Townhall.com The Blogspot for Political, Conservative and Republican Blogs and Bloggers

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Lefty Blog Forced to Retract Plagiarism Smear on McCain

Posted by: Amanda Carpenter at 8:29 PM

An arm of the liberal Center for American Progress falsely claimed Republican presidential candidate John McCain plagiarized his recent foreign policy speech made before the Los Angeles World Affairs Council.

Think Progress, a project of the think tank created to promote left-wing policy ideas, stated in a a blog post, "These lines are not McCain’s own. As TP reader 5th Estate discovered, they were in fact taken largely from a 1996 speech by ret. Rear Adm. Timothy Ziemer."

The post was promoted through left-leaning media outlets like the Huffington Post. See HERE.

The McCain campaign forced Think Progress to publish a retraction, made in the form of an "update" to their blog. Their correction said: As a blog that strives to maintain credibility and transparency, we would like to explain our mistake. When we were alerted to the tip that Adm. Ziemer gave a similar speech in 1996, we searched LexisNexis and McCain’s campaign site for whether the senator used the disputed phrases before that time. We did not find anything. After we published the post, the McCain campaign contacted us and pointed to a speech given by the senator in 1995, which appears on McCain’s Senate site. As soon as we were alerted to the error, we rushed to publish a correction. Once again, we regret the error.

A large portion of blog containing the false allegations, without correction, remains on the heavily-trafficked Huffington Post HERE at this time.

Update: The HuffPo now indicates Think Progress "redacted" their piece.

For those interested in comparing the speeches, here are the links.

McCain's 1995 speech
Ziemer's 1996 speech
McCain's 2008 speech

The lines Think Progress were calling into question were:
-"When nations seek to resolve their differences by force of arms, a million tragedies ensue."
-"[War] is wretched beyond all description."
- "Not the valor with which it is fought nor the nobility of the cause it serves, can glorify war."

(3) |

(0)

View in ascending order

View in descending order

pic82101 writes:	Thursday, March, 27, 2008 8:41 PM
Interesting link
http://gopcatholics.blogspot.com/2008/03/take-down-dictator s.html
Email It \| Print It \| Flag as Offensive

Keith writes:	Thursday, March, 27, 2008 8:45 PM
Um
What a crock. Ever consider DOING the research first?
Email It \| Print It \| Flag as Offensive

stormie writes:	Friday, March, 28, 2008 12:11 AM
So?
They retracted it and apologized! I realize that this is new concept here since the idea of actually admitting error and apologizing are unheard of in the GOP and amongst its minions. One only need watch FoxNews or read Malkin's many (purposeful?) flubs to learn just how the right uses misinformation to convince millions that up is down and right is wrong - so calling out an organization that admits their error seems somehow skeevy from the likes of Townhall.
Email It \| Print It \| Flag as Offensive

Please take a few seconds to sign up, then you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, create your own blog and more! If you are already registered, click here.

Townhall.com The Blogspot for Political, Conservative and Republican Blogs and Bloggers

Townhall Blog, Breaking News & Commentary from the Townhall Crew

Archives of our Conservative, Republican, Political Blogs

Comments Comments

The Latest on Town HallThe Latest on Town Hall

Blog Roll Blog Roll