Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
Terry Jeffrey :: Townhall.com Columnist
Harry Reid's Assault on American Workers
by Terry Jeffrey
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



Assume there are 100 people in your community who do the work you do and 100 jobs for that type of work that local employers want to fill. You are in a pretty good position: You can stay employed.

Now assume there are only 95 people in your community who do the work you do and 105 jobs that local employers want to fill. You are in an even better position: You can stay employed and demand a higher wage because the demand for the work you do exceeds the supply of able workers.

You are, in fact, like all workers in a free society, a small business owner. You are an enterprise of one. You have something of value to sell, which is your labor, and you have a right to hold out for the highest price you can get from willing buyers. Harvard Law School graduates have this right, and landscape laborers have this right.

It is at the heart of free enterprise, a core element of our American way of life.

Now suppose the government decides to stop enforcing the nation's borders and immigration laws, allowing 25 people from a foreign country who do the same kind of work you do to illegally enter the United States, settle in your community, and begin competing with you and your neighbors for the jobs you hold.

With additional illegal aliens pouring across the border daily, there are already 120 people seeking the 105 jobs of your type in your town.

A few of your lifelong friends are laid off. Your own job is threatened. Your employer slashes wages, and you accept the pay cut because the supply of workers now exceeds the demand.

You begin wondering when you'll see a pink slip in your pay envelope.

The illegal-alien families, which pay less in taxes than the formerly higher-paid American workers, put their children in public schools, secure health care at public hospitals and place a net financial burden on their neighbors. Taxes go up; the quality of services goes down.

This is before the recession.

First, economic growth slows. Then, it stops. Then, it drops off a cliff. Month after month, hundreds of thousands of additional workers are thrown from their jobs as the economy tumbles down a mountainside.

What policy changes do congressional leaders recommend as employment plummets?

In Washington, D.C., today, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., is plotting an attack on the surviving jobs of American workers.

"I'm going to do comprehensive immigration reform," Reid told reporters last week. "I'm not going to do it piecemeal. That's an excuse for everybody to do too little.

"We're going to do it all at once, and we're going to have comprehensive immigration reform that will include taking care of our borders, a decent guest-worker program, bringing the 11 million people out of the shadows, doing something that's so important with the employer sanctions bill that really is a catch-22 for everyone and a number of other things," said Reid. "We're going to do it all in one piece of legislation, not give people an excuse that they voted for one thing and think that they're through with it."

What Reid means by "bringing 11 million people out of the shadows" is making illegal immigrants legal -- thus rewarding illegal behavior and encouraging further illegal immigration.

What he means by a "decent guest-worker program" is giving employers the power to import foreign workers into the United States and keep those workers laboring here in a status that is inferior to a free American citizen or permanent legal resident.

These imported "guest workers" would not have the right to sell, or withhold, their labor at any time, place and price they choose -- like real Americans do. Such workers would be subject to federal laws and regulations meant to hold them captive to the employers who imported them.

Such workers would be half-slave, half-free -- and part of a country dividing against itself.

What Harry Reid is proposing is an assault on American workers and the principle of free labor. It is as contrary to the American way of life as the federal government owning General Motors.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

Terence P. Jeffrey is the editor-in-chief of CNSNews

Be the first to read Terence Jeffrey's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com delivered each morning to your inbox.

©Creators Syndicate
Out of the Shadows?
Those in favor of giving illegal aliens amnesty usually say they want to bring illegals 'out of the shadows', as if they are scared, quivering animals afraid of being beaten. I have yet to see any illegal alien 'in the shadows'. I see them boldly march around and demand their rights. They are in my grocery store cashing in WIC coupons and buying food on their EBT cards. No one remembers when they poured into our streets to demand 'their' rights, even though they have broken the law and are citizens of another nation? These people are NOT afraid. They are arrogant and hateful. They hate white people in particular, and black people, too, but not as much. I work for Welfare. They are NOT afraid to march themselves into our offices, demand culture / language workers, and file a grievance for just about anything. They are not slaving away in the fields, or in hotels, or elsewhere. They and their children are getting a free ride. Who are the hard working immigrants you people are talking about???? Once they have children, they no longer have to work because their children qualify for Welfare. They get free MediCAL, free education, free housing, without paying anything near equal to what they are receiving. And, we, as a government agency, are not allowed to report them. It is insane.

Illegal Aliens Take Jobs
And with respect to illegal aliens: if you lose your job to someone with a 3rd grade education, then you've got bigger problems than competition from illegal aliens.

Studies show that merely graduating from high school can increase one's earnings potential by as much as 40%. K-12 at no cost to the student. Myriad of trade schools, colleges, loans and grants are available. The only people adversely affected by the presence of uneducated illegal aliens are those that squandered those many,many opportunities.

Get off the couch, America.

The Heart of Free Enterprise
This is funny. Immigration laws by definition impair free enterprise. Free enterprise is impeded by prohibiting millions of willing workers from working for millions of willing employers.

Do we need immigration laws? Yes. We do. But don't try to convince me that prohibiting millions of willing workers from participating in our economy constitutes free enterprise.


Harry Reid
This piece of excremeent like so amny of his Socialist brethren, including "The One", is interested in nothing more than destruction of conservative views and values and the acquisition of power by servitude of the masses with promises of benefits that will nelp no one but the power base of the Demoncrats and their evil agenda.
He and his kind are not interested in solving the problems of our country. He's interested in power and his "solutions" are destructive.

Reid beyond description?
Jerk?Moron?Idiot? Fool? Sap? Anal?
Heck no, those terms would be lifting him up
a notch or two!
Elvis

"What if - keyboard slip

My keyboard is so touchy it has a mind of its own - sorry.

The point of the Democratic line is that they plan to talk, talk, talk, about immigration trying to put the Republicans in a bad light so all the immigrants will be on the Dem's side.
No votes until fall.

The Dems want to let the 11 million illegals with their families get in free and be dem-dependent.

If they don't try to pass the bill until fall, they plan to harangue the Republicans to keep any latino from voting that way.

BUT WHAT IF - what if the Repubs don't play -
don't take the bit.

The chief Dem technique is ridicule. Two can play at that game.

Any of you conservatives who might like this idea - harangue your Repubs to do this.

Bush lost the election for the Repubs because he could not and would not state any case other than "Terror".

The Repubs are not much better - they never put out any good reason for their "NO". Maybe one guy will come on, but that's all.

I keep nagging them to SPEAK UP. My senator probably has a "stop" watch on my communications but he is a good conservative.

What if they don't talk?

On the news tonight - FOX (I doubt if any other network would announce this) - the Sneaky Dems and wormy Obama are going to start talking about immigration reform.

THEY WANT TO PASS IT IN THE FALL

lack of integration
Accompanying and contributing to the destruction of wealth is the destruction of culture. When one refuses to acknowledge that to a large degree the US's prosperity has been due to a worldview that believes in success through hard work along with the rights of man to life, liberty and fruit of labor, then one will naturally see no wrong in allowing anyone in to the country regardless of whether or not that person will enrich the US.
This comes from the foolish progressive religion that has no absolute values, thus is unable to determine any standard for what is good for this country, or humanity in general. This also explains the death tax, and the success tax(also known as the progressive tax). Fools can only point to randomness and chance as why one prospers where another does not. So rather than reward virtue, "victimhood" is rewarded, and when one definition of "victimhood" does not suffice, then the definition expands.
Do not be confused, progressivism is only nihilism dressing up and putting on airs. This is why progressives refuse to countenance rewarding virtue, they do not want to face their own wrongdoing and evil intention, which they would have to if there are absolutes. This is also why they fight maniacally to promote their system of unbelief.

President Obama's
Inauguration was Jan.20, 2009. I think Harry will be running a tad bit late, when it comes to Liberals destroying jobs. The Waxman,the 70 Republicans who voted for HR 1256, Senators Snowe, Specter, and Collins, and the Moderate (Liberal)Republicans in Congress, have already made sure those in the shadows, and those who cross the border illegally every day will have no American Workers to compete with(10% Unemployment Rate today; 15% tommorrow). Now add to that the "Al Gore Cap and Trade TAX Bill" that will be passed before the crap Harry brings to the floor, and that will destroy thousands of more jobs, and Harry will be scraping the bottom of the bucket. The only people working will be those working for the President. Now I just know the President wouldn't throw Federal Workers under the bus for illegal aliens, like he did Rev. Wright?? I sure HOPE so, I am a retired worker, but staring down the barrel of hyper inflation, I will need to get me a Government Job. I got my eye on being an Inspector General like Mr. Walpin, in view of all of the "Ethical" firings of late.

Bureau of Engraving and Printing
Socialism by Obama is simply incomprehensible!

In order for Socialism to succeed and feed, clothe, shelter, educate and medicate the FREELOADERS, WELFARE CHEATS and every other moron in America who believes the government owes them ALL of the above...will be in for a very, very frightening experience when this insane idea by Obama comes to screeching halt!

Obama has already ordered little Timothy to print over $2,000,000,000,000 dollars that is backed by...NOTHING, NADA...except Treasury Bonds sold by the Treasury to our government which is backed by NOTHING, NADA...or to China or Russia using the United States properties as collateral which belongs to "WE THE PEOPLE...!"

The screeching halt will come faster than you realize! When all of the employers close their businesses because of the evergrowing, higher and higher taxes on everything and every body and less and less Americans working...the only people working will be illegal aliens doing slave labor...their measly taxes will NOT pay FOR squat!

Now Obama wants to ADD more costs to America's debt...like $1,000,000,000,000 for health care for ALL AMERICANS run by the U.S.GOVERNMENT!

Anyone know anything run by the government to be successful? RIGHT! What does Obama do when this happens? First local services in every city are cut dangerously low, every state...ditto then federal government...ditto!

Now, perhaps you are getting the picture…the United States of (maybe) America will be on par with CUBA, ZAMBABWE and every other Third World Country…with NOTHING, NADA!



Harold
“legal Mexicans…came here legally and don't like it when illegals come in and take our jobs any more than we do.”

This is why the Republican party needs to realize that they don’t have to support “immigration reform” or amnesty in order to get the Hispanic vote.

We hear this reasoning all the time. The leaders in the GOP think that if they want the Hispanic vote, they must line up in favor of amnesty. This is a lie. The LEGAL Hispanics that vote are NOT IN FAVOR of amnesty for illegals because the illegal immigrants hurt legal Hispanics as much or more than they hurt the rest of American citizens.

And you are right about the revolution. Our American dictators are not going to respond to pleas and bargaining. And throwing the bums out is not feasible anymore because of voter fraud. If we don't start to fight, we might as well run up a white flag.

Pete - when?
The country is already bankrupt. Maybe they have not filed papers as such, but there has been more going out than coming in for a long time, and that was BEFORE Obama.

Who will pay the bills? They won't get paid, so the ones we owe will stop extending credit. Pretty soon our country will resemble Zimbabwe, but for some reason idiot Democrats can't get this through their heads.

As for Democrats having a "hollow victory" No, it won't be hollow for them. A dictator never cares about the misery of those he dictates to. Have you ever known a dictator to give up his power because his people were suffering?

Even in North Korea, as the people languish in poverty, their insane dictator spends money on nuclear weapons that he could use to feed his people, but does that bother him? No, it does not, because all he cares about is looking like a BIG BAD WOLRD LEADER to the rest of the world.

Take Harry down in 2010
The illegal alien problem pales in consideration of the health care thing and the carbon tax thing. Dirty Harry is working for everything Obama wants. Our only hope is to throw out as many Dems as possible in 2010. Harry doesn't have a high approval rating here in northern Nevada, but the votes live in Vegas. Anybody who wants to really help better support whoever runs against Harry next year. It's my personal goal to get him out. I'd like to see Dean Heller run, but he hasn't committed. Sharron Angle is good, also, and needs support if she's the one.

Some hope for the future?
I saw that Harry Reid's approval rating in NV was pretty low. I am hoping that the housing forclosure crisis in NV will get the residents to vote Reid out. He is typical of all the Democrats at the federal level. He doesn't care about the people or state he is supposed to represent, he only cares about the Democrat Party and obtaining and weilding power. They see the illegals as Democrat voters that will help them stay in office. I do everything in my power to let me representatives know they will NOT get my vote if they don't stengthen border security, crack down on illegally cast votes and making sure that only US citizens vote. I have told my representatives I expect ACORN (or what ever they are changing their name to in order to avoid the stigma of voter fraud) to be defunded. They are not a non-partisan voter rights group. They are the community organizing arm of the Democrat party and not eligible for Federal funding.

Once the liberals impoverish us
who will pay the bills? Private industry and employment in private industry jobs is the only real source of wealth and tax revenue in the country. (Pay to government employees and the taxes they pay only recycles the same dollars -- no wealth or real tax revenue is created.)

As the impoverishment wipes out tax payers (and employers move off shore to avoid "cap & tax"), who is going to pay the bills?

The Democrats may have the votes, but it will be a hollow victory when they put the country into bankruptcy.

Blame the Employers
Employers in general, but especially
the chief executives of large companies here in the US, are always looking for a quick buck, and selling out their fellow Americans for cheap foreign labor is the American way.

There is no question in my mind that Harry Reid and similarly minded politicians are on these companies' payrolls.

The fact of the matter is ....

Liberals have a vested interest in keeping wages low.

The poorer people are, the more likely they will vote Democrat.

Illigals taking jobs...
...happen all the time. I used to work as a security officer in a high rise office building here in Seattle. About ten years ago the private club at the top of the building fired about half of their clean up crew who were Mexican immigrants--LEGAL Mexican immigrants. They were fired because they wanted to unionize to get better wages. They were getting only $6.00 an hour. The club replaced them with illegal Mexican immigrants paying them under the counter and, I understand, less than $6.00 an hour. The legal immigrants reported this to the Immigration Service but before those idiots got off of their dead a**es to do something about it the club replaced the illgals with other legals.

Even before this happened, those legal Mexicans had been complaining about the illegals that come to this country taking jobs. They came here legally and don't like it when illegals come in and take our jobs any more than we do.

The government does not care whether Americans have jobs or not. All they care about is the power they have and the ability to control us. Out government is nothing but a bunch of Nazis and Obama is the new fuhrer.

It's time for another American Revolution!!

ACORN loves illegals
"Acorn will be registering these illegals like crazy. Even more so when they suddenly have legal status."

Ditto Jag! One only needs to watch an LAUSD televised board meeting. You will see plenty questionable characters, addressing the board in their beloved spanish ( of course requiring a translator who's English is marginal at best), always with a sense of bravado and entitlement - while emblazoned in their red ACORN t-shirts.


ACORN loves illegals!
"20,000,000 new Dem voters. The American way of life is a cheap price to pay when your political future is at stake. Mexico has been governed by socialist/kleptomaniacs for decades. They make good Dem voters. "

Ditto Jag! I watched the LAUSD( which is no small feat, even on a good day) board meeting yesterday.

I watched several people( more than 5) get up to address the board. There was a group of individuals, all wearing similiar ACORN T-shirts. Surprisingly, not one spoke a word of English - ALL requiring a translator as the they addressed the board in spanish!


10-1 they were ALL illegal aliens! The bravado, arrogance and overall sense of entitlement for which they addressed the board was nothing short of shocking! God only knows how much the LAUSD spends on accommodating illegal invaders!

In any event, ACORN is already actively associating with illegal invaders, recruting them for their socialist and corrupt agenda, in an effort to destroy this country!

Harry Reid lookin out for Harry
Acorn will be registering these illegals like crazy. Even more so when they suddenly have legal status.

Ever stay in a casino/hotel in Vegas. Every maid speaks only Spainish. Harry's poll numbers in NV are in the dumper. His only chance for re election is the Acorn vote. This is his way of getting out the vote.

20,000,000 new Dem voters. The American way of life is a cheap price to pay when your political future is at stake. Mexico has been governed by socialist/kleptomaniacs for decades. They make good Dem voters.

illegal aliens
depending on the figures that are posted illegals are such a drain on the economy that many states could almost balance their budgets if they weren't funding all these illegal parasites infesting this country.

Cailfornia is said to spend some$10.5 billion paying for illegals both in and out of prison.

Other studies claim each illegal costs this country $20,000 more than they generate in their unskilled labor jobs.

But the dims/leftists/socialists that want to destroy america have yet to justify why the earners/taxpayers are burdened paying for these parasites and the lice they produce.

If a comparable number of americans invaded mexico they would find themselves in real duress. Seems while mexico has no problem exporting the trash they don't want to america, mexico treats all illegals as criminals with no rights

Seems that in the spirit of good neighbors, as exhibited by mexico, we should treat the illegal trash from mexico the same way, and quickly deport them and their families back to the third world toliet they came from

It's been done before
In earler times, American presidents found it necessary to deport illegals to make jobs for Americans. Hoover, Truman and Eisenhower all deported illegal aliens, especially Eisenhower who deported 13 million of them in beginning in 1954.

It can be done,we have the evidence to prove it. Opening the door to the illegals now in this country is not going to solve our economic problems and in fact will only make them worse.

Heavy fines
One way to stop this insanity is to fine the companies $5,000.00 for each illegal alien caught in a company. This would do away with their profit and be illogical to hire them. If you don't hire them, they won't have jobs and then they will have to go home.

It's illegal aliens Lon!
Lon, I notice you have an adversion to using the word "illegal," and choose to use the politically correct, all encompassing term "immigrants." These are not "immigrants" we are speaking of. They are illegal aliens!

Do you see the distinction?

In addition, what makes you believe that someone who choose to enter this country in violation of our immigration laws will suddenly transform into an honest, tax paying citizen if made legal?

Illegals are already supposed to be paying taxes Lon! In fact, our government requires illegals to pay their taxes through Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) numbers. So... if they are not paying taxes, they are breaking yet another law!

I know...shocking that an illegal alien would choose to ignore paying their taxes!

Besides, the majority of illegals would be receiving far more in social subsidies than they would ever pay in taxes. How else would someone from a third world country, with little or no education, usually with multiple children, be expected to make it in this country without substantial government assistance?

Care to explain how legalizing 20 million, third-world illegals( who have already demonstrated a knack for ignoring our laws) is going to be a financial boom for this country Lon?


harry reid
the same harry reid that was giving up the iran war?

A failer as a human bean, failer as a political person--not worth even talking about.

Dirty Harry Knows...
"Comprehensive immigration reform" is simply amnesty cloaked in feel good wrapping! Remember in 1986 when Reagan granted some 5 million illegal aliens amnesty? What happend to the "border security" we were supposed to get with that amnesty ? Never happened!

Well...here we are again, some twenty years later and traitors like Dirty Harry Reid are crying, demanding another amnesty! Could it have anything to do with the cheap labor his well heeled constituents need to work in the Nevada casinos and hotels?

In any event, it's not five million illegals, it's upwards of 20 million illegals( with more arriving daily) and their advocates( many in our own government)demanding amnesty this time around!

A pretty compelling argument that granting amnesties leads to further illegal immigration! Especially, when we have no lax border security and even more abysmal interior enforcement!

But it's not even 20 million! With chain migration, the number will likely double or triple - if any sort of amnesty is granted to those who entered this country in violation of our immigration laws.

I know I know ! This time it will be different! Dirty Harry even said so! Problem is, I know dirty Harry is lying once again!

How do I know?

Because his mouth was moving!

Dems are incredulous!
You need to read this black conservative's blog as he gives smackdowns to liberals on a daily basis. http://www.theblacksphere.net! FUNNY stuff!

Lon
You had me going there for a moment.

Jeffrey's is right
As Jeffrey has shown, large scale immigration is inconsistent with a growing economy. That is why all of the decades the US allowed large scale immigration, the US economy stagnated.

Oh wait, during most of that time the US economy was the envy of the world. Jeffreys is a bit of a simpleton isn't he? The effects of immigration are complicated. The Reid proposal may be a good one or it may be a bad one depending on the details. But the idea that this kind of argument tells you anything is nonsense.

Would bringing immigrants out in the open so that they pay the same taxes and so have less appeal to employers be worse than the current situation? Some of Jeffreys' argument suggests yes some suggest no, but his analysis is too shallow to note that there are consequences in both directions.

NUMBERSUSA.com
Anyone concerned about AMNESTY for illegals that this administration is trying to legislate, go to Numbersusa.com., sign up!

Become an advocate for LEGAL immigration and secure borders.



Best Cities for Jobs
2009 Best Cities for Jobs: Our Top 10
No. 3: Washington, D.C.

For better or worse, the federal government is big and getting bigger. Uncle Sam fuels nearby companies in almost every sector, especially law firms, lobbyists, and aerospace and defense companies.

http://jobs.aol.com/articles/photos/2009-best-cities-our-to p-10/2079543/

Heres what we do know.

Liberals have a long track record of hurting workers.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.