Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons

Townhall.com The Blogspot for Political, Conservative and Republican Blogs and Bloggers


Monday, August 20, 2007
Death Penalty Distortions Highlight Liberal Hypocrisy
Posted by: Michael Medved at 12:39 AM

   Liberals reveal their appalling hypocrisy when they proudly claim to oppose the influence of religion on politics, and then try to cite the Bible to argue against the death penalty..

   In one typical expression of sentiment, just today I spotted a bumper-sticker declaring, “The Last Time They Mixed Religion and Politics They Burned People at the Stake.”

   Nevertheless, opponents of capital punishment frequently resort to scriptural citations or faith-based arguments to try to make their case. The same “progressives” who react with horror at Christian, pro-life arguments when it comes to the issue of abortion, seem to welcome misguided Christian arguments against capital punishment.

   This point came home to me with unusual force during synagogue services this last Saturday. The weekly portion of the Bible which was read out loud this week by all Jews, everywhere, included verses (Deuteronomy 19: 11-13) that leave little doubt as to the Old Testament’s insistence on the death penalty. Scripture declares that “if there be a man who hates his fellow, and ambushes him mortally, and he dies” then the killer cannot escape to one of the established “Cities of Refuge” intended for perpetrators of accidental death. With a pre-mediated murder, the Bible says: “Your eye shall not pity him; you shall remove the innocent blood from Israel; and it shall be good for you.”

  Concerning this passage, the authoritative Twelfth Century sage, Maimonides, offers an explanation with haunting contemporary resonance: “The verse concludes that by executing the murderer, the nation will insure that it shall be good for you, because compassion for a murderer breeds further bloodshed, since it frees him from death and sets an example for others, who may be tempted to follow his example.”

   In other words, misplaced compassion for a pre-meditated murderer brings cruel consequences for future innocent victims – as recent academic studies of the death penalty and its powerful deterrent impact very clearly indicate.

   In response to the Old Testament’s direct (and frequently repeated) authorization of capital punishment, Christian opponents of the death penalty claim that Jesus replaced the harsh Mosaic law of justice with a new Gospel of forgiveness and mercy. They cite the famous Gospel injunction to “turn the other cheek” or the suggestion that “he who is without sin should cast the first stone,” without acknowledging that these exhortations apply to individual conduct and not to governmental authorities. In the New Testament, in fact, Paul makes clear in Romans 13:4 that believers should not expect society to abolish capital punishment: “But if you do evil, be afraid; for (the governing authority) does not bear the sword in vain; for he is God’s minister; an avenger to execute wrath on him who practices evil.”

   Moreover, the same section of Matthew’s Gospel that includes the celebrated exhortations to “love thine enemy” and “turn the other cheek” begins with Christ’s unequivocal declaration (Matthew 5: 17-18) that he has no intention of abrogating properly interpreted Old Testament law: “Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfill. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.”

   In this context, the early Church unhesitatingly endorsed the death penalty. Clement of Alexandria, the great scholar and teacher of the Second Century, declared that “if someone falls into incurable evil – when taken possession of by wrong or covetousness – it will be for his good if he is put to death.” In the Fourth Century, St. Jerome (venerated by Roman Catholics, Eastern Orthodox and Lutherans alike) wrote that execution of “murderers, blasphemers and poisoners” is not “shedding of blood, but administration of laws.” Aquinas also strongly reasoned for the death penalty, and as recently as the Catechism of Trent (1566), the Catholic Church unequivocally affirmed that “lawful slaying belongs to the civil authorities, to whom is entrusted power of life and death, by the legal and judicious exercise of which they punish the guilty and protect the innocent.”

  Of course, the Church has changed its position in recent years (particularly since the Second Vatican Council in 1962-65), in most cases discouraging the death penalty as non-reformative and non-rehabilitative. In terms of religious authority, however, sacred scholars and teachers many centuries closer to Jesus and his message (not to mention closer to Moses and his law) affirmed and prescribed the death penalty with scant hesitation.

  In short, the attempt by opponents of capital punishment to cite Biblical authority not only ignores the plain language of Old Testament and New Testament text as well as thousands of years of authoritative interpretation, but also highlights the hypocritical willingness of secular progressives to trot out religious arguments (no matter how specious) whenever it helps them to make their feeble case.  







Your Blog Postings:
Last updated 13 Minutes 19 Seconds Ago
Last updated 13 Minutes 33 Seconds Ago
Last updated 14 Minutes 21 Seconds Ago
Last updated 17 Minutes 11 Seconds Ago
Last updated 18 Minutes 22 Seconds Ago
 

Archives of our Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs

Blog Search



Townhall Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs Townhall Blogs
Townhall Conservative, Republican, Political Columns Columns
Your Townhall Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs Your Blogs
By Month
 July 2009
 June 2009
 May 2009
 April 2009
 March 2009
 February 2009
 January 2009
 December 2008
 November 2008
 October 2008
 September 2008
 August 2008
 July 2008
 June 2008
 May 2008
 April 2008
 March 2008
 February 2008
By Issue
 A Culture of Life
 Budget & Government
 Campaigns & Elections
 Education
 Energy & Environment
 Faith & Family
 Foreign Affairs
 Health Care
 Immigration
 Jobs & Economy
 Judges & Courts
 Media & Culture
 Property Rights
 Safety & Security
 Science & Technology
 Second Amendment
 Social Security
 Tax Relief
Advertisement

Comments Comments

Pope Admires Obama, Gives Him Gifts
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Andrea
Bk thanks 4 Stat Reminder. bo was major
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Legally Remove BO
The Pope Gives Obama Expensive Art Work
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Andrea
Speakin 4 Catholics outside kennedy
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Legally Remove BO
Andrea "2" Writes:
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By BK
Give Obama a Break?
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Diana
Announced
 Re: Smearing the "Little People"
  By deerhunter
Oops...
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Andrea
Yes, You Are Right Patriotic Liberal
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Andrea
Andrea "2"
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By BK
Pat Lib writes:
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By BK
Patriotic Liberal
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Andrea
as for the "results"
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Patriotic Liberal
Pat Lib:
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By BK
Andrea "2" writes:
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By BK
well
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Patriotic Liberal
Andrea 2
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By Patriotic Liberal
Andrea "2" writes:
 Re: Better Than the Pope -- He's the Messiah!
  By BK
Axe
 Re: Mancession
  By Big Sky Cowboy
second amendment poppycock
 Re: Long Live the Second Amendment
  By Patriotic Liberal

The Latest on Town HallThe Latest on Town Hall


Blog Roll Blog Roll