Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, December 13, 2006
Alan Sears :: Townhall.com Columnist
Christmas With The ACLU: Eliminating Freedom, To Protect Liberty
by Alan Sears
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Will the Dems' health care Christmas Present to America be an improvement or detriment to our health care system?


This Christmas, while most Americans are looking for presents under the tree, the American Civil Liberties Union will be following their own hallowed holiday tradition: looking for scapegoats, under the guise of preserving liberty.

Even now, the Tennessee ACLU is focusing on a lawsuit they've filed in federal court to eliminate what they consider a serious threat to the children at Wilson County's Lakeview Elementary School: "a pattern and a practice of promoting and endorsing" – wait for it – "religious activities."

Now, a warning: what's going on at Lakeview isn't pretty. It's enough, really, to make a Grinch blush. Among the activities giving the ACLU the willies:

  • The Praying Parents, a group that meets once a month in the school cafeteria before school to pray for students, staff, and faculty.

Pretty spooky, that. How to measure the emotional fallout for children, if they find out some grown-ups care? Of course, the ACLU is on record as defending adults who want to have sex with children, or put child pornography on the Internet. So, preying on kids is okay, but praying for them is dangerous stuff?

  • The district allows students to participate in the annual "See You At The Pole" event, where Christian young people across the nation gather at their school flagpole to pray for their teachers and classmates.

So: young people come together in small groups, of their own free will, to pray. Other than freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and free exercise of religion, can you think of any valid Constitutional defense for such behavior?

  • Students and faculty are also allowed to commemorate the National Day of Prayer, celebrated at the White House and the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C. each spring.

There they go again. Christian teachers and students sometimes … pray. On a day when their leading government officials meet to … pray. What horrors is this leading to? Calisthenics on the National Day of Fitness? Planting trees on Arbor Day? Can we sue them for that, too?

  • Some teachers have been known to allow students to pray and play worship songs in their classroom.

The offending prayer came during a re-enactment of the first Thanksgiving feast. (Maybe if the Pilgrims had known their pre-supper supplications would cause such a stir, they'd have just skipped the intercessions altogether. In which case, we'd now be celebrating …Eating Day.)

The worship song was on a CD brought in for Show-and-Tell by a kindergartener, whose three-year-old brother is suffering from cancer. The CD was made by family friends to raise money for his medical treatments.

  • And then there was the annual Christmas program, which ACLU officials contend was overly Christianized.

It's one thing to walk in a "Winter Wonderland." It's another to sing "Away in a Manger" and "Silent Night." Except, of course, that Christmas is a celebration of … the birth of Christ. If we start weeding that little detail out, what's next? We stop mentioning racial equality on Martin Luther King, Jr. Day? No reference to the Declaration of Independence on the Fourth of July?

"Religious freedom for everyone is jeopardized when public schools promote and endorse religious activities," according to Hedy Weinberg, executive director of the Tennessee ACLU. (They pay her to say things like that with a straight face.) "It is unfortunate that we had to go to court to protect religious freedom, but we had no other choice."

A lot of the soldiers overseas today think they're over there, among other things, to protect religious freedom. Turns out, they could've just stayed home and taken CDs away from kindergartners. And, really, as a parent, wouldn't you feel better, knowing no one else, anywhere, is praying for your child today?

"We are pursuing this lawsuit in order to ensure the constitutional guarantee of separation of church and state," Weinberg adds, "so that Wilson County residents can decide for themselves whether or not they want to practice a particular religious faith."

Fair enough, only a) there is no such "constitutional guarantee," and b) Wilson County residents have already made that decision. And most have decided that Christianity is the faith they want to practice.

Does everyone go along with that? No. Are Christians at Lakeview cramming their faith down the throats of those whose inclinations are toward other faiths, or toward no faith at all? No.

No one stood up in a Lakeview classroom and said, "Everyone here who's Baptist gets an ‘A.' Presbyterians can go to recess first. Catholics can have extra chocolate pudding at lunch."

No favoritism. No forced prayers. Just a group of Americans for whom faith is a natural, integral part of their day-to-day life.

And a few neighbors, and some well-funded attorneys, who find that terrifying.

This year, as every year, all the ACLU wants for Christmas is to find more ways of eliminating freedom, in the name of preserving liberty.

Here's hoping Santa passes them by.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Alan Sears, a former federal prosecutor in the Reagan Administration, is president and CEO of the Alliance Defense Fund, a legal alliance employing a unique combination of strategy, training, funding, and litigation to protect and preserve religious liberty, the sanctity of life, marriage, and the family.

Be the first to read Alan Sears' column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

Solution
There is an simple solution to the "separation of church and state" issues continually raised by the ACLU. The solution is to get government out of the education business. Vouchers are a good start.

The ACLU's
stated goal from the beginning has been socialism.

They know that our fundemental rights as Americans were endowed by the Creator, and they know that without wiping Christianity out of the minds of Americans, socialism will never take footing in the United States.

This is why the ACLU is behind selective enforcement of the Constitution. Only what is written that will help their agenda will be fought for. You will never see the ACLU take on a 2nd Ammendment case or take a stand for the first ammendment rights of anyone that does not subscribe to their worldview.

SEARS COMPLETELY MISSES THE POINT
ERIC BURNS WROTE ABOUT THE GAMES PEOPLE PLAY. THE POINT OF HIS WRITINGS WAS CIRCULAR CONVERSATIONS THAT DON'T GO ANYWHERE AND ARE NOT MEANT TO SOLVE OR RESOLVE ANYTHING. TAKE ANOTHER LOOK AT THE COLUMN. DOESN'T THE AUTHOR SOUND RESIGNED. HASN'T HE THROWN IN THE TOWEL. AND WITH THAT KIND OF ATTITUDE IS HE REALLY FOR US OR AGAINST US.

ALAN SEARS HAS AVOIDED THOUGHT AND MANAGED TO CHURN OUT YET ANOTHER INEFFECTIVE COLUMN BY PLAYING THE "AINT IT AWFUL GAME". CAN'T YOU JUST SEE ONE LITTLE KID COMPLAINING TO DADDY THAT ANOTHER LITTLE KID (THE ACLU) IS JUST BEING IMPOSSIBLE. CAN'T YOU SEE HIM STAMPING HIS LITTLE FOOT AS HE SAYS IT? AND WHO IS HE SAYING IT TO? WHO IS THE DADDDY HERE? THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO LOOK AT.

THE PROBLEM IS NOT AND HAS NEVER BEEN A GROUP OF ATTORNEYS WHO (HOWEVER WRONGHEADEDLY) PURSUE THEIR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO PETITION THE COURTS. THE PROBLEM IS THE COURTS. SO IF WE ARE GOING TO THINK AND FIGURE AND PROBLEM SOLVE, WE NEED COLUMNISTS TO ADDRESS THIS PROBLEM. WE NEED THOUGHT ON HOW TO POLITICALLY ATTACK THE COURTS.

ALMOST UNMENTIONED BY THE MSM WAS A CONGRESSIONAL ACT TAKING AWAY JURISDICTION FROM THE SUPREME COURT IN THE AREA OF PRISONER INTERROGATION. THIS IS ONE OF MANY WAYS TO FIGHT THE COURT'S AND THIS IS WHAT WE NEED TO HEAR ABOUT. YOUR MEDIAN RUN OF THE MILL BLOGGER (ME FOR JUST ONE EXAMPLE) IS MORE THOUGHTFUL AND HAS A BETTER HANDLE ON THINGS THAN ALAN SEARS DEMONSTRATES IN THIS COLUMN. SO WHY IS HE TAKING UP SPACE? WHY IS SEARS FEATURED ON TOWNHALL?

aclu
crummy organization that is trying to change america for the worse.

ACLU
The Anti-Christian-Lunatics-Union(ACLU for short)
have been showing their commie/socialist hides from the beginning, and now have gained enough support from 'certain' persons to cause much trouble in this nation.
In some ways their action 'could' be considered 'traitorus' so they should be disbanded and restricted from any and all legislative and judicial actions.

In Other Words!
Enemy of the State of this nation!
Locked up somewhere nice and quiet, and 'safe' and 'secure' in their little white jackets custom fit just for them.
Or the equivilent thereof:-)!!!!!!!!!

How is society harmed?
Sears makes an important point in all this. When it comes right down to it, who is harmed if my daughter or your son participates in the "See You at the Pole" event? Can we name anyone who would be harmed by that? Not my daughter, who as a devout believer in Christ finds a great deal of joy and comfort in her faith. Not her friends who, while they might not want to participate, recognize that her faith is part of what makes her the unique and intriguing person she is.

How am I harmed if somebody prays for my child? Let's just turn the concept on its head. What if a Muslim prays to Allah for my child to become a Muslim. Okay, I don't want my child to become a Muslim, but I consider Allah to be a false idol and not a real god, so I'm not too worried about him honoring the prayer. I think God is quite capable of outweighing any prayer a Muslim might make. I also think that any Muslim meeting up with my daughter's formidable faith and complex mind would likely end up accepting Christ through their attempt to convert her. So, if you're an atheist and you believe that God is a fantasy, why are you afraid that somebody might prayer for your child? If your child knows the "truth", my prayers should have no effect and if God is a fantasy, then I'm just talking to myself anyway. How is anyone harmed?

History records the Pilgrims (a religious group of people) celebrated their good harvest with a feast and a prayer. How is anyone harmed by historical accuracy?

Christmas celebrates Christ's birth (even if it didn't happen at this time of the year), so what is the problem with acknowledging that? How is anyone harmed by that? I don't know a single religious Jew who feels insulted by Christmas as a spiritual holiday, though most agree with me that the secular marketing fest is becoming nauseating. So who is being harmed by mentioning that Christmas celebrates Christ's birth? This is historically accurate. Again, why is that bad?

ACLU is the enemy..
"Dangerous" Dave writes: "The ACLU's stated goal from the beginning has been socialism."

True, though it has not been the "democratic socialism" of Western Europe but the "fascist socialism" (aka communism) of Father Marx.

Who is harmed
Well for starters let me say that I think the majority of what was said I believe as well. People and children have every right to meet at the pole and pray before school. Or before class starts or between classes on their own.

What worries me is when faculty and students get together or even make a class event (worship games) then you are going down a slippery slope and crossing the line.

SEND THE ACLU A CHRISTMAS CARD!!
Send the ACLU a CHRISTMAS CARD this year!

As they are working so very hard to get rid of the CHRISTMAS part of this holiday, we should all send them a nice, CHRISTIAN, card to brighten up their dark, sad, world.

Make sure it says "Merry Christmas" on it!!

Here's the Address, just don't be rude or crude. (It's Not the Christian Way, you know!)

ACLU
125 Broad Street
18th Floor
New York, NY 10004

Two tons of Christmas cards would freeze their operations because they wouldn't know if any were regular mail containing contributions. So spend 39 cents and tell the ACLU to leave Christmas alone.

Also tell them that there is no such thing as a "Holiday Tree". . . . It's a "Christmas Tree"!!

Everyone here should let the ACLU know that we really want to "communicate" with them. They DESERVE us, and all true Americans that understand how our country came to be!!

Just curious
From Miss Weinberg of the Tenn. ACLU: "Religious freedom for everyone is jeopardized when public schools promote and endorse religious activities. ... It is unfortunate that we had to go to court to protect religious freedom, but we had no other choice."

Why does that sound eerily like, "We had to destroy the village in order to save it"?

Radlad
Prayer was not ruled illegal in school, just faculty lead prayer. Like I said it is legal for children to pray before, between, and after school.

That darn Grinch !
I watched the Grinch that stole Christmas the other night( I'm 47 my kids are grown but I still watch it by myself because I simply love the story and message) and while watching the Grinch reminded me of the ACLU. He must keep Christmas from coming, BUT HOW ??. Whoville is America. That evil Grinch ended up taking everything away from Whoville to try to keep Christmas from coming. Why he even took the roast beast and the last can of who hash. But Christmas came anyway. No matter what the silly ACLU does to try and stop Christmas from coming it will never work. I only laugh at their efforts because they will NEVER remove Christmas from our hearts, which is their goal. Merry Christams ACLU , you will be getting a card from me, thanks Jerry !

fair and balanced
Here is what the aclu says about this:

http://www.aclu.org/religion/schools/26946prs20060927.html

I am so lucky we have a court system where we can reslove these differences, rather than with car bombs and IEDs

Jerry
You believe everything you read online?

http://www.snopes.com/politics/christmas/aclucards.asp

Radlad

Jeez, dont you people ever do any research on your own?

http://www.snopes.com/religion/islam.htm

Christmas Card to ACLU
I want to thank the person who posted the ACLU address. I sent my Nativity Scene Christmas card to the good folks at the ACLU Headquarters in New York yesterday. I truly hope they will be flooded with good wishes and the true meaning of Christmas. The Silent Majority better wake up, stand up,and speak up, and do so always in dignity and in truth.

Libertarian Athiest and Naked Pagan
Libertarian athiest states: "What worries me is when faculty and students get together or even make a class event (worship games) then you are going down a slippery slope and crossing the line."
Huh? How is that crossing the line? Again...our schools were originally started because our Founding Fathers believed it was important for people to read the Bible to build decent character for leadership. We are free to worship anywhere. Why should one parent be allowed to stop everyone else from religious activities? They are forcing their NON-BELIEF on the rest of us. How about their kid gets a legimate excuse to stay home from school that day if they find it so offensive? Better yet, why don't they home school their child or start a private athiest school? Oh right, that would be any muslim school.

Naked Pagan, we went over this snopes thing the other day. If the aclu has hired extra people so they won't be shut down...well then no worries right? If they have hired extra people for the CHRISTMAS season then we have given gainful employment to people who need some Christmas money and we are helping the aclu to have less funds for their pathetic lawsuits (oh, I forgot they make us taxpayers pay their bills).

As for the "legimate" "Associated Press and Reuters" would those be the same legitmate ones that published all those fake photos of the Israeli-Hezbollah confict? Would those be the same folks who used a photographer who was caught in an al queda facility and had traces of explosives on him?
Sorry, but I trust other news sources over those two organizations.

Tennessee Schools
i used to support the ACLU more than I do now, because of some of these Christmas things they are doing.
However, since this school was in Tennessee, I bet there is more to the story. My high school still had prayers over the intercom, at graduation, teachers prayed in front of classes on rare occasions, and teachers would give extra credit for attending certain religious activities. Also, atheists and pagans who were open about their beliefs often faced extra disciplinary scrutiny from the administration.
I think there was more going on here than voluntary prayertimes.

Christmas cards to ACLU
So what if it's on Snopes??

If your ONLY intention is to try to overwhelm their system, then you shouldn't be sending cards anyway (wrong motive).

But Snopes (and naked pagan) didn't offer any good reason NOT to send cards. My wife and I have been sending them out for the last week. Why? I want some of them to get through. Who knows? Maybe SOMEONE in that radical organization will be positively touched. MISSION ACCOMPLISHED! -- amen?

By the way -- Snopes isn't the ONLY research source on the 'net, np.

treadmilljoe and libertarianchick.
First a couple of questions for Joe. Would you be more specific about what Eric BERNE's theory about transactional analysis has to do with what Alan Sears has written here? Another question. Why all the caps. Is that designed to give your comments more weight?


Libertarianchick. Frankly, I don't believe you. The ACLU drools even contemplating a school that is that openly sympathetic to Christianity. Why haven't you alerted the ACLU? You sound really upset about what is you claim is happening in Tennessee schools.


Like I said. I don't believe you.

treadmilljoe and libertarianchick.
First a couple of questions for Joe. Would you be more specific about what Eric BERNE's theory about transactional analysis has to do with what Alan Sears has written here? Another question. Why all the caps. Is that designed to give your comments more weight?


Libertarianchick. Frankly, I don't believe you. The ACLU drools even contemplating a school that is that openly sympathetic to Christianity. Why haven't you alerted the ACLU? You sound really upset about what is you claim is happening in Tennessee schools.


Like I said. I don't believe you.

Ooops.
The screen just did something screwy. I have seen multiples of posts here before, but this is the first time it happened to me.

I'll remember the screen I got when I tried to submit the first post. Next time I will go bac k to the Home page, pull up the article and see whether my post is there.

To Skip
I'm not a liar...
My school is in the prong of the buckle of the Bible Belt. The things that happened were technically illegal, but it would have cost too much to complain about things that really didn't necessarily end up hurting me.
My parents were Christians and would have forbidden me to associate with the ACLU about it, plus it would have likely earned retaliation from my peers.
I don't necessarily think that the ACLU should always be dragged in, I'm just saying that there is likely more cause in this case than seems at first glance.

truthspotlight
I didnt say dont send the ACLU christmas card.

My point was you should not believe everything you read on line, and yes, if your intent is to be sarcastic and shut down their system, well, you arent being very christan, are you?

Re: SNOPES
I have significant trouble with the last paragraph at the snopes site regarding the cards to the ACLU.

It couldn't have been any better if it HAD BEEN WRITTEN BY A CARD-CARRYING ACLU MEMBER.

How sad.

Snopes used to be a strictly fact-based outfit which now seems to have taken a far-left tilt.

SkunkWorks
You know, I sort of thought the same thing as I looked over that page . . .

I mean, why the need to editorialize at the end? Isn't providing "facts" good enough anymore???

Arlington National Cemetery
has crosses on the graves, or at least on the headstones. So do the graves of many veterans. So do the WWII graves in France. When do those come down? And who's gonna have the gonads to do it?

Aliveinhim
not the aclu

http://www.aclu.org/about/faqs/index.html#3_8

You can put any headstone you want on your grave...its not government expression, its personal
express

http://www.aclu.org/religion/discrim/26970prs20060929.html

libertarianchick
If you were indeed reporting what happened in your school then I regret calling you a liar. It is just that everything I have learned about public schools indicates that they are under the control of secularists, and of the homosexual lobby.


When a teacher is chastised for wearing a cross around her neck, and school administrators insist that second grade children will be taught about homosexuality in spite of parental objection, it is startling to hear about the events that you report. These cases are widely reported, and occur all over America.


It just sounds strange, but your school may have escaped the attention of the ACLU. If so, I think that you are lucky.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.