Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
Austin Bay :: Townhall.com Columnist
Grisly Information
by Austin Bay
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


On Feb. 1, two remotely detonated terror bombs killed 99 shoppers in Baghdad's pet and bird markets. It was Baghdad's biggest mass murder since April 2007.

According to the Iraqi military, al-Qaida in Iraq's (AQI) twin terror atrocities had several particularly grisly twists: The radio-detonated high explosives were strapped to the waists of two women who may not have been aware of their mission to murder.

Amid the carnage of animal cages, animal carcasses and dead human beings, Iraqi police found the detached head of one of the bomb carriers. Al Bawaba, an Arab press service, quoted Baghdad police as saying the dead woman had "sold cream in the mornings at the market and was known to locals as 'the crazy lady.'"

Al Bawaba used a colloquial phrase to describe her. Other Iraqi and international media were less solicitous, describing both of the bomb-laden women as "mentally deficient" or lacking capacity.

Detectives drew a logical conclusion. The pet and bird market massacres were not committed by glory-driven jihadi martyrs slaughtering their way to Paradise, but by two poor souls calculatingly misled or seduced into committing a heinous crime. The women were double victims, first preyed upon by the terrorist schemer as the vehicle for murder and then unintentionally slaying themselves.

For the past year, we've heard rumors that AQI has had trouble recruiting murderers and penetrating increasingly effective Iraqi local security measures. Recently declassified intelligence, including captured terrorist diaries, appears to reinforce the rumors. Iraq's "Sunni awakening" has brought Sunni tribes into the democratic political process. That has left AQI demographically stranded -- without the protection of sectarian allies -- and thus more exposed to detection and destruction.

Perhaps an intelligence analyst would argue that using a neighborhood "crazy lady" to deliver a bomb is further evidence of AQI's declining operational capabilities -- i.e., at the moment AQI's emirs find macho, suicidal zealots seeking Paradise and 72 virgins to be in short supply.

That rather detached assessment wouldn't necessarily ignore the depravity of using these two particular women as involuntary kamikazes.

But what is the "news value" of added depravity? After all, al-Qaida has been committing mass murder for years. Overwhelmingly, al-Qaida attacks "soft targets" -- "soft" meaning unsuspecting civilians on trains (Madrid), in hotels (Jordan), in skyscrapers (New York) or in Iraqi neighborhoods.

Al-Qaida's method, reduced to a phrase, is blood for headlines, which is an old concept. Ninteenth century European anarchists exploited sensational magnification of hideous violence and used mass terror as a cruel marketing method.

The terrorist (of any type) frames his action as a tactic for achieving greater, inspired goals, either futuristic or apocalyptic. He frames his inspiration as political, cultural, religious, philosophical or tribal (think Rwanda or Bosnia). In doing so, he attracts the politically, culturally, religiously, philosophically or tribally sympathetic -- until time reveals his tactic for what it is: CRIME. Not the harbinger of the future or the omen of the end of this age, but despicable murder.

So here is the news value of dulled reactions to depravity, news more sorrowful and sobering than sensational: Al-Qaida's terrorists have not lost the ability to kill, but they have lost some of their ability to shock. Losing the sensationalist edge is a major blow for a terrorist organization and especially al-Qaida, which has always been foremost an information power. Al-Qaida's dark genius has been to connect the Muslim world's angry, humiliated and isolated young men with a utopian fantasy preaching the virtue of violence. That utopian fantasy sought to explain and then redress roughly 800 years of Muslim decline.

But in the process, they have killed indiscriminately and without regard to long-range consequences. Moreover, with Iraq and Afghanistan as the central battlefields, instead of New York or Madrid, al-Qaida's victims have been predominantly Muslim.

Arab Muslims have not missed that grisly bit of information.

And it is no longer news. It has, at least in Iraq, produced political and social revulsion.

In two columns I wrote last fall, I noted al-Qaida's "looming information warfare defeat" and mentioned reports from 2005 and 2006 that detailed the Iraqi people's rejection of al-Qaida as nothing more than a gang of criminals. I think in February 2008 that national rejection is apparent. That rejection could be the fragile foundation for securing al-Qaida's ultimate ideological defeat.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Austin Bay Austin Bay is author of three novels. His third novel, The Wrong Side of Brightness, was published by Putnam/Jove in June 2003. He has also co-authored four non-fiction books, to include A Quick and Dirty Guide to War: Third Edition (with James Dunnigan, Morrow, 1996).
 
Be the first to read Austin Bay's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Desensitivation is possibly
another form of terror.

Willy Victor 32
Dear Willy,

I remember when my cousin was in Vietnam, in the S & D (Search & Destroy) units out in the fields and for what were they searching...of course, Viet Cong, and most frequently when they found t hem in their little villages, what was the village defense system? A little child strapped with explosives. Sometimes it would be a young woman, appealing to a man's more sensitive side, but they found that strapping children with explosives was the best way to protect their village and kill the most naiiive disbelieving Americans.

As far as my cousin was concerned, he couldn't shoot a child, so I suppose it was a darned good thing for him that there were plenty enough men in his unit that handily would.

Another problem they had was identifying the South Vietnamese from the Viet Cong. Many of the men would work fo the Americans during the day, and then wowrk for the Viet Cong during the night, pulling in fantastic paychecks for the Vietnamese avereage.

This was in Iraq seems to be having the same problems, and we aren't doing any better with this civil war than we did with that civil war. Perhaps it is because they are civil wars we are kengaging ourselves in. Well, I just thought I'd bring up the simiilarities.

We should get out!
It's their civil war. We had one that was almost as bloody, and our tactics during the Revolution were almost as vicious (especially in the South). It's their country.

Let them fight until they are sick of it, and they will fix the problem themselves. We're all for self-determination, aren't we?

Oh, that's right. We're there for their oil.


Jeanne-marie
"we aren't doing any better with this civil war than we did with [Vietnam's] civil war."

We are doing better now than we were a year ago.

Why Not Here?
I am surprised that we haven't had a bombing here, with all of the whackos amongst us. Have they tried the halls (now painted pink) of our Ivy League colleges?

By the rules
Well no one has ever accused the religion of peace of playing by the rules. Only the US must abide by the rules. Yes, Mr Bush's War should be left to the Iraqi's to solve. If that's what they want then they got it. It's up them. It's their country. It's their people.

I find

I find it interesting that the posters so far seem to be avoiding the moral depravity of a group that would kill a non combatant in order to get to a soldier or other non combatants.

And yes Jeanne Marie , that was true in Vietnam, where the VC would kill villagers to intimidate others. Also the use of teen and sub teens in battle, using them as cannon fodder.

Many died after we pulled out of Vietnam and many will die when we pull out of Iraq.

I saw hope here
More than the well-known moral depravity of the Islamists. This column was about a turning tide.

But Goforth has a good point about "abide by the rules". My son is a Marine training in Naval Air Crew Candidate school now, to be followed by a two week SERE training (Survival, Evasion, Resistance, Escape) which he describes as "1 week of classroom and 1 week of them beating the *** out of me." He had to sign a release "in case they break something."

Funny what we consider "training" on our own would be considered "torture" if done to an enemy. We don't even consider that our enemy will abide by "Geneva Conventions", though we must extend a treaty to an enemy that never signed on to it.

How about the next time we need to get life-saving information from an Islamist, we simply enlist him and give him some free "training"?

al-Qaida and Women's Lib
You hard-nosed conservatives are so focused on the collateral carnage that you don't even realize what a step forward this is for women in the Arab world.

People we formerly thought were sexist pigs are now showing their gender-neutral qualities. No gentlemen they (and you know how much we Feminazis hate gentlemen)!

In addition to this, they are showing an equal-opportunity, hire-the-handicapped commitment that makes every NOW member proud as punch.

And speaking of equal opportunity for all, don't you think that some of the gals in comfortable shoes might like to line up for those 17 virgins?

Of course, you sexist homophobes would never think of that!

Other Reasons for Lefties to Love
Al-Qaida

Their commitment to ZPG.

Yes, with the Islamisist commitment to blowing each other up, it makes up for the "Population Bomb" taking place in the Western World.

We environmentalists who worry about too many people covering the planet are gratified when some globally minded individuals decide to do themselves in and take their neighbors with them.

We are considering sending Dr. Kevorkian over to take notes.

Of course, there is one drawback: the heat from those bombs undo the good we are doing by using low-energy lightbulbs.

Oh well, ya can't winnum all.

Civil War?
Right, like the Soviet and Chinese backed "civil wars" in Korea and Viet Nam. Both of which we won by the way. The Democrats just gave the second one back in order to win a domestic political victory. 58,000 dead Americans and several million SE Asians lives thrown away just so we could have 4 years of Jimmy Carter.

The Democrats are so eager to saddle Bush with a defeat that they don't give a rip about the consequences. After all, who cares what happens in the Middle East, they're just Arabs after all.

There are plenty of "crazies"...

...in the USA for Al Qaeda to exploit since the mental hospital closed due to JFK's 1963 legislation. The homeless could be now walking time bombs. Don't think so? Think about how ridiculous "9/11" sounded on Monday, "9/10"!

The way this country manages its mentally ill is crazy. In more ways than one.

Mountain Rose
LOL! But with the burgeoning muslim birth rate, it sort of gives new meaning to the phrase "population bomb", doesn't it? ;-)

Wake Up America!!
With the media annointing McCain or Obama as our new president, we can expect 100 more years of involvement in atrocities like this. Folks, it is time to take our country back to a republic based on the Constitution and the rule of law. If we do not have a declared war or a reason to be somewhere threatening American Soldiers and American life, we need to get out and mind our own business. Thomas Jefferson said "free trade and commerce with all nations, entangling alliances with none". The only presidential candidate who stands behind these words and the Constitution is Dr. Ron Paul. But he has been so crucified by the media and the GOP war mongers that he has no chance to lead us out of this quagmire. May God have mercy on America and send us some true leaders that will overcome the forces of evil that control our country and its politics! Wake up America! If this is truly a government by the people and for the people, quit following the media elite and decide for yourself what is best for America!

Remember the lessons of Tet?
The Tet (Vietnamese observance of the lunar new year) was marked by the assault on the South by 250,000 NVA regulars AND 100,000 Viet Cong sympathizers.

The result was the total destruction of the VC as a fighting force and the loss to North Vietnam of a whole generation of fighting men in a very short time. The reason it's counted as a "victory" for the North is that the world media captured hundreds of hours of footage that showed a degree of carnage the America public was not ready for.

The biggest mistake the Armed Forces made was in so sanitizing the war by denying access to realistic, but not sensationalized, coverage of the fighting. This created a scenarion of "pulling back the curtain" and it occurred with such speed and surprise that no amount of facts could convince Americans that the North WAS in fact losing badly. They never won a single significant engagement. Gen. Giap states VERY clearly that all their victories came in the American media and on college campuses.

He openly states with no equivocation that they were ready to sue for peace on OUR terms until they saw coverage of the "Winter Soldier" fraud starring Jean Francois Kerry.

-Ray

DeMolay: "Population Bomb"
Perhaps we can convince Muslim women to blow themselves up at the moment of conception.

This would reduce the "Population Bomb," and guarantee a really hot time in bed.

As we know, these are two very important Leftie values.

No...
Viet Nam was not, nor is Iraq a case of civil war.

For those of you who have stated so, you are badly misinformed.

wrat wrangler
Right on!

I'm waiting for the Iraqization then the total funding cut.

Wonder if we will have evacuations from Baghdad

Have we enough choppers this time?
They can hand onto MY skids.

-Ray

THE BLOODY DIFFERENCE
That's the bloody difference between those savages and people who simply want freedom to live and die free. Depraved isn't sufficient to describe the murderous cowards who would send the weak and helpless to do their filthy, murdering deeds.

We Should Get Out??
Folks:
What, you want it "HERE"?? I don't know about you, but I don't want to scrape my Sirloin Steak off the bottom of a Cloud every I light up my Barbecue, thanks so much.

Why doesn't everyone let the experts run the war, not the Press, peace placard shakers, and the big "D" who think they have a "Phd" in everthing with their foot on the "Barrail".

Nuff Said

Inventor.

Inventor
No one wants AQ "here." The idea though, that our army there is protecting us at home is weak. Before the war there wasn't AQ in Iraq, Saddam was afraid of them! Wouldn't it be better for Bush to fulfill his promise to our nation and get Bin Laden and destroy AQ?

Taft, Inventor
You both have good points but my question is this: How can we be serious about the WOT (which our family does support, especially with a son in the Marines) when we won't close our own borders? This I think is the only major weakness of the argument for the war. (We import only about 15% of our oil from the ME) The Middle Easterners can just as easily waltz into the country as any Mexican, after all-and I understand they've taken to learning Spanish and looking Mexican precisely because it IS so easy to get in...

What ?
No dimwit nutroot telling us yet what a brilliant strategy move by AQ this is ?

Update
The two women were mental patients who were unaware that bombs were strapped to them. The Psychologist at the institution where they were patients has been arrested and charged as a terrorist conspirator.

Wiseone- this shows that the Islamic
Terrorists are smarter than the Nazis.

The Nazis merely euthanized the handicapped. The Islamisists put them to work.

AQ in Iraq
**No one wants AQ "here." The idea though, that our army there is protecting us at home is weak. Before the war there wasn't AQ in Iraq, Saddam was afraid of them!**

We don't know the full extent of AQ's involvement in Iraq:

http://www.americanthinker.com/2006/02/saddam_and_alqaeda.h tml

I wouldn't be so quick to swallow the kool-aid!

Forgotten Salman Pak so soon?
IdahoGal,

The MSM has SPIKED all mention of Salman Pak for SEVEN years now. You can't bring it up. That's a town to the southwest of Baghdad. The Iraqi security service had a 767 fueselage on the ground. They used to TRAIN various terrorist groups in ways to take over an airliner with only small edged weapons and the threat of explosives.

From the cell calls it's known that one of the threats on Flight 93 was that of a bomb. It may have been a hoax as postulated in the film.

That establishes Al-Quaeda in Iraq AND the link to Al-Quaeda as well. If Saddam was training them in these techniques then he had more in mind than planes crashing into buildings.

The FBI agent who interviewed him in prison learned that, had the U.S. not intervened, he WAS ready to resume his pursuit of nuclear or biological weapons. Even that lying sack of manure Joe Wilson gave TWO different accounts of what he learned in Niger. The report to Congress is classified and is not likely to ever be made public. Enough has been leaked to suggest that he DID find an interest in yellow cake uranium. Then he writes what the moonbats WISHED were true.

The worst part of this dog and pony show was the so-called outing of a "covert" CIA operative. Valerie Plame had not been covert for a number of years. Long enough that exposure did NOT constitute a real crime but the DumboCrats ran with it like a bloody shirt. She was a SEAT WARMER at Langley!!!! Every dimwit on the D.C. cocktail circuit knew her story.

-Ray
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.