollars to creditors, who could force it into involuntary bankruptcy at anytime; beyond the imagination (around $90 Billion or more) in payment, retirement, health care, and other goodies to current and past employees; and, has no plan to immediately restructure the company, outside of bankruptcy, and wants a portion of, at least, $25 billion in a bailout (which is a next to big, fat zero on their balance sheet).

Obama spoke in the last two days that the global environment is in, basically, critical condition, and that no time is a good time to implement environmental programs; yet, he plans to do exactly that. He wants to place expansive cap-and-trade policies in America and force companies like GM to build more fuel efficient and lighter cars in the very near future.

Additionally, the Obama Administration and the Kyoto Treaty nations want to sign a more severe agreement in 2010. Today, Canada, a signatory and one of the best countries at attempting to meet the requirements, is further behind meeting the goals than when it signed, according to Canadian environmentalists. Yet, the US and the Kyoto nations are going to sign another document while excluding the two most explosive markets in the world, China and India.

Foreign manufacturers receive..
subsidies, too. Kia was recently wooed by the state of Georgia to build a plant there while Ford and GM were closing plants in the metro Atlanta area. Kia is investing it's own capital, but the state is also on the hook for $250million in outright expenditures and tax breaks. If things don't work out for KIA, the state taxpayers also lose as well as the people working for these manufacturers. In fact every foreign manufacturer that has set up operations in the U.S. has been subsidized by the respective state they are in.
Don't get me wrong, I think the big three should go to the bankruptcy courts. It's the only way to straighten out their situation. For all of the bad press they get, they still do make some good vehicles.

Unemployment will be
in double digits next year. The world economy is imploding and entering a dangerous deflationary sprial. Bailing out Detroit won't make much of a difference in a weak economy. Adding more debt to the Federal balance sheet is idiocy because that debt will be worth less in a deflationary environment. We're facing a bitter reality in this country. The lessons of the 1930's will have to be relearned all over again.

bailout
the author said "the politicians will continue fostering this disaster until the American people say, Enough." However, we said that once and they did not listen.

When our government does things that make no sense and are definitely NOT in the best interest of Americans and our country, I start to wonder WHY....

Situations like this make me think that they might have another agenda that they are not telling us about.........

Government OUT of bailing companies OUT
"...The bailout is a disaster. And the politicians will continue fostering this disaster until the American people say, Enough. We dont need your help. We will do this ourselves."

I've been saying "ENOUGH" since the first 700B bailout. Let the free market, capitalistic system work. Of course, American socialists/commies hate capitalism. To them I say: "Leave America. Go live in friggin' Canada or Sweden. They're nice socialist nations. Leave our system alone!"

God, I hope stupid, gullible Americans will finally wake the hell up to what is happening to this country and say "ENOUGH!!!"

America is suffering
America is suffering unlawful deception from the Alinsky group.
Group u$urp$ power on January 20th—the constitution violated.
The United States Supreme Court alone can relieve this outrage.

example: Bogus Selective Service System FOIA Registration?
http://www.debbieschlussel.com/archives/2008/11/exclusive_d id_n.html
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.