Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, March 07, 2007
Austin Bay :: Townhall.com Columnist
Maliki's Political and Economic Bullet
by Austin Bay
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Petroleum is the resource that dominates discussion of Iraq's economy.

However, water and rich agricultural land make the country much more than a desert oil spigot.

Combine water and productive land, and the product is history -- the history of civilization. As Mesopotamia (the land between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers), Iraq spawned the Agricultural Revolution and served as the cradle of city-states, and hence historical civilization.

Several economists and economic development experts argue that land --specifically "land reform" -- is key to ending Iraq's complex civil conflict. Among them is Peter Schaefer. Schaefer served in Vietnam as an American military intelligence officer, then in the mid-1970s became deeply involved in economic development analysis and property right issues. A former adviser to Peruvian economist Hernando De Soto, Schaefer is now working on a business project that involves "commercial scale" property registration in the developing world.

Vietnam sparked Schaefer's interest in economic development. In an interview last week, Schaefer told me: "I couldn't get my mind around the fact that the Vietnamese people were so smart and industrious, and yet they were just so damn poor. The (destructive effects of the) war didn't answer that for me. Why would someone choose Mao over Jefferson?"

Schaefer concluded the Vietnamese communists pursued a calculated land reform policy, one that leveraged Vietnamese villagers' traditional recognition of property rights.

In the 1990s, Schafer noted, Peru turned the "land reform" tables on the communists. Property rights reform helped defeat Peru's "Maoist" Shining Path guerrilla movement.

In Schafer's view, property rights reform gives Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki's government a very powerful political weapon, one that has war-winning potential.

Schafer supplied some fascinating evidence. According to him, less than 5 percent of Iraq's cultivatable agricultural land is "freehold" (owned with clear title). Ninety-five percent of the cultivatable land in Iraq is therefore "dead" (illiquid) and cannot be used as security for a bank loan. "Iraqi farmers who lack clear title can't get (bank) loans," Schaefer said. That limits economic creativity, particularly in a population demonstrably successful at small business operations. Schafer believes that 95 percent of family homes in Iraq also lack clear, secure title.

"Prime Minister Maliki needs to go on television," Schaefer advised, "and say: 'Citizens of Iraq, 95 percent of the property in this country is not legally in your name. You don't have title to your own land or your own houses. We're going to change that right now.'"

This reform would launch a liberalizing political and economic revolution, with the democratic Iraqi government empowering the people of Iraq. For maximum payoff, Schafer said, Maliki's government should support title reform with a mortgage program that provides wholesale money to banks and permits them to do mortgage lending for individual Iraqis, thus "jumpstarting" Iraq's sclerotic banking system.

Property rights reform also provides a political tool for assuaging sectarian and ethnic fears among Iraqi citizens, Schaefer said. Good title "means Iraqis can protect their houses with the law on their side."

This is nation-building at a subtle but fundamental level: moving from the rule of the gun to rule of law. Consider the case of Sunni Arabs who have abandoned property in Shia Arab neighborhoods. "Anyone who loses a home, but has solid title, will have legal recourse to regain (lost property) through the courts," Schaefer said. The law becomes a nonviolent option preferable to gang or militia-inspired retribution.

Schaefer thinks the Iraqi city of Kirkuk offers a perfect opportunity to link title reform to an economically productive housing construction program. Saddam Hussein "Arabized" the city by forcing Kurds to move away. Now, returning Kurds are evicting Arabs. Some 40,000 homes are in dispute. Schafer's solution: Build 40,000 new homes in Kirkuk. "Displaced Kurds have a choice -- their old home or a new one," Schafer said. "They can have their former home once an Arab family moves into one of the new houses." This defuses the ethnic clash, and Schafer noted, "the economic impact of the construction program will be enormous."

Schafer's suggestions aren't pie in the sky -- they are pragmatic, wealth-generating alternatives to ethnic violence, tyrant-imposed poverty and cowardly despair.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Austin Bay Austin Bay is author of three novels. His third novel, The Wrong Side of Brightness, was published by Putnam/Jove in June 2003. He has also co-authored four non-fiction books, to include A Quick and Dirty Guide to War: Third Edition (with James Dunnigan, Morrow, 1996).
 
Be the first to read Austin Bay's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Bullet?
Sounds more like a shot in the arm than a bullet.

Is it likely Maliki will follow such a path?

Complications....
This is a great idea, but it contains a major complication - social structure.

A move to grant individuals freeholds will meet a lot of political resistance from tribal and clan leaders, as clan members with freeholds will no longer be dependent on the clan for their economic existence, thus diminishing the power of the clan leaders over them.

On the other hand, freeing individuals from their social groups will have the effect of diminishing internecine warfare - a Shiite who owns his own business would have little problem dealing in a free market with Sunnis, their money is just as good. He would be unswayed by tribal and factional loyalties.

Examples of this transitional process abound the world over in developing countries, even among Native Americans on reservations; as soon as you grant individuals title to property, the social structure, and the ancillary effects crumble, though it is met with stiff resistance at first.

Gathering of Eagles/Move America Forward
Not on topic but important. These two great organizations are combining efforts for the pro troop rally in DC on March 17th. Move America Forward has organized a caravan that starts tomorrow in SF and ends on the 17th in DC. There are about 20 stops scheduled for the caravan. If you can't be in DC on the 17th to show your support go to one of the rallys. You can find the information here:
http://www.moveamericaforward.org/
http://gatheringofeagles.org/

Wonderful Idea
There is one other thing which should be done with the giving of free title for ownership. And that is passing an amendment to their constitution to prohibit any tax on property. Property tax is a socialistic or communistic tax. It is one of the tenets of Marx.

The United States also needs to liberate American citizens from the Marxist grip of property taxes.

Property tax
Quite right, Deacon, that slipped my mind. Good of you to bring it up.

I like to tell people I don't own property, I rent it from the government. What's the difference between a landlord who can evict you if you don't pay your rent, and the government who can evict you from your house if you don't pay your taxes? - Same thing, different words is all.

Certainly should be considered
but there are potential bureaucratic nightmares, even -- perhaps especially -- in small communities where records don't exist even as to who is living or farming on some particular property.

Before embarking on this, there needs to be a thorough investigation of inheritance patterns, lineage of descent, and land tenure and use at the LOCAL level. These will vary not simply by tribe, but also by locality.

Property disputes can be as deadly or more so than religious disputes.

Mortgages Against Islam Beliefs
Private property rights are a good idea for any country. Islam's prohibition of interest makes this highly problematical in Iraq and other Muslim countries.

Basic right of Free Men.
Owning your own home and a weapon to protect it is the basic right of Free People.
Free enterprise is the backbone of Democracy.
This must be done for Iraq to be an example of freedome in the ME.

If this was done, I think it would be hard for terrorists to find civilians willing to help them.

Universal concept
The right to own property is fundamental to any society where economic prosperity exists, property taxes or no property taxes, (which certainly needs to be addressed in some states here.) There is logic in the phrase "pride of ownership." Ever know of an employee who cares more about the success of the business than the owner who built it? Give people the right to own land and they will defend it.

Fantastic Article
Is the reason only 5% of land is freehold because of the possibility of undiscovered oil being underneath? Like in Iraq, it might not be feasible to have freehold estates - geez . . . I can't remember what the estate is called when somebody else retains oil/gas/mineral rights - anyway, the government would obviously have to retain that portion. But they should make available the surface rights - that ought to be sufficient a property right to secure a bank loan, don't you think?

PS This article is just wonderful - one of the reasons I venture away from my usual 'msm' sites (as you guys like to call them :))

PS
I guess in some states like Texas and Colorado surface rights and mineral rights are both recognized - in common law I guess surface rights would be considered fee simple subject to a profit (ie an easement) (?)

Maliki's Bullet
Owning your own land aand property sounds so fundamental
to me as an American. Would Maliki be strong enough to
have this implemented? Seems to me that peace would come much faster if the people had the incentive to own and
produce rather than just fight and lose their lives.

Private Property Rights
I worked in title insurance all my adult life and I can testify to the special gleam in one’s eye when he/she acquires that first piece of real estate that really belongs to him/her! The most excited purchasers we saw were the Habitat for Humanity buyers…they had put “sweat equity” into the house, they had been especially chosen because of their zeal and deep desire afford a better lifestyle to the family, and it was the fulfillment of their dream to own property. The right to own property is a “tangible” right, openly identifiable. A property you own is a place where you are always welcome, and a haven in good times and bad. It changes the attitudes of the occupants dramatically…and people who own property usually take care of it…it is a matter of personal pride…and parents instead of sending their sons and daughter to kill themselves in suicide bombings, can now have something to give to those children…a legacy of life, rather than of death.

These projects could create jobs for the citizens in the area, thereby instilling a sense of self-worth into people who have seen nothing but cruelty and oppression…both from their national leaders, and the religious leaders whose main function it seems is to incite violence, hate, and mayhem. Hopeless people are easily swayed as their futures ares bleak and uncertain. People who are given the idea that they can be masters of their own fate, and make independent decisions might be a real eye opener for those who have always followed, and never led. Culture is a hard thing to change, but there are those who will accept the new ideas and life styles, and others who will only watch…but the watchers will probably grab the brass ring when they see that it really does work!

What fun to trace the lineage of the families and determine true ownership, surveying large tracts of land and laying out private property parcels, and establishing a system of ownership records. Building new houses for the present “squatters” with small repayments back to the government, is a wonderful solution to the problems that would be caused by evictions. The clever Iraqis will figure out a way to get around the fact that their religion prohibits the payment or receipt of interest…leasehold is one option. Owners in large areas could participate in cooperative water companies, electric companies, and could actually create the infrastructures for their neighborhoods and cities possibly funded and maintained with oil money. I am betting those properties would pass from generation to generation and would become a source of “pride of ownership”, and a great sense of accomplishment. The right to own private property is one of the principal differences between the free world and the third-world dictatorships and communism. It is a wonderful place to start in the democratization of Iraq and Afghanistan.

I vote a hearty “yes” to this proposition
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.