Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
BREAKING NEWS  LeftArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican   RightArrow - Townhall.com : Conservative, Political, Republican  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!
  • Check the boxes and send us your email address to receveive your free newsletter
  • Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
  • Townhall.com’s weekly inside scoop on what’s happening behind the scenes in the world of politics. When news breaks, we report.
  • Signup to receive the latest daily Townhall cartoons
Tuesday, April 01, 2008
David Almasi :: Townhall.com Columnist
Racial Bias Is What Some People Want Us to See... No Matter What
by David Almasi
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 
Poll
Do you feel the leaked information from a global warming alarmist organization is meaningful?



Comedian Chris Rock used to play a recurring character on "Saturday Night Live" named Nat X. During the humorous, nonsensical rants of this Black Nationalist talk show host, Nat X would sometimes be chased by his studio's "white-man cam.” When it caught him, bars would appear on the screen and Nat X would yell "That's what you wanna see!"

April's cover of Vogue magazine, featuring an Annie Leibovitz photo of basketball phenomenon LeBron James and supermodel Gisele Bundchen promoting its "shape issue," is drawing fire for what magazine critic Samir Husni calls an image that "screams King Kong."

Leibovitz's photo featured James, dressed to play and bouncing a basketball, looking like he is yelling while clutching a smiling Bundchen around the waist.

Adding to Husni's criticism, University of Maryland assistant professor Damion Thomas told the Associated Press that the Leibowitz photo "reinforce[s] the criminalization of black men."

This criticism turns a high-end fashion magazine with a circulation of around a million into an international news story and a potential flashpoint for racial hostility.

The controversy over the photo is the creation of conspiracy theorists willing to find a racial angle in just about anything.

The alleged victim James' response was one of indifference. He told the Cleveland Plain Dealer, "who cares what anyone says?" and that he was "just showing a little emotion."

Darryn "Dutch" Martin, a black conservative with Project 21 (full disclosure: a group with which I work), said in a press release: "There are people who are, and probably forever will be, racially hypersensitive for either personal or professional reasons. Nothing that reasonable people say or do will convince them otherwise. I believe critics are using this canard of racial stereotyping as a smokescreen to hide their true disdain for any images of interracial closeness or intimacy between black men and white women."

Hours after Project 21's press release hit the Internet, I received an e-mail from liberal blogger Rogers Cadenhead suggesting I visit his blog. A fellow liberal blogger had already gone to the trouble of tracking down a World War I-era army recruiting poster that closely resembles the Vogue photo. On his "Watching the Watchers" blog, Cadenhead reproduced the magazine cover and the poster and opined: "Leibovitz, who has a history of referencing iconic images in her photographs, appropriated the composition from a famous poster that's believed to be an inspiration for the film King Kong… I wonder if James, presented with the two images, would be as generous."

Leibovitz has not yet said this is what she did – it is only speculation. And the poster was comparing Germans to apes (and not necessarily King Kong).

Vogue's cover didn't personally make me draw a comparison between LeBron James and King Kong until I read Husni and Thomas's criticism. Nor was I aware of the recruiting poster until Cadenhead contacted me. Despite now being exposed to it, I don't think of James as an ape not do I hold him in the same contempt as I do Kaiser Wilhelm II and the German empire of nearly a century ago.

To be honest, the first thing I thought about when I saw the photo was how it resembled the way James looks on the bottle of Powerade that is sitting in my refrigerator. James is an endorser of the sports drink.

LeBron James is a noted basketball player who is at the peak of his physical prowess, which is what Vogue was celebrating by featuring him on the cover with one of the world's top supermodels. Rather than judging James – and, by extension, other blacks – by the content of their character, skills or intellect as Vogue intended, the race-mongers instead seem more interested in bringing things down to the lowest common denominator. There never seems to be a party where they don't want to be a skunk.

After all, Nat X said that's what we wanted to see.

Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author

David W. Almasi is executive director of the National Center for Public Policy Research, a Capitol Hill think-tank established in 1982.

 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.

The Vogue cover
I hope this foolish, politically correct flap results in Vogue selling at least 2 million more copies of the magazine than its expected circulation. I am so tired of these scheming, nefarious race-baiters CREATING racial incidents!

Demosthenes, You hit
it right on the head-
As an attractive Israeli-ish woman married to an extremely buffed black man, I can personally attest to the fact that it is black women who are BY FAR the most obvious in their hate and anger toward me. They don't even bother to try and hide the eye-rolling or remarks uttered in my presence, the attitude is so thick you could cut it with a knife-

And kudos to Dutch Martin- What a good and brilliant man he is, a real blessing to his beautiful Morroccan born wife:)

Yikes, Skinny White Girl!
I saw the Vogue cover with some commentary about how the photo was in poor taste. All I thought when I saw the photo was "Good thing that stong basketball player didn't squeeze that skinny creature too hard. He might break her." Poor thing, she needs to eat something and lots of it.

Insulting remarks
Lebron posed for this picture and if he is satisfied with it, then everyone else needs to shut up. Saying that he looks like King Kong is insulting. I assume this is Black people making this remark, because if they were white, they would be fired or sued. I don't know about anyone else, but I am sick of all of the racial remarks. You can't pick up a newspaper or watch TV unless the Blacks are complaining about something. I guess the media enjoys telling everyone so they can keep things stirred up. These people need to be ignored. It doesn't seem to me that some people want the races to get along. They cause trouble so they can have something else to complain about.

Competition
"I believe critics are using this canard of racial stereotyping as a smokescreen to hide their true disdain for any images of interracial closeness or intimacy between black men and white women."

Who has true distain? The late comedian Richard Pryor commented on one of his many albums that when black women saw a black man like Mr. Pryor dating a white woman they "look at you like you just stabbed your momma"- apparently they don't appreciate the competition.

Here's the Vogue cover
Here's a copy of the cover photo:

http://tinyurl.com/2mfmv3

I don't see "King Kong" in his photo.

I see a skinny looking blonde white woman with some black guy standing next to her.

This is what psychologists refer to as "figure-ground."



Re: Cover shot
As a resident of MA who can't hide from the 24/7 Tom Brady/Gi stories, I can't understand why they didn't allow "the couple" to appear on the cover. Did Tom say NO? He certainly is posing here, there and everywhere else!

No complaints about the cover, just wondering...

Thanks, Happy
for a most insightful post! Peace to you and how I wish more could find it!

Blacks, Liberals & The Truth
Townhall,

I'm not gonna bore you with poetic verses, just the facts.

Black people in this country are supporting a political party which was anti-black in the past, and it's anti-black today.

Democrats reinvented themselves in the 1960s to make blacks think they had kicked all of the racist whites out of the party, but that didn't happen. They took the sheets off!

Republicans fought a bloody civil-war with "The Confederate Army" to free blacks from slavery,so,Why are black-americans voting for Democrats/Dixiecrats? Dr. Martin Luther King is the reason why 90% of blacks in this country are Democrats. Dr. King's father was a Republican, and so was he, What Changed? As you all know, Barry Goldwater was a strong supporter of states' rights, as it related to the passage of the Civil Rights Act. Dr. King did not like that,thus, it made him doubt the sincerity of the Republican Party as a whole. Republicans fought to pass the Civil Rights Act for decades, but their efforts were shot down by dem-controlled administrations and congresses. At the time, Dr. King believed the Dems were serious about shedding their racist past, he was wrong. Dr. King's decision to get in bed with Democrats was a fatal miscalculation, and you see the results of that today.

Peace,
A FREE BLACKMAN IN MIND,BODY,AND SOUL

Warrior
Well said.

When I was in college, I preferred blacks who were from other countries, because they were there to get an education and would spend many hours in the library studying. They shared my values.

Half Racist ?
Suppose I liked half of the American Blacks (estimate) but not the other half. I don't know all Blacks so how would I distinguish or how could I identify the half I do not like. I could identify them by the traits I am prejudiced against.I don't like corn rows, foul language (particularly the fact that Mother is a half word to too many), and slovenly dressed (pants down to their knees) people. I don't like guns being discharged in the neighborhood, gangs of thugs, or gold teeth. I do not like people that don't work and don't care that they do not. I do not like people that expect strangers to willingly give them money and feed them while they make little or no effort to feed themselves. I do not like people that give up their lives because some one in their family was a slave, in fact, I am tired of talking or hearing about slavery. I don't like men that impregnate women and abandon them, I don't like men that brag about their sexual conquests and boast by saying, "I put a baby in her". I do not like RAP music, or loud speakers in cars, I do not like sub-cultures , ebonics, or people that fight, pull hair, cuss each other in school. I do not like people that murder, lie, and steal and make excuses about it. I don't like people that will not clean up their own neighborhoods, lie to the police, and allow drugs to be sold to their children right in front of them. All I have described is the Black subculture, there are pockets of these type people in segregated neighborhoods all over America and they are rife for the spread of Communism. I do not like them, they are expensive, and they add very little that is good to our world. There are Whites, Hispanics, and Asians I do not like either but not near as many. It is not the people; it is their conduct, the way they act that I find offensive.

King Kong Photo Hubbub
I'm not going to pass judgement on the photo until Reverend Jeremiah Wright explains the hidden meaning behind it. Only then will the Truth be known...

racist cover?
we have a subscription to Vogue, and I got this issue in the mail the other day. my immediate thought on seeing LeBron and Giselle on the cover was "wow! a beautiful strong athlete and a gorgeous strong supermodel, both larger than life, both radiating health, both at the top of their game." that some people can see some racist sub-text here is really incredible.

1/2 if urban high school kids graduate
Jeez, that multiculturalism is really helping those inner city kids, ain't it? Pimpin their rides and all. Check this link out --

http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=080401184532.kxjxy7 xo&show_article=1

Let's see, they cannot read, nor write, but they KNOW that George Washington was a racist bigot, that white men are evil SOBs, that capitalist imperialist dogs have ruined the world, that global warming is occurring, how to put on a condom, and the list goes on.

And THESE people are supposed to pay for our social security? N - O - T!

Get out of this country while you can move your assets. Just go. Because it's not worth your time, energy or intelligence anymore. Let George W. and crew, and his successors, figure out how to do it on their own from here out. Hey, maybe he can even go fight in Iraq. Now there's a thought! Cowboy that he is -- but the skirts come out when it comes do fighting Dems on budgetary issues. He puts on those high heels and bends over for Ted and crew. Maybe it's best he just stick to flying onto carriers to declare victory after the first wave of attacks are over.

Isn't it time to admit that, even if you are a war supporter (which I am reluctantly in this case), that this President is an abysmal, awful failure on almost any conservative measure and not much of a commander in chief at that?

No, it is time to leave.


Diddo
That is what is so great about Liberals....













.


And thanks for the reminder what MSM will do on slow news days when there is a Democrat in the WH. (they'll be lots of them :-)

Racism is as Racism does
For this cover shot to be considered racist, one would have to look at the cover and immediately have a negative response; something along the lines of "what is the big black man doing with the skinny white girl?".

That it was the purveyors of racial guilt is hardly surprising; that they were willing to admit they think it is inappropriate for James to be photographed with Gisele is more than simply surprising.

Tubbs
Much ado..........


When you think you speak for most...whatever, its funny that is what these critics claimed. So your argument is not with conservatives per se. I always get leery when one (namely liberals) think that he/she speaks for most people. If it were nothing, they wouldn't have rushed out that day to denounce it.

Tubbs
Good post. Appropriate point, strongly and succinctly made. Most people don't really want to be classified merely as a member of a monolithic group, at least most of the time.

Picayune Drivel
GOOD GRIEF!!!!!!!WTF is wrong with disussing something other than how a fricking photo affects a race of people or a few race mongers.

Who gives a rat's @$$ about the cover of a rag magazine with a black athlete and a white model posing? GHEEEEZZZZZZZ!!! GET A GRIP!

If this is torture...
Let's see. A multimillionaire with every man's dream job is photographed with a gorgeous supermodel on his arm by a world-famous photographer, probably paid a bunch of money to do it, and some people still call him a victim? I'm starting to suspect their standards are set a bit too high. Please let me know how I can sign up to be the next victim.

Seriously, why waste any bandwidth on these kooks?

Much ado about nothing . . . as usual
First, TUBBS, everybody on both political sides thinks one person speaks for all of them. Just human nature. However, it's nice to hear at least one black liberal that doesn't care about this Vogue cover. The problem is that not enough black liberals that don't care about this cover make noise about that fact and of course the liberal media don't want to interview you because that's not news, is it? So until enough people stand up and speak out against this kind of thing, the other side will assume that the race-baiters speak for all of you. Same goes for the "moderate Muslims" - how do we know what they think since they don't say anything?

Second, when I first saw the picture, with the tag line about it being racist, I couldn't figure out why anyone would say it was racist. Because it was a black man with a white woman? Couldn't figure it out. Then I heard the King Kong bs and I was still astounded.

The media has nothing else to write or talk about and the race-baiters have gone too long without anything to write or talk about, so here we go again.

Whatever. There are more pressing issues in this world than Vogue cover.

Much ado about nothing
I'm a black liberal and I think I speak for most of us in saying that we really don't care about this Vogue cover.

Let me ask you this: should every conservative who screams about some nonsensical issue (like the alleged attacks on christmas, or changing french fries to freedom fries) be deemed a representative of your entire group?

They're out there
So this is, immediately on looking at it, a racial statement and stereotype. That is according to the race-mongers. The word King-Kong is then tossed into the fray. This goes hand in hand namely with the political left. Brand something with an image, via association, which is meant to replace the real image. If done correctly it stigmatizes even the idea of what was the actual point.

Get real
Notice the ones who hollered about it first. This calls into question what they see; which is akin to what they want to see and are looking for. Now if that were on a hip-hop record, it would not likely have been a "problem".

Looking at the photos, ...
What hogwash!

Looking at the photos: http://www.style.com/vogue/feature/032508

I see a pretty woman who looks pretty happy to be on the arm of a top athlete.

And if you look at #8 in the slideshow you'll see a white athlete with a different model actually draped over his shoulder. She doesn't look quite as happy about it.

Maybe she wanted to pose with LeBron James and didn't get too?

No Surprise!
The reaction to Vogue should not be a surprise in or multi-racial society. Would Japan have this problem? I'm sorry, that first sentence wasn't PC. This is a common reaction in a multi-genetically clustered society!

Vogue Cover--Blown Out of Proportion
I heard about the hullabaloo on the radio, wherr hyper sensitive liberals were crying out that Lebron was made to look like a gorilla in King Kong.

I imagined him forced to pose on top of a building, holding that white model while she screeches like a damsel in distress, and little model airplanes flying around them. That is what I pictured based on all the rants against it.

So, I went to the grocery store and saw it, and I thought, "Is this it?" Because nowhere and no how does it make Lebron look like King Kong nor does the photo in total make you think of King Kong.

He just looked like a big guy, like he was trying to look tough, and the girl in his arms didn't even pose like the woman in King Kong. She just sort of molded up to his body, attempting to look like a sexy heroine addicted anorexic.

If it was the purpose to image King Kong, they failed. If it is the purpose to make people really believe that this is racial and insulting, they should fail.

Lebron didn't protest, he got paid, if he didn't like it, I haven't heard him complain once about it.

Just another liberal rant to see how far they can go.

Everything is Biased

Racism is without scientific validity. Racism is merely a social action or government policy based on such assumed differences. Consequently any race of people who may consider themselves superior to another will automatically place them in the business of being prejudicial against another race of people.

Individuals who are independent of this thought could be considered prejudiced of all others which ensures ALL of us are prejudiced about something or somebody as we should be. We must prejudge everything and everybody or follow blindly into the ignorance of one thought.

Darryn "Dutch" Martin has the race mongers pegged with..."I believe critics are using this canard of racial stereotyping as a smokescreen to hide their true disdain for any images of interracial closeness or intimacy between black men and white women."
Sign Up to Post Your CommentsSign Up to Post Your Comments
If you are already registered, click here to login. Otherwise, please take a few seconds to register with Townhall.com. Once you sign up, you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, and more!
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.