|
On Friday, I sent off this brief letter to a friend who's concerned (appropriately, it seems to me) with the current effort to smear a decent and sincere Friend of Israel, John Hagee, as some sort of closet anti-Semite. The attacks on this good man are horribly unfair, politically motivated and, ultimately, despicable. "Dear.......
I've already defended Hagee on the air in this latest nonsense, and suggested that McCain made a mistake in his over-reaction. The fact that the brief excerpt from the sermon dates from ten years ago only highlights its irrelevance: with Pastor Wright, the controversy re-emerged because of comments he made last month.
Meanwhile, my main objection to the substance of Hagee's remarks involves its reenforcement of the mistaken strategy of linking Israel to the holocaust. I've written and spoken for years about the historical illiteracy and strategic stupidity behind this notion -- inviting the likes of Ahmadine-wackjob to say "since Germany committed the holocaust -- if it happened -- why not place the Jews on German land, rather than displacing Palestinians?"
You know that the 600,000 Jews who defended their functioning, independent community so successfully in 1948-49 had all arrived BEFORE the Holocaust--- only a handful were survivors smuggled into the Yishuv after the war. The Brits did a remarkably effective job preventing Jewish immigration both immediately before and after the war. Even after the new state earned its independence, no overwhelming wave of survivors arrived. In fact, the number of refugees from Islamic lands (800,000) outnumbered the total number of Holocaust survivors by at least four-to-one.
This is an important point, because Israel and its population emerged at least as much in response to persecution in Islamic nations as from the European Holocaust.
You know all this, and so does Pastor Hagee. But his unfortunate experience with this latest distortion and smear only re-emphasizes the importance of dropping Hitler references whenever talking about Israel -- or about contemporary politics, for that matter....
Thanks for your thoughts. I may try to talk some more on this subject today.... M"
|