Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, February 20, 2008
Austin Bay :: Townhall.com Columnist
Fidel Castro's Painfully Long Finale
by Austin Bay
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


Anti-Americanism energizes numerous dictatorships. Check the miserable roster. Iran's noxious mullahs have invoked the anti-American liturgy since 1979. Mass murderers despise America, with Cambodia's (thankfully deceased) Pol Pot, Serbia's Slobodan Milosevic and Sudan's genocidal junta as examples.

Three particularly long-lived dictatorships make "America hate" the staple gruel in their propaganda diet: the Assads' Syrian Baathist regime, the Kims' gulag of North Korea and Fidel Castro's communist slum, otherwise known as Cuba.

This week, after suffering another bout of illness, Castro announced he is resigning his presidency. Is the slum getting a new landlord?

Not really. The world has seen little of Fidel since 2006, when he turned the day-to-day task of running Cuba over to his brother, Raul. Get the pattern: Bashir Assad followed his father, and Kim Jong Il got North Korea from his dad. Hereditary fascism and communism -- keep it all in the family, and blame America in the process.

Don't listen to what they say, watch what they do. The America-haters practice the politics of distraction, and the distraction begins with their co-optation of democratic political language. A "presidency" suggests electoral politics and democratic governance. We all know otherwise. Fidel is a dictator, a military monarch with a fatigue cap rather than a crown. He is, however, a consummate spin-meister -- the entire anti-American crowd is, to some degree. Media posturing and word manipulation veil their reigns of terror, corruption and crime.

Fidel and Raul, like their kaput revolution, are old. Combat fatigues don't hide Fidel's paunch. His face sags. He doesn't look like the future he claimed to be in 1959.

In the 1990s, Fidel declared a "Period of Emergency" in Cuba. The emergency still persists. During this long emergency, Cuban agriculture has moved from tractors to oxen; transportation from buses to bicycles. And the Cuban Army (reminiscent of Guatemala?) has become a larger presence in the economy.

Yet in his decline, Castro continues to style himself as The True Believer in communism. More likely, he is the last romantic communist revolutionary, faithful despite the ugly reality of national poverty and fascist repression, his own handiwork.

International "progressives" -- those sad cases -- still venerate Fidel Castro. If Raul does indeed become the face of the regime, we may catch something of a break. Raul Castro lacks his brother's charisma and pizzazz. He isn't a personality capable of jiving mass audiences with the rhetoric of "hope" and utopianism. Raul, in fact, has the dull snake eyes of a secret policeman who gets his jollies with a truncheon.

There's a reason for that. During his brother's five decades of rule, Raul has bossed Cuba's "security apparatus" (i.e., the secret police). Fidel handled the media and manifestoes; Raul commanded the thugs and kept the crumbling jail of an island locked tight.

But back to the "progressives." "Progressive" in this sense is another word damaged by Marxist autocrats and various other political authoritarians. For 50 years, the language of leftist "progressives" dovetailed quite well with Stalinism. They gave Red fascism its international political cover. Bad habit explains some of the international leftists' ludicrous admiration for Fidel.

Castro's real progressive appeal, however, is hatred for America. This is why so many of the old Cold War progressive left quickly became apologists for al-Qaida's mass murder -- Osama Bin Laden has the anti-American bilge down pat.

Now, Venezuela's Hugo Chavez, a former right-wing military officer, claims Castro's mantle. The anti-Americans love him. Chavez' "Chavismo" combines machismo, socialism, Caudilloism, populism, anti-Americanism and oil money. Chavez, however, doesn't command the podium and television cameras like Fidel in his prime. Castro squandered his charisma and political talent; Chavez is squandering Venezuela's petro-dollars.

And what comes next for the failed state of Cuba? Fidel's painfully long political finale has damaged economic institutions, exacerbated ethnic tensions between "white" Cubans and Afro-Cubans (black and overwhelmingly poor), and created a generation of alienated, disenfranchised youth. Raul's regency could be a time of transition, as the regime attempts a Chinese communist-like economic liberalization without political liberalization. This will enrich the Cuban Army and Communist Party elites, but do damned little for everyone else.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Austin Bay Austin Bay is author of three novels. His third novel, The Wrong Side of Brightness, was published by Putnam/Jove in June 2003. He has also co-authored four non-fiction books, to include A Quick and Dirty Guide to War: Third Edition (with James Dunnigan, Morrow, 1996).
 
Be the first to read Austin Bay's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Fidel Is Like The Neighbor's Dog
He hates you, but likes your side of the fence better and after all these years, all the barking in the world- can not excuse the fact that the Cuban Revolution that him and his boyfriend Che organised has failed miserably.
The reasons are endless an important one is rejecting technology, the whole "period of emergency" thing was just that him on one of his heavy flow days, he went from being one of the top sugar cane producers to being a has been, even in the tobacco industry the quality of his cigars have gone way, way downhill thus empowering the Dominicans to mount stiff competition for top market share.
He needed to go away a long time ago, especially in regards to his love affair with Communism.
Communism like disco, sucked, at least with disco it moved on and became retro plus you can at least, dance and have a decent good time, communism is just old, backward-assed ideology which has since been abandoned by it's godfather the Soviet Union and still we have Fidel practising, and ruining a beautiful country like Cuba. It's such a shame.

Why the
"white" Cubans in quotation marks and the Afro-Cubans not in quotation marks? Are "white" Cubans questionably white? Do I smell a whiff of the one drop rule? Or that other argument that Sicilians and other swarthy Southern Europeans are not Nordic, therefore only "white"?

WELLLLL,
it looks like the liberals(communists) in America are losing the idol. What a shame!

Sean Penn & his lover boy, Hugo Chavez will now have to visit Castro in the old folks home.

And the anti American lib whacko posters here are no doubt saddened as well.

It's the way of communism
Castro, like many other's before him are victims of communism which is a flaw ideology totally based on nothing, but blaming others for the conditions in which the poor live. Castro was always in fatigues which gave the inpression that the revolution was still still alive. Cuban's love it. That is, those who looked at Castro as great for thumbing his nose and middle finger at the American's. It worked pretty good for Castro. His constant anti American rhetoric was always good in his speeches. It kept Cuban's loyal to Castro regardless of their living conditions. Even if Castro's brother did offer some type of change, the people are Castro's people, in mind and ideology. The Cuban's have been brainwashed for so long, it's doubtful if Raul could bring about much changes without the Cuban's themselves objecting to having Castro's policies changed in honor of Castro. If Cuba was thrown into too much freedom, the same thing could happen to it the way it happened to Russia. The mafia took over. I'm sure the Cuban's have their own form of mafia there also waiting to see what Raul is going to do.

DON'T DIE A FOOL ...
CASTRO and Everybody,

TRUST IN JESUS AS LORD AND SAVIOR BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE.

http://evolutionfacts.blogspot.com/#the_message_that_we_wer e_born_to_hear


Boutte
You need to read the U.S. Constitution on electing Presidents. There are time tables in the Constitution for turning in your State's electoral votes.
If you think Fidel's Cuba is so good go live there.
Under President Clinton two U.S. citizens were shot down by the Cuban airforce for throwing leaflets out of their airplane in Cuban airspace.
I think there is still some questions as to where they were shot down, Cuban airspace or International waters. The fact is the Clinton administration did nothing.
Even Al Gore said Bill Clinton cost him the Presidency.

As for Raul Castro
One often-overlooked fact about the younger Castro brother is that, as Defense Minister and commander of the Cuban "Security Police" (i.e., secret police, a force separate from the military), Raul has been Fidel's chief hatchetman for the last half-century, going back to the days of the "barbudos" in the Oriente hills.

Ernesto "Che'" Guevara (de la Serna) may have been the Revolution's chief "ideologist", but Raul was the local version of Stalin's resident Talleyrand, "Iron Feliks" Dzherzhinskiy. And in the process, Raul was the one who repeatedly "suppressed" any dissent about Fidel's policies, not just in the general populace, but in the military as well- by using his secret police rather like a cross between the SS, Gestapo, and NKVD.

In fact, there are elements in Cuba's government that still suspect that when "Che'" became a potential challenger to Fidel for power, it was Raul who suggested sending him to Bolivia in 1965 to "spread the Revolution"- and then tipped off the local authorities as to his whereabouts, resulting in his capture and execution. This removed "Che'" as a problem, and gave the Revolution a very useful martyr. (And of course gave self-styled "progressives" everywhere a new idol.)

The end result of all this is that Raul has so much blood on his hands, and so many people wanting to settle old scores with him, that he cannot look forward to a comfortable tenure, or retirement. His only safety is the loyalty of the Cuban hierarchy to Fidel, which gives him "cover". He still has that, as long as Fidel is alive.

Once Fidel goes to his eternal reward, as all men must, all bets are off.

cheers

eon

Certainly Not Sad To See..
..one of the few remaining communist dictators consigned to history but I don't think the US comes out of the whole Cuban affair looking too good. The embargo, futile and unnecessary as far as I can see, gave Castro his perfect excuse for Cuba's weak economy and America's support of Batista prior to the revolution hardly leaves them smelling of roses!!

Pathetic Castro
Although socialism was supposed to take over the world, the last big revolution was the Iranian one, and it was not a socialist revolution. It was an Islamist one. And now we in America don't even think much about communism anymore, but are focused on our war with the Islamo-fascists.

And when a couple of Che's kids went over to Iran recently, they were told by the Iranians that their father believed in God. When they insisted otherwise, they were whisked away. The far left working with the far right just isn't going to go very well.

We All Need Enemies - Who America Hates?
Enemies are a way to rally and unite the population for a common cause. Enemies allow us to define ourselves as good and moral while our enemies are evil. It justifies our wars.

So who does the US hate..?

Cuba, Russia, Terrorists, Iran, Libya, Iraq, N. Korea, Venezuela and of course the French.

How would we know good from bad if we had no enemies..?

My 2 cents
1) Not long from now fidel will be asked a question by the God whose existence he has labored so hard and long to deny, and the question is simple: "What have you done with your life?"

2) End the embargo and let the chips fall where they may. fidel and now his brother have used it as a crutch ever since it was invoked and it has done us no good at all.

But to do so will take a politician with two qualities which seem to be lacking today - cojones and brains.

Wake me up when is all over
For those wrongly impressed by the word "president."

In a Communist country the Secretary General of the Communist Party runs the country, not the President.

The "president" is a manager or, administrator. The Party sets policy. The President makes sure trains run on time.

Had Castro stepped down as party boss, that, would have been news.

Maybe the Headlines should read:

"Demented senior to still function as head of the Cuban Communist party."

How long?
How long will it be before Castro makes his first appearance before a doting audience on Oprah?

Castro won you lost: get over it
When history is written people will note that despite the rage of America's right wing, Castro stayed in power for 50, count em, 50 years. Eisenhower, Nixon, Ford, Reagan, Bush I and Bush II could not get him out. All the sound and fury of Cuban exiles could not get him out or foment a true counter revolution. All you can say is that 50 years of communist rule has left an agrarian society an agrarian society.


Bleeding idiot
You forgot mousey carter & bubba(sexual offender) clinton.

JFK...
...was also left off the list.

for Bleeding Heart Liberal
Bleeding Heart Liberal writes: "All you can say is that 50 years of communist rule has left an agrarian society an agrarian society."

I can also generalize from your statement to make the following accurate observation:

Communist rule is how a primitive backward society can continue to survive indefinitely as a heavily armed primitive backward society.

That has been the experience of Russia, China, Cuba, North Korea, and Vietnam.

The fact that they have zero immigration and massive emigration tells you how well their "socialist experiments" have worked. Nobody, given a free choice, wants to live there.

for stedes
stedes writes: "So who does the US hate..? Cuba, Russia, Terrorists, Iran, Libya, Iraq, N. Korea, Venezuela and of course the French. "

Don't worry.
On our Enemies List, we're saving space for you.

Yes to all
I left out JFK, LBJ, Carter and Clinton, because they are obviously fellow travelers (by your light). Your Republican leaders were incapable of getting rid of the failed experiment in Cuba. Why is that? I mean the people are so obviously oppressed. All the expatriates say so. Wait, they tried that at the Bay of Pigs.

Does the fact that people leave a country for better economic conditions mean the country is Communist? What does that say about Mexico and the rest of Central America. Should we over throw those governments? Wait, we tried.



Bleeding Heart
I have notice an amusing trend from people of the left: They often speak of Castro and JFK with the same sense of reverance and respect.

Funny when youn consider that the men were hardcore adversaries and almost went to war twice.

Castro and Kennedy were were 180 degrees out of phase ideologically. Yet the left seems unable or unwilling to draw clear distinctions between them. Why is that?

You yourself seemed to gloat in your post that Castro was in power for 50 years as if that was a good thing. Frankly the only people who have suffered from his longevity are Cubans.

Two or three subject


I have been against the blockade of Cuba from the start, just like I was against the Korean, the Viet Nam, and the Iraq wars. That is not the way to implement a democracy.

A Democracy can best be implemented by example. Without going into a lot of detail, I am connivenced that Cuba would have changed their type of economics, and their government, if there was a couple of dozen McDonald’s, and a few hundred new Chevy’s and Ford’s available for use as taxies.

How about the number of tourists, and the amount of money they would have spent, if they had been permitted? It seems the word is spelled FREEDOM.

A country consists of a border and a culture, and it is not up to us to mess with any, except to keep our borders secure, and our culture safe. (That’s difficult with Hollywood and computer games training criminals.)

------

Let me be among the first to remind all those people in Florida, who brag that they are Cuban, that the ships will be leaving soon, and will be crowded.

Don’t you dare say you are a Cuban, and not be pushing into that line for a space on the ship to Havana. All these years we have heard your cries and complaints about the fact that you had to leave that wonderful country.

Well, now let’s hear all those cheers as you board the ship, and don’t you dare say you are not going home.

If you have become an English speaking person, who brags that you are an American and your only reference to Cuba is that you or your parents were born there, OK, but otherwise, home you go.

-------

Oh my, but one more word about the Korean War, the world event that changed my life. As I was re-called into the Army in 1950, I told a friend that I had no one to kiss goodby.

Pat gave me the phone number of her beautiful friend, and the rest is history, or better yet, herstory. For over 55 years that “phone” rang and rang and rang, and was “answered” each and every time.

No Peace Treaty would ever be worth as much as that Marriage License!


Get me straight
This is not about communism and it is not about hero worship.

This is about the failures of capitalism and the expatriates who want to return to those failures.

This country, our country, has had its foreign policy dictated by a knee jerk reaction to communism. The former rich and powerful from Cuba have exploited that reaction and molded our Policy towards Cuba.

Bleeding Heart
Prior to the Castro revolution, Cuba was the third wealthiest country in the Western Hemisphere behind only America and Argentina. The country's most powerful entrepreneurs either escaped or faced death (the Bacardi family is an excellent example). The result devestated the economy. The reason history is important is for preventing repeat mistakes. How many times must communism fail violently before mankind gives it up?

Please check out http://www.therealcuba.com for more information.

Hope for the Cuban people--
even if Raul continues the tyranny, he is also an old man.

In Eastern Europe in the end, people just walked away from communism and its depredations. They tore down the Berlin Wall as East Germany watched impotently.

I hope the oppressed people of Cuba will have the same opportunity to walk to freedom.

The former "rich and powerful from Cuba"
Is he talking about the 125,000 between 18 and 25 year old men who left the island during the Mariel boatlift?

"How many times can a (Liberal) man turn his head and pretend that he just didn't see?"

This is the American Left: celebrating that the same man had run a country like his personal plantation for the last 47 years.

American "Socialists" don't deserve the name "Liberal" since their real secret wish is to have Castro's power to humilliate and rob those whom they hate.

Castro won?
Click here:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyrrhic_victory

Bleeding Hart, how old are you?
I was in Grade 5 when Castro came to power; I will be 60 next week. That is two things I have seen rise and seen fall -- the Berlin Wall and Uncle Fidel. Both about the same time they went up, too.

In fact, my Grade 5 teacher put up Castros name on our collage of great happenings of our age. Soon that collage had a hole scissored in it and the teacher was looking for work. You could do that in those days.

So BH,if you live long enough, you will find things you thought would last forever will fall down. It is the way life works.

Renny
I agree with you, but I think about the chaos when Russia - I know it's a different kind of case - suddenly exploded into capitalism. I have no doubt that Cubans will finally get the
lives they deserve, but I wonder what it will be like with so many people there who have never known anything else.

I'm also wondering how they will manage economically - it's not a very prosperous country and has almost no natural resources - I don't think today's global markets will reward their old sugar-based economy, either. capitalism, almost by definition has to have winners and losers in order to survive -it seems that Castro has turned them into an entire country of losers.

This was a pretty good column.

Maximilian writes:
Maximilian writes: Wednesday, February, 20, 2008 6:27 PM
Bleeding Hearts:

Max, You forgot WE haven't tried communism yet, but we appear to be well on our way to doing so. Will the world survive our transgressions.??.

I see a world wide dictatorship shaping up, and powers that be doing the shaping.


Is calm.touj......

........touj. .??.

Capitalism=a Good Cigar
Unlike socialism/Communism capitalism works wherever it's tried. I've worked with a number of Cubans in this country and found they're very hardworking and intelligent. Cuba would have been the most prosperous country in the Caribbean if Castro had been strangled in his crib.

I agree that we should drop the embargo and let trade flourish between our two countries. Within 10 years insidious capitalism will have leached into this former tropical prison and its GNP will rocket upwards...and Hollywood leftists will be able to freely smoke Cuban cigars and nostalgically talk about the good old days of Fidel.


Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.