Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
Ann Coulter :: Townhall.com Columnist
NYT: Duke Lacrosse Players Killed Meredith Kercher
by Ann Coulter
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Was the Copenhagen Global Warming Summit Walk-Out a Win for the U.S.?


Whether it is Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the Weather Underground, Central Park rapists, Mumia Abu-Jamal, Jim Jones and the People's Temple, welfare recipients, Palestinian terrorists, murderers, abortionists, strippers or common criminals -- liberals always take the side of the enemies of civilization against civilization.

In the view of The New York Times, every criminal trial is a shocking miscarriage of justice -- except the ones that actually are shocking miscarriages of justice.

Thus, in last week's Times, Timothy Egan wrote about a shocking miscarriage of justice being carried out against a "high-spirited" American girl accused of murder by a crazed prosecutor in Perugia, Italy.

Egan's column bears as much relationship to the facts of the case as -- well, I guess as anything printed in the Times. And yet every American news network has embraced Egan's version and is flacking for the accused.

Amanda Knox, her erstwhile boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, and another man, Rudy Guede, stand accused of murdering Knox's roommate, Meredith Kercher, on Nov. 1, 2007, at the house Knox and Kercher shared with two other girls in Perugia.

Egan triumphantly cites an "outside expert hired by CBS News" who calls Knox's prosecution, "the railroad job from hell." Egan does not mention that the "outside investigator" is Paul Ciolino of the "Innocence Project," whose investigations always seem to conclude that the accused is being railroaded.

Ciolino's theory of the crime -- adopted unquestioningly by Egan -- is that the third man, Guede, who has already confessed to the crime, acted alone.

Despite Ciolino's careful analysis of the evidence, his theory is contradicted by Guede himself, as well as the coroner and a leading forensic geneticist, both of whom have testified that Kercher's massive injuries could only have been inflicted by multiple assailants.

It is also contradicted by the court's 106-page report, released in January, explaining the judge's reasons for refusing to release Knox and Sollecito on bail.

Even the "48 Hours" executive producer doesn't endorse Ciolino's preposterous "single knifeman" theory, admitting: "Do we know every piece of data? No. Is there some troubling DNA? Yes."

Hey, does anyone know if CBS hired more than one "outside investigator" to look at the Knox case? Because if Egan considers one CBS "outside investigator" the Rosetta Stone of this case, it would be odd if he didn't mention the conclusions of another CBS outside investigator.

Why yes there was!

The second investigator, Paolo Sfriso, didn't pronounce judgment, but he did cite some of the evidence. The evidence includes:

-- a large kitchen knife, believed by forensic investigators to have caused at least one of Kercher's three wounds, found at Sollecito's house. Despite having been thoroughly washed, the knife had Knox's DNA on the handle and the murder victim's DNA on the blade.

-- a bloody footprint at the crime scene that matches Sollecito's. The floor had been cleaned so that the footprint was invisible to the naked eye, but was revealed with Luminol (just like on "CSI").

-- Knox's bloody footprints, mixed with Kercher's blood, were found in another roommate's room, where a window had been broken to make it look like there had been a break-in -- a theory discounted immediately by investigators. Knox's footprints, too, had been scrubbed but were discovered with Luminol.

-- Kercher's bloody bra strap at the crime scene that had abundant amounts of Sollecito's DNA on it.

Egan explains away the devastating DNA evidence by denying it exists. Delusionally, he writes:

"(I)f Knox and Sollecito had killed Kercher, and were in that blood-splattered room, why is there no physical trace from them on the body? A print? A swap of DNA somewhere? After all, Kercher had died after a brutal strangulation, evidence of considerable struggle, with knife pokes in the neck."

Read the trial transcript, Matlock.

Egan does acknowledge the bloody bra strap covered with Sollecito's DNA, but dismissively writes: "(T)hey discovered Kercher's clasp nearly six weeks after the murder -- a highly suspect and tainted piece of evidence from a contaminated crime scene."

Even the defense isn't complaining about the amount of time that passed before the bra strap was tested. The bra strap was found during the initial search of the crime scene -- which was promptly sealed off -- and then was collected for testing during the second search of the sealed crime scene some weeks later.

True, the defense has tried to minimize all the evidence by throwing out the old "contamination" chestnut, but without proof of systematic contamination of the evidence, this is just a boilerplate defense, much like "but he hit me first." (Next the defense will be vowing to look for the "real killer.")

Egan also dismissed the knife at Sollecito's house with Knox's DNA on the handle and Kercher's DNA on the blade, claiming the knife contained only "a tiny amount of DNA that might match that of the victim." (I know I'm constantly finding small amounts of other people's DNA on the blades of my kitchen knives.)

When the defense tried the "small amount of DNA" argument at trial, forensic biologist Patrizia Stefanoni replied, "If the blood evidence is a positive match, it is not always important how much there is -- and the material on the blade matches the victim."

Even the accused murderess has a better theory to explain the DNA on the knife. Knox wrote in her prison diary: "I think it is possible Raffaele went to Meredith's house, raped her, then killed her and then when he got home, while I was sleeping, he pressed my fingerprints on the knife."

These are only a few examples of the wildly deceptive account of the Amanda Knox trial printed in the Times. The reason this is important is that this is how the Times portrays all criminal prosecutions: Ruthless prosecutor railroads innocent bystanders for mysterious reasons. (Unless the victim is a late-term abortionist or the accused is a Duke lacrosse player.)

The only difference in the Knox case, compared to run-of-the-mill criminal cases, is that the copious foreign reporting on the case makes it child's play to see how egregiously the Times is lying this time.

I don't know if Knox murdered her roommate, but I am sure that America's news coverage of this case is a crime.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Ann Coulter is a columnist and author of Guilty: Liberal Victims and Their Assault On America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Ann Coulter and Townhall.com's daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
The NYT
Just curious - Does anybody with a functioning brain actually believe anything printed in the New York Times?

Who do you think has stronger credibility - Hal, ranger, zapper, Mario, shorts, and jeremy or NYT?

Truly a sad, sad, pathetic little paper.

Yikes
I saw that story. It really, really did leave out all of these points. I thought it seemed really ridiculous, but the story also had some pretty damning things to say about the prosecutor, so I bought it.

Even now, I am really not sure what to make of the whole story. Not sure why Ann didn't mention the prosecutor's problems with the law in his own right. I would think that would be appropriate.

Annes the best
Keep up the good work anne.

NYT bias
This writer Egan is like so many I have known who selectively trashes criminal justice. I guarantee you that if the defendents had killed an abortion doctor, tortured someone at Gitmo, committed some kind of "hate crime" against a minority or gay person or done some other anti-PC crime, Egan and others would want the suspect hung at dawn.

For some reason this case had no political or social overtones worth pursuing in Egan's opinion. It was just a murder of a young woman by other young people. I guess in Egan's mind trying these three suspects limited their freedom somehow. I am guessing he is a liberal. Most liberals I have known tend to look down on the criminal justice system for the freedom limiting aspect alone.

Of course if he was the victim of a violent crime Egan might change his mind. What is that old defintion of a new conservative? A liberal who has been mugged?

Ann
YAWN!!!! Better find a day job Ms. Silverspoon.

Birthers Are Insipid Morons!
BIRTHERS? Every word this babe Rachel Maddow, (calling us whacko’s and she does NOT know WTF she is) spews the same arrogant, pompous BS that the Fascist/Socialist use from their daily 'playbook' throughout the leftist news media filled with total IGNORANCE and DENIAL and continuous LIES denying that BHO, Jr. is an USURPER and all the while...believing and I mean believing that we are insipid morons!

It is beyond the pale that BHO, Jr., has spent over a $1,000,000 of taxpayer or campaign funds to SEAL ALL of his RECORDS from the electorate, "WE THE PEOPLE...", his kindergarten, grammar and high school records, Occidental College records, Columbia and Harvard Universities records, his Thesis', his Harvard Law Review letters and publications, his Illinois Senatorial and U.S. Senator records, Adoption, Divorce and Marriage records of Barry Soetoro and Stanley Ann (Dunham, Obama, Soetoro and other AKA) records, his Indonesian Pass Port, ABA test results for qualifications to be appointed an ATTORNEY the state Bar of Illinois, Health Records, Baptismal records...et cetara.

Perhaps NOBODY KNOWS WHO BHO, Jr. IS except his wife, Michelle and Bill Ayers who, is the ghost writer for BHO, Mr.’s books!

AND MOST IMPORTANT OF ALL OF THESE RECORDS...his long form Birth Certificate that will verify his 'live birth', the name of the Doctor in attendance, the name of the hospital, the name of the city, state and country of his birth, DOB, TOB (time), weight, length, feet prints, Nurses in attendance during the birth procedure and ALL Witnesses present at birth and in the delivery room at Barack Hussein Obama Junior's complete with signatures of the Doctor, Nurse(s) and witnesses that will verify...

When and where BHO, Jr. was born and who his parents were on August 4, 1961!


Semper Fi,
Jason Leverette
Alabama State Director

Hal is funny
He says, "YAWN!!!! Better find a day job Ms. Silverspoon."

And yet, he takes the time to read the article and post his nonsense.

Wow.

Wasn't OJ the victim of a
contaminated crime scene and forensic evidence that was manufactured by investigators? OJ is now looking in the NV state pen for the real killers. Go juice. Everyone knows its just a matter of time till you find the real killer.

Who Cares?
This is another reason the NYT will soon be joining the dodo bird.

Applause for Hal Donahue
I want to thank Hal Donahue for his brilliant analysis and ingenious riposte of Coulter's column posted at 9:48PM. If only more people were as clear spoken and incisive as Mr. Donahue these threads would be much more interesting. Mr. Donahue's item by item dissection of the arguments put forth in the column is truly inspiring. Well done sir.

MNDuck
What leads you to suspect Hal actually read the article?

13-Bravo @ 10:12
Thanks for the laugh. It made my night.

Regards from the land of 10,000 taxes.

Hey! I know!

They could send the evidence to the Detroit Police Crime Lab for a second opinion!

http://www.upi.com/Top_News/2008/09/26/Detroit-crime-lab-sh ut-down-after-audit/UPI-24361222443305/


Liberalism = Failed Government

All the news fit to misrepresent.
As for the NYT’s coverage of the Amanda Knox case, everyone can just relax; they have assigned one if their top journalists to investigate the obvious miscarriage of justice. Jayson Blair has jumped on the red eye to Italy and promises to begin issuing articles as soon as his mother gets off the computer and leaves the basement.

13-Bravo
Good call of doofazz' response but Hal was quite REACTIONARY as well, don't you think?

Charles Sch
I would suggest that only an idiot would comment on an article being boring without first reading it. . . . . Oh, I see your point.

Regards

That is a GREAT closing line.
"I don't know if Knox murdered her roommate, but I am sure that America's news coverage of this case is a crime."

What a closing line. It really sets up a sequel article...hint, hint, Ann!

i

Another Democrat in the Wood-Pile...

Rep John Conyer's(D-Detroit) wife looking for (savior) Obama to call off the Federal Dogs...

http://www.wxyz.com/news/story/Under-Pressure-Feds-Zero-in- on-Conyers/LBmZbH2epEirk2llS2sRdQ.cspx


Conyers hangs with fellow UAW friends of Obama...

http://www.ci.detroit.mi.us/Legislative/CityCouncil/Members /ConyersM/images/uaw_LG.jpg


Detroit Democrats = Criminal

MNDuck @10:17pm
Thank you for the kind thoughts but truly the credit must go to Hal. He is an exceptional political analysist with a wit that is rapier sharp and has an eye for detail. He is my new hero (sorry Mario but you have become boring).

On a different note... when I went through AIT at Ft. Sill there was a guy we called Duck (he loved all ducks except Daffy; go figure) who was from Minnesota if I remember correctly. Would you possibly be him or maybe related?

I'll check back in the morning. Good night all.

13-Bravo and Carlos:
You guys crack me up! Thanks, I needed that! Kudos on the Detroit Crime Lab reference, Carlos; our sole claim to fame here in Michigan, except of course for Kwame Kilpatrick, Monica Conyer, et al.

i

It looks like one comment got lost.
"I don't know if Knox murdered her roommate, but I am sure that America's news coverage of this case is a crime."

Great final comment, Ann. Please post a followup article sometime.

i

MNDuck
Good call on the credibility.

Believe it or not I've actually gotten a reply from Hal where he admitted he was mistaken once, over whether Sotomayor would be the first Hispanic on the SCOTUS. (She wouldn't be.)

And Mario finnaly agreed that it was wrong for the Holder Justice Department to have dropped the charges on the Black Pathers in Philadelphia, so IMHO both of them are more credible than the New York Slimes.

Let's see...how do I really feel about the NYTimes?!?

I would consider using the New York Times to wipe my bunghole if there wasn't a fire ant hill available.

Hope that clarifies things.

Hal
Truly, not her best work. But when you have 6 or 7 best sellers under your belt, you be sure to let us all know, k!? =)

maurcreepio ...

Go away creep!

No one wants to read your ignorant comments.

sqrt(cos(180))

Yes, thank you!

Michigan (+14% unemployement) is a vision of America's future under Obama.

Is there anything Governor Granholm(D) hasn't done -or tried to do over the past 7 years- that Obama isn't proposing to do for the entire nation?

It's pure and simple...

Michigan = Obamanation

Obama is a total FRAUD
And everyone who will look into these details will know he is.
========================

FromTheTop1 wrote:- 9:54 PM EST

BIRTHERS? Every word this babe Rachel Maddow, (calling us whacko’s and she does NOT know WTF she is) spews the same arrogant, pompous BS that the Fascist/Socialist use from their daily 'playbook' throughout the leftist news media filled with total IGNORANCE and DENIAL and continuous LIES denying that BHO, Jr. is an USURPER and all the while...believing and I mean believing that we are insipid morons!

It is beyond the pale that BHO, Jr., has spent over a $1,000,000 of taxpayer or campaign funds to SEAL ALL of his RECORDS from the electorate, "WE THE PEOPLE...", his kindergarten, grammar and high school records, Occidental College records, Columbia and Harvard Universities records, his Thesis', his Harvard Law Review letters and publications, his Illinois Senatorial and U.S. Senator records, Adoption, Divorce and Marriage records of Barry Soetoro and Stanley Ann (Dunham, Obama, Soetoro and other AKA) records, his Indonesian Pass Port, ABA test results for qualifications to be appointed an ATTORNEY the state Bar of Illinois, Health Records, Baptismal records...et cetara.

Perhaps NOBODY KNOWS WHO BHO, Jr. IS except his wife, Michelle and Bill Ayers who, is the ghost writer for BHO, Mr.’s books!

AND MOST IMPORTANT OF ALL OF THESE RECORDS...his long form Birth Certificate that will verify his 'live birth', the name of the Doctor in attendance, the name of the hospital, the name of the city, state and country of his birth, DOB, TOB (time), weight, length, feet prints, Nurses in attendance during the birth procedure and ALL Witnesses present at birth and in the delivery room at Barack Hussein Obama Junior's complete with signatures of the Doctor, Nurse(s) and witnesses that will verify...

When and where BHO, Jr. was born and who his parents were on August 4, 1961!


Semper Fi,
Jason Leverette
Alabama State Director