Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Wednesday, April 09, 2008
Michele Bachmann :: Townhall.com Columnist
Freedom Is Not the Problem, It Is the Solution
by Michele Bachmann
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



Doesn’t it seem like year after year, more and more decisions we should be making for ourselves, are instead being made by nameless bureaucrats in Washington? They tell us how to spend our money. They tell us how to run our businesses. They tell us how to raise our families. And now, when you thought things couldn’t become anymore absurd, they even tell us what kind of light bulbs we can use in our own homes.

Yes, that’s right, a recent piece of legislation passed in Washington has outlawed the everyday household light bulb.

Think this a joke?

I only wish it were. Congress slipped into the recent energy bill a mandate that within four years the everyday incandescent bulb is to disappear from the shelves of your local grocery and hardware stores. In it’s place? The fluorescent bulb that for years many consumers have avoided.

The list of complaints about fluorescent bulbs is long. Some are bothered by the higher price, others by the harsher light, others by their lack of adaptability to household fixtures, and still others by concerns over their mercury content.

So on what grounds has Washington justified this unwanted intrusion into our lives?

They say that these high-mercury bulbs will reduce the strain on our energy supply, reduce the carbon footprint, and lead to greater energy efficiency. But there’s little to no evidence to back up their claims.

Congress has intruded on your shopping list on a whim; in favor of a fad.

Well, that doesn’t sit well with me and I know it doesn’t sit well with you.

America was founded on the idea that people are far better able to make their own decisions than the government.

So I’ve the Light Bulb Freedom of Choice Act, which makes a simple challenge to Big Brother: either Congress’ own independent investigative arm, the Government Accountability Office (GAO), marshals evidence to back up the assumptions behind the light bulb ban – or Congress repeals the mandate.

In other words, I’m asking Congress to actually be – hold your breath – accountable to the people. If they are going to intrude into our lives, and control our most basic decisions, the least they can do is have enough respect for the American people to back-up their claims.

Specifically, my bill would ask the GAO to study whether the ban:

1.) leads to lower costs for consumers,
2.) leads to reduced carbon emissions, and
3.) does not lead to a health risk, particularly for vulnerable populations, like those in nursing homes, day care centers, schools, and hospitals

Congress is quite right that we have an energy crisis this country. But Congress itself is to blame.

Year after year, Congress has failed to take advantage of clean nuclear power, failed to build new refineries, failed to tap into oil-rich resources in our country, and failed to utilize the genius of private enterprise.

As a result, Americans are dependent on foreign oil from unstable or dangerous regimes – and paying top dollar at the pump for the privilege.

Forcing a fad on the American people isn’t a real energy policy. It’s eerily reminiscent of Jimmy Carter asking Americans to turn down the heat and put on sweaters in answer to the 70’s energy crisis.

What Washington fails to understand is that freedom is not the problem: it is the solution.

America has the ingenuity, resolve and the resources to harvest all the clean and affordable energy we could ever need. But from exploring untapped resources to new scientific frontiers, this future is found not in handcuffing Americans but in unleashing the power of their free will.

Coincidentally, it’s the one thing Congress hasn’t tried.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author


Congresswoman Michele Bachmann represents Minnesota's Sixth Congressional District

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.

individuals
"Rather than giving people information and allowing us to make individual decisions"

If your individual decision is to use ten times the amount of energy and create ten times the amount of waste and pollution as everyone else it will be my individual decision to vote for people who will regulate the activities you indulge in that are messing up the land air and water we both share.

Congresswoman Bachmann
The issue isn't lightbulbs; it's much broader. The issue is that government regulation has gone way beyond what the Constitution allows because science has become so politicised. Rather than giving people information and allowing us to make individual decisions about what is in our enlightened best interest, environmentalists, et al. have concluded that we folks don't have the intelligence to make such decisions; therefore, they need to decide for us.
The problem is that they are no smarter in the aggregate than we are, and unintended consequences often result when everyone is forced to behave in a particular way. For example, we were not aware that removing lead from paint would result in a dramatic increase in mold infestations with resultant health problems for many people. Because lead was outlawed, there was not time to compare the health effects of leaded paint and unleaded paint, or to develop safe alternatives. Our nation is in a precarious energy situation because Congress mandates which energy sources are acceptable or not acceptable; therefore we do not use domestically available resources optimally. This has made us dependent on foreign energy sources which are controlled, in many cases, by people who are not our friends, if not our enemies. Many other examples could be given.

dim bulb
Bachmann has never let a little ignorance stop her. Now, she is trying to roll back a bill which moves light-bulb manufacturing away from incandescence towards fluorescence with a target date of 2012. Her claim? The mercury in fluorescent bulbs is an environmental hazard. Yes, she is right that mercury is an element in fluorescent lighting. Yes, she is correct that disposing of mercury lighting requires special handling. Yes, she is right that mercury bulbs cost more individually than do standard incandescent light bulbs.Those are the only three things she is right about. Coal-powered electricity, such as we rely upon in Minneapolis St. Paul, emits mercury. Mercury emissions get into the water. Fish absorb the mercury and store it in their fatty tissues. We can’t eat more than three meals of fish per week because of the mercury content. Using incandescent lighting requires more electricity than fluorescent lighting. Using more electricity means burning more coal and from that increasing the amount of mercury in the environment. Fluorescent bulbs last longer.


"dimmest bulb" Really!
I didn't realize that earmarks could replaced faulty gussets in a bridge. How many bridges in Minn. collapsed? I noticed you said bridges meaning more than one.

Isn't Michele Bachmann a Congress woman from Minnesota? I'm shocked that she didn't spend millions of dollars on earmarks for Minnesota's levee system. I hear many parts of Minnesota are below lake level.

Now I know that since a county in her district has the highest rate of mortgage foreclosures in the state that she is personally responsible for people and lenders making unsound financial decisions.

Maybe with a little luck she will end the virtual flag flying of the hammer and sickle over Minnesota and send it to you so you can cherish it with the rest of your Nazis socialist propaganda.

Monkeywrench
Countries throughout Africa want to use DDT to combat malaria [it's MOST effective at killing the carrier of the disease] but the environmentally conscious countries will not let them use it.

Malaria is killing millions, and for bogus reasons it [DDT] was banned, when it could save lives around the world.

Some cavemen had it better
I wish I'd learned how to sew a good tepee. I'd head for the hills and live out my days (no doubt fewer but happier) without ever considering any of this.

@ Monkeywrench
"And pesticides? Nothing works as well as good ol' DDT--legalize it!"

Sounds like a good plan to me. The stuff was effective, and based on some of what I've read, the evidence in favor of its supposed problems was built in the traditional manner of politicized science: Any competing evidence is simply ignored, while corroborating evidence was constantly trumpetted.

What a joke
How many Republicans does it take to change a light bulb?

Why stop at incandescent bulbs?
If it's gummint intrusion that our dim-bulb congresswoman is worried about, why not get them out of the business of regulating paint? Let's get the lead back in! And pesticides? Nothing works as well as good ol' DDT--legalize it! Smokestack emissions? Let 'em rip--more sulfur, carbon dioxide, arsenic, mercury!

Check out Rep. 5-Watt's burgeoning screen career here:

http://tinyurl.com/3r3e6b


Dear Monkeywit,
You have a problem with a congress critter who DOESN'T request earmarks? REMARKABLE! And shouldn't the STATES be taking care of their own infrastructure? Neither should tax dollars be used to bail out people who made questionable financial decisions. Unless they intend to pay us taxpayers back ala Chrysler. Oh! Wait! They can't pay their frigging mortgage how will they pay back us taxpayers?!

As for light bulbs, thats just another sign of the continuing encroachment on our, the American peoples', freedom. Which any TRUE American should oppose.

I guess the following quote applies to you: "Most men do not desire freedom, they wish only for a just master." - Salust

Michele Bachmann: Congress' dimmest bulb
Bachmann has refused to request any earmarks for any projects in her district, leaving many communities high and dry with failing bridges, levees and other legitimate projects. A county in her district has the highest rate of mortgage foreclosures in the state. Yet this is what concerns Michele Bachmann--friggin light bulbs. What a fraud!

Here's a better illumination of Bachmann's ignorance:

http://tinyurl.com/5q8xwp

Congresswoman Bachmann
Let's not even mention the mandate to use corn for ethanol. The result of this folly was to dramatically raise prices for almost every grocery item on the shelves, while having little effect on the targeted shortage and decreasing the energy content of the adulterated gasoline.

Lawyers should stay home and wrangle -- unfortunately, they are the only ones who can increase the income of their offices at home while sitting in Congress and selling their votes to special interests.

Congresswoman Bachmann
Excellent column! Congress, especially with Dems. in charge, have shown a total lack of letting us "little people" do our own thing. More nuclear power, building refineries, and drilling ANWR and off the coasts of Fl. and Ca. would employ thousands of people, rid us of expecting oil from tyrant states, and solve if not cure our fuel problems. Congress makes to much money off the oil/gas taxes to help us "little people" out as well, roughly 65 cents a gallon? Until REAL Consevatives get elected in masses we will all be suffering the whims of the "Big Brother" cure all Government of the liberal Democrats, and all the RHINO's. I guess I'll have to protect my "old" light bulbs like my guns...

Congresswoman Michele Bachmann
Why the outrage with the light bulbs? Where was your protest over the forced switch from analog to digital TV? What about your protest on the govt peering into our personal phone records?

Oh, I get it... you only protest the light bulbs because it has to do with global warming.
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.