Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Austin Bay :: Townhall.com Columnist
Memorial Day 2008
by Austin Bay
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


"We're a military at war, not a nation at war," the lieutenant colonel said ever so quietly but harshly as he leaned across the table at an Austin, Texas-area Rotary Club luncheon.

"We're a military at war, not an entire country," the newly promoted Marine major said vehemently, in the confines of a classroom at the USMC Command and Staff College at Quantico, Va.

"You know what the problem is, Col. Bay. We're here at war, and the rest of the country is on its butt," the operations sergeant said to me.

Let's review the timeline. The lieutenant colonel said that to me in spring 2006. The Marine major said that to me the first week of May 2008. As for the ops sergeant, his blunt instrument of an observation hails from summer 2004, delivered in and around Baghdad and delivered often.

For the mass audience, I have scrubbed his language. But in the cinema verite version I wouldn't -- not for the sake of drama or display of tough guy anger, but for his genuine expression of deep disappointment and thorough disgust.

Anyone who spends time in the field encounters outstanding men and women from the State Department, U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and CIA, but since 9-11 the American military and their families have certainly borne the brunt of our war efforts.

Maybe it was always so. My diet of U.S. Civil War histories has increased in the last couple of years -- the 150th anniversary of Fort Sumter is less than three years away. The Civil War remains America's "great brush with history" and close brush with national demise. I've paid more attention to descriptions of the Union's "home front," particularly in the Midwest and Illinois -- and I am certain this is due to our current experience with the War on Terror's complex home front. At times anti-war sentiments in the North were expressed as disdain for Union soldiers.

Yet in the wake of the greatest, most destructive war the United States has ever experienced, Memorial Day emerged. Decoration Day, a day in May set aside for "decorating" the graves of dead soldiers with flowers, began as a Union observance. The Website usmemorialday.org notes that Southern states "refused to acknowledge the day, honoring their dead on separate days until after World War I (when the holiday changed from honoring just those who died fighting in the Civil War to honoring Americans who died fighting in any war)."

Memorial Day became a national day, a healing day of remembrance to say "thanks," no matter one's history.

Public observances have waxed and waned. Post-World War II, they waxed. Post-Vietnam, in many places they faded.

Fellow soldiers keep the faith, however. On May 28, 2005, I delivered a brief Memorial Day speech at the Travis County International Cemetery. The place is one of those plots of ground with a decidedly checkered past. In the 19th century, it was a "paupers graveyard." Today, a group of Hispanic veterans, Tejanos in Action, tends the graves of indigent American veterans buried in the cemetery.

The ceremony was simple. A Tejanos honor guard conducted a flag ceremony. A bugler played taps, and the honor guard fired a 21-gun salute. I kept the speech short -- and here's the gist of it:

"... At one time, this cemetery is what another era called a potter's field ... a gravesite for the destitute, for the disenfranchised, for the socially disdained, for those grand society might conveniently forget.

"... Tejanos in Action has changed that sad legacy ... for this cemetery is now dedicated to remembering, not forgetting. Thank you and your organization for this gift, which enriches our history and in doing so enriches our spirit and ... our democracy. The mission of each generation is to take what we have and do better, do more with it. Liberty gives us this chance, to choose to take a sad and forgotten plot and turn it into a beautiful, peaceful place.

"... Memorial Day is about taking a moment to reflect and to remember, to reflect and to respect the special gift of those who did their duty."

And -- I'll add in 2008 -- it is a day to thank those who do their duty now.

NOTE: The entire speech may be found at the May 28, 2005, entry of austinbay.net/blog.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Austin Bay Austin Bay is author of three novels. His third novel, The Wrong Side of Brightness, was published by Putnam/Jove in June 2003. He has also co-authored four non-fiction books, to include A Quick and Dirty Guide to War: Third Edition (with James Dunnigan, Morrow, 1996).
 
Be the first to read Austin Bay's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
A Sad Day
Today I went to a fellow American Legion brother's funeral. We marched in, stood tall, said a prayer, placed a Poppy upon his cold chest and saluted him for his life and his service. We did not know the man, but we knew his heart. He was an American who seved his country long ago.

To many Americans have forgotten what Memorial Day means. It is not just a three day weekend. Nor is it a time to go to the lake and forget about the world. It is a time to remember those that have gone before us and have fought for or stood guard for our liberty to respect or disrespect these efforts.

Thank you for your efforts to do the former Mr. Bay. Please continue your efforts to spread the import of respect for our Fallen Heros.

I have created a place where anyone within eyeshot can write a heartfelt tribute for our fallen heros in time for Memorial Day. To do so, do it here, or go to http://djgoski.com

Semper Fi and may God Continue to Bless the United States of America!

Memorial Day 2004
It was on this day, that my 5 yr old son taught me a lesson. I was a soldier from 82 to 92 and a gulf war veteran. I have always tried to educate my sons on the importance of memorial day and the respect of those who have paid the ultimate price. On this particular day, my wife and son went to visit her grandmothers grave. While at the cemetary, he noticed a section of the cemetary that was adorned with american flags. It was the predominately military section. With reverence, he took my wife by the hand, led her to this section, and had her read to him the headstones of these 2 dozen graves. He was deeply sadened but at the same time proud of what these men have given. Later that day he asked me why I wasnt serving in the war. I did not have a good answer. I reflected that night, decided even at 42 I was healthy enough and went to the recruiter the next day. I gave up my 50K a year job and was in Afghanistan 6 months later. At our countries time of need, and my way of honoring those that went before me I am serving my country once again thanks to my 5 yr old son.

SSG, Military Police

The American Legion
Still doing it's Duty in District 11, NC. Every post will be laying flags in Cemeteries to remember our fallen and will be saluting those serving. Hooah!

Butt: Sorry to say, you wouldn't know a

principle if it came up and hit you right square in the head!

In fact, I'm convinced that you wouldn't even know THAT you've BEEN HIT RIGHT SQUARE IN THE HEAD!

But what's REALLY sad, is that those who do serve are also protecting your right to be the reprehensible, ignorant person you are.


Thank you again Anne,
Boutte, you have my sympathy, sorry you are low on gas and can not make it to the Mall. My grandson is on his third (voluntary) tour in Iraq, which is keeping you free to say the disgusting things you say. I believe you and your believers have been rooting for the terrorists to win this mission with all your negativity, Thank God the Iraqis have more trust and faith in our military and theirs in charge than you do. I am sure if you can not stand the gas crunch you certainly would not been able to have the courage to vote with a gun aimed at you. In am also convinced that you must have voted the new congress, and senate in 18 months ago, so thank them for your gas hike, thank them for not letting us drill our own oil, and soon with you and yours you will be able to thank them for the new tax hikes we will have.

Memorial Day
"...Memorial Day emerged. Decoration Day, a day in May set aside for "decorating" the graves of dead soldiers with flowers, began as a Union observance."

Sorry pal, but "Memorial Day" is a SOUTHERN day of observance. As you said, in the north, it was "Decoration Day" and it ment nothing more than placeing flags on graves and a few flowers from friends and famlies placed on the graves of NORTHERN solders.
But in the South, the day was marked by music, songs, grave-side observances, parades and the tending of the graves of BOTH sides. It was a true "Memorial Day and was called such.
The northern veterans were shocked by the lack of respect for their sacrifices by the north and fought to adopt a day of observance such as the ones seen in the South. (April 28th or May 5th, depending on the state)

PS:
It's a shame, Mister Bey, that I must agree with the solders you talked to. It seems that CERTAIN PEOPLE are at war with the COUNTRY OF THEIR BIRTH as if the barbarians who are fighting a religious war against anyone who does not dress, talk, worship and THINK exactly like themselves.

What happened to the Liberals' demands for "tolerance"?

Every Day Is Memorial Day
for a family that has lost someone serving in the military. Does not matter the "when" it is that they "did," and are no longer with us because of their service.

Many a "Cold War" warrior died "in training accidents" being prepared for the war (thank G-d) that never came. Hundreds more died in "conflicts" considered "less than war" and often times were just a "blip" on the MSM radar that was not worth the air time.

My family KNOWS we are at war, my neighbors know we are at war. But I know, there are communities just like mine that surround military facilities across this country. But yep all those States without a "military" presence, what war?

Greenhornet, I totally agree with you,
"It seems that CERTAIN PEOPLE are at war with the COUNTRY OF THEIR BIRTH as if the barbarians who are fighting a religious war against anyone who does not dress, talk, worship and THINK exactly like themselves."

Of course these people are going to be the first to die at the hands of the barbarians cursing "why aren't we fighting?"

Military at War
It sickens me to see how blase many Americans are regarding the war against Islamic Fascism. I can't understand how a movement that is so openly evil and hateful is considered so benign by so many.

I remember how reviled I was as a returning Vietnam Veteran. Much of the nation had transferred opposition to the war into hatred and disgust for the vets who fought the war in service to their country.

The constant ridicule of administration war policy simply out of unreasoning hatred for President Bush is inevitably degenerating into hatred and betrayal of the heroes presently serving.

Col. Bay, here's hoping our comrades won't have to face anything worse than apathy when they return. Like most, I'm guessing they signed up out of a sense of duty rather than a wish for ticker tape parades. Service, honorably rendered is it's own reward. I'm grateful for all that do and have.

Memorial Day / Remembrance Day
ISTM that people from the Commonwealth countries do a much better job with Remembrance Day than we do with Memorial Day. I think part of our problem is that the Memorial/Veteran's split dilutes both and little practical distinction seems to be made between them.

What bothers me here is there seems to be a trend to turn Memorial Day into a day to remember all the dead, with no notion of sacrifice.

Dolly: No thanks to me, but to you,

your grandson, and his family.

My father was a career Naval Officer, so I grew up knowing what each and every family sacrifices when a father, mother, sister or brother is away defending us, our freedoms, and our way of life.

One of the things that I learned was that there are two kinds of people... Those who step up to the plate and put their lives in the line so we can all live in safety and freedom.

The others are those who sit back, fat, dumb and happy (or not) simply enjoying the freedoms that OTHERS are willing to sacrifice their lives for.

Unfortunately, amongst the "fat, dumb and happy group", there is also a group, like Boutte, who actually and unbelievably ridicule those who are defending their rights, and yes, "have been rooting for the terrorists to win this mission with all your negativity."


I do believe, Dolly, that you're right too... "... convinced that you must have voted the new congress, and senate in 18 months ago, so thank them for your gas hike, thank them for not letting us drill our own oil, and soon with you and yours you will be able to thank them for the new tax hikes we will have."

While I don't believe that any life lost, or those injured in Iraq have ever been a waste. It's just so painful to think that those lives have been lost... and those injured, while those such as Boutte can still enjoy the freedoms they have now to be so vile and reprehensible.

God Bless your grandson, his family, and you, Dolly. Know that you are all in my prayers, and I will pray especially for all of you over this Memorial Day Weekend....


Thank God for the American Warrior!
American warriors are the finest people from America and the bravest.

God Bless our Warriors and their families and all who serve and protect.

When we were attacked in NYC many run from while others ran to the the attack scene.

After doing my duty in the Vietnam era 1965 as I was returning from my service and duty, some hippy girls spat on my uniform just like the cowards do today.

Hold your heads up soldiers it has happened to many before you and probably many after you. Duty and honor is your call - stand firm we appreciate and respect you!

Cowards always run when duty calls and hide behind the shallowness of their supposed objections to unjustness - cowards have run since the beginning of man they are nothing new.

Warriors who serve and protect have always been here since the beginning of man also - stand proud.

Boutte I normally avoid you
Boutte I normally avoid you because intellectually you are not worthy of debate.

Your 'dyslexic logic' and 'myopic reason' and inane comments are laughable at best and treasonous at worst. I respect a 'sadistic' homosexual in a San Francisco homosexual parade more than I do you.

Boutte you are a contemptible ignorant shallow person especially at this time of year when we mourn our American Warriors and salute those who protect us.

Boutte you can try and hide behind your self declared intelligence all you want.

Boutte you are a Coward plain and simple not to be held in as high a regard as a graverobber.

Boutte you are as transparent as glass.

Boutte
You sir are a lowlife scumbag. If it were not for the Ladies posting on this thread and the risk of getting booted, I would revert to the foulest barracks language imaginable to tell you what I think of you and your ilk. You better get down on your knees and thank the good Lord that there are men and women willing to put their lives to protect your sorry a@@.
An Ole Korean War Vet

Boutte
Wars of Imperialism?
You cowardly ENEMY COLLABORATORS do not even know the meaning of that word.
What nation in your lifetime has America conquered and annexed?

"Bogus alarmists"? "Duped"?
You are the only "Bogus alarmist" around here and you certainly are a Communist anti-war "Dupe"!

Weak people like YOU invited the series of attacks adding up to 9/11 forcing America into this ancient cultural war. Weak people our enemies see as decadent cowards lacking in morals. Weak people like YOU who whimper and cry and lack the courage to sustain a prolonged war.

These same weak whimpering people continue to assure our enemies that Americans will soon capitulate.
Our enemies use these public displays of weakness to entice recruits to join their cause and gain favor in the eyes of Allah by helping to cleanse the World of unbelievers.

Don't worry about a war with Iran.
You Communist cowards will surrender preemptively!

Please Ignore Boutte!
I was the first to post a comment here. The subject is Memorial Day 2008. By responding to this moron and getting off of the subject, this moron wins and gets plenty of viewers!

Please, if you would like to post a "Memorial Day Tribute" or support our troops through your words do it here or go to http://www.djgoski.com

These people get you all talking about them, and what happens is that the thread gets off subject and puts the moron's name out there. We get to talking mean about these baiters and are labeled as "Hate Filled Fascists" on other blogs. Don't fall for it!

Semper Fi and May God Continue to Bless the United States of America.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.