Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons

Townhall.com The Blogspot for Political, Conservative and Republican Blogs and Bloggers


Tuesday, October 24, 2006
Roseanne's Minimum Wage Video Almost As Effective As Yesterday's Waterboarding Video
Posted by: Mary Katharine Ham at 4:31 PM

Successful, that is, in solidifying my current position.

Perhaps this one and the waterboarding one were produced by the same guy? Maybe that guy was David Zucker, and he's just pulling a fast one on clueless Democrats who don't know where his allegiances lie?

Watch closely. I'll list the crimes against humanity visited upon this young woman after the YouTube. This is a Roseanne Barr/AFL-CIO production

First, did you catch that she actually makes more than minimum wage? This is one of only seven sob stories these folks felt compelling enough to convince people to support a wage hike, and they couldn't even find someone who's on minimum wage?

I really only need to pull one quote from this (of course, I'll do more), and this is it. Am I the only one who laughed out loud at the fact that the girl is almost weeping over this? Weeping.

"When you work a job that doesn't pay a lot, you have to work a lot of hours to make a decent amount...I'm not making that much, but I'm working almost, almost 40 hours a week every week and I just look at my paycheck and I wanna cry."

Almost 40 hours? Every week? Hot diggety, it's like the ever-lovin' Gulag! Sweetie, take that mess somewhere else, 'cause it ain't gonna sell around here. In what world is almost 40 hours "a lot of hours" for a grown-up to work? But, give her a break, Mary Katharine. Surely she's got children to take care of and a mortgage to pay?

"I'm young and I'm still living with my parents."

Seriously, this is one of the best seven stories they can come up with to illustrate the dire need to raise the minimum wage? That makes me rather more convinced than I was before that we shouldn't. She's a 20-something in her quarter-life crisis, possibly mooching off her parents, and she's only got minimum wage to serve as spending money, and I'm supposed to be upset about that? More going-out money for Erin is what raising the minimum wage will get us? Hey, it's not me telling you. This is what the advocates say. This is the case the supporters make.

"I'm gonna probably end up going to get a two-year degree or something...So, that I can at least get a job where they pay decent, so that I can move out of the house and figure out what I want to do with my life."

Once again, not sad. There is not a wet eye in the crowd. In fact, this is wonderful. Making minimum wage and sitting at her parents' house with no direction for her life is not making Erin happy. She wants bigger and better things, and has the desire to get the education needed to get there. Now, what would happen if we gave this young, smart lady who is capable of moving upward and onward $15 an hour to run a cash register at the Food Lion?

She'd much more likely stay in that job, which is partly fine, but isn't it nice that she's incentivized to move upward when she's perfectly capable of doing so instead of sitting at her parents' house forever? In addition, once she leaves that job, it comes open to someone who is either still in their quarter-life crisis and living at Mom's crib, or someone else who may not be blessed with the skills and time Erin has to get a two-year degree, but who needs a job.

"You pretty much have to just do something that you really don't want to do to make the money that you need to support yourself."

Yes, this is true, Erin. Most people call this truth "their job." That's the way the world works.

And, here's the saddest part. Bleeding-heart liberals like Roseanne actually have this girl convinced that she should be crying over her situation. Crying. The situation in which she gets a discount on a 24-pack of The Beast before she takes it home to her parents' house to sit on her rent-free deck and drink it with her old buddies from high school. It may not be the richest life, and Erin I'm sure has problems that are worth sympathy, but this does not seem to be one of them.

Erin says herself that she's not sure what she's gonna do with her life, but is planning on getting a two-year degree and figuring it out. That's awesome! The fact that some people want to make a smart young woman like this pity herself and ask the government to solve her problems for her is so counterproductive and sad. It's so infantilizing.

Liberals subsist on creating victims because victims are their voting base. If this young woman doesn't see herself as a victim of the system; if she acts on her desire to move out of this job by saving some money and going to college; if she then succeeds in making plenty of money and acting as a model of self-sufficiency to other members of her community and family, the Democratic Party is out a couple of votes. Which is sad for Democrats, but great for Erin and her family, who will find much more happiness and long-lasting prosperity in self-sufficiency than in a minimum wage hike.

People look on conservatives as heartless for opposing minimum wage hikes, but is it any wonder I don't want my tax dollars being used to make this girl a perpetual victim instead of the smart, confident, successful person she's meant to be? I've seen it happen to too many people. The wrong kind of compassion can hurt exactly those it's meant to help.

This is the exact same thing the welfare state in Ohio is trying with the Amish community. "Hey, I've got a great idea. We've got an entire population of people that is responsible, self-sufficient, and supportive of one another without government help. Let's dismantle all that to hit our food stamp quota, shall we?"

I was covering a school board meeting several years ago when the conversation turned to free-and-reduced lunch numbers. You see, public schools often get state and federal aid based upon the number of free-and-reduced lunch students they have. Thus, it's in the schools' interest to make sure all of their eligible students are taking advantage of the free-and-reduced lunch program. Of course, a lot of poor families were not willing to accept free-and-reduced lunch just because Dad had recently lost his mill job. They wanted to tough it out and provide for themselves. It was a point of pride.

"Well, how do we get them to let go of that? We've got to get these kids on free lunch."

Let go of that pride, kid. It certainly won't serve you as well as this $1.50 credit for over-greasy pizza and a pint of milk. The nature of the liberal wing of the Democratic Party and federal government programs is to squelch personal responsibility and self-sufficiency. They think it's compassionate, but in extremes, it is neither the path toward better government nor happier citizens.

There are better ways to help people. Much better.

Update: I figured out how we can raise the minimum wage to $100 an hour!

 

 



View in ascending order View in descending order
Mike Doyle writes: Friday, October, 27, 2006 4:01 PM
More to Erin than meets the eye...
I interviewed Erin. In her defense, a lot of her backstory did not make it into the final video. Behind the camera, she was as affecting to me as when I interviewed Day Four's Jessica.

Until literally the week of the interview, Erin and both of her parents lived on minimum wage in northwest Indiana. No one had benefits, no one had a set schedule, and they all lived together because otherwise no one would have a roof over their heads.

Northwest Indiana is a highly depressed area. Although those steel mills and other industry left the Gary/Hammond/Michigan City area in decades past, the people who live there did not. In the local economy, a full-time job with benefits is hard to find and hard to trust that it will stick around when you do luck into one.

Erin was not living at home in order to go to school. She was living at home because she had no other choice. She wanted to go to school and live on her own--she was working almost 40 hours per week at the time of her interview, AND going to school, and while she was making it through school those work hours STILL were not enough for her to live on her own.

What Erin told me was that three adults living together at a time in all of their lives when they did not expect to be together in the same house, with all of them on minimum wage, none of them with health benefits, and little money for any real other purpose than necessities (especially gas) to go around, her family was coming apart emotionally, psychologically, at the seams. She cried not just because she hated her job. She cried also because she was losing her family over it it.

Her choice became: either stay in school, work as many hours as physically possible, and live at home with mom and dad while everyone's familial relationships continued to dissolve; or leave school and leave town to find a better job elsewhere, have your education go nowhere, and be far away from your loved ones.

What kind of a choice is that? The kind of choice that millions of unfairly paid workers are faced with in America. Every. Single. Day. Whiny? No. Erin was something else. Erin was desperate. No law should ever place any American into that kind of desperation, that kind of choice.

Finally, let's get rid of one big misconception. Some people have pointed out Erin worked almost 40 hours a week. True. At minimum wage and with absolutely no health insurance because, as with Jessica, her job refused to grant her enough hours to qualify for insurance. The week I interviewed her, her biweekly paycheck amounted to less than $400. God forbid she get sick and need to pay to see a doctor that week.

In other words, almost doesn't cut it.
rivlax writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 6:30 PM
BPOP obnoxiousness
Anyone who answers his own posts without waiting for someone to respond should be banned on general principles. This guy is obviously just trying to be a creep, so just ban him. He's like a guy who comes into your living room and takes a dump and then wonders why everyone gets upset.
MoleOnABull writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:49 PM
I'm going to GAZE now
Mary K,
I take it this person trolls the boards around here pretty often. Just GAZE.

And keep up the great work!
USN RET writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:47 PM
Re: Cracked Prat of Grease( aka:BPOP)
This was about setting minimum wage. I thought the posting was well thought out. People need an incentive to improve their situation. Setting the minimum wage high does not provide that incentive. It would only raise prices on all products. I grew up on a family farm, where I worked my behind off on a daily basis. I then went on to the Navy and took classes while in and now I work in the biotech industry for a very nice wage. As for your comments,I find you a rude uncouth little brat, who should be sitting in a corner
MoleOnABull writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:45 PM
you have no 1st Amendment rights
Mini-civics lesson: The First Amendment restricts government, not private citizens, from infringing on your right to free speech. On this blog, your speech is a privilege. On your blog, your speech is a right. Learn the distinction.

Credit: La Shawn Barber
MoleOnABull writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:39 PM
I'm with Frank J.
Or we could just GAZE.
MoleOnABull writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:36 PM
BPOP, you sound angry... heh, typical
Someone sounds like they have a big chip on their shoulder...

Let's all cry for you now. Let's all reinforce those liberal priciples that were obviously ingrained into you as a child.

Or we could tell YOU to move up in this world if you are not satisfied with your job.

I'll go with the latter.

Paychecks are for workers. Lot's of money = hardwork
Frank J. writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:31 PM
Just Ban Him
If BPOP can't even be polite, what the chance he's going to have anything worthwhile to say?

And why do trolls always have to write so long? Where are the pithy trolls?
Mary Katharine writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 5:14 PM
BPOP
Just fyi. I don't mind you hanging around so much. Your criticism is somewhat less than devastating, and you make it wholly unnecessary for me to respond by negating everything you say, every time, with personal attacks upon me...

But, if you keep on with the racism and sexual references, you'll get banned. Watch it.
Ennuipundit writes: Tuesday, October, 24, 2006 4:52 PM
As someone who...
never moved back home witht he fam, I get weary of these kids who are complaining about making it in the big bad world. That's why you work hard (he types from work, when he ought to be working) Ummm, pay no attention to the man behind the curtain...
Sign Up to Post Your Comments Sign Up to Post Your Comments
Please take a few seconds to sign up, then you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, create your own blog and more! If you are already registered, click here.
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.
 


Your Blog Postings:
Last updated 24 Minutes 4 Seconds Ago
Last updated 36 Minutes 41 Seconds Ago
Last updated 46 Minutes 2 Seconds Ago
Last updated 51 Minutes 51 Seconds Ago
Last updated 1 Hours 5 Minutes 29 Seconds Ago
 

Archives of our Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs

Blog Search



Townhall Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs Townhall Blogs
Townhall Conservative, Republican, Political Columns Columns
Your Townhall Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs Your Blogs
By Month
 November 2009
 October 2009
 September 2009
 August 2009
 July 2009
 June 2009
 May 2009
 April 2009
 March 2009
 February 2009
 January 2009
 December 2008
 November 2008
 October 2008
 September 2008
 August 2008
 July 2008
 June 2008
By Issue
 A Culture of Life
 Budget & Government
 Campaigns & Elections
 Education
 Energy & Environment
 Faith & Family
 Foreign Affairs
 Health Care
 Immigration
 Jobs & Economy
 Judges & Courts
 Media & Culture
 Property Rights
 Safety & Security
 Science & Technology
 Second Amendment
 Social Security
 Tax Relief
Advertisement

Comments Comments

ray
 Re: Only Global Warming Critics Can Save Climategate Scientists
  By Pat
Oh yeah
 Re: 'This isn't the Britain we fought for,' say the 'unknown warriors' of WWII
  By twomay
Axe eternally gets it wrong:
 Re: This Day in American History...
  By homer noble
More facts wrong by Jo
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By Careful with that axe, Eugene
Oops
 Re: Only Global Warming Critics Can Save Climategate Scientists
  By Pat
Jo
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By Careful with that axe, Eugene
Say what?
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By Jo
Been around over 60 years, Munck
 Re: Only Global Warming Critics Can Save Climategate Scientists
  By ray
Peer review
 Re: Only Global Warming Critics Can Save Climategate Scientists
  By Pat
Jo, it was a pleasure posting with you..
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By clarityseeker
D'oh Homer...
 Re: This Day in American History...
  By Careful with that axe, Eugene
NeoConScum 3:05 PM
 Re: Only Global Warming Critics Can Save Climategate Scientists
  By Bob Munck
Let's talk about your real problem
 Re: Twenty lessons your teenage daughter will learn from the Twilight movies
  By Careful with that axe, Eugene
Dreadnuts on the movies...
 Re: Twenty lessons your teenage daughter will learn from the Twilight movies
  By Careful with that axe, Eugene
And finally, resolute words from Christ:
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By clarityseeker
I was really glad
 Re: ACORN and "Journalistic Standards"
  By TheHistorian
Axe the delusional:
 Re: This Day in American History...
  By homer noble
After sufficient proof, PL vanishes...
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By clarityseeker
Clarity
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By Careful with that axe, Eugene
Four
 Re: Here Comes the Judge?
  By Jo

The Latest on Town HallThe Latest on Town Hall


Blog Roll Blog Roll